In Re Minton

271 B.R. 335, 2001 Bankr. LEXIS 1684, 2001 WL 1614118
CourtUnited States Bankruptcy Court, W.D. Arkansas
DecidedDecember 11, 2001
Docket01-60699
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 271 B.R. 335 (In Re Minton) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering United States Bankruptcy Court, W.D. Arkansas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
In Re Minton, 271 B.R. 335, 2001 Bankr. LEXIS 1684, 2001 WL 1614118 (Ark. 2001).

Opinion

ORDER SUSTAINING RENT-A-CENTER’S OBJECTION TO CONFIRMATION OF DEBTORS’ CHAPTER 13 PLAN

ROBERT F. FUSSELL, Bankruptcy Judge.

Pending before the Court is an objection to confirmation of chapter 13 plan filed by creditor Rent-A-Center, Inc. (“Renb-A-Center”) on June 13, 2001. An evidentiary hearing on the objection to confirmation was held on September 6, 2001. At the conclusion of the evidentiary hearing, the Court took the matter under advisement. Because this involves the confirmation of a chapter 13 plan, this is a core proceeding pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 157(b)(2)(L), and the Court may make the following findings of fact and conclusions of law pursuant to Federal Rule of Bankruptcy Procedure 7052.

*337 I. Findings of Fact.

On June 4, 2001, Johnnie J. Minton and Janice Minton (“Debtors”) filed a joint voluntary petition for relief under the provisions of chapter 13 of the United States Bankruptcy Code. The Debtors’ proposed chapter 13 plan was filed contemporaneously with their petition. Debtors’ schedules list Rent-A-Center as a secured creditor with a claim of $600.00 secured by a refrigerator and stove. Debtor’s plan proposes to pay Rent-A-Center’s claim in full, with interest at the rate of 10%. Renb-A-Center is to receive a pro-rata share of Debtors’ monthly $500.00 plan payment over the thirty-six month duration of Debtors’ proposed plan.

Rent-A-Center filed an objection to the confirmation of Debtors’ plan on June 13, 2001. In its objection, Renb-A-Center argues that certain agreements between Debtors and Renb-A-Center constitute “true leases” which must be accepted or rejected by Debtors under the Bankruptcy Code. Because Debtors’ plan treats Rent-A-Center as a secured creditor, Renb-A-Center contends that confirmation of Debtors’ plan should be denied and that Debtors should be required to accept or reject the agreements with Renb-A-Cen-ter.

On September 6, 2001, the Court conducted an evidentiary hearing on the objection to confirmation, at which time the Court received into evidence a joint stipulation of facts executed by counsel for Debtors and counsel for Rent-A-Center. The Court adopts the parties’ joint stipulations of fact. The parties stipulated that Debtors and Renb-A-Center entered into a number of agreements entitled “Rental Purchase Agreements,” which were attached to the joint stipulation as exhibits A-F. The parties further stipulated that only exhibits B, C, and F, which were related to a refrigerator, an electric range, and a mattress, pertain to property still in possession of Debtors and in dispute in this matter.

Exhibit B, which pertains to a refrigerator, states as follows:

RENTAL PURCHASE AGREEMENT

Date: March 25, 2000

Agreement Number: 88604379

Lessor: Rent-A-Center, Inc. [address omitted]

Renter: Minton, Johnnie J/Janice D [address omitted]

TERMS OF AGREEMENT

As used in this agreement “you” and “your” mean the person(s) signing this agreement as renter; “we” and “our” mean the Lessor/Owner (the rental company); “property” means the items described in the disclosures; and “lease” means this Rental Purchase Agreement including the disclosures.

RENTAL PURCHASE DISCLOSURES

1. RENTAL TERM: MONTHLY> WEEKLY.

Rental payments are due at the beginning of each term that you choose to rent the property. There are no refunds if you choose to return the property before the end of the term.

2. DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY AND RENTAL RATES:

*338 Unit # 86600739

Categ./Descp. Appliance/Refrigerator

Serial # Cond. EJ1024493 USED

Monthly Rent 79.96

* Optional Weekly Rent 19.99

3. INITIAL RENT PAYMENT. Your initial rent payment will include the following charges:

Rent Delivery Charge Sales Tax Other Total

19.99 .00 1.63 1.50 23.02

4. OTHER CHARGES:

N/A

Optional Damage Waiver Fee 6.00/Month 1.50/Week

Reinstatement Fee $5.00/Payment missed while you retain the property.

Late Charge 5.00

5. COST OF LEASE. If you choose to rent to own you must rent the property for the following number of months or weeks:

22 Months@ 79.96/mo. for a total cost of $1,760.62 TAX

96 Weeks@ 19.99 /wk. for a total cost of $1,920.54 «s» TAX

You do not acquire any ownership rights in the property until you rent the property for the months shown here, or purchase it for cash sooner.

6. RISK OF LOSS. You are liable for loss and damage in excess of normal wear and tear, and destruction to the leased property. If the property is lost, damaged, or stolen while you are renting it, or if for any reason we are not given possession of it when this lease ends, you are liable for the lesser of our repair or replacement cost.

7. REINSTATEMENT. If this lease expires you many reinstate (i) within five (5) business days of expiration date if renting monthly or (ii) within two (2) business days of the expiration date if renting weekly, by paying all rental payments and other charges that are due. If you do not pay and you return the property within the appropriate reinstatement period (other than through judicial process), you will have thirty (30) days from the date of return of the merchandise to reinstate without losing any rights or options. Upon reinstatement, we will provide you with the same or substitute property of comparable quality and condition. You have no right to reinstate this agreement more than three (3) times.

TYPE OF TRANSACTION: THIS IS A RENTAL TRANSACTION. You may use the property for the term of this lease. At your option, you may renew this lease, by making a rental payment in advance for each term you choose to rent the property. The rental rates are shown in the disclosures. Time is of the essence in this lease. INTENT: You agree that your intent is to rent rather than purchase the property. TERMINATION: You are not obligated to renew this agreement and may terminate this agreement at any time without penalty by returning the rental property. CONDITION OF THE PROPERTY: You agree that you have received the property in satisfactory condition. TITLE AND TAXES: We retain title to the property during this lease and will pay any taxes which may be levied on the property. You do now [sic] own the property unless you buy it or acquire ownership as provided in the terms of this lease. FORBIDDEN ACTS: You cannot sell, mortgage, pawn, pledge, encumber, hock or dispose of the property. You cannot move the property from your current residence without our consent. Each of these acts is a breach of this lease. OUR RIGHTS TO TAKE POSSESSION: If you do not renew this lease or if you breach this lease, we have the right to possession of the property.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

KFJ Enterprises, LLC v. Rembert (In Re Rembert)
293 B.R. 664 (M.D. Pennsylvania, 2003)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
271 B.R. 335, 2001 Bankr. LEXIS 1684, 2001 WL 1614118, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/in-re-minton-arwb-2001.