Page 1 of 11
NO.04-14-00509-CV If ■■-.
3 ;r- FOURTH COURT OF APPEALS DISTRICT 1 -■rn Q 3:
CADENA-REEVES JUSTICE CENTER
300 Dolorosa, Suite 300
San Antonio, Texas 78205-3037
February 9, 2015
APPELLANTS BRIEF
GLORIA E. OCHOA-APPELLANT, APPELLANT IN PROPIA PERSONA
V.
NAIL FLOWER NAIL/BEAUTY SALON-APPELLEE. m
GJ
ON APPEAL FROM THE 224TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURTS
IN BEXAR COUNTY, TEXAS c^
CAUSE NUMBER 2013-CI-12691 Page 2 of 11
From the 224th Judicial District Court, Bexar County, Texas
Trial Court No 2013-CI-12691
Honorable Antonia Arteaga, Judge Presiding
Appellant/Plaintiff: Plaintiff/Appellant's Counsel
Gloria E. Ochoa -Appellant in Propria Persona
542 Williamsburg Place
San Antonio, Texas 78201
Phone: 210-308-0744
Phone: 210-736-1408 Page 3 of 11
Appellee/Defendant: Defendant/Appellee's Counsel:
Campbell, Miller & Associates
Elizabeth W. Lennane
IBN. 24053014
300 Convent, Suite 2350
San Antonio, Texas 78205
Phone: 210-229-9879
Fax 210-229-9878 Page 4 of 11
Summary:
Gloria E Ochoa, plaintiff, moves the court to set aside the Summary Judgment rendered against it on 6-19-14 and grant a new Trial. Seeking justice in this Personal Injury case.
Citation: This case did not go to trial and thus no court reporter records available.
1. This motion is presented within the time limits prescribed by the Texas rules of Civil procedure for Motion for a new trial.
2. The Judgment of the court is contrary to law.
3. There was insufficient evidence to support the engorgement as delivered, as Plaintiff was not allowed to present reasons for not responding in a timely manner.
4. Plaintiffs failure to file an answer before judgment was the result of an accident and or mistake, rather than due to an intentional act or the result of conscious indifference.
5. Plaintiff "is" the "Injured Party" and unrepresented by attorney as previous attorney abruptly canceled agreement to represent her. Plaintiff has been unable to locate other attorney who would take case due to limited time frame to research/work on this case. Also, Plaintiff is and has been under ongoing medical care and continues to suffer from effects of staph infection obtained at the Defendants place of business/Nail Flower Salon.
6. Plaintiff/Gloria E Ochoa has been and is currently under physicians care and on medication for extreme pain. Diminished use of hands, fingers, loss of balance in legs/feet & other related injuries, since date of injury in 2011. Plaintiff is now disabled and no longer able to work. Prior to this injury, Plaintiff worked over 40 years and was going to work an additional 10 years before retiring.
7. Above described situation and severe injuries from staph infection at nail salon prevented Plaintiff from responding in a timely manner. Page 5 of 11
8. Gloria E Ochoa files this Appeal Brief complaining of defendant and how defendant caused great "Personal Injury" to her.
9. Gloria E Ochoa requests opportunity for verbal discussion/elaboration etc, to answer in person any questions from the judges to decide this case.
10. Gloria E. Ochoa requests your help and compassionate review of this case and grant a new trial. Gloria E Ochoa is a single senior citizen and raising 4 grandchildren, ages 13,11, 7 and 5.
Thank you. Page 6 of 11
HOW WAS I INJURED?
On August 9th, 2011, Gloria E Ochoa, plaintiff, went to Nail Flower Beauty/Nail Salon located at 4535 Fredericksburg Rd, Suite 211, San Antonio, Texas to have a manicure.
See included copy of my bank record showing date of visit to Nail Flower Nail/Beauty Salon and charges.
Manicure preformed by employee, Ben Nguyen. Gloria Ochoa, plaintiff was instructed by "soak" her nails in manicure dish that had a soap solution to soften cuticles.
A short while later, Gloria Ochoa, plaintiff, suffered severe infection to thumb, that necessitated emergency medical treatment. Thumb was very swollen, blue in color and extremely painful.
