Krumpelman v. Louisville & Jefferson County Metropolitan Sewer District

314 S.W.2d 557, 75 A.L.R. 2d 1110, 1958 Ky. LEXIS 310
CourtCourt of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)
DecidedJune 20, 1958
StatusPublished
Cited by11 cases

This text of 314 S.W.2d 557 (Krumpelman v. Louisville & Jefferson County Metropolitan Sewer District) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976) primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Krumpelman v. Louisville & Jefferson County Metropolitan Sewer District, 314 S.W.2d 557, 75 A.L.R. 2d 1110, 1958 Ky. LEXIS 310 (Ky. 1958).

Opinion

*559 STEWART, Judge.

This action was filed as an agreed case under KRS 418.020, and involves the proposed construction of sewers and drains in territory newly annexed to the City of Louisville. The particular area contemplated to be served is a triangular tract across Taylorsville Road from Bowman Field in the southeast section of the city.

Under an Act adopted by the 1946 Legislature (KRS Chapter 76) the Louisville and Jefferson County Metropolitan Sewer District (hereinafter referred to as “Metropolitan”) was created for the purpose of providing adequate sewer and drainage facilities in and around the City of Louisville. This Act recited that such a sewer district had no authority to levy property taxes but that it had the right to fix rates, rentals and charges, to be collected from the property owners served in the manner prescribed by the district. Nevertheless, this right to establish and collect sewer rates and other charges was subject to the approval, supervision and control of the legislative body of the city.

Service collections have furnished the sole source of income for Metropolitan in its operation and maintenance of the city’s sewer and drainage systems and in its construction of additional sewers. However, the income of Metropolitan by itself was insufficient to provide funds for the installation of both trunk and lateral sewers in areas annexed to the city since July 1, 1946 (when KRS Chapter 76 became effective). These sections had been largely improved with residences depending on septic tanks for sewage disposal. The use of such methods in these closely-built-up sections presented a serious health menace, and, to bring relief as early as possible, Metropolitan adopted a policy of laying trunk sewers to reach all areas possible. This plan required separate financing of the lateral sewers which connected to these trunk sewers.

The 1952 Legislature amended the Act under which Metropolitan was created by providing in KRS 76.171 that where adequate sewers or drains have not been constructed in any territory annexed to a city of the first class since July 1, 1946, the city legislative body may by ordinance, on recommendation of the director of works, or of the board of a metropolitan sewer district if the city be in such a district, install branch or lateral lines within such territory to connect with the city’s sewer or drainage systems.

KRS 76.172 of the Act was also amended in 1952 so as to authorize the sewer district to construct such branch or lateral sewers at the exclusive cost of the owners of land as set forth in KRS 93.370 with reference to the improvement of streets or alleys. The method of financing prescribed by KRS 93.370 was by the use of apportionment warrants issued against the benefited property.

In addition, the 1952 amendment placed the responsibility for approving plans, advertising for bids and issuing apportionment warrants on city officials, in accordance with KRS Chapter 93. Since the projects for new sewers and contracts for sewers generally were in all other cases made exclusively by Metropolitan, this statutory method as to lateral sewers proved to be impracticable. Therefore in 1956 the Legislature clarified KRS 76.172 by placing the aforementioned administrative features, as well as the construction work and control relating to lateral sewers, in the hands of Metropolitan. However, the 1952 amendment which fixes the apportioning of the cost among owners of benefited property remained unchanged.

The 1956 amendment further cleared up KRS 76.172 by incorporating the applicable wording of KRS 93.370 therein, which the 1952 amendment referred to only partially. This section now reads:

“When such sewers or drains are located in a public street or alley, the construction thereof shall be at the exclusive cost of owners of lots in each one-fourth of a square to be equally ap *560 portioned by the metropolitan sewer district according to the number of square feet owned by said property owners. Each subdivision of the territory bounded on all sides by principal streets shall be deemed a square.”

The 1956 amendment also states in subsection (6) of KRS 76.172 that a lien is created against the respective lots or land for the cost of such sewer facilities with interest thereon at the rate of six per cent per annum. Subsection (8) thereof requires Metropolitan to enter a record of all apportionment warrants in a register. Subsection (9) thereof provides that a lien shall exist from the date of the apportionment warrant, but that such lien shall not be valid against a purchaser for a valuable consideration without notice unless the apportionment warrant is entered and registered within ten days of its issuance.

Pursuant to the Act as amended, the Board of Aldermen of the City of Louisville, on Metropolitan’s recommendation, enacted Ordinance No. 132, Series 1957, calling for the installation of sanitary sewers and property service connections in the area involved in the instant case. These five points are presented for adjudication :

(1) Is the lien given by the 1956 Act (or KRS 76.171 and 76.172) to the holder of an apportionment warrant for the construction of lateral sewers and service connections superior to any lien (except the statutory lien of other taxes) existing against the property benefited?

(2) Is the 1956 Act constitutional as to territories annexed to the City of Louisville since July 1, 1946?

(3) Is Ordinance No. 132 valid in respect to delegating the right to Metropolitan to make contracts for the construction of lateral sewers and property service connections at the cost of the property owners and issuing apportionment warrants therefor ?

(4) Is Ordinance No. 132 valid in providing that such cost of construction of lateral sewers and of property service connections be assessed against the property owner without any provision therein for payment in annual installments?

(5)Is property that cannot be served directly, although it lies within the quarter block where sewer laterals are to be laid, subject to assessment to any extent in apportionment of the cost of such sewer construction ?

The lower court answered each of the first four questions in the affirmative and the last or fifth in the negative.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Pinnacle Development II, LLC v. RML Construction, LLP
410 S.W.3d 169 (Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 2013)
Kentucky River Auth. v. City of Danville
932 S.W.2d 374 (Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1996)
In Re Africo Explorations, Inc.
146 B.R. 280 (D. Kansas, 1992)
Barber v. Commissioner of Revenue
674 S.W.2d 18 (Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1984)
Conrad v. Lexington-Fayette Urban Cty. Govern.
659 S.W.2d 190 (Kentucky Supreme Court, 1983)
Malakoff v. Washington
434 A.2d 432 (District of Columbia Court of Appeals, 1981)
Wasson v. Hogenson
583 P.2d 914 (Supreme Court of Colorado, 1978)
City of Hazard v. Payne
439 S.W.2d 774 (Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1969)
Barnes v. Jacobsen
417 S.W.2d 224 (Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1967)
McCoy v. City of Florence
409 S.W.2d 511 (Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1966)
City of Maysville v. Coughlin
399 S.W.2d 297 (Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1966)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
314 S.W.2d 557, 75 A.L.R. 2d 1110, 1958 Ky. LEXIS 310, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/krumpelman-v-louisville-jefferson-county-metropolitan-sewer-district-kyctapphigh-1958.