Scott v. Barclay's Amer. Leasing Service

506 So. 2d 823
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedApril 14, 1987
DocketCA 86 0279, CA 86 0280
StatusPublished
Cited by16 cases

This text of 506 So. 2d 823 (Scott v. Barclay's Amer. Leasing Service) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Scott v. Barclay's Amer. Leasing Service, 506 So. 2d 823 (La. Ct. App. 1987).

Opinion

506 So.2d 823 (1987)

Catherine Bonita SCOTT, Natural Tutrix of the Minor, Kendrill Davon Jackson
v.
BARCLAY'S AMERICAN LEASING SERVICE, INC., the Motor Convoy, Inc., Michael Bennett and Transport Insurance Company.
BITUMINOUS CASUALTY CORPORATION
v.
Michael W. BENNETT, the Motor Convoy, Inc. and Transport Insurance Company.

Nos. CA 86 0279, CA 86 0280.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, First Circuit.

April 14, 1987.
Writ Denied June 19, 1987.

*825 Larry C. Dupuis, Crowley, for plaintiff-appellee Catherine Bonita Scott on behalf of Kendrill Davon (Scott) Jackson.

James E. Moore, Franklin, Moore & Walsh, Baton Rouge, for plaintiffs-appellees Bituminous Cas. Corp., (also as defendant and as compensati intervenor) and La. Church Contracting Services, Inc.

Ernest L. O'Bannon, John C. Tollefson, Bienvenu, Foster, Ryan & O'Bannon, New Orleans, for defendant-appellant Michael Bennett, The Motor Convoy, Inc. and Transport Ins. Co.

Before EDWARDS, WATKINS and Le BLANC, JJ.

Le BLANC, Judge.

FACTS

On March 11, 1982, at approximately 11:00 a.m., Douglas Benoit was driving his Plymouth Valiant in a northerly direction on Louisiana Highway 1 approximately two miles north of Thibodaux, Louisiana. Marcus Ellis and Doug Percle were passengers in Benoit's vehicle. As Benoit approached the Ellis' private driveway, he turned on his blinker light and either slowed or stopped his car in order for the southbound lane to clear so that he could turn left onto the Ellis' driveway.

The vehicle immediately following Benoit was a truck driven by Joseph Jackson, Jr. in the course and scope of his employment with Louisiana Church Contracting Services, Inc. The trial court found that Mr. Jackson was not paying proper attention to his driving because while Benoit's vehicle was stopped, Jackson rear-ended Benoit's Plymouth Valiant.

Within seconds of the Jackson-Benoit collision, a tractor-trailor rig driven by Michael Bennett, while in the course and scope of his employment with The Motor Convoy, Inc., ran into the back of Jackson's pickup truck causing it to collide for a second time with Benoit's vehicle.

As a result of these accidents, Marcus Ellis was severely injured and Joseph Jackson, Jr. was killed.

At the time of the accident, Jackson lived, without the benefit of marriage, with Catherine Bonita Scott and her two minor children by other men. Scott and Jackson had one child, Kendrill Davon Scott Jackson, who was 2½ months old at the time of Joseph Jackson Jr.'s death.

On January 10, 1983, Catherine Bonita Scott (Scott) as natural and qualified tutrix of Kendrill Davon Scott Jackson (Jackson) filed suit against Barclay's American Leasing Service, Inc. (Barclay's), The Motor Convoy, Inc. (Motor Convoy), Michael Bennett (Bennett), and Transport Insurance Company (Transport), the liability insurer of Motor Convoy in the Seventeenth Judicial District Court. On January 16, 1983, Bituminous Casualty Corporation (Bituminous), the worker's compensation insurer of La. Church Contracting Services, filed suit against Michael Bennett, The Motor Convoy and Transport Insurance Company in the Nineteenth Judicial District Court to recover property damages, workers' compensation benefits, medical expenses and funeral expenses it paid and would pay in the future to the dependents of Joseph Jackson, Jr. On February 4, 1983, Scott filed suit on behalf of Jackson against Barclay's, The Motor Convoy, Bennett and Transport in the Nineteenth Judicial District Court.

The Bituminous and Scott cases filed in the Nineteenth Judicial District Court were transferred to the Seventeenth Judicial District Court and consolidated with a case filed by Mildred and Wayne Ellis, individually, and on behalf of their minor child, Marcus Ellis, against The Succession of *826 Joseph Jackson, Jr., Jackson's employer, Louisiana Church Contracting Services, Inc., Bituminous Casualty Corporation, Bennett, The Motor Convoy and Transport Insurance Company.