Treatment included "lancing" of thumb to expel infection. Subsequent and ongoing pain in left thumb & hand. Discoloration, Disfigurement /Loss of use on thumb and hand. Chronic ongoing pain in thumb and hand/shoulder, IAccount number: July 29, 2011 - August 25, 2011 WELLS FARGO
Transaction history (continued)
Check Deposits/ Withdrawals/ Ending daily Date Number Description Additions Subtractions balance 8/4 POS Purchase - 08/04 Mach ID 000000 Samsclub #8227 San 130.54 6.822.25 Antonio TX 3860 0O4612167B42531S0 ?McC°5300 8/5 Check Crd Purchase 08/03 El Potlo Loco «S950 San Antonio TX 4.42 434258xx)ooc<3860 217140008285929 7McC°S814 90 8/5 Check Crd Purchase 08/03 Taco Cabana #105 San Antonio TX 7.45 434258)00000(3860 217140006192098 7McC°5814 90 8/5 Check Crd Purchase 08/03 McDonald's F78S0 San Antonio TX 11.88 4342SBxxxxx»3860 217140010620379 7McC"5814 90 8/5 Check Crd Purchase 08/04 LA MIchoacana SA4 San Antonio TX 6.48 434258X10O0OO860 217140008364040 TMcC-5411 90 8/5 POS Purchase - 08/05 Mach ID 000000 Dollar-General San 62.51 Antonio TX 3860 00301217681393338 7McC°S310 8/5 1451 Check 225.60 6,503.91 8/8 Check Crd Purchase 08/04 SA Goodwill-Summit#29 San Antonio 15.07 TX 434258)oooc«3860 219140021493542 7McC=S691 90 8/8 POS Purchase - 08/06 Mach ID 000000 Dollar-General San 24.12 6.464.72 Antonio TX 3860 00301219048715524 7McC°5310 Check Crd Purchase 08/08 Fedex Office #0127 San Antonio TX 18.96 I860 221140006943859 ?McC°7338 90^——— Check Crd Purchase 08/08 Nail Rower San Antonio TX 434258xxxxxx3S60 221140011622307 7McC"7230 90 50.00 T Cheat Crd Purchase 08/08 Hub tf356 San Antonio TX 130.19 434258)00000(3860 221140014360087 7McC°5411 90 ATM Withdrawal - 08/09 Mach ID Wtxw2106 'Store #2106 'Store 202.00 #21 San Antonio TX 3860 00301221749110586 8/9 Non-Wella Famo ATM Transaction Fee 2.50 6.061.07 8/10 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Sonic #3630 San Antonio TX 8.59 434258)00001x3860 222140014729801 7McC°S814 90 8/10 POS Purchase - 08/10 Mach ID 000000 Samsclub #8227 San 55.31 5.997.17 Antonio TX 3860 00581222687040546 7McC°5300 6/11 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Salvation Army • Son A San Antonio TX 3.77 434258)0OOC«3860 223140006996477 7McC°S931 90 8/11 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Total 20 Shamrock San Antonio TX 11.48 434258)00000(3660 223140008476103 7McC»5541 90 8/11 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Salvation Army - San A San Antonio TX 23.74 4342S8xxxxxx3860 223140006996476 7McC°5931 90 8/11 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Total 20 Shamrock San Antonio TX 35.05 434258)00000(3860 223140OQ8476109 ?McC°S542 90 Check Crd Purchase 08/10 LA MIchoacana SA4 San Antonio TX 8.92 434258)00000(3860 223140O0814S801 7McC"5411 90 POS Purchase-08/11 Mach ID 000000Dollar-General San 18.11 5.896.10 Antonio TX 3860 00461223771799102 ?McC°S310 Check Crd Purchase 08/11 Taquerta Jalisco 13 San Antonio TX 10.80 5,885.30 434258)00ixxx3860 224140014543417 7McC°5612 90 VTM Statement Fee - 08/13 Mach ID 0202F 4522 Fredrlcksburg 1.00 Rd.. Sen Antonio. TX 3860 Check Crd Purchase 08/12 a Polio Loco #5950 San Antonio TX 4.42 434258xxxxxx3860 226140007912421 7McC»5814 90 Check Crd Purchase 08/12 Taquoria Jalisco 13 San Antonio TX 551 43425B)ooooo(3660 226140029346497 7McC°5B12 90 (Crd Purchase 08/12 Subway 00023689 San Antonio TX 9.19 434258)0000013860 226140008431941 7McC°5814 90 Check Crd Purchase 08/12 Hab #556 San Antonio TX 73.88 4342S8)oooooi3860 226140028791708 ?McC°5411 90 POS Purchase • 08/13 Mach ID 000000 Sales N Service Sugarland 32.43 TX 3860 005812255SS231633 7McC=-4812 POS Purchase - 08/13 Mach ID 000000 Stein Mart.
