Hall v. Annucci

Opinion

ENDORSE Hens Nistaet BENeto ak eae PS, Met □

Ralph Hall oe

A ppedawt Wofiee avr □□□□□

po onen Te Vatnte

_ Agape) 87> “uMmMAKY Lioymenst ee By LovepevdenT

Hell up ees: 9 (kink)

porolty oF peryua oer FOWETS Rove” 3 Ay □□□□□

bo Gene ae (2% 08/80/4022 he

Dereuno As A esulf mained 1 Favor oF THE

\LokkTHer defeokavTs EMPRO MER Aways is, OF

5G apphoniion, (Set fie eniites 75 THER. □□□□

yppx. 577 Ca Lia. ey Oe RL 656 □□

at Peo □□□ ee Sake 86

| Maeve iy

| 1, USED > rt both ve ey CtAr ntele Tb

ow moves, Foc Melisk 4 + gman. FRo-Se Mounet

/80F As □□□ □□□ "Men saeco Fie Messevyere w Manerson, Aas L we ER mils, (9ee

vy nites AAS UA, 43.6, 444 Vila)),

{ , 540 US. $46; 38/- 43 (20039)

Lene The Lovett WiiMmo EDorsEd Fon Rule bo Relies, □□□ enEr On O1f9F/2024 — □□□

03/16/2024, Keles on Tite Law oF Tite Cas€

ROCHE Anil EMphas ves Tet, Are rygee] ATée Court Has CE NEGRED Aro issue, THE Tkm|

|loutt, AKA /dTeR STAze OF THe lighten, +S

«| LfrubeR 4 Rouly 7 Fe/low The Ayppellaye Cou □□□□□□ 20 stint issue, Cecon % Gy oF Syzstuce 673 □□□□ 4,197 aba aela)) The Lave oF Ti Case octauw Hareven, Yen of BIT AA Ceuta Frzom □ Diszayaneing And ERe/ex He Ismg Lov] 302022) Tireperi ©? 1s SougHT fay (RO-SE □□□□□□ 76 Vacdé wmpreyper Grant of (ule 5b, 03/0! 2244 Lalla Me

ifhow TE Veale Inprenper. GpansT | BF Semnnety Sengmesr By TanepenoenT” AtaT 3 ocnes Fe. 2, /938; BA bT eT □□ □

Jaap! Kia// BAY THE GtaAnT af SHIM □□ efit RGMENT MA BEVWEWENK tS A CorJEmaT Peper □□□ AS App lens 2 0) in) THIS CASE sfrow 7b Vacate {4 y REepew RENT “ation □ 4s Avie lank iver BQbyY AuThaTy, AS FE/fows □

see HAZEl- “Tt. las Glass Co.s, Hiatt Peas China By, 8228. 338 C1944)

LOpfene THe Couct +s | Awuly Td Fellocs THe staf Bab G On THE [RYE Summary engmew 3 □ (EEO USON? FRSIn even omits 22 An APF afer PEPE LT musT BE AdmRERER Unser Hite.

hese, Blake, E78: at GY3-LY¢ C2Ol) □□ eset” Ato), Glare Bummany ducgmen? oa FEnnandTs Mrrouts Ta Ar? mpLopeR Joan oF Summary ure men Tha LORS RES URE CnieddsaeTaniees wii Bil (LRA ExHnuTIon Cergeuner nent; (LEINETONG Svmmany ebganwt? Kygo trenton? uo via □□□ (Abiwenson \ Lraeryy LsBey 77 L481 AY2,AYS (ve)) Lyyene heube- COCR) +17 A AK TAz- wilEqury a he Cong, Chraas 2 Lee Vatks, 67/7 38 7YCA U2,4002)), A> LOS Denier wren Heolamgs tnx Beat Vy Cy oF Synaue, b73 F38 Hl, 1497 C2 Ua, AO/2) ~ Suck pert hag le fecha esis? orsly iy STON TOR Rithep Rey Bitrennent ROT760+

