Saucier v. Walker

203 So. 2d 299
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedNovember 6, 1967
Docket44447
StatusPublished
Cited by32 cases

This text of 203 So. 2d 299 (Saucier v. Walker) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Saucier v. Walker, 203 So. 2d 299 (Mich. 1967).

Opinion

203 So.2d 299 (1967)

Herbert SAUCIER
v.
B.F. WALKER and B.F. Walker, Inc., et al.

No. 44447.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

October 9, 1967.
Suggestion of Error Overruled November 6, 1967.

*300 William E. Andrews, Jr., Purvis, for appellant.

Simrall, Aultman & Pope, Hattiesburg, for appellees.

ROBERTSON, Justice:

The Appellant, Herbert Saucier, has appealed from a $5,000 judgment entered in his favor by the Circuit Court of Lamar County, Mississippi, against Appellees, B.F. Walker, B.F. Walker, Inc., Raymond G. Brakefield and Charles Wade Phillips. No verdict was returned by the jury against Appellees, Henry Williams *301 and H.D. Campbell, consequently no judgment was entered by the court against them. Appellees, B.F. Walker and B.F. Walker, Inc., cross-appealed.

The appellant assigned as error the following:

1. The gross inadequacy of the verdict and judgment, indicating that the jury wholly disregarded all of the clear and credible evidence, ignored the instructions of the court, and evinced bias, passion and prejudice against the appellant;
2. The form of the verdict is improper and not in accord with the laws made and provided;
3. The jury failed to return a verdict against Appellees, H.D. Campbell and Henry Williams;
4. The court erred in giving an instruction for Appellees, Williams and Walker, after the appellant had opened his argument to the jury.

The principal contention of the Cross-Appellants, B.F. Walker and B.F. Walker, Inc., is that the trial court erred in overruling their motions for a peremptory instruction.

The accident occurred at about 10:30 p.m. on the rainy and misty night of January 22, 1965, on U.S. Highway 11 about five miles south of Lumberton, Mississippi, and about one-fourth of a mile north of the highway bridge over Wolf River. Henry Williams, driving a 1956 White tractor and pulling a tandem trailer float loaded with heavy steel tubing, left the warehouse of B.F. Walker, Inc. in Harvey, Louisiana, just before dark on the evening of January 22, 1965, enroute to Magee, Mississippi, where he was to deliver his cargo. He had driven similar equipment for eight years and had made this particular trip before.

He testified that the fuel tank held "80-something gallons," and that to his personal knowledge the tank was full when he left Harvey, Louisiana. His tractor had functioned perfectly until he proceeded uphill in a northerly direction on U.S. Highway 11 after crossing the Wolf River bridge. He described his suddenly developed trouble in this way:

"As I started up this grade it started missing on me like it was catching air in the line. I didn't know what was wrong with it. I came to a dead stop and I figured then I was out of fuel and when it stopped and wouldn't start again I was going to let it roll off of the highway off on the shoulder and that is when the trailer slid off in the ditch."

When the trailer jackknifed and slid against the embankment, this caused the tractor to extend in a northwesterly direction across most of the east half of the highway. The west half and two or three feet of the east half were clear and unobstructed. Williams immediately set out fuses and reflectors, placing two reflectors south of the tractor and one north. He borrowed more fuses from a passing truck and set them out.

After about forty-five minutes, Appellee H.D. Campbell came along, and Williams asked him to get him some diesel fuel. Campbell went to Lumberton, obtained five gallons of fuel and accompanied by Appellant Saucier, returned to the disabled tractor of Williams. He parked his 1964 Ford Sedan on the east shoulder of the highway with about two feet of his car on the pavement. He parked about 30 yards south of the disabled tractor leaving his headlights on dim, and with a red and white rotating flasher light on top of his car.

Williams put the five gallons of diesel fuel in the tractor and tried unsuccessfully to start it. In the meantime, a highway patrolman had arrived on the scene and had parked his patrol car about 30 yards north of the disabled tractor with his lights on, and also, a red and white flashing light on top of the patrol car. Highway Patrolman Robinson with his flashlight, *302 then took up a position opposite the tractor to direct oncoming traffic around it. Appellant Saucier, at the suggestion of Patrolman Robinson, returned to Campbell's car and got in out of the rain, sitting on the front seat of the car.