On June 29-30, 1985, trial was conducted in the Seventeenth Judicial District Court on the Ellis, Scott and Bituminous cases. The trial court made the following findings of law and fact regarding the Scott and Bituminous cases.

(1) Douglas Benoit was free from fault in both collisions.
(2) The first Benoit-Jackson collision was caused 100 percent by Jackson.
(3) The Jackson-Bennett collision was caused 100 percent by Bennett.
(4) The damages sustained by the Ellises were caused 50 percent by Jackson and 50 percent by Bennett.
(5) Catherine Bonita Scott, as tutrix of the minor child, Kendrill Scott Jackson, is entitled to $8,000.00 for loss of past support, $35,000.00 for future support, $100,000.00 for the loss of love and companionship as a result of the death of his father, Joseph Jackson, Jr. and $12,000.00 for Mr. Jackson's conscious pain and suffering from the time of the accident until his resulting death from The Motor Convoy, Inc., Michaell Bennett, and Transport Insurance Company, in solido.
(6) Bituminous Casualty Corporation is entitled to recover the sum of $5,621.42, representing $2,621.42 in medical expenses and $3,000.00 for funeral expenses incurred on behalf of Joseph Jackson, Jr. from Michael Bennett, The Motor Convoy, Inc. and Transport Insurance Company, and all sums paid or to be paid as Workers' Compensation Benefits on behalf of Joseph Jackson, Jr. to Catherine Bonita Scott, Kendrill Scott Jackson, and the two remaining children of the Jackson household.

On December 3, 1985, judgment was signed by the Seventeenth Judicial District Court awarding Catherine Bonita Scott, as tutrix of Kendrill Scott Jackson, $151,000.00 instead of the $155,000.00 awarded under the judge's written reasons for judgment.

ASSIGNMENTS OF ERROR

Michael Bennett, The Motor Convoy, Inc. and Transport Insurance Company filed a peremptory exception of no cause of action for the first time on appeal.

In addition, these defendants-appellants filed the following specifications of error:

(1) The court's finding that Joseph Jackson's negligence was neither the sole cause nor the concurrent cause of the accident resulting in his death was clearly erroneous.
(2) The damages awarded to Catherine Bonita Scott, as tutrix of the minor, Kendrill Davon Scott Jackson, were excessive.
(3) The court erred in failing to follow La. R.S. 23:1103 and in making an award in favor of Bituminous Casualty Corporation against Michael Bennett, The Motor Convoy and Transport Insurance Company for past and future compensation paid and to be paid to Kendrill Scott Jackson.
(4) The court erred in awarding judgment in favor of Bituminous Casualty Corporation for amounts paid or to be paid by Bituminous for the benefit of Catherine Bonita Scott and her two minor children by men other than Joseph Jackson, Jr.

The plaintiff-appellee, Catherine Bonita Scott, answers and files one assignment of error in which she contends that the trial court erred in awarding $155,000.00 to Kendrill Scott Jackson in its written reasons for judgment yet awarded only $151,000.00 in the judgment itself. Although raised, this assignment of error was not briefed and is considered abandoned on appeal. Uniform Rules-Courts of Appeal Rule 2-12.4.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Clement v. Frey
666 So. 2d 607 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1996)
Norris v. Goeders
652 So. 2d 144 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1995)
Cosse v. Allen-Bradley Co.
625 So. 2d 486 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1994)
Gauthier v. O'BRIEN
618 So. 2d 825 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1993)
Stapleton v. Great Lakes Chemical Corp.
616 So. 2d 1311 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1993)
Nelson v. State, Dept. of Public Safety
581 So. 2d 344 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1991)
Wells v. Winn-Dixie Louisiana, Inc.
572 So. 2d 210 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1990)
SUCCESSION OF THEROIT v. Southern Pacific Transp. Co.
560 So. 2d 861 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1990)
Herrington v. Mayo
550 So. 2d 745 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
South Cent. Bell Tel. Co. v. American Holding Corp.
548 So. 2d 339 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
Trabeau v. MacK Trucks, Inc.
543 So. 2d 1381 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
Holloway v. State ex rel. Department of Transportation & Development
549 So. 2d 859 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
Thomas v. Hartford Ins. Co.
540 So. 2d 1068 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1989)
Williams v. American Crescent Elevator
518 So. 2d 1091 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1987)
Vallere v. Nicor Exploration Company
512 So. 2d 514 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1987)
Scott v. Barclay's American Leasing Service, Inc.
508 So. 2d 88 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 1987)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
506 So. 2d 823, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/scott-v-barclays-amer-leasing-service-lactapp-1987.