McMillan v. Puckett

678 So. 2d 652, 1996 WL 255465
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedMay 16, 1996
Docket94-IA-00166-SCT
StatusPublished
Cited by35 cases

This text of 678 So. 2d 652 (McMillan v. Puckett) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
McMillan v. Puckett, 678 So. 2d 652, 1996 WL 255465 (Mich. 1996).

Opinion

678 So.2d 652 (1996)

Dr. Beverly A. McMILLAN and Mississippi Baptist Medical Center
v.
Thomas D. PUCKETT and Tamara L. Puckett, Individually and on Behalf of the Wrongful Death Heirs of Sandra L. Puckett, Deceased.

No. 94-IA-00166-SCT.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

May 16, 1996.
Rehearing Denied August 22, 1996.

*653 Al Nuzzo, Markow Walker Reeves & Anderson, Jackson; Alan C. Goodman, Williams Jelliffe & Arnold, Ridgeland; Cary E. Bufkin, Eugene R. Naylor, Shell Buford Bufkin Callicutt & Perry, Jackson, for appellants.

Crymes G. Pittman, Robert G. Germany, Pittman Germany Roberts & Welsh, Jackson, for appellees.

En Banc.

McRAE, Justice, for the Court:

In this Interlocutory Appeal from an order of the Leake County Circuit Court denying the appellants' motion for a change of venue, we are asked to consider where venue is proper in a wrongful death action. We find that the circuit court correctly ruled that venue was proper in Leake County, where Sandra Puckett died, and conclude that a wrongful death action may be brought in the county where the death occurred, thus commencing the cause of action, or in the county where the wrongful act causing the death took place pursuant to Miss. Code Ann. § 11-11-3, which provides that venue is proper where the cause of action occurred or accrued.

I.

Thomas and Tamara Puckett filed a wrongful death action in the Leake County Circuit Court on December 8, 1992, seeking damages for the death of their infant daughter, Sandra Puckett. The complaint alleged that after Tamara Puckett was admitted to the Mississippi Baptist Medical Center in labor on June 29, 1991, Dr. McMillan was negligent in her examination and treatment of the mother and her yet unborn child; that Dr. McMillan failed to advise the Pucketts of the risks associated with the various medical procedures performed upon both mother and baby and failed to obtain their informed consent; and that the Medical Center, through its employees, was negligent in its treatment of both Tamara and Sandra Puckett. The negligent acts, deviations from the standard of care, and lack of informed consent which occurred on June 29, 1991 in Hinds County, Mississippi, are alleged to have resulted ultimately in the infant's death on December 31, 1991 in Leake County, Mississippi, causing the Puckett family extreme mental anguish and anxiety.

Dr. McMillan resides in and practices medicine in Hinds County, Mississippi. The Medical Center, likewise has its sole place of business in Hinds County. Consequently, the defendants moved for a change of venue from Leake County to the First Judicial District of Hinds County. That motion was denied on August 20, 1993. The circuit court found that the cause of action had accrued in Leake County and therefore, that venue was proper there. Dr. McMillan then requested certification for an interlocutory appeal which was denied by the trial court but subsequently granted by this Court. McMillan v. Puckett, 641 So.2d 757 (Miss. 1994).

*654 II.

Dr. McMillan and the Medical Center contend that venue is proper only in Hinds County, where the events that are alleged to have caused Sandra Puckett's death took place, and not in Leake County, where she died. We disagree.

Wrongful death action in Mississippi are controlled by Miss. Code Ann. § 11-7-13, which, in relevant part, provides:

Whenever the death of any person shall be caused by any real, wrongful or negligent act or omission ... as would, if death had not ensued, have entitled the party injured or damaged thereby to maintain an action and recover damages in respect thereof ... and such deceased person shall have left a widow or children or both, or husband or father or mother, or sister, or brother, the person or corporation, or both that would have been liable if death had not ensued, and the representatives of such person shall be liable for damages, notwithstanding the death....

