Mackechnie v. Lyders

279 N.W. 328, 134 Neb. 682, 1938 Neb. LEXIS 94
CourtNebraska Supreme Court
DecidedApril 29, 1938
DocketNo. 30250
StatusPublished
Cited by8 cases

This text of 279 N.W. 328 (Mackechnie v. Lyders) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Nebraska Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Mackechnie v. Lyders, 279 N.W. 328, 134 Neb. 682, 1938 Neb. LEXIS 94 (Neb. 1938).

Opinion

Messmore, J.

This is an appeal from the district court for Dodge county in a law action to recover damages for personal injuries on account of defendants’ negligence. The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff, and from such verdict defendants have appealed.

Plaintiff’s petition alleges ownership of the bus in defendant Lyders, the occurrence of the accident, the driving of the bus by defendant Lyman as an employee of defendant Lyders, and alleges certain acts of negligence on the part of Lyman, the injuries sustained by plaintiff, and prays for damages. The answer of defendant Lyders admits the occurrence of the accident; that the plaintiff sustained injuries; alleges certain affirmative acts of contributory negligence on the part of the plaintiff, and denies ownership, of the bus in Lyders. The answer of defendant Lyman is to the same effect. Both answers deny negligence on the part of defendants. The reply is, in substance, a general denial of defendants’ answers.

The evidence discloses that Professor Lyders was the head of the music department of Midland College, Fremont, Nebraska; that defendant Lyman was a student in such college, and the plaintiff was an employee of the college, being an assistant to Professor Lyders. In April, 1936, a trip was planned to transport the acappella choir, consisting of 65 members, by two automobiles and two busses through certain parts of the state of Texas on a concert tour. On April 19, 1936, the choir had given a concert at Fort Worth, Texas, and was about to give another concert at Denton, Texas, approximately 35 miles distant, at 8 o’clock on the same evening. To be present in Denton for the concert required some haste on the part of the members of the choir. The 1928 Studebaker bus, in which the plaintiff was riding and which defendant Lyman was driving at the time of the accident, left Fort Worth about 5:30\ p. m. When midway between Fort Worth and Denton, and when the driver of the bus was about to negotiate a curve on an oiled road, the right wheels of the bus followed the [685]*685right shoulder of the road across and over a ditch and into a field where the bus circled and was stopped. Plaintiff fell from the rear door of the bus and was injured.. The: facts will be more specifically covered in this opinion in: relation to certain assignments of error, to which such facts as may be necessary will be applied.

The first four assignments of error are as to the. insufficiency of the evidence to support the verdict; that the verdict is contrary to law, and that the separate motions of defendants for a directed verdict should have been sustained by the trial court.

The ownership of the bus in Lyders is questioned by defendants. The pertinent facts relating to this question, follow: There had been some discussion between Lyders and Doctor Martin, the head of Midland College, relative, to transportation of the choir and athletic teams of the. college to and from different points, and that the hiring of transportation created too much expense on the part of the college. Lyders discovered the 1928 Studebaker bus, involved in this action, in the city of Omaha, took up the matter of purchasing it with Doctor Martin, and both agreed that it was a bargain at the price offered. Doctor Martin, however, stated, in substance, that the college did not have sufficient funds with which to buy the bus; that if Lyders would assume full responsibility for the purchase any profits made from the trips would be used to reimburse Lyders for the moneys expended. Thereafter Lyders purchased the bus, paying for it personally. He borrowed the money from the Fremont State Company, and gave a chattel mortgage on the bus to that company for the loan.

January 21, 1935, the original motor vehicle license, issued to Smith Robinson Motor Company, from whom Lyders purchased the bus, was transferred on the transfer record on the back of the original certificate to Lyders, and signed by Smith Robinson Motor Company of Omaha. Plaintiff’s exhibit Y (defendants’ exhibit 6) is an affidavit signed by Oscar Lyders and sworn to before a notary public on April 2, 1936, wherein he states that he is the [686]*686owner of the bus and petitions the treasurer of Dodge county to issue a license to “Midland College / Oscar Lyders.” The transfer record shows a transfer to Oscar Lyders, and a bill of sale on a regular state of Nebraska form for the transfer of motor vehicles was issued to Oscar Lyders, sworn to before a notary public on January 21, 1935, and contained in the bill of sale were the words “has sold and transferred to Oscar Lyders.” Subsequently, on January 23, in the same bill of sale appears “Midland College Choir, Oscar Lyders, Mgr.,” which is also sworn to before a notary public. The county treasurer of Dodge county on January 23, 1935, issued a motor vehicle license covering the Studebaker bus to Oscar Lyders. The registration fee was paid by Oscar Lyders in the amount of $15. On April 16, 1935, a readjustment was made on the certificate and the sum of $3 was returned. This certificate reads in part: “This certifies that Midland College / Oscar Lyders * * * has registered as owner.” A bus owned by an individual and used for transportation requires a higher registration fee than a bus used by a college or school. The state department had returned to the county treasurer the certificate for collection of the additional, or correct, amount, which was the reason for the showing of Midland College on the certificate. This required an expenditure of $12. April 2, 1936, there was a license or certificate issued reading “This certifies that Midland College / Oscar Lyders of Fremont,” etc. There was no bill of sale of any kind showing the transfer of this property from Oscar Lyders to Midland College of record or filed with the county treasurer, as provided for by law. The registrations were made and paid for by Lyders; whatever personal tax assessed was paid for by him. Lyders individually executed a chattel mortgage to the Fremont State Company on the Studebaker bus, of record in the office of the county clerk, March 30, 1936. This mortgage was made for the.purpose of financing the International bus, a second bus, and it is claimed that Doctor Martin and Mr. Lyders executed the note secured by the mortgage. The note is not in the [687]*687record. The mortgage was signed by Oscar Lyders. At the time of the purchase of the Studebaker bus a chattel mortgage for $275 to the Fremont State Company was filed of record, signed by Oscar Lyders. On September 26, 1936, a chattel mortgage was executed by Oscar Lyders, which included the Studebaker bus. Repairs were made on the Studebaker bus in the amount of $260 which were paid for by Lyders, and subsequent to the New York trip in 1936 there was a general overhauling of the bus, with a new motor and several other mechanical changes being made, requiring an expenditure of $233, paid by Lyders.

The appellants contend that Lyders was the agent of the college, and that the Studebaker bus was purchased for the college, used in its service, and that Lyders had the overseeing of the bus; that he had given a bill of sale for the bus April 15, 1935, and that the registration for the license for the bus discloses that the mark “/” meant “by” and therefore at no time did the registration disclose Lyders as the true owner of the bus. The bill of sale, as testified to by Lyders, was to put the ownership of the property where it belonged. This bill of sale was never filed of record, nor was it filed with the county treasurer of Dodge county as evidence of ownership in the college.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Burt v. Cordover
117 A.2d 116 (District of Columbia Court of Appeals, 1955)
State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance v. Drawbaugh
65 N.W.2d 542 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1954)
Sutton v. Inland Construction Co.
14 N.W.2d 387 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1944)
State Farm Mut. Automobile Ins. v. Mackechnie
114 F.2d 728 (Eighth Circuit, 1940)
Hackbart v. Rohrig
287 N.W. 665 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1939)
Falstaff Brewing Corporation v. Thompson
101 F.2d 301 (Eighth Circuit, 1939)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
279 N.W. 328, 134 Neb. 682, 1938 Neb. LEXIS 94, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/mackechnie-v-lyders-neb-1938.