Fort Dearborn Life Insurance v. Holcomb

736 N.E.2d 578, 316 Ill. App. 3d 485, 249 Ill. Dec. 384, 2000 Ill. App. LEXIS 710
CourtAppellate Court of Illinois
DecidedAugust 28, 2000
Docket1-99-3627
StatusPublished
Cited by23 cases

This text of 736 N.E.2d 578 (Fort Dearborn Life Insurance v. Holcomb) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Appellate Court of Illinois primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Fort Dearborn Life Insurance v. Holcomb, 736 N.E.2d 578, 316 Ill. App. 3d 485, 249 Ill. Dec. 384, 2000 Ill. App. LEXIS 710 (Ill. Ct. App. 2000).

Opinion

JUSTICE COHEN

delivered the opinion of the court:

Following the death of Paul Downing, plaintiff Fort Dearborn Life Insurance Company filed an interpleader action (735 ILCS 5/2 — 409 (West 1998)) against Susan Downing, the decedent’s widow, and Janet Holcomb, the decedent’s companion at the time of his death. The action sought to resolve competing claims to the proceeds of two insurance policies decedent held with the plaintiff. Defendant-appellant Janet Holcomb appeals from the circuit court of Cook County’s grant of summary judgment in favor of defendant-appellee Susan Downing which declared Susan the proper beneficiary under the life insurance policies. Janet argues that the trial court erred in applying the provisions of the Illinois Power of Attorney Act (755 ILCS 45/1 — 1 et seq. (West 1998)) to the uncontested facts with regard to two issues: (1) the scope of the agent’s authority pursuant to the subject power of attorney and (2) whether the agent’s authority had been revoked. For the following reasons, we reverse and remand for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

I. FACTS

Paul and Susan Downing were married on February 27, 1967. The couple had three children. On June 27, 1990, Paul executed a document entitled “Power of Attorney” (1990 power) which appointed his wife Susan as his agent to act on his behalf in certain enumerated property transactions. The agency created by the 1990 power became effective only upon Paul’s disability. In 1992, Paul and Susan experienced marital difficulties which culminated in Paul’s departure from the marital home in June of 1992. In 1993, Susan filed a petition for dissolution of marriage in the circuit court of Cook County under case number 93 D 6708.

On December 22, 1993, Paul and Susan entered into a formal separation agreement (1993 agreement) which provided for the equitable distribution of most of their assets in the event that their current attempts at reconciliation failed. Assets accounted for in the 1993 agreement included the Downings’ marital home, located at 1015 Pine Street in Winnetka, Illinois, a single-family residence in Galena, Illinois, which the Downings owned jointly through a land trust, jointly held investment accounts with a total value of $1,328,400 and retirement funds owned by Paul totaling $1,099,950. The agreement further provided that neither party would by beneficiary designation, will, inter vivos trust or in any other way allow the property subject to the agreement to become the property of any other person at the death of the party holding title.

At the time the 1993 separation agreement was executed, Paul was the named insured on two group life insurance policies issued by the Fort Dearborn Life Insurance Company. The first policy was issued to the Safer Foundation, Paul’s employer, as policyholder with a death benefit equal to $158,000. The second policy was issued to Healthcare Services Corporation, as policyholder, with a death benefit of $120,000. The 1993 agreement did not account for or include any reference to the subject life insurance policies. The policies named Susan Downing as the sole beneficiary.

Sometime prior to 1994, Paul returned to the marital home. On April 19, 1994, Paul and Susan executed an additional agreement whereby Paul agreed to leave the marital home and to remove most of his possessions. Paul and Susan lived separate and apart from that time forward. In 1995, a second petition for dissolution of the Downing marriage was filed in the circuit court of Cook County under case number 95 D 3620.

In early June 1995, Paul became seriously ill and sought medical treatment at Northwestern Memorial Hospital. During a series of admissions to Northwestern, Paul was diagnosed with a widespread, virulent cancer. His health rapidly deteriorated. Paul died from cancer on July 7, 1995, leaving three adult sons and his estranged wife Susan surviving him.

