Pilcher v. State

296 So. 2d 682
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedJune 4, 1974
Docket47664
StatusPublished
Cited by9 cases

This text of 296 So. 2d 682 (Pilcher v. State) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Pilcher v. State, 296 So. 2d 682 (Mich. 1974).

Opinion

296 So.2d 682 (1974)

James PILCHER
v.
STATE of Mississippi.

No. 47664.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

June 4, 1974.
Rehearing Denied July 15, 1974.

*683 R. Jess Brown, James E. Winfield, John C. Brittain, Jr., Jackson, for appellant.

A.F. Summer, Atty. Gen. by Ben H. Walley, Asst. Atty. Gen. and Karen Gilfoy, Sp. Asst. Atty. Gen., Jackson, for appellee.

ROBERTSON, Justice:

James Pilcher, an 18-year-old black male, was indicted, tried and convicted in the Circuit Court of Carroll County of the murder of Mrs. Eugenia James, a 49-year-old white female. The jury returned a verdict of guilty as charged, and the court sentenced the defendant to death by lethal gas. Pilcher appeals from the verdict and sentence.

The facts are undisputed. About 5:30 P.M., February 12, 1971, in Carrollton, Mississippi, Pilcher caught a ride with Mrs. James. The temperature was around freezing and a fine misty rain mixed with snow and sleet was falling. According to Sheriff Lagrone Nunley of Carroll County, to whom the defendant confessed about 4:00 P.M., February 13, 1971, this is what happened:

"He said — I caught a ride with Mrs. James last night. I got in the back seat and we were riding up the road and, when I came to these woods, I just lost my head. I picked up an oil can and hit Mrs. James back of the head. It caused her to wreck the car and she ran off the road. Then, I opened my knife and put it on Mrs. James and forced her out of the car into the road. He said — she was screaming and begging me not to do this and I still put the knife on her and made her go down to the fence and she said — you ought not to do this to me. So, I reached around her waist and held the knife against her waist and put my foot on the wire and held up the other wire *684 and told Mrs. James to crawl through. She got on through and, at that time, I forced her down into the woods and, when I got down to the woods, I tore her girdle off and her underclothes and told her, with the knife on her, for her to lay down on the ground. She was still screaming and hollering and begging me not to do it. Then, we scuffled around there and he said — we had an awful struggle — struggling around on the ground there and finally Mrs. James rolled over out from under him and he began stabbing her — and I said — James, how many times did you stab her — and he said — one time, I think. He said he couldn't be sure — that it might have been four or five times I might have, Mr. Nunley, I don't know. He said — as I got up, she was lying still on the ground — just lying there still — and I got up and walked down through the woods and went up on the road and walked by Mr. Pete Holiman's place and threw the knife up on the left bank of the road. I walked on down the road and Mr. Tingle picked me up down about Mr. Stratton's house and brought me into town. Then I said — what did you do then. He said he was there in town and he got Sack — I call him Sack — his name is Willie Roy McNelson. He said — I paid him to carry me out to my brother's house to change those pants and Willie Roy also brought him back to town."

Mrs. James was found about midnight on February 12th and was taken to the emergency room of the Greenwood-Leflore County Hospital. Dr. Raymond W. Browning testified that she was unconscious when brought to the emergency room about 1:00 A.M., February 13th, and his diagnosis was:

"[S]hock and hypothermia secondary to multiple injuries and to exposure to extreme weather conditions or adverse weather conditions."

She lived until March 17, 1971, and died without ever regaining consciousness. Dr. Browning further testified:

"[T]he primary cause of death was a severe brain injury and contributing or secondary causes were exposure to cold, multiple stabbings in the chest and pneumonia."

Dr. Browning stated that she was stabbed seven times, four times in the front chest and three times in the back, with all stab wounds penetrating the thoracic cavity and some penetrating her lungs. Dr. Browning described the blow that inflicted the brain injury in this way:

"She had an extremely severe scalp laceration and a fracture of her skull which was visible on the exposed skull and the fracture was not depressed — just a crack in the skull and the scalp on the entire left side of the head had been detached and was dropping down to the left side exposing approximately half of the skull as well as a part of her face below.
"Q Can you tell the jury, in your opinion, what was the cause of the severe lacerations that exposed her skull?
"A A blow by a blunt instrument."

Clifford Lemley testified that he saw appellant get into Mrs. James' car in front of a store in Carrollton about 5:30 P.M. He followed them for about a mile, until he turned off in another direction. Mike Tingle testified that he was traveling towards Carrollton about 6:45 P.M. when he came upon appellant walking along the road; Tingle picked him up and gave him a ride into town. Elmer Wilson and Alec Beckwith, Jr. saw appellant in Price's Store sometime between 7:00 and 8:00 P.M. and both noticed stains or spots on his trousers.

Willie McNelson, a friend of appellant, testified that appellant paid him to take him to his brother's house to change *685 clothes. McNelson further testified that the stains on the appellant's pants appeared to be blood stains. After appellant changed his pants, McNelson brought him back to town about 8:30 P.M. The next day, Guy Lee Pilcher, appellant's 25-year-old brother, on the advice of his uncle, Buddy Swims, stopped Sheriff Nunley and told him that he had appellant's trousers at his house. They drove to his house and Guy Lee gave the pants to the sheriff.

Herman L. Parrish, Toxicologist of the Mississippi Crime Lab, testified that soil samples taken from the knees of these pants and from knee depressions in the ground where Mrs. James and the appellant struggled were microscopically and spectrographically identical.

There was testimony by M.A. Bass, Jr., a criminologist with the Mississippi Crime Lab, that fibers from appellant's sweater were identical with fibers found on Mrs. James' coat, and that Negroid hair fragments found on the appellant's sweater were identical with those found on Mrs. James' sweater, her slip and girdle.

The assignment of errors filed by the appellant recites:

"I. The 4 month delay between the time of arrest and the date of indictment in which the defendant was never taken before a magistrate, constitutes a grossly unreasonable delay resulting in the denial of due process as guaranteed by the 14th amendment, § 26 of the Mississippi Constitution and § 99-3-17 of the Mississippi Code.
"II. The Honorable Marshall Perry, a publically self-declared segregationist, who exhibited overt hostility toward the defendant and his attorneys, ought to have recused himself upon request by the defense.
III. The trial judge blatantly deprived the defendant of his right to exclude illegally obtained evidence by summarily denying him a full and effective suppression hearing.
"IV. When the Defendant, a black man charged with the rape and murder of a white woman in a sparsely populated rural county, showed that knowledge of the incident had widely spread throughout the county resulting in violent emotional tension and prejudgment of the case along racially polarized lines, the trial court erred when it refused to change the venue.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

James Pilcher v. State of Mississippi
Mississippi Supreme Court, 1997
Lanier v. State
533 So. 2d 473 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1988)
Lambert v. State
524 So. 2d 576 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1988)
Clemons v. State
482 So. 2d 1102 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1985)
Johnson v. State
476 So. 2d 1195 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1985)
Ethridge v. State
418 So. 2d 798 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1982)
State v. Harriston
253 S.E.2d 685 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1979)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
296 So. 2d 682, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/pilcher-v-state-miss-1974.