Harris v. State

104 So. 2d 739
District Court of Appeal of Florida·Decided August 15, 1958·No. 133·Published·Cited by 26 cases

Opinion

104 So.2d 739 (1958)

Clarence Jackson HARRIS, Appellant,
v.
STATE of Florida, Appellee.

No. 133.

District Court of Appeal of Florida. Second District.

August 15, 1958.
Rehearing Denied September 2, 1958.

*740 D.C. Laird, Lakeland, and John W. Stanford, Fort Lauderdale, for appellant.

Richard W. Ervin, Atty. Gen., and George R. Georgieff, Asst. Atty. Gen., Tallahassee, for appellee.

BIRD, JOHN U., Associate Judge.

This is an appeal from a judgment and sentence of manslaughter in the Criminal Court of Record of Polk County, wherein appellant Clarence Jackson Harris was sentenced to the State Prison.

The facts, as disclosed by the record, are that appellant and his wife and daughter, Willie Dean Harris, were at their home in the country in Polk County when the deceased, Cecil Brewer, Jr., came to see the daughter and an argument soon developed between them. As the argument progressed, the deceased used very abusive and profane language to her. The mother called appellant, who was working in the back yard or grove, and when he reached the front of the house where the parties were he told them to stop the fussing and requested deceased to leave the premises. He then returned to his work in the back. Deceased, however, failed to leave and pressed his argument with the daughter and angrily pushed her down on the driveway. Appellant was again called to the front, and he then called his daughter into the house and again ordered deceased to leave. The deceased, nevertheless, followed the daughter into the house over her protest and that of her mother and father, and continued to curse and abuse her and her family. When deceased said that appellant's daughter was a whore, appellant again told him to leave, and deceased arose from a sitting position and made some kind of motion, which is not clear from the record but which seems to have alarmed appellant, and he went into his bedroom and secured a pistol and returned to the livingroom with it in his hand. The deceased started out. When he got to the steps on the unscreened porch he suddenly and angrily turned and started back into the house, opened the screen door and said,

"I came here for trouble and I'll give you plenty of it."

At this time the fatal and only shot was fired. The bullet entered and passed through the upper right arm and entered the body at the level of the seventh rib,

"* * * approximately going straight, perhaps slightly toward the back. There wasn't much difference in the plane of the bullet." (Dr. L. Stephan)

deflected and came to rest near the eleventh rib.

The record indicates that the deceased was a relatively young man, 31 or 32 years of age, six feet tall and weighing 180 to 200 pounds and was very active and strong. The appellant was of a slight build, 70 years of age and had an injured shoulder. The deceased and the daughter had contemplated marriage and had gone so far as to have blood tests made to secure a marriage license, but disagreement occurred and she called the marriage off. This apparently was the cause of the trouble between them.

It appears that the deceased was not armed at the time, but appellant did not know this. The daughter testified that the deceased usually carried a pistol and had drawn it on her and had told her that if she did not marry him nobody else would.

*741 The porch where deceased was lying when the ambulance arrived was six feet eleven inches in width, the floor being five and one-half inches lower than the floor of the house. There was a screen door between the porch and the livingroom and it was apparently through this opening that the deceased was shot. At the time of the shooting appellant was standing in the livingroom, about six feet from the door, and the deceased was on the porch at or near the door — re-entering the house. They must have been some six or eight feet apart. The bullet did not pass through the screen, so the door must have been open or partly open. After the shooting, deceased was made as comfortable as possible and an ambulance and officers called. When the ambulance arrived deceased was either dead or died soon thereafter

The daughter, who was the Court's witness, testified in part as follows:

"I tried to get him to leave and he wouldn't. He said some smart remark and pushed me and pushed me down. Mother saw that and that's when she called my father back.
"And daddy came to the front porch and said, `Hun, will you please come in the house?' I said, `Yes sir.'
"And he said, `Cecil, you get on away from her.' I went in the house and Cecil got out and followed me in the house. He wasn't invited in.
"Daddy, when I walked in, my father was sitting down on the settee there. I walked in. Mother was already sitting down. He walked in right behind us and daddy said, `Cecil, I told you to get away from here. I've asked you now.' And I even begged him, but he insisted, fact, forced his way in, invited his own self in. He wasn't invited. And he sat down and said, `I want to say something to Dean.'
"I said, `I don't have anything to say to you.' And he called me — he said in front of daddy and mother, he said, that I wasn't nothing but a damn whore. When he said that daddy jumped up and said, `Cecil, get out of my house.' And he said, `The whole damned bunch of Harrises,' something like that, `is nothing but damn so and so's.'
"Daddy begged him to get out. So daddy jumped up and he jumped up. Daddy was scared of him and I was too. In fact, he had me scared all the time. He threatened me lots of times.
"So daddy got up and went out of the living room. I guess he went into the bed room. I said, `Cecil, please leave from here.' And he got up and left, and he got to the doorsteps, and fact, I went to the door there. He got on the steps and turned around and said, `I came out here for trouble and I'll give you plenty God-damned of it.' On the order of that. I can't remember exactly the words he did say.
"When he started back in the house, when he grabbed for the door, he really was mad coming back in. I stepped back and that's when the gun went off. I didn't know daddy was behind me, but daddy said he was frightened of him, but he wouldn't have done anything if he hadn't started back in, because he was coming back to harm some of us. * * *
"But he was still breathing when they put him on the stretcher and carried him off the front porch. That's the way it was, and I was scared of him. That's one reason, he had me scared of him, because he told me lots of times if I didn't marry him, nobody else would.
"In fact, he carried a gun on me once before and I swore out a warrant for him at Winter Haven for coming to my apartment drawing a gun on me. I was frightened of him, scared of him. My daddy done what he thought trying to protect us. I don't know if he would *742 have harmed me, father or mother. We was there and father is small. Cecil was six foot something and weighed 180 pounds. He was a strong person and I know he carried a gun most of the time."

The appellant testified in part as follows:

"A, Well, just as soon as he sot down, he asked Willie wasn't she going with him, to marry him, and she says, `Heck, no.' And then he popped out and said that bad word about her, and I hopped up and got between him and the dining room. You all

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Harris v. State, 104 So. 2d 739 (Fla. Ct. App. 1958).

104 So. 2d 739 (Harris v. State) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

State v. Braveheart
South Dakota Supreme Court, 2026
Juan Javier Oquendo v. State of Florida
Supreme Court of Florida, 2025
State v. Birdshead
2015 SD 77 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 2015)
State v. Ojeda
147 So. 3d 53 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2014)
State v. Bundy
2012 Ohio 3934 (Ohio Court of Appeals, 2012)
Jenkins v. State
942 So. 2d 910 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2006)
State v. Pellegrino
1998 SD 39 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 1998)
Lord v. State
667 So. 2d 817 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1995)
State v. Fernandez
526 So. 2d 192 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1988)
Brown v. State
454 So. 2d 596 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1984)
Falco v. State
407 So. 2d 203 (Supreme Court of Florida, 1981)
McCauley v. State
405 So. 2d 1350 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1981)
State v. W.J.B.
276 S.E.2d 550 (West Virginia Supreme Court, 1981)
Knight v. State
392 So. 2d 337 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1981)
Sanders v. State
359 So. 2d 899 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1978)
Bates v. State
325 So. 2d 449 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1976)
Bacom v. State
317 So. 2d 148 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1975)
Edwards v. Hardin Properties, Inc.
313 So. 2d 82 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1975)
Raneri v. State
255 So. 2d 291 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1971)
Stinson v. State
245 So. 2d 688 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1971)