For several years prior to and continuing until his death, Paul Downing was involved in a romantic relationship with Janet Holcomb. While confined to Northwestern for tests and treatment, Paul requested that his private secretary, Laverne Anderson, obtain change of beneficiary forms for his life insurance policies with Safer Foundation and Healthcare Services Corporation. On June 21, 1995, Anderson delivered the forms to the hospital and observed Paul complete and sign them. After signing the forms, Paul then instructed Anderson to deliver the change of beneficiary forms to the human resource department at the Safer Foundation. The change of beneficiary forms executed by Paul on June 21, 1995, named his companion Janet Holcomb as the sole beneficiary.

The power of attorney executed by Paul in 1990 states that the agency created therein would become effective upon a written declaration of his disability by his personal physician, Neal Stone, M.D. On June 27, 1995, at the request of Daniel Hales, attorney for Paul’s wife Susan, Dr. Stone declared Paul disabled. On. June 30, 1995, Susan faxed a copy of the 1990 power to the Safer Foundation as insurance transactions were included in the agency. In response, Paul’s attorney, Anthony J. Pauletto, immediately faxed a letter to both Susan’s attorney and the Safer Foundation denying the validity of the 1990 power based on the acrimonious nature of the Downings’ relationship and the pending litigation for the dissolution of their marriage.

On July 2, 1995, Dr. Stone reexamined Paul and notified both Janet and Susan that Paul was now competent to make decisions. Shortly after Dr. Stone’s declaration, Paul drafted and signed a statement, dated July 2, 1995, which appointed Janet Holcomb as his attorney-in-fact for the purpose of making medical decisions and granted her unlimited visiting privileges. Paul also stated that Susan was not allowed to make decisions regarding his care or finances. Paul further stated that Susan was prohibited from visiting or contacting him absent the express consent of his attorney, Anthony J. Pauletto. This statement was not communicated to Susan or the Safer Foundation until after Paul’s death.

On July 5, 1995, Paul was again declared disabled by Dr. Stone. On this date, considering herself acting as Paul’s agent pursuant to the 1990 power, Susan executed a change of beneficiary form for the life insurance policy held by Healthcare Services Corporation. On July 6, 1995, Susan executed an additional change of beneficiary form for the life insurance policy held by the Safer Foundation. On each change of beneficiary form, Susan named herself as the sole beneficiary. After Paul’s death on July 7, 1995, Susan submitted a claim to Fort Dear-born Life Insurance Company for death benefits under the subject policies.

In light of the foregoing facts, Fort Dearborn instituted an interpleader action in the circuit court of Cook County, under case number 95 CH 9183, alleging that the rightful claimant to the insurance proceeds remained unclear. In response to this action, Janet Holcomb filed a counterclaim against Susan Downing and Fort Dearborn claiming that she is entitled to the death benefit proceeds as a result of the June 21, 1995, beneficiary designations by Paul Downing.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

In re Estate of Hirschfeld
2023 IL App (5th) 220630 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2023)
Collins v. Noltensmeier
2018 IL App (4th) 170443 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2018)
In re Estate of Shelton
2017 IL 121199 (Illinois Supreme Court, 2018)
Kindred Healthcare Operating, Inc. v. Boyd
2017 WY 122 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2017)
Alford v. Shelton (In Re Estate of Shelton)
2017 IL 121199 (Illinois Supreme Court, 2017)
Testa ex rel. Testa v. Emeritus Corp.
168 F. Supp. 3d 1103 (N.D. Illinois, 2016)
Battaglia v. 736 N. Clark Corp.
2015 IL App (1st) 142437 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2016)
ESTATE OF NICHOLLS v. Nicholls
2011 IL App (4th) 100871 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2011)
Carlson v. Glueckert Funeral Home, Ltd.
943 N.E.2d 237 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2011)
Carlson v. Glueckert Funeral
Appellate Court of Illinois, 2011
In re Estate of Trevino
886 N.E.2d 530 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2008)
Schmitz v. Firstar Bank Milwaukee
2003 WI 21 (Wisconsin Supreme Court, 2003)
In re Estate of Romanowski
Appellate Court of Illinois, 2002
Amcore Bank, N.A. v. Hahnaman-Albrecht, Inc.
759 N.E.2d 174 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2001)
People ex rel. Graf v. Village of Lake Bluff
321 Ill. App. 3d 897 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2001)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
736 N.E.2d 578, 316 Ill. App. 3d 485, 249 Ill. Dec. 384, 2000 Ill. App. LEXIS 710, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/fort-dearborn-life-insurance-v-holcomb-illappct-2000.