Kyle Miller v. State

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided April 1, 2015·No. 04-14-00041-CR·Published

Opinion

/\i5.l>H-H-Cfiy\K6

T-NiTi-fe CduPtt cf FWsftus Teas THE fcumi supreme cmoic^lipsrfti&r or TtXR-s

- • on

, ; \-— . -

- 4, ^O :••-- T\ --• ;- CO . .J—

KVLE HXLlEfi -H rw •-».

CD

;.-• ''

— '

-o

Hppellanl *

: r> - f

i

^ ro

CD

\/S. CD '

Appellee-

CiAi^C 10)5. 2&\- CJPr 65C&

6Af^ f^jTO!viXQ,TeX^o ISA)"

"XMrac of AurrttoKrraBs . . . .iih/ii ftMOJCCD/SUPPLeKOOTTEO AWdAHCKJT . .1-9

Tke bVrW\+ disregard 4or pJlcy oni ^rc^We, a^ tuetta^ +lte - -*J Ab ^VEx/^usU bfv&feA/4\\e aA<vu-tW<*e c^4e^^^i^WCak4, . -5

C^THEXQPfTE OF SESUieE, . . -.10

ii

Ekto ftp flmtrftnzcE.'

4t-hd. App>6, t6felhOif. (Texv?_ceo) . - U 'Afifirrl V/.Phi-k.iOrrlC:.

105 5,US ^ M05,W tofe.%,-TLjWr IQ&i 3

iSg Ll.S. SSCvSSSfeCb) , ., , 3

cfn. as. iSBGrid) . . . .2- Ll.S.SL^.CrhCKit'i). CL

Cojq \/. Sfafe. o

<Wl S.CO.. 2d 2foD., X4fe. (YiR, App. RTfo. 3

Qaabiift v/. <U> r o S14 S.lO. 3d 351 C-tex. Qm S:^ Unbnlo^UOJ . .; Ce*\l.. Pi.r-l-m . ^TrSujf>Qrici(SCLvJ.:P.Nfe\r2t;ib) . , .Si

^&lo^6upp.2cl^C€.t).Va.9>£)tS) . . .1 fKrkpf.W\/.l.l..s. U.6.Sup. (M-.ftcoo) .. . . A,S 505 US. ctj- L5£,^, 1, ID. s.&. atttCPfiS) . .1 3ia U.S134,131, <S5 S.Gfcl&S^lOl.eJ/aJ I0&(fafa3) . .3 0li46h VS^'a-I? Cm S.UJ. 2d HWiy^lt.'itfec. Cnm. A$.WS-D. . . 2> 1113x0. tA aW/slfa-nfe. cSv, %. aosJi . . k/2

ill

(Vxrnpr V S33i 665 S. 3. Sd t6C-yf>S8 a. 1&Sc. fWfw4 uW1 lc'S\3, ^ rert) .4,, ? 495u.6.Se>qk6.c34:3X3iq%) . . -V? (9"irWn\/» IxtolhuiririlvP UL6.Suf.Gfc(W$> . . . - .4 ^9rU3i.l\/9-^o\-Qia 94fc bbS-Hs^s, lot- s.cx 199434 L.-&.S. >i aflsCnaSx. .7

UflMm\f.SWigR<, ibLm4sqq(iOP.i3:.9cS4 . . . 3

folSf.ad S5%699GSttiCrcRK) . . -<§

yggjagap \/. 5.3.3 tf(&> S.W.gd 5^5q^56&t. fljf"Ei ft»si l^ . -3 4ib bbs. 93^ 40 b.ex;^i pqq,itso.cs wii ftttft . .I Sfffi.V^ V. l.P|i9s ,_ s r: si ilsd,ac^Cq^Aqsm:i). . . . => :3w?-s3SS3 5443i0/2dlSi/i4^^.CViK, ffyttrfc} . . .3 ^iS.L9^\c4bgCl€y;.%-fi«xM-;\Wiqq3l . - .3 .UfltfBs V. Sbff. 12990.9d MwCaflod). . . . 3

49B blS. 6&,(cflk/ft S.C3 A464, 336(Rig). . .3 LimfatyriAZJ iii"ifli.mh afc6TThJWl5Co\SHffl) . . . .(? Lopez \/ c4Mp Lv3S4^59S(9ec. (W bW9 94iS) J4a13i V, l-liwu-) -

.45

Mf,oP-3/.3WX 49^ 3 9d i62o taq S4gd94 . . . 3 jJdcJWi \/ Rr.TSnP L 96 KId »('C3 4 1^54 . . . 3 38^ U.S.. ia&tma&s.efcs^.-aat 14 LsJL ad J-sfe (fid) • .i

iv

9194 \i lur-lSf-r- 4 n as 493331) . . . . As 430 r.9dii.^fc\4i mi) , . . .%6f° MiirrfiuV..Gyn9r_ 411 U.S. 4%, 41 L.Ed. 3d 3qiy\0o S-99 9634CH&>. •8 Mr,f.i.tf. V feopte 3 43i 1W.3 , 4S0 Q. S. 9(4i5UE4. id P99,'14 3. 04. Iftb Qf\90 , .4*,5> Akffl V- F4o.rUb.iirr. sqir.^i 441344 (ss CjcWM) Duteas, V. S3&3- __ 433. S.bJ.24 341 tex.ftpp.TS4 bQj,SU(J9499 . .1 Pnvb \/. gj a^ o C

