Genova v. FLA. NAT. BANK OF PALM BEACH CTY.

433 So. 2d 1211
CourtDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida
DecidedJuly 27, 1983
Docket81-941
StatusPublished
Cited by4 cases

This text of 433 So. 2d 1211 (Genova v. FLA. NAT. BANK OF PALM BEACH CTY.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering District Court of Appeal of Florida primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Genova v. FLA. NAT. BANK OF PALM BEACH CTY., 433 So. 2d 1211 (Fla. Ct. App. 1983).

Opinion

433 So.2d 1211 (1983)

Ann Cleary GENOVA, Appellant,
v.
The FLORIDA NATIONAL BANK OF PALM BEACH COUNTY, a National Banking Institution, Appellee.

No. 81-941.

District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fourth District.

February 2, 1983.
As Modified on Denial of Motions for Rehearing and to Intervene July 27, 1983.

*1212 Elaine F. Miller of Miller & Miller, P.A., West Palm Beach, for appellant.

Victoria F. Peet of Gibson & Gibson, West Palm Beach, for appellee.

Richard A. Kupfer of Cone, Wagner, Nugent, Johnson, Hazouri & Roth, P.A., West Palm Beach, for intervenors.

GLICKSTEIN, Judge.

This is an appeal by the settlor of a revocable trust from a final judgment which dismissed her petition for writ of mandamus and granted the appellee/trustee's petition for instructions. We reverse and remand with direction to grant the writ of mandamus. The final judgment reads in part:

2. This matter is centered around an attempted revocation of a revocable trust which was created by a trust agreement dated January 31, 1979, between Ann Cleary Genova as Settlor and Co-trustee and the Florida National Bank of Palm Beach County as Trustee. The trust agreement was modified by written instruments dated May 15, 1979, August 27, 1979 and May 12, 1980. Based upon the attempted revocation of the trust, a Petition for Writ of Mandamus was filed by Ann Cleary Genova requesting the entry of an order compelling the Florida National Bank of Palm Beach County to surrender the assets of the trust to Ann Cleary Genova. A Petition for Instructions was then filed by the Florida National Bank of Palm Beach County in the discharge of its duties as a fiduciary under the trust. The Petition stated that the Trustee doubted the validity of the attempted revocation due to the possible exertion of undue influence by Mark T. Genova.
3. Mark T. Genova and Ann Cleary Genova were married on September 5, 1978, at Las Vegas, Nevada. The marriage was dissolved by the Order of the Honorable Thomas E. Sholts on October 10, 1979. Bifurcated jurisdiction was retained to determine certain property rights between the parties. On April 28, 1980, Judge Sholts entered his final judgment and in the terms thereof found that an agreement titled "Resolution and Affidavit" executed by Ann Cleary Genova, and which Mark T. Genova sought to enforce, was void as having been procured by the undue influence of Mark T. Genova.
4. On July 3, 1980, Mark T. Genova and Ann Cleary Genova were remarried at Fort Lauderdale, Florida. At the time of their marriage, Mrs. Genova was approximately forty-five (45) years older than Mr. Genova.
5. By letter dated July 8, 1980, Ann Cleary Genova advised the Florida National Bank of Palm Beach County that she wished to transfer the trust assets fo [sic] the First National Bank of Riviera Beach. This letter was signed in the presence of Mark T. Genova at the Alibi Bar in West Palm Beach, Florida which was owned by Mr. Genova. On July 9, 1980, Ann Cleary Genova signed a power of attorney directing the transfer of the trust assets to the account of Ann Cleary Genova in the Pan American Bank of Palm Beach County, Florida. On July 10, 1980, this power of attorney was presented by Billy R. Jackson to Brenda Earl, a Trust Officer of the Florida National Bank of Palm Beach County. On July 11, 1980, Ann Cleary Genova and Billy R. Jackson advised Robert J. Pflieger, a Trust Officer of the Florida National Bank of Palm Beach County, that Ann *1213 Cleary Genova wished to revoke the above trust.
6. In the month following the attempted revocation of the trust, Ann Cleary Genova transferred her only asset not in trust, a commercial rental property, to Mark T. Genova reserving the right to rents and profits during her lifetime. Shortly thereafter, Ann Cleary Genova executed a new will in which Mark T. Genova received her residuary estate. During this same period of time, Ann Cleary Genova signed a real estate contract to purchase a residence for One Hundred Fifty Thousand Dollars ($150,000.00).
7. The Court finds that the attempts made by Ann Cleary Genova during July of 1980 to revoke the aforesaid trust were effected through the use of undue influence, practiced intentionally by Mark T. Genova upon Ann Cleary Genova and that the revocation attempts are therefore determined to be invalid and of no legal significance.

Although the final judgment and the parties' briefs center upon the question whether appellant was unduly influenced to revoke the trust by her husband — 45 years her junior — we conclude that not to be the determinative question. Instead, we believe the latter to be whether the settlor, who is the sole beneficiary of the trust during her lifetime (subject to her right to direct otherwise) could be deprived, prior to her death, of her right to revoke the trust in the absence of judicial determination or medical certification of her physical or mental incapacity. We answer that question in the negative.

The trust consisted of over $475,000 in treasury bills, certificates of deposit and a savings account. Paragraph 3 of the instrument creating the trust provided with respect to management of the trust:

3. During the lifetime of the SETTLOR, and unless this Trust Agreement shall have been otherwise revoked or amended, the TRUSTEES shall retain and administer the property comprising the TRUST ESTATE in the manner following:
(a) Unless the SETTLOR shall be or become incapacitated as defined in Subparagraph (b) hereinafter, the TRUSTEES shall retain and safeguard the property comprising the TRUST ESTATE, shall collect the income therefrom and shall pay to the SETTLOR or apply to her benefit, the net income derived therefrom in quarterly or other convenient installments, or upon direction of the SETTLOR shall pay and distribute such net income to such person, or persons, and in such proportions as the SETTLOR may from time to time direct. During such times, the SETTLOR shall be solely and entirely responsible for the management and investment of the properties comprising the TRUST ESTATE, and any changes in investment or purchases or sales of the Trust assets shall be made by the TRUSTEES only at the written direction of the SETTLOR; and the TRUSTEES' sole duties hereunder shall consist of the holding and administration of the TRUST ESTATE, maintaining accurate and appropriate records, the collection and distribution of income and the performance of such other ministerial duties in connection therewith as shall be deemed proper in their sole discretion.
(b) Upon the occurrence of any one or more of the following events, TRUSTEES shall assume full responsibility of the management and investment of the TRUST ESTATE:
(1) The receipt by the TRUSTEES from the SETTLOR of a signed statement requesting and directing that the TRUSTEES assume full management and investment of the TRUST ESTATE, and the acceptance of such direction by the TRUSTEES.
(2) The adjudication by a court of competent jurisdiction of the physical or mental incompetency of the SETTLOR.
(3) The receipt by the TRUSTEES of a certificate in writing executed by the *1214 attending physician of the SETTLOR certifying that the SETTLOR has become incapable of the management of her business and personal affairs by reason of physical or mental disability.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

MacIntyre v. Wedell
12 So. 3d 273 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2009)
Brundage v. Bank of America
996 So. 2d 877 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2008)
In re the Trust of Genova
472 So. 2d 478 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 1985)
FLA. NAT. BANK OF PALM BEACH CTY. v. Genova
460 So. 2d 895 (Supreme Court of Florida, 1984)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
433 So. 2d 1211, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/genova-v-fla-nat-bank-of-palm-beach-cty-fladistctapp-1983.