Te Court Aeties.2nt, lORLG HT. ve bole,

| Fi Saygp. Bk BVO, AYE CEdNY), as Lied ef tHe Case RogTRine fbuttes tis Cteez” □ | Fem grtanYing Kile bo Letiet lem tHat Neotfh we CINE bs Hera. ba —[eseen, 7 Coxe 4 Aa ST Hg pT 1s lek wa Iauty TB Foi. the H8TE Cow®l< C0 1Har Le30e, finest oF mimustAtive remedy)

| Lee THE wsTAnt eT 002, he Casati oot Condsiénance -Avarleas)) Ty Mach JexTial (exec Wow 10 THE Cov ELT oF LonTholl nny □□□□□ Bepbonant beyens Fife 78 Comply □□□□ all Ther governing Kites pues TB Qeaact Lat, 3Et77on 489, NYCRR, Far F648 of Tie 7 WninecTive _ HELD Ye, SECTIo FOIE (ANCE), Tole Glormy, | POLS ans Meyer THat Frrfupe re Awalysis oF exHauiTon 5F Abmintsfenfi bm SévEnm TE WoT Bencewe D&FEnha From Falling AL YovERg berexoentt sun 420s allege, pagtlixes Apy apphentioa Fou Summ Any Somber

bape were Anh lates heerivoh—

pron □□ rb LAD 00 “6X EP TER pay@Ie= FIVER THE / SS ef 9 BEA Aycan len 701k USCA/S bor tontlDs swnsezuertthy COUROUEN Tats Lato

Felidae Te Replys (20EVT VALE | Neko Rowr Wwolafeh on DEpATTEs

\exa Sis FO THe Cu fez, (Cstefiaay rodent, tp LLB, □□□ Lr 7972 At Pad RBNy-20/6) awn, X28 el pass Lo. v, Admel

Ae APSALLALS/ L7y oF Damire Peart emery ¢ fem, On UNAG MIEN —

epuben THESE dre ttm STAR) wes apne: □

tot te Tee) COLO. ARIA □□□

Spr A Onn Joan Coen Bcormany FonsT WeTeqe te

Aa ined ist fisles ~hWT □□

Zo carro CAE [Hee leis OF S+}Kee

Grevewente fio ttn. OOY □

Goma tron oe perth. YoYo Leow! a AVE eesT Ufa Pro Oe (CERRO

son, ation THAT >I WAJF Losier

Bory LovH VEO

his spueggtive!” Bue7y asim GHoP LAS oot TT WE

OY they, Corfina bys TE

12 20 TAR ABUT RE Hh

Lendl ee Gy pean Oe wrallintly Fr □□□

ow 12/25 12017 47 grerevaw WO,

eT al OT on) Fort fron VAbI Tint □ fAaeT te ba vant Lee Glen wh tHE

Reda fpeveaT Aon) Saye oF THe Fast oF (7Wvo [ne PO FOL 3y-Leyerel Hip Veep buementth At THE (6 Ciyperria Ain) Sige OF THe SE40W pant oF THE Suagety, Bere nant rn wot Frle A Seton YSN for tHe Cor lAacTo oF An [A CLL PE an Wee AITENMUG FLESH EVM NY SERSE aller Mensa, or S/ApH [ro FEET 10 ne 4 JORESEER le fw FECT

HET Rs peed E0TED tay eM rISIAs 9 THE QE Loot h “AFnb CHANG IY tHe DAESSING Lat enilEe Bar — ligerly, Whdes Tae FEn eAnTS Fruilem on efuse TS Pe FAs ceil Aire 1 LOOKS Four > that THe Uuvkhy yer bed. persica! Crane Ham (lesy /tis two THE Op npene Too ak SHe sn dural > /Sanse, 4 Sagoo BE eres rel” Filer | BECAUSE the © Fins] mer real yarey Are

LORS pot Timely (peo cess a Lino THE JOvernhy flit Fou Paolass Yeran ke

(Nerevnm Fy Juez 76 Fas} “ALL”

