Matter of Estate of West

887 P.2d 222, 269 Mont. 83, 51 State Rptr. 1409, 1994 Mont. LEXIS 322
CourtMontana Supreme Court
DecidedDecember 20, 1994
Docket94-252
StatusPublished
Cited by10 cases

This text of 887 P.2d 222 (Matter of Estate of West) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Montana Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Matter of Estate of West, 887 P.2d 222, 269 Mont. 83, 51 State Rptr. 1409, 1994 Mont. LEXIS 322 (Mo. 1994).

Opinions

JUSTICE WEBER

delivered the Opinion of the Court.

This is an appeal from the District Court of the Thirteenth Judicial District, Yellowstone County, of an order establishing a limited guardianship and terminating the general guardianship of Don C. West. The order also continued a conservatorship with Norwest Capital Management and denied a joint petition from the protected person, his guardian and the conservator to substitute the conservatorship with a trust. We affirm.

The questions for review are:

I. Did the District Court err in establishing a limited guardianship?

II. Did the District Court err in denying the joint petition to terminate the conservatorship?

Don C. West (Don) is a “protected person” whose personal and financial interests have been managed by his mother, Mary Lou West, as guardian, and Norwest Capital Management Co.-Montana, formerly Northwestern Union Trust Co., as conservator, since 1978. In October of 1976, Don sustained severe injuries in a motor vehicle [85]*85accident in New Mexico, when a vehicle in which he was a passenger collided with an oil tanker. As a result of this accident, Don suffered extensive physical injuries, including bums, blindness and head and leg injuries. He suffers from motor difficulties in his legs and has some deformity in his legs and ankles which requires him to wear braces. His head injuries caused some mental impairment and he has also lost physical sensitivity in his fingers because of bums.

Following the accident, Don remained in a coma for over three months. In November of 1976, a New Mexico state court declared Don an incompetent person “until such time he is able, unassisted to properly manage and take care of himself and his property.” The New Mexico court also appointed his mother, Mary Lou West, as guardian ad litem. In her capacity as guardian ad litem, Mary Lou West initiated a personal injury suit in New Mexico on Don’s behalf. The lawsuit resulted in a negotiated settlement in the spring of 1978.

In May of 1978, following the settlement, the Montana district court appointed Northwest Union Trust Co., now operating as Nor-west Capital Management & Trust Co.-Montana (Norwest Capital), as conservator of Don’s financial affairs. The conservatorship was initially funded with $463,319. By the end of 1978, after payment of medical expenses and other bills on Don’s behalf, the value of the conservatorship was reduced to $374,323. Social Security Disability Payments have been deposited into the conservatorship during the years of Norwest Capital’s management of Don’s estate. During the years since 1978, the conservatorship has increased in value under Norwest Capital’s management, with the result that at the time of the hearing on this matter, the conservatorship held assets in the amount of $1,084,239. In recent years, the annual income of the conservatorship has consistently exceeded the amount necessary to meet Don’s needs.

In June of 1978, the Montana district court also appointed Mary Lou West as general guardian. Mary Lou West has made several personal care arrangements for her son in the years since 1978. In the last few years, however, she has been increasingly less involved in making such arrangements.

After being released from the hospital in January 1977, Don completed a rehabilitation program at St. Vincent’s Hospital in Billings, Montana. His guardian then placed him in a rehabilitation program for the blind in Topeka, Kansas; followed by the Lighthouse Program for the Blind in Seattle, Washington; and then in High Hopes Brain Trauma Learning Center in Costa Mesa, California. [86]*86After the High Hopes program, Don had live-in assistance in two separate living arrangements in Orange County, California. After being notified by California authorities that the second of those arrangements was unsatisfactory and had to be terminated within two days, Mary Lou West arranged for Don to fly to Billings, where he resided with her for a short time before being enrolled by her in The Villa in Greeley, Colorado.

Don was unhappy with the arrangements made by his mother in Greeley and, after a short time, he enrolled himself in the Colorado Rehabilitation Center, in Denver, Colorado. This program taught mobility, daily living skills, Braille typing and other skills to enable him to live on his own. With the assistance of these rehabilitation programs and physical therapy, Don has gradually recovered and achieved a great deal of self-reliance in many aspects of his life. At the time of the hearing in this matter, he had lived on his own for over a year.

Although Don is now 43 years old, currently lives alone and has learned to be quite self-sufficient, he continues to require some assistance. At the time of the hearing, he employed a personal care manager, who assisted him with safety issues, personal hygiene, social activities and money management. Don hired his care manager after approval from Mary Lou West. The care manager communicates regularly with Mary Lou West concerning Don’s personal affairs. Don has also hired other people — and sometimes fired them when they did not work out satisfactorily — to get his mail, pay his bills, clean his apartment and cook for him. He can cook some meals on his own using a microwave oven, but sensory loss in his fingers causes problems with cooking on an electric range.

Don uses the aid of customer assistance at stores when he purchases his food, clothing and other personal items. He arranges for his own transportation using taxis and can complete sales transactions on his own. However adept he has become, he recognizes that he must rely on the assistance of helpers and recognizes his limitations when it comes to managing his money and making investments. He testified that he knows that he needs assistance in financial matters and appreciates the manner in which Norwest Capital has handled his finances.

All the interested parties in this action agree that Don no longer needs the extensive assistance from others to manage his affairs that he needed at the time the guardianship and conservatorship were established in 1978. Indeed, the District Court emphasized and it is [87]*87clearly evident in the record that Don has made a phenomenal recovery since that time, culminating in his present ability to live independently and to arrange for necessary assistance from third persons without his guardian’s help.

Evidence was presented at the hearing from several physicians to establish that Don no longer needs extensive assistance and to establish that he is capable of managing many of his personal affairs. However, the evidence also established that he has some “mental status abnormalities” consistent with the head injury he suffered in the 1976 accident and that some aspects of his personality are impaired due to the head injury as well. The physician preparing the report for purposes of this proceeding stated that Don suffers extremely gross deficits in information gathering (primarily due to the blindness), markedly impaired concentration, slightly impaired memory and markedly impaired mathematical skills. Despite these deficits, Don has recovered remarkably well and is able to live a relatively normal life. He brought this action to terminate the guardianship as he believes he no longer needs assistance in his daily living arrangements and feels he can handle such matters on his own.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

In re the Estate of M.D.
2017 MT 22 (Montana Supreme Court, 2017)
Matter of M.D.
2017 MT 22 (Montana Supreme Court, 2017)
In re J. A. L.
2014 MT 196 (Montana Supreme Court, 2014)
In Re the Guardianship & Conservatorship of Anderson
2009 MT 344 (Montana Supreme Court, 2009)
Stave v. Estate of Rutledge
2005 MT 332 (Montana Supreme Court, 2005)
In Re Co-Guardianship of D.A.
2004 MT 302 (Montana Supreme Court, 2004)
In Re the Marriage of Denowh
2003 MT 244 (Montana Supreme Court, 2003)
In Re the Estate of Prescott
2000 MT 200 (Montana Supreme Court, 2000)
Matter of Estate of West
887 P.2d 222 (Montana Supreme Court, 1994)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
887 P.2d 222, 269 Mont. 83, 51 State Rptr. 1409, 1994 Mont. LEXIS 322, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/matter-of-estate-of-west-mont-1994.