Kansas Enters., Inc. v. Frantz

6 P.3d 857, 269 Kan. 436, 2000 Kan. LEXIS 531
CourtSupreme Court of Kansas
DecidedJune 9, 2000
DocketNo. 82,658
StatusPublished
Cited by2 cases

This text of 6 P.3d 857 (Kansas Enters., Inc. v. Frantz) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Kansas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Kansas Enters., Inc. v. Frantz, 6 P.3d 857, 269 Kan. 436, 2000 Kan. LEXIS 531 (kan 2000).

Opinion

[438]*438The opinion of the court was delivered by

Davis, J.:

Kansas Enterprises, Inc., (taxpayer) paid its 1994 ad valorem personal property tax under protest. It claimed that its property was exempt as merchant’s inventory under Article 11 of the Kansas Constitution and K.S.A. 79-201m. After a full hearing, BOTA denied the exemption. The district court affirmed BOTA. For reasons set forth in this opinion, we affirm.

The facts are not in dispute. The taxpayer is a Kansas corporation doing business as AAA Rent-All Equipment Sales and Service and AAA Equipment and Supply. The taxpayer owns and operates four locations in Wichita for the rental and sales of various types of personal property. The taxpayer’s business consists of owning an inventory of personal property which it makes available to the public for sale and rental in the ordinary course of business. Virtually all of its inventory is sold to the public and 70% to 80% of its business is done on open accounts, which extend credit to business customers.

The personal property claimed as exempt merchant’s inventory consists of general inventory and construction equipment. General inventory includes such items as ladders, sawblades, small power tools, lawnmowers, rototillers, power rakes, and hand tools, which are sold and rented to homeowners, fight and heavy construction contractors, and other businesses. The taxpayer’s construction inventory consists of expensive equipment such as Snorkel-Economy aerial work platforms, Scat-Trak loaders, backhoes, small engine equipment (pumps, generators, welders, and compactors), forklifts, air compressors, and large electric tools, which are sold and rented to fight and heavy construction contractors and to other businesses.

The taxpayer’s business has changed dramatically during the past 15 years. In the past, the taxpayer rented primarily to homeowners but beginning in the mid 1980’s, its customers demanded newer equipment and began to look to the' taxpayer as a source from which they could purchase both new and used equipment. Since that time, rental and sales to homeowners have diminished; sales and rentals to construction contractors have increased. The tax[439]*439payer has evolved into a large full-scale equipment sale, rental, and service business providing services to customers within a 100-mile radius of Wichita.

The industry which the taxpayer serves has also changed dramatically. Construction equipment dealers which used to only sell new equipment now rent a substantial portion of their inventory. Construction rental dealers which used to only rent equipment now sell a substantial portion of their inventory. The taxpayer, as well as similar businesses, sell outright to some customers; however, it is more common for sales to be made after the construction equipment has been rented for a period of time. This rental period allows the customer to determine if the equipment meets their needs and provides the customer a method of financing the purchase. Rental payments made before the purchase reduces the ultimate purchase price.

The taxpayer is an exclusive dealer for Snorkel-Economy high-reach equipment in 54 counties in Southern Kansas. As an exclusive dealer, the taxpayer is the only business in the territory authorized to sell new Snorkel-Economy equipment, perform repair and service, stock and sell parts, perform warranty, and rent high-reach equipment. It also has a dealer’s agreement with Trak International for the Scat-Trak skid steer loaders and Sky-Trak forklifts for the sale, rental, and servicing of this equipment. In 1993, the taxpayer was the number two dealer in the United States for sales of Scat-Trak equipment. It employs five full-time commissioned salespersons and a sales manager whose primary duty is to sell inventory.

Over the years, the taxpayer has experienced substantial increases in sales of general inventory and construction equipment inventory. On any given day, 16% of the value at cost of their inventory is out on rental contracts while the remaining 84% is physically located at the store. The taxpayer’s sales for fiscal years 1988 through 1994 were as follows:

Fiscal Year Ending 11/30/88 $1,219,022

11/30/89 724,163 FYE

11/30/90 765,445 FYE

[440]*440FYE 11/30/91 756,780

FYE 11/30/92 891,933

FYE 11/30/93 1,435,029

FYE 11 months ending 10/31/94 1,869,794

At the present time, sales now constitute a larger portion of total revenue than equipment rentals. The taxpayer presented the following evidence regarding its income source changes from 1987 to 1995:

11/30/87 11/30/94 8/31/95

Sales: $950,000 $2,000,000 $1,800,000

Equip Rentals $2,050,000 $2,000,000 $1,550,000

The taxpayer claims depreciation on its federal income tax return for its general inventory and construction equipment inventory.

The taxpayer applied for exemption in the tax year 1994, claiming that its equipment qualified as merchant’s inventory and was therefore exempt from personal property taxes under K.S.A. 79-201m. In order to qualify for the merchants’ inventory exemption the taxpayer must show that it is a “merchant” and that its personal property qualifies as “inventory” under the provisions of K.S.A. 79-201m. •

The statute defines the term “merchant” to include

“every person, company or corporation who shall own or hold, subject to their control, any tangible personal property within this state which shall have been purchased primarily for resale in the ordinary course of business without modification or change in form or substance, and without any intervening use, except that, an incidental use, including but not limited to the rental or lease of any such property, shall not be deemed to be an intervening use.” K.S.A. 79-201m(a)(l).

The statute defines inventory as

“those items of tangible personal property that: (1) Are primarily held for sale in the ordinary course of business (finished goods); (2) are in process of production for such sale (work in process); or (3) are to be consumed either directly or indirectly in the production of finished goods (raw materials and supplies). A capital asset subject to depreciation or cost recovery accounting for federal income tax purposes that is retired from regular use by its owner and held for sale or as standby or surplus equipment by such owner shall not be classified as inventory.” K.S.A. 79-201m(a)(3).

[441]*441BOTA concluded that the taxpayer was a merchant under the provisions of K.S.A. 79-201m but failed to present sufficient evidence to establish that the personal property for which the exemption was claimed was “purchased primarily for resale in the ordinary course of business . . .

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Attorney General Opinion No.
Kansas Attorney General Reports, 2007
In Re Tax Appeal of City of Wichita
59 P.3d 336 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 2002)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
6 P.3d 857, 269 Kan. 436, 2000 Kan. LEXIS 531, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/kansas-enters-inc-v-frantz-kan-2000.