Jovending fea kr yheESERT EM RY bso ds Ieetive No, YoY Fire fHLOCESING ([Rotermuaes Concerning THE Adegysresh jam Kau s7700 oF Pom porta] Wwe Aimeatsy | Peron FO Filing PIMOATE OFS y (WeEc leben eFepkan7s From mpoplyswy AWE □□□ semmrny dudg rent 708 Str AFR riMAT va Ine Fense, (sec- FRCP Rufe □□ Calvo SCe, Ex CeeyTI0 09% 75 THE MIL KA WMAPRATORY CRAAURTIO“N Mey Me ens AT Kalinga or dw Rolling US. Supreme Covat—- ‘Pole □□□ w Kos + Bhke, 57S. At 693-94 (C20 /6). The svailaeilty oF ftrammrsTReative [lemery 40778 ph20T fitofrenly Pr GMIREDS tro THE AY page OQpmorn ans Oren, EW7ENED By tHAS AsueT On 30/9022 , hockat No. 07 wes EYE, SuoH. Avala ailiTy oF AisminytsTaT □□ Agmery Wust- ee Beez mineds ReFone A peoper yrant— Fon Summniry duagment □ ‘ChAW BE MAE, CpHwson v, lbuwensiTy oF Kowhscter. Menidal Cen. HER , GY2 F7 BR Jal, □□ C2 Gr. dot), Collin Vv; freatine , FF 3d We, fa3-/a7 C8 biadaok) Caro, Harvey , Corettionel OFficens, 1 throught ©, Fi Appr, 88, 87 We, Bols))-

(loi STPPl Toa n chem THE EKRDR yp Gear] af Surmaty= LIGMEENT

LywvarsT Tilo AND te Viole iorI BF

(Cott FR, Ri le bb Arb Con7rto}lt1 La, DePEwbatTt. Avs THE Cour 1 HE

page fone Ans ORDER Based 173 oF Slummrtey JiupgymeiT FoR tHe (REFER PANE Ufo. tHe MbsknE OF %petiFit. LittemsTAnctes Lonitp 1s We ongeR #+HE Appeepanlé Analysis APTER Foss « HbuxeveR, ‘DeTay tv THE pre G5 OF GSEV ” Ia0ESs comenTive “trorvalarhTy (herekbey □□□□ 20/¥ WL 37867Y Yole) ABopTED RO/F tl 8730178 ANY ROME BEE alko, Hennes ws Aunied), LOL B0a96F7 ATT1O CAN gee) ‘ □

sTion OF Mr mie alive fetmerbrest

Aiton) LilgaTow 4eForem Mtr CfL 4A PLUS LIT Caguines pw pormte TS exnRnust “ALL” AvirlaBle perryrt! hee farmediss Pra TE SatCOGING A Fevetrd dre ights telon, THE EXKRUST □

ptour prison IiFé, LOMETHER they Lino Mee gqewerca/ Otte OR. PAE iti bah leprsewes, ABS pate Ess OF THE □□□□ iaVTER OF THe er. (see Onsme. Goorks 3% Fad 675-% Le. ouy) A og Bren v. Ussher, 58Y US, 676, 589 (2025) □□□ eetinst- There sersminisT Rate fembirexs THey Ae Bekins □□□

moosy bamages 7HO7T Are prot” Avie □□ Ww fatson “emia VE 9/20 LEEDS,

Thx lune TO ELKHART +8 fan AP Eiremative pestenre” that must BE (LYSE Ry (AE perevnaddt, (dques vu Bowk , SY9 48, 199, Wb 007); Scts00~, Textinan , 8 Fad OY, 695 (2 Le 200%) Ks Av ht firemive REFER SE, 1775 Shh Fp err S$ relueken □□ Bae SHAT T0FF Fp let 73 □□□ THE wx Rausiionw (CEU EMET, (KEY TaussanT, 610 Fi Sug LR 518,EAS (Shry- AT)

Ll

— | PRIDQIISTRAT Fy = ALEVE AES. J Vkli& CLU/TES.. | S7A7ES Sipreeme= Cheeta] Ais HEI»