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
Page 1 of 11
NO.04-14-00509-CV If ■■-.
3 ;r- FOURTH COURT OF APPEALS DISTRICT 1 -■rn Q 3:
CADENA-REEVES JUSTICE CENTER
300 Dolorosa, Suite 300
San Antonio, Texas 78205-3037
February 9, 2015
APPELLANTS BRIEF
GLORIA E. OCHOA-APPELLANT, APPELLANT IN PROPIA PERSONA
V.
NAIL FLOWER NAIL/BEAUTY SALON-APPELLEE. m
GJ
ON APPEAL FROM THE 224TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURTS
IN BEXAR COUNTY, TEXAS c^
CAUSE NUMBER 2013-CI-12691 Page 2 of 11
From the 224th Judicial District Court, Bexar County, Texas
Trial Court No 2013-CI-12691
Honorable Antonia Arteaga, Judge Presiding
Appellant/Plaintiff: Plaintiff/Appellant's Counsel
Gloria E. Ochoa -Appellant in Propria Persona
542 Williamsburg Place
San Antonio, Texas 78201
Phone: 210-308-0744
Phone: 210-736-1408 Page 3 of 11
Appellee/Defendant: Defendant/Appellee's Counsel:
Campbell, Miller & Associates
Elizabeth W. Lennane
IBN. 24053014
300 Convent, Suite 2350
San Antonio, Texas 78205
Phone: 210-229-9879
Fax 210-229-9878 Page 4 of 11
Summary:
Gloria E Ochoa, plaintiff, moves the court to set aside the Summary Judgment rendered against it on 6-19-14 and grant a new Trial. Seeking justice in this Personal Injury case.
Citation: This case did not go to trial and thus no court reporter records available.
1. This motion is presented within the time limits prescribed by the Texas rules of Civil procedure for Motion for a new trial.
2. The Judgment of the court is contrary to law.
3. There was insufficient evidence to support the engorgement as delivered, as Plaintiff was not allowed to present reasons for not responding in a timely manner.
4. Plaintiffs failure to file an answer before judgment was the result of an accident and or mistake, rather than due to an intentional act or the result of conscious indifference.
5. Plaintiff "is" the "Injured Party" and unrepresented by attorney as previous attorney abruptly canceled agreement to represent her. Plaintiff has been unable to locate other attorney who would take case due to limited time frame to research/work on this case. Also, Plaintiff is and has been under ongoing medical care and continues to suffer from effects of staph infection obtained at the Defendants place of business/Nail Flower Salon.
6. Plaintiff/Gloria E Ochoa has been and is currently under physicians care and on medication for extreme pain. Diminished use of hands, fingers, loss of balance in legs/feet & other related injuries, since date of injury in 2011. Plaintiff is now disabled and no longer able to work. Prior to this injury, Plaintiff worked over 40 years and was going to work an additional 10 years before retiring.
7. Above described situation and severe injuries from staph infection at nail salon prevented Plaintiff from responding in a timely manner. Page 5 of 11
8. Gloria E Ochoa files this Appeal Brief complaining of defendant and how defendant caused great "Personal Injury" to her.
9. Gloria E Ochoa requests opportunity for verbal discussion/elaboration etc, to answer in person any questions from the judges to decide this case.
10. Gloria E. Ochoa requests your help and compassionate review of this case and grant a new trial. Gloria E Ochoa is a single senior citizen and raising 4 grandchildren, ages 13,11, 7 and 5.
Thank you. Page 6 of 11
HOW WAS I INJURED?
On August 9th, 2011, Gloria E Ochoa, plaintiff, went to Nail Flower Beauty/Nail Salon located at 4535 Fredericksburg Rd, Suite 211, San Antonio, Texas to have a manicure.
See included copy of my bank record showing date of visit to Nail Flower Nail/Beauty Salon and charges.
Manicure preformed by employee, Ben Nguyen. Gloria Ochoa, plaintiff was instructed by "soak" her nails in manicure dish that had a soap solution to soften cuticles.
