Pirkey v. Grubb's

94 S.E. 344, 122 Va. 91, 1917 Va. LEXIS 86
CourtSupreme Court of Virginia
DecidedNovember 15, 1917
StatusPublished

This text of 94 S.E. 344 (Pirkey v. Grubb's) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Virginia primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Pirkey v. Grubb's, 94 S.E. 344, 122 Va. 91, 1917 Va. LEXIS 86 (Va. 1917).

Opinion

Prentis, J.,

delivered the opinion of the. court.

At its 1912 session, the General Assembly of Virginia passed an act in these words:

“An act to permit the county of Rockingham, through its board of supervisors, to accept donations and trusts made for benevolent or charitable objects of a public character [93]*93within its territorial limits, and to perform such conditions and execute such trusts as may be connected with the same. Approved February 29, 1912.
“Whereas a citizen of this Commonwealth has manifested a desire by his last will and testament to bestow his estate, or a part thereof, upon the county of Rockingham, on condition that said county shall forever pay interest on the amount received by it to the Rockingham Memorial Hospital, a corporation without capital stock, incorporated to establish and conduct' a hospital in the town of Harrison-burg, in the said county, the interest so paid to be applied by the hospital authorities to the discharge of the expenses in the hospital of indigent patients from the county of Rockingham and the town of Harrisonburg; and some doubt existing as to the legal competency of a county of this State to accept a gift of the sort proposed; and it being deemed to be in accordance with sound public policy and the public good to sanction and permit the acceptance of a gift of the sort so proposed, or others of a like or similar character or object; therefore,
“1. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of Virginia, That the coiinty of Rockingham shall be capable, through its board of supervisors, to accept any donation or any trust made for benevolent or charitable objects of a public nature, not religious or sectarian, within its external territorial limits, and to perform such conditions and execute such trusts as may be imposed upon it by the terms of the instrument by which the donation is made or the trust is created.
“No such gift or trust, if accepted by the board of supervisors, shall be declared or held to be void for insufficient designation of the beneficiaries or uncertainty as to the objects thereof, but in all such cases the gift, grant, devise or bequest, as the case may be, shall be valid; and in any case where, under the principles now governing "in [94]*94courts of equity, the objects or beneficiaries of the donation or trust are so undefined or uncertain as not to admit of specific enforcement or administration by a court of equity, the same, if accepted by the county authorities, shall be administered or executed so as to effectuate as nearly as may be the intent or object of the donor or founder.” (Acts 1912, p. 111).

On the 11th day of May, 1912, R. M. Grubb made his last will and testament, the pertinent parts of which are:

“I, R. M. Grubb, of the county of Rockingham, in the State of Virginia, do make, publish and declare this to be my last will and testament:
' “I will and direct that all my property, both real and personal, shall 'be sold by my executor at public sale to the highest bidder, and that all my just debts and funeral expenses be paid as soon after my decease as practicable.
“I bequeath an annuity of sixty dollars‘a year, to be paid semi-annually during her lifetime, to Clementine Thompson, who served faithfully' during the last illness of my mother and sister and has since been my housekeeper; this annuity to be paid out of the income of my estate; and as a first charge upon it, by the Rockingham Memorial Hospital, hereinafter mentioned. * * *
“I give and bequeath all the residue of my estate to the county of Rockingham on condition that said county shall forever pay interest, at the rate of six per centum per annum, on the amount received by it, payable semi-annually to the Rockingham Memorial Hospital, a corporation duly incorporated under the laws of Virginia, now equipping a hospital in the town of Harrisonburg, the said hospital to pay the annuity aforesaid to Clementine Thompson during her lifetime out of the interest or income so received by it, and apply the residue of such interest or income to the support or maintenance in its hospital of indigent patients from the county of Rockingham and the town of Harrison-[95]*95burg, the hospital authorities to provide by means of such by-laws, rules and regulations as they may see fit to adopt the benefits of this fund, it being my desire and intent, as far as my substance will suffice, to provide the means of furnishing hospital advantages to indigent persons of the county and town who may have need of the same, leaving it to the hospital authorities to ascertain or determine the individual beneficiaries of this fund. The benefits of this fund, however, to be apportioned between indigent patients from the county, and indigent patients from the town in proportion to population.
“In case the county of Rockingham should decline the bequest made by this, my will, of the same should fail for any cause, then and in that event, I give and bequeath the whole of my estate, left after the payment of my debts and funeral expenses, and the satisfaction of the provisions for the cemetery fence, to the said The Rockingham Memorial Hospital, the same to be placed at interest in the safest and best paying securities and the interest or income to be applied as hereinbefore provided.
“And in the event that the bequests hereinbefore made to The Rockingham Memorial (that is the bequest of the interest to be paid by the county of Rockingham, or, in case that should fail, the bequest of my whole estate made in the clause immediately preceding this one) for the uses specified should fail or be defeated on the ground of uncertainty, as to the individual beneficiaries, or for any other cause or reason whatsoever, then and in that event, I give and bequeath the whole of my estate left after the payment of my debts and funeral expenses, and the satisfaction of the provisions for the cemetery fence aforesaid, to the said The Rockingham Memorial Hospital without condition, limitation or qualification of any sort whatsoever, except that the said corporation shall pay the annuity aforesaid to Clementine Thompson.
[96]*96“I hereby revoke all words or clauses in this will giving any part of the principal of my estate to the Rockingham Memorial Hospital.”

Codicil to the Within Will.

“I hereby alter the conditions of the bequest to the county and limit the rate of interest to four per centum per annum on the entire amount which it may receive.
“In case that the county of Rockingham should refuse the gift of the residue of my estate after paying annuity to Clementine Thompson and the bequest to the cemetery, I then give the same to Miss Fannie Pirkey, daughter of Albert and Amanda Amanda Pirkey, of near Massanutton Springs, in Rockingham county, Va. Provided she pays the two former bequests made in this my will.”

The testator died in January, 1913. On the 7th day of April, 1914, the board of supervisors of Rockingham county, against the protest of counsel for the appellant, Fannie V. Pirkey, passed a resolution in these words:

“It appearing to the board that the greater portion of the Grubb estate is in the hands of the executor ready for disbursement and that Dr.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Button v. State Corp. Commission
54 S.E. 769 (Supreme Court of Virginia, 1906)
Commonwealth v. Henry
65 S.E. 570 (Supreme Court of Virginia, 1909)
City of Lynchburg v. County of Amherst
80 S.E. 117 (Supreme Court of Virginia, 1913)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
94 S.E. 344, 122 Va. 91, 1917 Va. LEXIS 86, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/pirkey-v-grubbs-va-1917.