TRE tomate fnirst- Cerna hite- Ste Apna VE fle) [ULES S$ fw

eodocemante: csttl pate Leyyplrea le STATE ules, Clowes Bock SYygLLES, Ar QY-IIP. Ui, BxopFar wv. NGo, □□□ | Us-S. ©/CRQO06)) eee gain by Nez York _4___. Trener Rotess, THe Must” Bele A qarevrnta t00f/d Pee promt

gevevanig CEsohiT Commitee (L6 RL) AN PRUETISE REtISton, OF THE TGKE may Be Apoen len FZ Super □□□ wt ok THe helt Pibveévise- Peraisjows 47-7 tHe Sua’ Level May Le fypenler Fo Hes Cereal □□□□ Maeve Committee CORO), | ee Aeilenlty 5 Momnusfen tive Kemeny! Te Court ino 178 Analysis oF Derernarstt Mion Tha Bemmany arg lis ror fanoacne re LONet SAI □□□

LF the Coue7s_ HRs Corse eiss that

lneFepenavts Loeree~ fPCECLURES Fitom Ahaplhy wg Apo AE mative EFEN8E— pK Sumrww lag ment (207 ba Leola

— pAVeBEEW REIDIER Of), 19188 ER, —

Ave tla rilTy As _ KeFET Tb bn

| fhoss v. Blake /36 3. Uh at L954 QOl6) □□□ petivy Bilesu,ladtharany, CF 6 Fen, Appx SAFE Ma Aole) gusting Koss: 8 uch 3 Ty, 1m +he= GorTert oF Aremm □□□□ | sezseres 40 se can As A TeRTia) | fou! Ta, MAvnileay ex ttuTion, i pris poe!” Become Omer □□ THe Plree FRETOAS ee RETERM unis gy Such [eens KEDIE fs Z AVval Lg Qt LT □□ □□

Coven la, dx moss Teal ive Keemerss □□

Tae Cre} Fajen, 1d Coos ber 1B Anirlysis eF CxFeW Sempmneiy du NgmenT— Motzon?, LOMETHER _PrinnIiS7128iter (Ebi icby LIAS mlacle on □□□ ve! los] Cun REn □□□□□

Suppene Court fanguage Arts Cexstico/hwy rn Biles , Sysen. Ruoting Koss vt

o-Se QETTOIENS SBS bn) FOR

Baler By [ALOE BIDEIOT~ AFBT/ >.—~_____ 4s 848A d7e tay THE Lowucdts RY Page Opinions Ants Orrser THat Does 100% First Analy ce SHE | AvaleOeshiTy oF bry □□□

(CEM ETSY [WUOR TO STS Gitar OF

Ti Fo hg pest BE~ fegFeT Rem

|\T8_AS BROS Ton LeoHelaer

REFER ASTS Fa! Ti tOmpolh, Lott A THE fovéliatry Kicles For 2obEssin 1 LO MATE evan2les - Suctt Fra luaen 72 FoV/0a2. rtd 1 THE GNERD itag hisses

“nels E8TéfPe/ RAAT” Thom even

(basen Ato Pinplive "XFERSE | oe □

_Refeonan/& lsparttuae Freom THe. | eee. Loads, rns AHlayet Mid, MLECSU ASE /4 WAT oF Summary Wurgneat Fou Peron nants, By Leta.

_ iL _ Hoel FRO,

Kho ey Metipal Led se) BE Mlo-S. YUL. □

42X3 Com a/aneT 2200s AMytexes Tey fol eileen ys PATINA hy PERS □□□ □□□□ Fa 1 Damstit# Frylia Fe ChMeuTO SEA (CEMER ES.