595 33i.casC:'ft43.G3 . . , 3/3 3/9 ai'Aieod 351,5406:1!. !%6) - . - 3 fesok \33vi3<, Wl /3j3S4b>(fS444l4) . . , 3 ftjCS \/. Pvi ;,arSrawn

jSS4r^:W, Sdxde 134 S.Ob. 2A ~m t&L FW- Car^usChm£ 2c£4) . .8 SftfUS. Pi 1,111 L3d.03'393 lag &..03 2drt3(ScfiL>. -"\ <9f^4-4 \/l3cs / -N _. 439 S,uX 9x1 aoi frex. ftpp. isV.T^sV. OcVS) • •' ^Sp.mpA^q- \/. fS-6.3 546 6. lO. 2d-icrt/idk-cnCiec. QKw. fipp 141b) . .3 j3sn vi.s. j&3,asaCiW) . - - .2. \osff V.-Skfe N 3.9c- s.lO, ail (otf-KHsu « . . .a S\bbP3>E i39 b.gd.. 31 333C M& . . ,4,5 44^r,?rfVrl V. £&£&. . . 944 a.S..43fo3sS-CS i25a/iaL£i. MeCn4«) . .1 ikrfefl 9X4^. V A-y>.^.. . N 434 U.S./ cd ICfL 1Q.- US/it 6.(1+., q+ 3941, 2tf0l-3{tot( 1449) .3 iinlkdJSkk:-, V. P>Wti - 1ST Jr. 3d £35, fc2fe (34a Ok. 1b\Z) . . .2 3443 33Xh\4333^. 305t93d4inrn^3sQ n Ur,i43 SjafeAZ Bobt&aso . 4S33'34l903b3TL33c9r.3xtt-) . . J iI i P. 3d "10S CChS 1441) . . , .2.

4tb U.S. G48; 19-19X4. 2e:6L3b L.td.2d fcSiCiwO . i.b-S. \/. (--a rem (30P Supp. 2d 9SI ClX/D. KieW. 2m) %4 bbS. 361,645,43 639.465,60 LPX ad 4fa8flcn0 ,1 (PS. U Pm/prq / 364 3 3d 44 COft 6 2£&\) . . • -b LisALSal+zac Sc\6 33dli9C.C(l.^lD^\d) . . . .1

bsS+SSh-MlCsft 4X516) . , . .X 11 6. \/43rii sa +73d 231 (c.a4 \pqq9) . . . 4,s35/6 Vr3n-3v V. Skjg 5S1 S. IX, 3d DlSdaXbldex-bldw.App.lQTO . ,3 \Sl3 /.33-^lk ' . lOS^Sd 43-1(03 6 i4S6) . . . .(e? (,\YdSrr3/.3P-yoel 9b>US3l 1011CCR1 W5) . . - .2,/ 9>95 S. U). 2d 4piSS3-34 fe.6rW.App R18) . .3 LkJa^flAmdoO 9 SPSe. r-P4evo.*s 2>6&lX&4443b.SX2d 329Si S-CSiq^PiqfcS . .S 611.5. IS 3d 462,46%(hex. 33. App.Ofi<S). . .3 •7prWf\/llS. ^S9 U.S. SPfl, 14*4 SlSl 2d 144,13X S-CL-h WltC 9CC(4 .| jlll F3_, SexLxS QuW% e£1SuicWce- Rule 263(0 . . .7 ieyws, -Rules cT PtypeUo-W Q-cceriure-Md-Xbc^ . .3 13xq5 Rules of Anpdlc+e Cac-cSwe-44.2(b4 . .3 3f14Tl/r14=6

FWieJk 3H.Cn, . . , 1 Ar+3U>. 3g.09> . . . . '.5 /'OO^PXTb'aiSKifit. PqrMTSTDk^ "1^^ G^fr\+UVioo, Ar-Uc.W Xi4 ID . . .5,4,8

\/p

UX'i+ecl 5+A+es Cais\i4v,vS^f)/ld»'mi.rl(i(Vie\3"XZ .5,£> l-W-Wcl 3+a-les, Cc/\5\t3+K4v A\WirW3 AZ

P-PA/P32k',MSK3 (3643 S fe tts.c $ 3\u go

VI

(J,S3/(3^S 4/ob U.S. (o% 19-16X4. 2o:>X3b b.SX 3) k6nCfi&4) . (A.-S. \/. P^rrTn (SOP Supp 2d 2SI SCO. Kick. Ittfi) If.66/. HW7a/1 *\CA U.S. 301/315,43 SCX.466,60 L-EX addPlXPnD (36- \/- TWrrq 3S4 3 3d44lCVl6 2^-0 . . . > LLsALSaJ+zer 646 SSd 1110 (bfl ID *dd) . . . 1 U.fi6\96W^

