Koch v. Mielak

CourtNebraska Court of Appeals
DecidedMarch 2, 2021
DocketA-20-293
StatusPublished

This text of Koch v. Mielak (Koch v. Mielak) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Nebraska Court of Appeals primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Koch v. Mielak, (Neb. Ct. App. 2021).

Opinion

IN THE NEBRASKA COURT OF APPEALS

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND JUDGMENT ON APPEAL (Memorandum Web Opinion)

KOCH V. MIELAK

NOTICE: THIS OPINION IS NOT DESIGNATED FOR PERMANENT PUBLICATION AND MAY NOT BE CITED EXCEPT AS PROVIDED BY NEB. CT. R. APP. P. § 2-102(E).

MARK ALLEN KOCH, APPELLANT, V.

JASON MIELAK ET AL., APPELLEES.

Filed March 2, 2021. No. A-20-293.

Appeal from the District Court for Platte County: ROBERT R. STEINKE, Judge. Affirmed. Mark Allen Koch, pro se. Jason D. Mielak, of Fehringer & Mielak, L.L.P., for appellees Mielak and Flanagan. Jerod L. Trouba, of Trouba Law Offices, L.L.C., for appellees First Security Mortgage and Carlson. Victor L. Lacy, pro se. Clark J. Grant, of Grant & Grant Law Offices, P.C., for appellee Joseph Dalton.

RIEDMANN, BISHOP, and WELCH, Judges. BISHOP, Judge. I. INTRODUCTION Mark Allen Koch brought this action against seven defendants to set aside a trustee’s sale of residential real property pursuant to a deed of trust. The Platte County District Court dismissed Koch’s claims against three defendants and granted summary judgment in favor of the remaining four defendants. Koch, pro se before the district court and on appeal, appeals; we affirm.

-1- II. BACKGROUND In November 2006, Koch was referred to First Security Mortgage Company (First Security) by another entity to assist Koch in securing a loan. Donald Carlson, the president of First Security, acted as a loan broker between Koch and Victor L. Lacy, a private lender. On November 21, Koch executed and delivered to Lacy a promissory note in the principal amount of $29,000 with interest. To secure the loan, Koch also executed and delivered a deed of trust encumbering residential real estate located in Columbus, Nebraska, owned by Koch in fee simple. The deed of trust named Koch as trustor, Lacy as beneficiary, and attorney Larry D. Ohs as trustee. The deed of trust was recorded on November 30 in the Platte County Register of Deeds. On September 10, 2010, Lacy recorded a substitution of trustee naming attorney Joseph E. Dalton as the successor trustee to the deed of trust. Subsequently on May 1, 2015, Lacy recorded a second substitution of trustee naming attorney John D. Rouse as the successor trustee to the deed of trust. Neither Ohs, Dalton, nor Rouse exercised the power of sale under the deed of trust or otherwise affected Koch’s rights concerning the real property, promissory note, or deed of trust. However, during the period where Lacy remained the beneficiary, several notices of default were recorded and shortly thereafter cancelled. On October 22, 2015, Lacy assigned and conveyed his interests in the promissory note and deed of trust to Clifford P. Flanagan. This assignment was recorded on January 15, 2016, in the Platte County Register of Deeds. On July 17, 2018, Flanagan executed a substitution of trustee naming attorney Jason D. Mielak as the successor trustee to the deed of trust; it was recorded on July 23. Koch failed to make payments due to Flanagan under the promissory note. On July 23, 2018, a notice of default was recorded with the Platte County Register of Deeds. Within 10 days after filing the notice, Mielak, as successor trustee, caused a copy of the notice of default to be mailed to Koch and other parties entitled to notice under the deed of trust. Koch thereafter failed to cure the default described in the notice within 30 days, and Mielak, at the request of Flanagan, elected to declare the entire balance and interest immediately due and payable. Mielak then executed a notice of trustee’s sale, which was published weekly in the Columbus Telegram for five consecutive weeks commencing on September 18 and ending on October 16. Mielak mailed to Koch and other parties entitled to notice under the deed of trust a copy of the notice of trustee’s sale with the time and location of the trustee’s sale. The sale of the residential real property subject to the deed of trust occurred on November 1 at the Platte County Courthouse in Columbus. Mielak accepted Flanagan’s bid of $40,000 as the highest bid for the real property subject to the deed of trust, and on November 16, Mielak executed and delivered to Flanagan a trustee’s deed conveying the property. Koch then filed a complaint in the district court on November 20, 2018, and an amended complaint on March 1, 2019, seeking to set aside the trustee’s sale of the real property due to failure by the defendants to comply with the requirements of the Nebraska Trust Deeds Act. Koch named seven defendants in his operative complaint, including Mielak, Flanagan, First Security, Lacy, Ohs, and Dalton. The seventh defendant was named by Koch as “Burlowitz, Rouse and Dalton” (BRD), but Koch’s pleadings contained no allegations as to the nature or organization of this defendant.