7 Folloe Joven (MCCS of Jasevanee 43 Eaahvardanay , for) || chee Yelevanese We, GH-SEAVIALT Comeere! AG. Threents’ tons pooT

| IFPEre bts Compl arte _tutttt Wsreextive NO FOU, s¢tttiow FOS CAV(E)2 i COC SHpl) feeview ere | ___ Appen!, Kemrer 4 BEGSION ON

| bétison to He Fhei/Ty, vote Memsons STH , Fon THE YO VAT, — THe pttevante al€rk.,. THe CBE TENE _ WAWN Any B/rlecr” PRRTIES CotfAyn) tr Bo dwlewran lyrys Piet “715 pot pT peed wis Cetedvern!

| ABD IT wel ly, Fenn, D1p_AOT Fo//oo _

_ □□□ +AE GOVEMMUNG feitles. LATE YOGO, | Scav7w ZO Lo lalalin Jf | | “Cmengewtres, the- LS P_SUfJETIISOR__ AEPER Any garevavtes of AQ

| EINERG CULES UAE Rireeth, FO Appaoparate- Kespoase five! Hay) WG

_AtAonity Fd Suc fea pmmebiale oe EXPE /Tious Daerans eg Fud ____ Resour, Ary Meyer SMe A ate, L807 6S, fons Tir Te, a SIGART 0 pA Con, Oe Cert by)

off cote Ana pumete $ Or Ay Emplryeee a _Hentil , SHEIy or fAler 1S 4) SERIOUS

| ‘THe ort angen. THE SUMarevon

tert SHS CHhapestey 6

flier S8TaelcMen Free wene Beougrt By □□ Ln Ars Casing lhynIt [UO On tere Yayo, sectiow. FOLGE

_ purinte An jpre-Howser ) nav esTtigation □□

|

™ 08 | pte tHe Adleg@PoIs I COWRTHIVETS pro THe garner “7

Aftevadling Fnats SMxO pt/] oF | Ahovern DEAIIFIEK Gas ivarn te~ [Wee LESS — PRoteetings. Laat pel” Fe/lOLoEh AVDA

Server 76 THwan)l” SHE Filing oF ECOL tes SF _AhiyjpedlanAS Fl00 — gat yi Letecag | BUG Eye ee

BefiorarcTs Store ACions “e/wzvens YeserarTT-

fi (BEC Nain IT ey ver (Certrtsrssy OT aele, (882 TERT ine! Exdegi tion), (also vee Ress, sepan, Aes SAvailarihTy sf pry m rmasttytivc.

fRed& Noval. motion Fog eleF Ry

Semmaty tang mad on_pssue- Frilyace ORLA AUST— A om ST TIBI (ERTIES yy | Ze

i¢ teouws(s) One

Fee Klick Jung pment tLiesteass] Aille33, By TI EMDENT KOT Dn)

lonternindy the AppleaThn of Able 5é. By Metion Fix en ee oe zs 2 > THT THE LYVURCR YING UE VBE ons File Fa, Deteuna cle facchiwsr For Applying Fea, Axaemative Défense" 4wh- (Seamaty CefieP OnTtHEe-Vaners OF Peete Ak free 15. Cesrrygly bo □□ 7720 Minsg Littos ptabfon Wey COCA y rleles } COME SANT □ Looe ACs proms BITES KURA Mmaredtony Be ENTE NG LOST □□ oF Pomualiafive Cemeny, (SEE Conastiron lar, SEAT iD -3BS, avr sods... QyaeeTive- Fi ofp (tompmne Rites ve Bvertenn, FE. Kop. SH La biaPt) | Bee Ros Lboke, SAP US: at 683-47

Goon ok STATI? Se borer WER, WE Oye pgTJRn0es LOOKS MD. lAssauftén THE WWE Geel7y ol the Couct

| LOAETHER ore roo he Re reopant LOEKHE EXVII/EN TS SuaH- Stmmany oo parent Myahag]70s). Csee- PREP Rule 5Z) (tks Ser Avatraoa v. [i @erTy Lo BB. _SFF U8, RYA, □□□ C19 $6); Hemp Hl 0. Sate oF Mew York, 880 F 3k 68, 696 (2422004); KEV ws Toussaint, 640 F’ Suga, AR 5/7, □□□ CsdWy~-d009)) Semmprey détteymenIt LAREN (Pe Cvrétwra Tan les wns,” Fraubs on tHe Aer oF tHe Cour.” (see FRCP Rule bO(3) (Also SGE ctotiay uw, Ups WeTesiTy, oF RotHhesten Merrie] Goin, 64% F3d 121,195 (2 bn,don)) Ane. loess FE F3L at EF Ca Lie), Bean v- CLARK, 7a7 Fad 67%, 7O4¥ (rbin □□□□