A short while later, Gloria Ochoa, plaintiff, suffered severe infection to thumb, that necessitated emergency medical treatment. Thumb was very swollen, blue in color and extremely painful.
Treatment included "lancing" of thumb to expel infection. Subsequent and ongoing pain in left thumb & hand. Discoloration, Disfigurement /Loss of use on thumb and hand. Chronic ongoing pain in thumb and hand/shoulder, IAccount number: July 29, 2011 - August 25, 2011 WELLS FARGO
Transaction history (continued)
Check Deposits/ Withdrawals/ Ending daily Date Number Description Additions Subtractions balance 8/4 POS Purchase - 08/04 Mach ID 000000 Samsclub #8227 San 130.54 6.822.25 Antonio TX 3860 0O4612167B42531S0 ?McC°5300 8/5 Check Crd Purchase 08/03 El Potlo Loco «S950 San Antonio TX 4.42 434258xx)ooc<3860 217140008285929 7McC°S814 90 8/5 Check Crd Purchase 08/03 Taco Cabana #105 San Antonio TX 7.45 434258)00000(3860 217140006192098 7McC°5814 90 8/5 Check Crd Purchase 08/03 McDonald's F78S0 San Antonio TX 11.88 4342SBxxxxx»3860 217140010620379 7McC"5814 90 8/5 Check Crd Purchase 08/04 LA MIchoacana SA4 San Antonio TX 6.48 434258X10O0OO860 217140008364040 TMcC-5411 90 8/5 POS Purchase - 08/05 Mach ID 000000 Dollar-General San 62.51 Antonio TX 3860 00301217681393338 7McC°S310 8/5 1451 Check 225.60 6,503.91 8/8 Check Crd Purchase 08/04 SA Goodwill-Summit#29 San Antonio 15.07 TX 434258)oooc«3860 219140021493542 7McC=S691 90 8/8 POS Purchase - 08/06 Mach ID 000000 Dollar-General San 24.12 6.464.72 Antonio TX 3860 00301219048715524 7McC°5310 Check Crd Purchase 08/08 Fedex Office #0127 San Antonio TX 18.96 I860 221140006943859 ?McC°7338 90^——— Check Crd Purchase 08/08 Nail Rower San Antonio TX 434258xxxxxx3S60 221140011622307 7McC"7230 90 50.00 T Cheat Crd Purchase 08/08 Hub tf356 San Antonio TX 130.19 434258)00000(3860 221140014360087 7McC°5411 90 ATM Withdrawal - 08/09 Mach ID Wtxw2106 'Store #2106 'Store 202.00 #21 San Antonio TX 3860 00301221749110586 8/9 Non-Wella Famo ATM Transaction Fee 2.50 6.061.07 8/10 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Sonic #3630 San Antonio TX 8.59 434258)00001x3860 222140014729801 7McC°S814 90 8/10 POS Purchase - 08/10 Mach ID 000000 Samsclub #8227 San 55.31 5.997.17 Antonio TX 3860 00581222687040546 7McC°5300 6/11 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Salvation Army • Son A San Antonio TX 3.77 434258)0OOC«3860 223140006996477 7McC°S931 90 8/11 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Total 20 Shamrock San Antonio TX 11.48 434258)00000(3660 223140008476103 7McC»5541 90 8/11 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Salvation Army - San A San Antonio TX 23.74 4342S8xxxxxx3860 223140006996476 7McC°5931 90 8/11 Check Crd Purchase 08/09 Total 20 Shamrock San Antonio TX 35.05 434258)00000(3860 223140OQ8476109 ?McC°S542 90 Check Crd Purchase 08/10 LA MIchoacana SA4 San Antonio TX 8.92 434258)00000(3860 223140O0814S801 7McC"5411 90 POS Purchase-08/11 Mach ID 000000Dollar-General San 18.11 5.896.10 Antonio TX 3860 00461223771799102 ?McC°S310 Check Crd Purchase 08/11 Taquerta Jalisco 13 San Antonio TX 10.80 5,885.30 434258)00ixxx3860 224140014543417 7McC°5612 90 VTM Statement Fee - 08/13 Mach ID 0202F 4522 Fredrlcksburg 1.00 Rd.. Sen Antonio. TX 3860 Check Crd Purchase 08/12 a Polio Loco #5950 San Antonio TX 4.42 434258xxxxxx3860 226140007912421 7McC»5814 90 Check Crd Purchase 08/12 Taquoria Jalisco 13 San Antonio TX 551 43425B)ooooo(3660 226140029346497 7McC°5B12 90 (Crd Purchase 08/12 Subway 00023689 San Antonio TX 9.19 434258)0000013860 226140008431941 7McC°5814 90 Check Crd Purchase 08/12 Hab #556 San Antonio TX 73.88 4342S8)oooooi3860 226140028791708 ?McC°5411 90 POS Purchase • 08/13 Mach ID 000000 Sales N Service Sugarland 32.43 TX 3860 005812255SS231633 7McC=-4812 POS Purchase - 08/13 Mach ID 000000 Stein Mart. Inc San 17.30 Antonio TX 3860 00301226042704616 7McCa5310 I Crd Purchase 08/13 Burlington Coa000016S1 San Antonio 6.48 TX4342SB)OOC«x3860 227140004635139 7McC°5651 80 Purchase 08/13 The Right Choice #1 San Antcnlo TX 40.00 434258xxxxxx3860 227140009800950 7McC°5S42 90
Sheet Saq = 0015544 Sheet 00002 cf 00004 Page 7 of 11
DEFENDANTS BREACH OF DUTY.
