Hooper v. FREEDOM FINANCIAL GROUP, INC.

784 N.W.2d 437, 280 Neb. 111
CourtNebraska Supreme Court
DecidedJune 25, 2010
DocketS-09-796
StatusPublished
Cited by88 cases

This text of 784 N.W.2d 437 (Hooper v. FREEDOM FINANCIAL GROUP, INC.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Nebraska Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Hooper v. FREEDOM FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., 784 N.W.2d 437, 280 Neb. 111 (Neb. 2010).

Opinion

784 N.W.2d 437 (2010)
280 Neb. 111

Donald HOOPER and Marilyn Hooper, husband and wife, appellees,
v.
FREEDOM FINANCIAL GROUP, INC., et al., appellants.

No. S-09-796.

Supreme Court of Nebraska.

June 25, 2010.

*439 Jerry W. Katskee and Rubina S. Khaleel, of Katskee, Henatsch & Suing, Omaha, for appellants.

Clifford T. Lee, of Rasmussen & Mitchell, Omaha, for appellees.

HEAVICAN, C.J., WRIGHT, CONNOLLY, GERRARD, STEPHAN, McCORMACK, and MILLER-LERMAN, JJ.

STEPHAN, J.

Following a bench trial, the district court for Douglas County found Freedom Financial Group, Inc. (FFG), J. Patrick Pierce (Pierce), Carolyn K. Pierce (Carolyn), and Westley M. Pierce (Westley) jointly and severally liable to Donald Hooper and Marilyn Hooper for violations of *440 the Securities Act of Nebraska.[1] FFG and the Pierces appeal from that judgment. We affirm.

I. BACKGROUND

Prior to 2003, Pierce; his wife, Carolyn; and their son, Westley, were principals in a group of interrelated corporations which included Freedom Group, Inc., and its six subsidiaries, two of which were Freedom Financial, Inc., and FFG. These companies were headquartered on a multiacre tract in Omaha which also included the residence of Pierce and Carolyn, as well as an equestrian center which Pierce and Carolyn operated.

Freedom Financial was a Nebraska corporation registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as a broker-dealer of securities. It sold various financial products to the public through registered representatives located in 125 offices. As a broker-dealer, Freedom Financial was responsible for performing the due diligence process for financial products to be sold by its registered representatives. The Pierces were all directors of Freedom Financial and were responsible for establishing the policies and procedures of the company and for ensuring general compliance with such policies. Pierce was the president of Freedom Financial.

FFG was formed in February 2001 as a holding company for the purpose of acquiring a trust company and other financial entities. Pierce was an officer and director of FFG, and Westley was a director.

Michael Casper was the owner and president of Capital Equity Fund, Inc. (CEF), and a principal in other companies. The Freedom Group entities began a relationship with Casper in 2001, in connection with a stock offering by a company in which Casper had an interest. Although Freedom Financial was initially involved in the offering, it withdrew its participation due to concerns about the offering's compliance with securities regulations.

Around the same time, FFG announced a private placement stock offering in which it sought $10 million in capital to acquire a trust company and other financial entities. After some FFG stock had been sold, Olde South Trust, Inc., in which Casper had an ownership interest, made an offer to purchase $15 million of FFG stock under a new private offering. FFG and Olde South Trust signed a funding agreement in June 2001. But in August 2001, FFG signed a new funding agreement with Ambassador Trust, Inc., in which Casper also had an interest. Ambassador Trust agreed to provide FFG with $15 million in capital prior to the end of 2001 so that FFG could acquire a bank and a trust company. FFG and Ambassador Trust also entered into a separate funding agreement whereby Ambassador Trust agreed to provide FFG with an additional $10½ million so that FFG could acquire a second financial company to operate as a clearing broker-dealer. These agreements replaced the original FFG agreement with Olde South Trust. By the end of 2001, Ambassador Trust had not provided any of the promised funds, and FFG used other funds to complete its acquisition of a South Dakota trust company, which became Presidents Trust Company, LLC. In 2002, Ambassador Trust provided FFG and Presidents Trust Company with $310,000 pursuant to additional funding agreements executed in March, April, and May of that year.