ZL Sun: Wolou 73 Vacate THe CoucTs O¥ Gp 2022 Peony SangmenT % y Lu prepenrsen)T Atpiow Cf

SSSSSESeseM

Sous bE qaAnTbh , W/30FER AS □ HER IodTme ferenh, (FALL Auk 33), (sex a Lastiro Le Wishes STATES, 5% U3. □□ 3¥7/-¥3 (3003) Kei Chenks wutNpaity 73 We C/a8s/Fy Suem agra )e (1 Litem h lv Yreronsew, 20/6 WL 12°79 99. CBB HY -Id 46) hei Coutts preoper HETHUg Ta Vermin ore Autrlyze, EXAAUSTIO) OF ferme rnatrve (Comers), ( Maze/- Atlas G □□□□ Co. Hany Forn Empire, Coy 822 UE 2B □□□□ Ei MusTPrTlow [BEfov70 Vacanze By

were’ 08/olfroay LER My Svemitten

Baral ph Hea) GALE SOY Keute Mh Shem fle, NY (Fe

PC?

loaifatle oF Gevite

5 Hole Mall *OSAS8S7 say Aenetty? of petyuay thay HE Served By aS OS, 1m SASE, Wofiee ano Comemers Notion □ 78 Vadde Summany Atregment- tay Tnvepensenst Aetow YeuJe BB) TEL

Us sé /Sdany A, Spren JS. Yawn □ 500 Pern! Sthect R«sTe Gol, Genenn/ NED York, NY 12007 Bnys A Gevene| 48 I avgsay lems) 3ay Leenty S7aect RYC, BY SOOO ks. es/oifsosy — Lik Hall Rolph Nel AS38367 | SITY Lote BIG sxe Ile, NY paste

¥ □□ 4 9 NX & & ER g 4 ety BO BER □ OD a

88%

eK ye SS 3 □□□ FS

oe] (© ow a

| IS eG

Plaintiff has filed a Motion to Vacate the Court’s Summary Judgment Order “by Independent Action” (the “Motion”). (See Dkt. Nos. 209-12.) However, the Court notes that Plaintiff has also filed a Notice of Appeal. in which he appeals the Court’s denials of his motions pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60 for relie from that same summary judgment order. (See Dkt. No. 207.) “As a general matter, the filing of the notice of appeal confers jurisdiction on the court of appeals and divests the district court of its control over those aspects of the case involved in the appeal.” United States v. Jacques 6 F.4th 337, 342 (2d Cir. 2021) (quotation marks and emphasis omitted). “It is not tolerable to have a district court and a court of appeals simultaneously analyzing the same judgment, [that is,] to have situations in which district courts and courts of appeals would both have the power to modify the same judgment[.]” /d. (alterations adopted) (quotation marks and citations omitted). Although, in certain situations, clerical corrections may be made to a judgment under appeal, “substantive modifications of a judgment while an appe: is pending” are not permitted. /d. at 344. Accordingly, Plaintiff's Motion is denied, because the Court lacks jurisdiction to vacate the challenged order and judgment. See Caldwell v. City of New York, No. 21-CV-6560, 2024 WL 1586695, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Apr. 11, 2024) (denying the plaintiff's motion for reconsideration of the court’s summary judgment opinion on tk basis that the plaintiffs notice of appeal divested the district court of jurisdiction). The Clerk of Court is respectfully asked to terminate the pending Motion, (see Dkt. No. 211), and to mail a copy of this document to Plaintiff. SO ORDERED.

4/29/2024