Oceanographic Commission v. O'Brien

447 P.2d 707, 74 Wash. 2d 904, 1968 Wash. LEXIS 842
CourtWashington Supreme Court
DecidedNovember 21, 1968
Docket39914
StatusPublished
Cited by13 cases

This text of 447 P.2d 707 (Oceanographic Commission v. O'Brien) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Washington Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Oceanographic Commission v. O'Brien, 447 P.2d 707, 74 Wash. 2d 904, 1968 Wash. LEXIS 842 (Wash. 1968).

Opinions

Hamilton, J.

This is an original mandamus proceeding. Plaintiffs seek to compel defendants, the State Treasurer and the Budget Director, to honor certain vouchers, and to execute, issue and honor warrants thereon in payment of expenses incurred by six members of the Oceanographic Commission of Washington. The defendants’ refusal to make these payments is based upon the fact that these six members of the commission were also members of the fortieth (1967) state legislature which created the commission [906]*906through enactment of Laws of 1967, ch. 243. Because of this fact, defendants contend the respective legislative-members of the commission are constitutionally ineligible to serve upon the commission during the remainder of their present terms of office. Defendants predicate this contention upon the language of article 2, section 13 of the state constitution, which provides:

No member of the legislature, during the term for which he is elected, shall be appointed or elected to any civil office in the state, which shall have been created, or the emoluments of which shall have been increased, during the term for which he was elected.

The question thus presented is whether membership on the Oceanographic Commission constitutes a holding of “civil office.”

Generally speaking, the basic considerations, and a starting point, in determining the character of a public office, e.g., whether it is a “civil office,” are the purposes of its creation and the nature of its duties and functions. State ex rel. Brown v. Blew, 20 Wn.2d 47, 145 P.2d 554 (1944); State ex rel. Johnston v. Melton, 192 Wash. 379, 73 P.2d 1334 (1937); 67 C.J.S. Officers § 2 (a) at 99.

With this in mind we turn to the pertinent legislation.

Laws of 1967, ch. 243, § 1, declares that this state’s unsullied seacoast and Puget Sound area

presents a natural base for expanding efforts to uncover and utilize the potentially rich food, oil and mineral natural resources of the western Pacific Ocean continental shelf, to locate and harvest abundant fish and marine life, to develop fish farms and aquatic agriculture through the utilization of the estuaries and bays of Puget Sound, to conduct studies of marine and aquatic life, to research and' develop seafood uses and seafood processing plants, to locate a temperate zone marine laboratory, to collect and distribute living marine organisms for marine and biological research, and to conduct research into weather forecasting and modification.

The legislation then points out that a permanent organization is essential to fully exploit the strategic position of [907]*907the state as a base for the listed activities, with appropriate regard for

the ancillary needs of providing planned waterfront development, public recreation, conservation, and prevention of water pollution ....

Against the backdrop of these asserted objectives, section 2 proceeds to create the Oceanographic Commission. It provides, among other things, that the commission will be composed of 12 members, three of whom are to be appointed from the state Senate by the President of the Senate, and three of whom are to be appointed from the House of Representatives by the Speaker of the House. It further provides that members of the commission are to serve without compensation, although reimbursement for necessary travel and other expenses incurred in the performance of their duties is authorized.

Section 4 of the act enumerates the powers, duties and functions of the commission as follows:

(1) Encourage, assist, develop and maintain a coordinated program in oceanography for the benefit of the citizens of the state and the nation;
(2) Encourage private industrial enterprise to utilize the Puget Sound area as a base for oceanographic work;
(3) Promote national interest in Puget Sound as a base for national oceanographic programs;
(4) Assist in developing educational programs to provide the professional and technical graduates required by oceanographic expansion in the area;
(5) Undertake projects designed to inform the citizenry of the importance of oceanography to the development of the area;
(6) Assist in the study of problems of waterfront development, pollution, and parks and recreation areas for public use;
(7) Accept funds, gifts, bequests, and devises from any lawful source given or made available for the purposes of this act, including but not limited to grants of funds made with or without a matching requirement by the federal government;
[908]*908(8) Encourage, supplement and assist the development of programs under the National Sea Grant College and Program Act of 1966 by the University of Washington and other participating educational institutions of the state and region. The programs and mission of the commission and its institute are not to be in duplication of the existing program of the University of Washington or other educational institutions of the state in oceanographic research, training or public service, or of the program developed under the National Sea Grant College and Program Act of 1966.
(9) Make annual reports to the Washington State Legislature, or to the appropriate interim committee thereof, all activities undertaken in connection with the power, duties and functions assigned in this section together with any recommendations for new legislation designed to accomplish the purposes of this act.
(10) Delegate in its discretion and to the extent permitted by the state Constitution, any of the powers and duties set forth in subsections (1) through (8) to the Oceanographic Institute of Washington formed pursuant to section 5 of this act.

By section 5 of the act, the commission, in the furtherance of its duties and functions, is authorized to form a nonprofit corporation under the provisions of and with the powers provided by ECW 24.04,1 with members of the commission being members and trustees of the corporation together with such additional trustees, not exceeding 20 in all, as a majority of the commission members shall accept. [909]*909This corporation, pursuant to this section of the law, shall be designated as the Oceanographic Institute of Washington and is empowered to coordinate, promote and carry out such policies for oceanographic programs and development as may be advised, consented to and formulated by the commission. Furthermore, the corporation is authorized to accept, use and expend such public funds as are lawfully made available to it, and to exercise such other powers and duties as the commission may legally delegate to it.

Following enactment of Laws of 1967, ch. 243, the legislature by Laws of 1967, Ex. Ses., ch. 143, § 1, appropriated the sum of $150,000 to finance the operations of the commission for the 1967-1969 biennium.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

State Ex Rel. Rist v. Underwood
524 S.E.2d 179 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1999)
Miller v. City of Tacoma
138 Wash. 2d 318 (Washington Supreme Court, 1999)
Latham v. Molpus
642 So. 2d 1340 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1994)
Vreeland v. Byrne
370 A.2d 825 (Supreme Court of New Jersey, 1977)
Warwick v. State Ex Rel. Chance
548 P.2d 384 (Alaska Supreme Court, 1976)
Anderson v. Chapman
543 P.2d 229 (Washington Supreme Court, 1975)
Hsieh v. Civil Service Commission of Seattle
488 P.2d 515 (Washington Supreme Court, 1971)
Oceanographic Commission v. O'Brien
447 P.2d 707 (Washington Supreme Court, 1968)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
447 P.2d 707, 74 Wash. 2d 904, 1968 Wash. LEXIS 842, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/oceanographic-commission-v-obrien-wash-1968.