Hattori v. Peairs

662 So. 2d 509, 1995 WL 588300
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedOctober 6, 1995
Docket95 CA 0144
StatusPublished
Cited by13 cases

This text of 662 So. 2d 509 (Hattori v. Peairs) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Hattori v. Peairs, 662 So. 2d 509, 1995 WL 588300 (La. Ct. App. 1995).

Opinion

662 So.2d 509 (1995)

Masaichi HATTORI and Mieko Hattori
v.
Rodney PEAIRS, Bonnie Peairs and Louisiana Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company.

No. 95 CA 0144.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, First Circuit.

October 6, 1995.
Writ Denied January 12, 1996.

*511 Charles Moore, Baton Rouge, for plaintiffs-appellees Masaichi Hattori and Mieko Hattori.

John Hainkel, Jr. and Arthur H. Andrews, Baton Rouge, for defendants-appellants Rodney and Bonnie Peairs.

Before LOTTINGER, C.J. and GONZALES and FITZSIMMONS, JJ.

LOTTINGER, Chief Judge.

This is a wrongful death and survival action filed by the parents of a 16-year old Japanese exchange student who was shot and killed by a homeowner. From a judgment in favor of the parents, the homeowner has appealed.

FACTS

In the fall of 1992, Yoshihiro Hattori (Yoshi) was a foreign exchange student from Nagoya, Japan living with the Richard Haymaker family at their home in Baton Rouge. Yoshi had come to the United States in August, and attended McKinley High School with the Haymaker's son, Webb. Both boys were nearly seventeen years of age and members of the senior class at McKinley.

A few weeks prior to the incident in question, the boys learned through an acquaintance, that another Japanese exchange student was living in the Baton Rouge area. She and Yoshi later spoke over the telephone, and the boys were subsequently invited to a Halloween costume party to be held for area exchange students at the home of the girl's host parents, Frank and Connie Pitre. On the evening of the party, Saturday, October 17, 1992, Webb's father allowed him to drive the family's car and provided him with directions to the Pitre home which was located in Central, an unincorporated community north of Baton Rouge.

Not being familiar with the Central area, Webb experienced some difficulty in finding the Pitre home which was situated at 10131 East Brookside. When Webb and Yoshi finally found East Brookside, Webb proceeded slowly down the street whereupon he observed various Halloween decorations at the third house on the right. Because the house bore a similar number, 10311 East Brookside, and had three cars parked in the driveway, the boys thought they had found the party. Having driven past the house, Webb turned the car around, and returned to park in front of the house.

As this was to have been a costume party, the boys were dressed up. Because Webb wore a soft cervical collar as a result of an earlier diving accident, his costume was that of an accident victim. Dressed in shorts and tennis shoes, Webb had a bandage around his head, a hand splint and an ace bandage around his knee. He wore no makeup or fake blood. Yoshi loved to dance and had decided to go as John Travolta's character from the movie "Saturday Night Fever". He rented a white tuxedo jacket, black pants and a ruffled white shirt of which he had unbuttoned the top three buttons. He also carried a camera. Neither boy wore a mask.

At approximately 8:15 P.M., the boys walked up the driveway, and rang the front doorbell.[1] No one answered the front door; however, the boys heard the clinking of window blinds emanating from the rear of the carport area to the left of where they stood. Webb, followed by Yoshi to his left, proceeded around the corner, under the carport, toward the carport door. As the boys turned the corner, Webb observed a small boy, approximately eight or nine years of age, peering *512 through the blinds of the carport door. A moment later, the door was opened by a woman wearing a bathrobe and glasses. As Webb attempted to speak to the woman, she slammed the door.

At this point, the boys turned around and walked down the driveway towards the sidewalk. Webb was fairly certain they had stopped at the wrong house, and attempted to communicate this fact to Yoshi. As they stood on the sidewalk near a streetlamp, the carport door opened again, and Webb observed a man standing in the doorway with a large handgun. At that point, Yoshi moved towards the house exclaiming enthusiastically, "We're here for the party!"