-2- Subsequently, Lacy and BRD each filed motions to dismiss Koch’s claims against them, and Mielak, Flanagan, First Security, and Dalton filed motions for summary judgment. The district court held a hearing on the motion for summary judgment brought by Mielak and Flanagan on June 4, 2019. Koch did not appear at this hearing. Subsequent to this hearing, Koch filed a motion for rehearing. On June 27, the district court held a hearing on Koch’s motion for rehearing and for the remaining defendants’ motions for dismissal and summary judgment. Koch was present at this hearing. On October 24, the district court entered several orders dismissing the claims against Lacy, Ohs, and BRD and granting summary judgment in favor Dalton, Mielak, and Flanagan. The court dismissed the claim against Ohs due to the failure to serve process within 180 days of Koch filing the amended complaint. The court further dismissed the claims against Lacy and BRD, finding that Koch had failed to state a claim upon which relief may be granted. The court granted summary judgment in favor of Dalton, noting that Dalton was not the trustee at the time of the sale and never exercised his power of sale as trustee under the deed of trust. The court further granted summary judgment in favor of Mielak and Flanagan, finding that both Mielak and Flanagan, as trustee and beneficiary at the time of the trustee’s sale respectively, complied with the requirements of the Nebraska Trust Deeds Act in exercising the power of sale under the deed of trust and in carrying out the trustee’s sale. In this same order, the court denied Koch’s motion for rehearing. Also on October 24, the district court determined that First Security’s motion for summary judgment would be continued until further order of the court in order to provide First Security the opportunity to retain counsel. On November 4, 2019, Koch appealed the orders of the district court. On November 20, in case No. A-19-1051, this court dismissed Koch’s appeal pursuant to Neb. Ct. R. App. P. § 2-107(A)(2) (rev. 2017) for lack of jurisdiction, as the district court had not yet disposed of Koch’s claims against First Security. The district court held a hearing on March 12, 2020, concerning First Security’s motion for summary judgment. The court thereafter entered an order on April 3 granting First Security’s motion for summary judgment, noting that neither First Security nor its president, Carlson, were “involved with any servicing, collection of payments, or communications with Koch” after the loan proceeds were distributed to Koch in November 2006. Koch timely appealed from the district court’s April 3, 2020, order. III.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Gilroy v. Ryberg
667 N.W.2d 544 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2003)
Steffy v. Steffy
287 Neb. 529 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2014)
Friedman v. Friedman
290 Neb. 973 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2015)
Klein v. Oakland/Red Oak Holdings
883 N.W.2d 699 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2016)
Wynne v. Menard, Inc.
299 Neb. 710 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2018)
Rosberg v. Rosberg
25 Neb. Ct. App. 856 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2018)
Cruz v. Lopez
301 Neb. 531 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2018)
Pitts v. Genie Indus., Inc.
302 Neb. 88 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2019)
Pitts v. Genie Indus.
302 Neb. 88 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2019)
Wintroub v. Nationstar Mortg. LLC
303 Neb. 15 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2019)
Wintroub v. Nationstar Mortgage
303 Neb. 15 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2019)
U.S. Pipeline v. Northern Natural Gas Co.
303 Neb. 444 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2019)
Western Ethanol Co. v. Midwest Renewable Energy
305 Neb. 1 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2020)
Sundermann v. Hy-Vee
306 Neb. 749 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2020)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
Koch v. Mielak, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/koch-v-mielak-nebctapp-2021.