In late 2001, Freedom Financial entered into an agreement with Casper regarding *441 the private placement offering for preferred stock of CEF, a Tennessee corporation organized in 2001 to engage primarily in the business of charged-off consumer debt receivables. Casper held 80 percent of the common stock of CEF and served as its president and one of its directors. Freedom Financial served as the "Broker/Dealer Manager" for the offering. The CEF preferred stock was not registered with the SEC or any state securities commission. Pierce testified that there are specific requirements for this type of offering, including that all investors be accredited, meaning that each investor had $1 million in net worth or met other specified criteria.

In its role as the managing broker-dealer for the CEF offering, Freedom Financial was responsible for (1) approving broker-dealers involved with the sale, including reviewing representatives to make sure they had the necessary license to sell the CEF stock; (2) reviewing advertising and promotional literature used to market the CEF offering; and (3) reviewing information on proposed investors to ensure they met the requirements necessary to purchase the CEF stock. Pierce testified that Freedom Financial exercised due diligence in reviewing the CEF offering prior to agreeing to be the managing broker-dealer. While the record suggests that CEF was responsible for preparing its marketing brochure and private placement memorandum, Pierce or other representatives of Freedom Financial reviewed the materials prior to their use in the CEF offering. The CEF offering became effective in October 2001.

At the time of the CEF offering, Heartland Financial Group was an Omaha investment and insurance firm, whose employees, Carl Wyllie and Jerry Dickinson, were also registered representatives of Freedom Financial. The Hoopers purchased CEF stock through Wyllie and Dickinson on March 28, 2002. Prior to the sale, the Hoopers provided Wyllie with information about their finances and their past experience with investing, which was mostly limited to Donald's retirement fund. That fund, then valued at $105,000, represented approximately 25 percent of the Hoopers' combined net worth. After reviewing the financial information, Wyllie ultimately recommended that the Hoopers invest Donald's retirement fund account in CEF stock.

Wyllie gave the Hoopers a marketing brochure which described the CEF stock as having "[n]o stock market risk"; as being "[s]uitable for investing by qualified and retirement plans, including IRA, 401(k), and 403(b)"; and as a "great investment vehicle for seniors." Wyllie told the Hoopers that they were getting "beat up" in the stock market and that CEF provided a more stable, safer investment and a better return than their previous investments. Wyllie also stated that the CEF stock would provide a guaranteed 11-percent rate of return over a 3-year period, and a 9-percent return if the stock were sold earlier. Dickinson was present during this discussion.

Wyllie also provided the Hoopers with the private placement memorandum for CEF. Donald testified that he did not read the materials but stated that Wyllie reviewed the documents with him. Marilyn testified that she reviewed the information on the risk factors associated with the CEF stock as described in the private placement memorandum but relied on Wyllie, who equated the risk with that of a savings account. There was never any discussion between the Hoopers and Wyllie or Dickinson about the connection between Freedom Financial, FFG, Presidents Trust Company, or CEF.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

30 Metropolitan Place v. Dana Partnership
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2023
Lueth v. Lashley
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2022
McGill Restoration v. Lion Place Condo. Assn.
309 Neb. 202 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2021)
Ralston Investment Group v. Wenck
27 Neb. Ct. App. 574 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2019)
U.S. Pipeline v. Northern Natural Gas Co.
303 Neb. 444 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2019)
Ziegler v. Bloemer
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2019
Bloedorn Lumber Co. v. Nielson
300 Neb. 722 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2018)
Bloedorn Lumber Co. of N. Platte, Corp. v. Nielson
300 Neb. 722 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2018)
Bermudez v. Salazar
Nebraska Court of Appeals, 2017
Merie B. on behalf of Brayden O. v. State
290 Neb. 919 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2015)
DMK Biodiesel v. McCoy
Nebraska Supreme Court, 2015
Elting v. Elting
Nebraska Supreme Court, 2014
Lustgraaf v. Behrens
619 F.3d 867 (Eighth Circuit, 2010)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
784 N.W.2d 437, 280 Neb. 111, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/hooper-v-freedom-financial-group-inc-neb-2010.