Webb, immediately grasping the seriousness of the situation, pleaded with his friend to come back; however, Yoshi, who was not wearing his contact lenses that evening,[2] continued towards the man smiling and explaining several times that he had come for the party. As Yoshi reached the carport, Webb heard the man in the doorway yell, "Freeze"; however, Yoshi continued to move towards the man. From Webb's vantage point, Yoshi was adjacent to the rear-view mirror of the Toyota station wagon parked on the right of the double carport, when the man in the doorway fired. The bullet struck Yoshi in the chest, causing him to fall to the ground on his back, with his head about a foot from the carport door.

At this point, Webb ran to the house next door, and screamed for the residents inside to call 911. The homeowner, Stan Lucky, answered the door and advised that his wife was calling the emergency number at that moment. Mr. Lucky then returned with Webb to the house next door, the home of Rodney and Bonnie Peairs, to render aid to Yoshi. Mr. Lucky elevated Yoshi's feet and instructed Webb to apply pressure to the wound in Yoshi's chest. The two labored until relieved by personnel from the Central Volunteer Fire Department who administered treatment while sheriff's deputies secured the scene. E.M.S. technicians arrived on the scene a short while later at 8:39 P.M. Sometime between 8:48 and 8:49 P.M., while en route to the hospital, Yoshi stopped breathing.

The homeowners, Rodney and Bonnie Peairs, testified that upon hearing the doorbell that evening, Rodney sent his stepson to answer the carport door. Not wanting her son to answer the door after dark, Bonnie Peairs stopped him and answered the door herself. Upon opening the door, she observed a person in bandages standing near a pillar of the porch at the end of the carport. A moment later, she observed an oriental person taller than she, with a small build, come quickly around the corner toward the door. Startled, Bonnie slammed the door, locked it, and yelled for her husband to, "Get the gun."[3]

Stating that he had never seen his wife so frightened, Rodney Peairs ran to the master bedroom, followed by Bonnie and their three children. There he retrieved the .44 magnum Smith & Wesson revolver equipped with a scope which he kept loaded in a suitcase situated on the top shelf of his closet. Now armed, Rodney raced to the carport door and peered through the blinds. Not seeing anything, and without seeking an explanation for his wife's startled behavior, Rodney flung open the carport door.

With Bonnie behind him to his right, Rodney positioned himself in the doorway. After observing movement at the rear of the Dodge vehicle parked in the driveway behind his pick-up truck, Rodney, moments later, was confronted by a figure to the rear of the Toyota station wagon which was parked on the right side of the carport. In the carport light, Rodney was able to discern an approaching oriental male approximately 5'7" in height wearing a white jacket who appeared to be laughing and carrying an object in his left hand. Raising his weapon with both *513 hands, Rodney shouted for the individual to "Freeze"; however, the stranger continued towards him uttering something unintelligible.

Several seconds later, Yoshi came alongside the right passenger mirror of the Toyota station wagon, Rodney, from the doorway of his home, fired his weapon striking Yoshi in the chest.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Williams v. Jamison
W.D. Kentucky, 2022
Hansen v. Thorpe
E.D. Louisiana, 2020
Pruco Life Ins. Co. v. Breen
289 F. Supp. 3d 777 (E.D. Louisiana, 2017)
Doris Saunier v. Lacye Nolan
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2008
Rideau v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.
970 So. 2d 564 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2007)
Clark v. State Dept. of Pub. Saf. and Corr.
861 So. 2d 603 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2003)
Scott v. American Tobacco
830 So. 2d 294 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2002)
Harris v. Carter
768 So. 2d 827 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2000)
Exxon Pipeline Co. v. Hill
763 So. 2d 144 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2000)
State v. Brooks
734 So. 2d 1232 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1999)
Declouet v. Orleans Parish School Bd.
715 So. 2d 69 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1998)
Babb v. Boney
710 So. 2d 1132 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1998)
Anderson v. Beauregard Memorial Hosp.
709 So. 2d 283 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1998)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
662 So. 2d 509, 1995 WL 588300, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/hattori-v-peairs-lactapp-1995.