(cSS A3 31961 (3^9 9516) .% l.i S.\;i7ri., 52 XT 3l 2Xn (CA 4 PPiS) . . . .1,3^6^ \/r.3S6,» \/. SP-3 531 5. UX 2d 34<:l/4cC6d(Tex.^dra.Arp.lQ13) , ,3 \XIa\/333P IDS +32d 454(0^61456) . . . ..(p (\VdK^m\/3C-yQel S(Xl22dl01b(0S114S3 . . . .2,3 lkb^tfeo \/- Sb-4y 3S.o5 S. LO. 3d 45i,q33>~64 fe.6f>M.%,p. I4i3 . .3 3S& U.'obPlp? LSd. 2d \c&\, S7 S.tX. Waaftfol) . .S USI</\r3/.Sto4e 311 ,S. IS od 462/46%(lSc. (33 App,3>63). . A 74-v3/blS. n 6m U.S. SSfl,1^4 Ufa! 2d 144,136 S3X. KHfcftoOfc") •gMFS- 70<1\6 6uWs oVAcuXWe- Rule 263(0 . . 3 ieyp& ^ules cT C^iSAe QWwre-44.2(c4 . .3 3xa5 fiu3s of Acpdlc+e bae<~fS(e-44,2(bN) - '

sri43bm=6 ~1e>fts PnAf rC Odivviiv-d VWfrW: i33\c>> 31-01 . . 1 Ar-Vvck. S3.a?> . . . . '.5 ~ ^3PPTbH69>k Iftl. PQ (MT.STn^ l^Xa-^ Gsn-sX^+ud+on, PlrXcW X5 10 . . .5,0,8 1£k&6 Q,*sXS\33ryAr3eWXfl4 . . . Q,

\/p

VI

(J. 3 V. (Wu-, 4(3 U.S. 04s, 1016XX 2c5X?b 1/6=1. 2d Oo iGqg4) . iA.-s. \/. P>n.f6ii (SOP. Supp. 2d 3SI Sen. Kieh. 2fitf0 Ub6..\/.HW7f.,n 404 U.S.- 3C1,245,43 503.466,60L.EX addOSficnD Pi.S. \/. Pb/Wo , 264 P3 3d 44 (046 2.03) . . , >

S46S6f3i9C(94l0^\d) . . . ,\ IbS. \96Wpvb S3b3Sl349(m4a(6S . , . .2. I \ S3)l3ru 52X7 3d 2ti (OA 4 14qS) . . . J, 3/4,5/^ Vr-.U-Un, \/. 5kk 531 5. CO. 3d 3l^4cC-0l(Tex-b93^,App.lQT0 . ,3 \4klZ£5klk 1C^A32dq^i COfl S1456) . , . ..<d [kVdVvm\/.3r-yQd soU+bod ion (ovxi idsbd . , . .2, i 5^6 S.LO, 3d 45133364 fe.OSM.App. I4i3 . .3) LiLgtoaadaa 9. Sksd& o£^aa 63& ix3ss.sb.sd. 3d 324 si 6.(3Ration . .£ UPl</\n\/SPde- . ., Sll ,S. IS3d 462,46%(l3, fink Hpp."lo\6). . -3 7p^p3/11S. , , M 559 iJ.S. 651; 104 LEA 2d 344,130 S.CM-. Pill-(icbb) .|

Xmxs QuW% Qp-15/icWce- Rule 263(0 . . .7 ieyw=> ^ules dP PippeVloAe QWwre-44.2(54 . .3 l2xo.l> Rules of PpiKilla+e. (Wt-+We-44.2(b) 3n4Tbtn=s 73fr>s PrAp r^Sduvuivd VfriT^rW:. FVUck 31.01 .1 Plr+3k ^SS.02> . . . . .5 3(3 VsPXxi.rrr^K ifti. Pa oMtsxd >a<> OK6 Gaa&UWdon, P\r-UckXi40 . . .5,0,8 Im-s G^sXS'dXory ArdiC.k Xf l4 . . . (o u(Pi+e4 Stages Cais\i4u\3on, A»'nWwe\3"3I . .5,£> lifo-ta) SM-es, ConsVrUrion, A^rWia43ZL . . ly4;k,7 oV)\/33ktMSkYr 9r.\0ES fe Us.C. $ sifcl GO . . . .1

VI

Ahmed /a w pu^k && ftx&r PlC/^t ry jaegog.

At> AW l\n\Ad SkAts Gorv^AuAich Onl Ak ^^ee^^r^\ (^ S^(o\^j •,/•. i x\ - -.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Kyle Miller v. State, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Kyle Miller v. State (Kyle Miller v. State) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.