The statute makes no provision for the venue of such actions. Instead, we turn to the general venue statute, Miss Code Ann. § 11-11-3, which provides for venue as follows:

Civil actions of which the circuit court has original jurisdiction shall be commenced in the county in which the defendant or any of them may be found or in the county where the cause of action may occur or accrue and, if the defendant is a domestic corporation, in the county in which said corporation is domiciled or in the county where the cause of action may occur or accrue ...

It is the phrase "where the cause of action may occur or accrue" that serves as a point of consternation between the parties. Dr. McMillan and the Medical Center urge a narrow construction of the phrase to mean where the alleged act of negligence occurred. The Pucketts, on the other hand, champion an interpretation consistent with our finding of when a wrongful death cause of action accrues for purposes of the statute of limitations. We have no question that venue is proper in Hinds County, where the individual defendant may be found and where the defendant corporation is domiciled. At issue, therefore, is whether venue is also proper in Leake County, where Sandra Puckett died, as well as in Hinds County, where the injuries that are alleged to have caused her death were inflicted.

A tort is not complete until an injury occurs. Smith v. Temco, Inc., 252 So.2d 212, 216 (Miss. 1971). In this, as in any other wrongful death action brought pursuant to Miss. Code Ann. § 11-7-13 (1972), there is no injury, and hence, no cause of action until a death occurs. Sweeney v. Preston, 642 So.2d 332, 336 (Miss. 1994); Gentry v. Wallace, 606 So.2d 1117, 1123 (Miss. 1992). Thus, for statute of limitations purposes, we have found that a wrongful death action cannot accrue prior to the death of the decedent. Gentry, 606 So.2d at 1123. No distinction can be made between when an action accrues and where it accrues. Accordingly, while the Pucketts might have been able to bring a negligence or a malpractice action for the injuries caused to Mrs. Puckett and their daughter prior to the infant's death, a wrongful death cause of action did not accrue until December 31, 1991 in Leake County. Only then and there did they have an actionable claim for Sandra's death against Dr. McMillan and the Medical Center.

In Owens-Illinois, Inc. v. Edwards, 573 So.2d 704, 706 (Miss. 1990), wherein we found that a cause of action accrued only when illness was discovered in asbestosis cases and not when the plaintiff was first exposed to the toxic substance, we stated that "[a] cause of action accrues only when it comes into existence as an enforceable claim; that is when the right to sue becomes vested." Applying that principle in the wrongful death context as we did in Sweeney and Preston, the Montana Supreme Court recently applied its finding that a cause of action for wrongful death did not accrue until a death occurred, rather than at the time of the wrongful conduct that caused the death, for purposes of the statute of limitations, to the same venue question now before this Court. Gabriel v. School District Number 4, Libby, Montana, 264 Mont. 177, 179-180, 870 P.2d 1351

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Katherine Grace Short v. Darren Versiga
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2019
Caves v. Yarbrough
991 So. 2d 142 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2008)
Bullock v. Lott
964 So. 2d 1119 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2007)
In Re Estate of Beckley
961 So. 2d 707 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2007)
Irene Caves v. Benjamin Yarbrough
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2006
BOLIVAR LEFLORE MED. ALLIANCE v. Williams
938 So. 2d 1222 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2006)
Beckley v. Beckley
961 So. 2d 712 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2006)
Mississippi Dept. of Transp. v. Allred
928 So. 2d 152 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2006)
Ronald A. Bullock v. W. L. Lott
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2005
Clarence Beckley v. John Beckley
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2005
Black v. Ansah
876 So. 2d 395 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2003)
Sunderland v. R.A. Barlow Homebuilders
791 A.2d 384 (Superior Court of Pennsylvania, 2002)
Wayne General Hospital v. Wanda Hayes
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2001
Schmidt v. Shearer
995 P.2d 381 (Court of Appeals of Kansas, 1999)
LW v. McComb Separate Mun. School Dist.
754 So. 2d 1136 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1999)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
678 So. 2d 652, 1996 WL 255465, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/mcmillan-v-puckett-miss-1996.