Defendant "OWED" plaintiff a "Duty" to "Care", "To Protect" its client by cleaning, disinfecting, sterilizing all its equipment.
Emergency room doctors termed this a severe "Staph" infection due to nail salon not/sterilizing/cleaning their soaking dishes /equipment etc.
Defendant "Breached the duty owed" to Plaintiff in that they FAILED to properly disinfect, sterilize, clean their equipment.
DEFENDANTS NEGLIGENCE.
As the direct and proximate cause of the defendants "NEGLIGENCE", plaintiff suffered the following personal injuries:
Pain and Suffering, Loss of Use for thumb and hand. Inability to continue working/earn a living, disabled status, loss of earning ability, now and future earnings, emotional stress, anxiety, etc. Significant unpaid med bills due to these injuries. Ongoing medical treatment*. Page 8 of 11
WHAT DO I WANT TO SEE COME OUT OF THIS NEW TRIAL?
1.1 do not want this to happen to any other innocent person walking in to this nail salon for a simple manicure.
Needless ONGOING suffering due to Defendants Negligence.
2. Defendant must ACCEPT FULL RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE GREAT INJURY THEY HAVE CAUSED.
They must sterilize all equipment with each client or use disposable equipment.
3. SEEKING REASONABLE COMPENSATION for ONGOING PAIN and SUFFERING /LOSS OF USE FOR THUMB/HAND. DISFIGUREMENT FOR THUMB. DISABLED STATUS DUE TO THIS "STAPH INFECTION" THAT COULD HAVE NEEN AVOIDED BY DEFENDANT "STERILIZIING" EQUIPMENT. LOSS OF ABILITY TO EARN A LIVING NOW AND FUTURE EARNINGS and payment of unpaid med bills. I had intended to work another 10 years before starting social security. That option was taken away by defendants NEGLIGENCE . PAGE 9 OF 11
PRAYER FOR RELIEF.
Therefore, plaintiff, respectfully requests Judgment/
Reversal of summary judgment against plaintiff and grant a New Trial.
1. Damages in an amount within the jurisdictional limits of the court.
2. Pre-and postjudgement interest on that amount of the legal rates.
3. Costs of suit and
4. Any other relief to which plaintiff is entitled.
Respectfully submitted,
Gloria E. Ochoa an Individual, Plaintiff.
Phone:210-309-0744. 210-736-1408
Phone: 210-331-4492 Page 10 of 11
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE 192.3
I, the undersigned, Gloria E. Ochoa, certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was served to Defendants attorney by "Certified" mail, return receipt requested.
Gloria E Ochoa
542 Williamsburg PI.
Phone: 210-309-0744
Phone: 210-736-1408 Page 11 of 11
CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE WITH BRIEF LENGTH AND TYPE SIZE REQUIREMENTS.
BRIEF LENTH:
I certify that (1) this brief complies with the word-count limitation in ORAP 5.05 (2) the word count of this brief (as described in ORAP 5.5 (2) (a) is 1,747 or less. (1137 words).
I certify that the size of the type in this brief is not smaller that 14 points for both the text of the brief and footnotes as required by ORAP 5.05 (4) (1). 14 font size.
Gloria E. Ochoa,