Fisher v. Parks

618 N.E.2d 1202, 248 Ill. App. 3d 666, 188 Ill. Dec. 632
CourtAppellate Court of Illinois
DecidedAugust 3, 1993
Docket5 — 91—0629
StatusPublished
Cited by6 cases

This text of 618 N.E.2d 1202 (Fisher v. Parks) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Appellate Court of Illinois primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Fisher v. Parks, 618 N.E.2d 1202, 248 Ill. App. 3d 666, 188 Ill. Dec. 632 (Ill. Ct. App. 1993).

Opinion

PRESIDING JUSTICE CHAPMAN

delivered the opinion of the court:

Jeffrey A. Fisher filed a complaint against Harry Parks and Steven Nuernberger, alleging that he had been a partner with the defendants in a medical pathology practice known as Southern Illinois Medical Business Associates (SIMBA) and that the defendants wrongfully expelled him from the partnership and failed to account for his financial interest in the business. The trial court, sitting without a jury, entered judgment for the defendants. Plaintiff appeals. We affirm.

The first issue on appeal is whether the trial court erred in finding that defendants complied with the procedural requirements of the partnership agreement. Specifically, Fisher argues that the notices of expulsion were not in accordance with the agreement and that he was wrongfully denied a 60-day probationary period. To resolve this issue, we must turn to the testimony adduced at trial.

In July of 1977, pathologists Steven Nuernberger and Harry Parks entered into a partnership agreement to provide clinical pathology services under the name of Southern Illinois Medical Business Associates. In July of 1978, Jeffrey Fisher, also a pathologist, joined the partnership. Throughout the term of the partnership, two of the partners in SIMBA would service several rural hospitals in Southern Illinois, including those at Sparta, Pinckneyville, Murphysboro, and Du-Quoin. SIMBA also serviced the hospital in Mt. Vernon and Alton Memorial Hospital in Alton. At each hospital SIMBA pathologists operated the hospital’s laboratory, supervised and trained hospital lab personnel, participated in the training of medical staff, and undertook any clinical pathology while on duty. The remaining partner would service and supervise SIMBA’s Collinsville-Belleville laboratory and was on call for the coroners or physicians in St. Clair and Madison Counties to perform autopsies. In addition, all of the partners were on call to do any autopsies which were required on Saturday and Sunday. The duties of the three partners were rotated.

Neither Parks nor Nuernberger had any criticism of Fisher’s performance during his first year with the partnership. The first complaint regarding Fisher came in September of 1979, from Mr. Nehrt, the administrator of the Sparta Community Hospital. Nehrt withheld a day’s pay from SIMBA amounting to $250, for Fisher’s failure to attend certain meetings. Parks testified that he believed SIMBA could forfeit its contract with Sparta Community Hospital if these actions continued. Parks testified that during this same period he was given the impression from others that Fisher had begun a practice of jogging during office hours when he should have been attending to matters at the laboratory or servicing client hospitals. Parks testified that this practice continued from the fall of 1979 until Fisher’s departure from SIMBA in 1981.

Mary Cruzvergara, Ruth Joachimsthaler, and Arna Trotter, employees of SIMBA, testified that because of Fisher’s jogging there were times when he could not be reached either at a particular hospital or at the laboratory. They testified that although the laboratory hours were 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., Fisher usually spent six hours at the laboratory, which included the 45 minutes to an hour and a half he spent jogging. Cruzvergara and Trotter both testified that Fisher’s jogging during working hours and keeping minimal hours never changed. Cruzvergara testified that once Fisher got lost while jogging in Collinsville and someone from the laboratory had to retrieve him. She recalled that in early 1989 Fisher told her that he did not feel pathology was for him and that he would be happier practicing holistic or nutritional medicine in New York.

There was also testimony that Fisher jogged while he was on duty at client hospitals. Nancy Powles, a medical technologist at St. Joseph’s Hospital in Murphysboro, testified that Fisher went out jogging more than half the times that he visited the hospital and that he would do this shortly after he arrived. On a number of occasions Powles had to tell physicians that Fisher was unavailable because he was out jogging. Jo Ellen Heggemeier, a medical technologist at Sparta Community Hospital, testified that Fisher went jogging nearly every time that he visited the hospital. Due to his jogging, he was unavailable for meetings and was not as available to her or the laboratory staff as Parks and Nuernberger were. She also testified that while Nuernberger’s, Parks’, and Fisher’s hospital visits averaged two hours, Fisher’s two hours included the time he spent jogging.

David Hosier, chief executive officer of Marshall Browing Hospital in DuQuoin, testified that, during the time SIMBA has provided services to the hospital, he has been critical of only one pathologist, Jeffrey Fisher. Hosier testified that Fisher would spend minimal time at the hospital and was not fulfilling the obligations for which the hospital had contracted with SIMBA. This matter, along with other problems, caused Hosier to rewrite the contract with SIMBA to specify more clearly the length of time a physician was required to spend at the hospital.

Ruth Lafferty, a pathology secretary at Alton Memorial Hospital, testified that Fisher serviced Alton Memorial Hospital on numerous occasions and that he would go jogging nearly every day. Lafferty testified that on one occasion Fisher could not be reached to perform a frozen section because he was out jogging.

SIMBA was also responsible for performing autopsies in St. Clair and Madison Counties. Alva Busch, a crime-scene technician for the State of Illinois, testified that in November of 1979 Fisher performed an autopsy of a man who was shot through the head. Busch testified that he feels it is difficult for a pathologist “not knowing the circumstances of the other facts of the case to be able to sit and make a total evaluation of what occurred to a body at a given time without knowing the surrounding facts of the case.” Busch cited an incident where Fisher did not wait for Busch to present evidence of the crime-scene investigation but rendered his report without that information. As a result, Fisher’s autopsy report was in error because he showed the entry and exit wounds in reverse. Busch testified that he believed some of Fisher’s “priorities were a bit out of line.”

Madison County Assistant Coroner Dick Mizell testified that Fisher was always in a hurry to do things and that he always talked of jogging. Mizell recounted an occasion where he wanted to have a body re-x-rayed, but that Fisher did not want to wait the half hour it would have taken to re-x-ray the body. Mizell spoke with the coroner about problems he had with Fisher. Mizell testified that he preferred not having Fisher perform autopsies.

Dr. Nuernberger wrote Fisher and Parks a letter dated March 27, 1980, outlining particular complaints he had regarding the partnership and the activities of his partners. With regard to Parks, Nuernberger complained of Parks’ failure to complete autopsy reports in a timely manner. Parks agreed that he had been late in completing the reports, but he testified that he corrected the problem after receiving Nuernberger’s letter.

In the letter of March 27, particular references regarding Dr. Fisher were set forth:

“I have been approached by the nursing coordinator at St.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Pielet v. Hiffman
948 N.E.2d 87 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2011)
Galesburg Clinic Ass'n v. West
Appellate Court of Illinois, 1999
Winston & Strawn v. Nosal
664 N.E.2d 239 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 1996)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
618 N.E.2d 1202, 248 Ill. App. 3d 666, 188 Ill. Dec. 632, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/fisher-v-parks-illappct-1993.