Charles Wade Phillips, driving a 1964 Chevrolet owned by Raymond G. Brakefield, crossed the bridge over Wolf River, rounded the curve and proceeded up the inclined highway at a speed estimated at between 60 and 90 miles per hour. He hit Campbell's parked car head-on and greatly injured Appellant Saucier and Campbell, who at the time, was preparing to enter his car on the driver's side.

A wrecker arrived soon thereafter and pulled the tractor-trailer from the ditch and on over the crest of the hill toward Lumberton. The tractor finally started as it was being pulled down the hill, and thereafter proceeded under its own power to Lumberton. Driver Williams there had his fuel tank filled and signed for 76 7/10 gallons, which included the five gallons of fuel brought to him by Campbell.

With these facts before it, the jury returned the following verdict:

    "WE, the JURY, find for the PLAINTIFF against the
  following DEFENDANTS:
    B.F. WALKER & B.F. WALKER, INC.         $5,000.00
    RAYMOND G. BRAKEFIELD                   $5,000.00
    CHARLES WADE PHILLIPS                   $5,000.00"

The jury returned no verdict against Henry Williams, the driver of the tractor-trailer, or H.D. Campbell, the owner of the 1964 Ford Sedan in which Appellant Saucier was sitting at the time he was injured.

Appellant Saucier sustained bruises and abrasions of the neck and head, fractured ribs, laceration of the right elbow, a severe sprain of his neck and cervical spine and lower lumbar region. The humerus, the bone between the elbow and the shoulder, of his right arm was fractured. Dr. Francis R. Conn, an orthopedic surgeon, performed an operation on February 3, 1965, using the open reduction method, and inserted two steel pins on the inside of the bone. After the bone had knitted, Dr. Conn, on June 11, 1965, operated again, this time removing the pins.

Saucier was 56 years old at the time of the accident, and was earning $240 per month as night marshal of the Town of Lumberton. He went back to work at his old job of night marshal on July 1, 1965, after being incapacitated for over five months. He incurred medical and hospital expenses of $1,287.80. Dr. Conn testified that Saucier will continue to have a 20 to 25 per cent overall limitation of his right arm.

The jury possibly intended to return a $15,000 verdict in favor of the appellant, but the form of their verdict is such that they have actually returned a verdict totalling $5,000 against three joint tort-feasors.

As was stated in the Appellant's Brief, the law of Mississippi has been settled for a long time that in actions based on joint negligence of several tort-feasors, a separate verdict against each defendant cannot be rendered; there must be one verdict rendered against all defendants whom the jury finds liable. Now a jury can determine which defendants are liable and which are not, as they did in this case. It was proper for them to leave out Henry Williams and H.D.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

George Ready, II v. RWI Transportation, LLC
203 So. 3d 590 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2016)
Margaret Byrd v. Kenneth Stubbs
190 So. 3d 26 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2016)
James Terry Campbell v. James Jones
200 So. 3d 1126 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2016)
Debra Bartley-Rice v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company
172 So. 3d 1227 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2014)
Johnson v. Cumberland
91 So. 3d 646 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2012)
Baham v. Sullivan
924 So. 2d 580 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2005)
HWCC-Tunica, Inc. v. Jenkins
908 So. 2d 150 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2004)
Mississippi Dept. of Transp. v. Johnson
873 So. 2d 108 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2004)
Eckman v. Moore
876 So. 2d 975 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2004)
Walter W. Eckman v. Linda Michelle Moore
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2002
Boyd v. Continental Baking Co.
887 F. Supp. 913 (N.D. Mississippi, 1995)
Sweeney v. Preston
642 So. 2d 332 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1994)
Breland, by and Through Breland v. United States
791 F. Supp. 1128 (S.D. Mississippi, 1990)
M & M Pipe & Pres. Vessel Fab., Inc. v. Roberts
531 So. 2d 615 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1988)
Touche Ross & Co. v. Commercial Union Ins. Co.
514 So. 2d 315 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1987)
Adams v. Green
474 So. 2d 577 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1985)
Jesco, Inc. v. Shannon
451 So. 2d 694 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1984)
Roche v. Egan
433 A.2d 757 (Supreme Judicial Court of Maine, 1981)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
203 So. 2d 299, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/saucier-v-walker-miss-1967.