Fiorella v. State

142 So. 2d 885, 41 Ala. App. 3, 1959 Ala. App. LEXIS 345
CourtAlabama Court of Appeals
DecidedAugust 18, 1959
Docket7 Div. 508
StatusPublished
Cited by5 cases

This text of 142 So. 2d 885 (Fiorella v. State) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Alabama Court of Appeals primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Fiorella v. State, 142 So. 2d 885, 41 Ala. App. 3, 1959 Ala. App. LEXIS 345 (Ala. Ct. App. 1959).

Opinion

PRICE, Judge.

The defendant was convicted of being a vagrant, as defined in subsection 11 .of Section 437, Title 14, Code of Alabama 1940, in that, “he was the keeper ■ or proprietor of a gambling house, * *

The house was described as a house situated in Shelby County, Alabama, located west of the old Birmingham-Montgomery paved highway, and being the first house south of the Cahaba River, said place having been formerly known as the “McCoy place.”

Carl Crump, a police officer of Columbiana, testified that in 1955 he had a deputy’s commission for Shelby County. Around the first part of December he went to the old McCoy or Fiorella place about 10:30 at night. The house had a main floor, a basement and an upstairs. In the upstairs room he saw and examined a pool or billiard table. There were no pockets in the table for balls to fall into. The table was clean. He found some pool or billiard balls in the cashier’s cage. They were at the bottom of a drawer in the counter. The balls were covered with heavy dust.

Herbert Pool testified he had delivered mail as a substitute carrier for three years on Helena Route 1. He knew the house commonly called the old McCoy place and had occasion to deliver mail to Box 38, the box serving that house. Within a twelve-month period prior to January [7]*724, 1956, he'delivered mail to that box addressed to Sam Fiorella. The box is about a block from the house, at the entrance to the highway. ITe never personally delivered any mail to Mr. Fiorella. He did not recall delivering mail to other named persons in that box, and did not recall delivering any mail to Jack Fiorella. He did not deliver mail to Mr. McCoy. Mr. McCoy died in 1951. He was never at the house and never had seen Mr. Fiorella there.

The house and the premises were described by Mr. Hugh Sims, Sheriff of Shelby County, as follows: The driveway leaves old 31 and goes back due west almost to a large house in the edge of the woods. At the entrance, which is approximately one hundred feet from the corner of the house there is a block wall built up, ■beginning at the driveway, three and a half or four feet high and continues around in an L shape on the north and west sides of the house. The land is lower there and the wall on the lower corner is twelve or thirteen feet; room for parking forty or fifty automobiles.

The house has a main floor. From the front on the side of the hill it has a basement on the back. It has an entrance on the main floor. There is a large dining room on the back and on the north there is a kitchen and a small breakfast room. To -the left as you enter there is a room the furnishings of which consisted mainly of an office desk and chair. Adjoining that on the west side of the same room there is a bedroom with a double bed and clothes hanging in it. From the main entrance to the living room in front is the stairway leading to the upper floor. At the'top of the stairs there is a door opening into one large room. Along the south wall of this room there was a billiard table. There were six window openings in this room, all of which were covered. In the northwest corner of the room there was a cashier’s cage, which contained drawers and storage space under it. In the basement there was a wire enclosure containing soft drink bottles and several cases of drinks. Separate rest rooms for men and women, with neon signs on therrt, were in the house.

The Sheriff testified he had been to the house on more than one occasion when Mr. Fiorella was there, and when there were from 8 to 20 persons present,'but he never saw any gambling going on.

Shortly before midnight on January 24', 1956, a raiding party, consisting of the Attorney General and some members of his staff, four highway patrolmen, Sheriff Sims and several other persons went to the house. The first floor entrances had .steej and iron grill doors, and there were padlocks in the hasps. . .

The officers were admitted to the house by a white man named Burt Kendricj^. The only people in the house were Ken’drick, another white man named Hardin, a Negro man named Jack Lowéj and Dorothy Battle, a Negro woman. No gambling was taking place at the time of the raid. Sam Fiorella, the defendant, came to the house some fifteen or twenty minutes after a telephone call was made by Kendrick. He unlocked the office door. There were poker chips in plastic boxes stacked in the corner, and two felt-bpttom wooden trays with poker chips in them. deck of playing cards was found in the pocket of a coat hanging in the bedroom closet. A box of cards with the name “Happydale Farm Home Bred Cattle”, and a sketch from Highway 31, around the old 31 at the location of the old McCoy home, were in the desk. . .

The billiard table in the upstairs room was raised on blocks and there was a small wooden platform on either side of the table. The table was clean. There were pool or billiard cues but no billiard balls. The windows were covered on the inside with heavy paper and curtains covered the paper.

• There was an electrical address or loud speaker system installed in the. house. There was a drink box in the' dining room and twelve to twenty cases of drinks in [8]*8the basement. In a room to the right of the front entrance there was a round table which looked like a breakfast room table, with chairs. The table was covered with a green felt-like cloth over which there was a white cloth.

Two of the witnesses testified they heard defendant say to Jack Lowe just before and at the time he was being questioned by the officers, “you don’t remember a thing.”

Several photographs portraying certain objects in the house were introduced in evidence and appear in the record. Two sticks, one described as about four feet long, and the other about thirty inches to three feet in length, each of which had a right angle turn at the end, approximately three and one half inches long beyond the right angle turn, were introduced in evidence.

Hugh Chambliss, a Birmingham police officer, testified he was not at the house on January 24th. He stated he had visited many gambling houses in Alabama and elsewhere, and had been present at such places when there was crap shooting and poker playing, and knew how it was played. He was familiar with the duties of the people operating the table and the manner in which bets are placed. The chips, trays, table and sticks shown in the state’s exhibits are of the kind ordinarily and customarily used in the operation of a gambling game. The chips are used as a representation for money. The stick is known as a dice rake, used for raking dice and chips from one end of the table to the other. The witness explained to the jury in detail the use of such a table, stands, sticks and chips in the operation of a dice game.

Herman Evers, Jr., a Birmingham police officer, testified that on the night of the 28th or 29th of March, 1955, between the hours of nine and ten p. m., he went to the Fiorella place in Shelby County. Cars were parked at the house. The witness stated to the man who came to the barred -door that he had been told he could come there and engage in games, such as dice and poker playing. The man said they were out of business at that time and told him to return in about thirty days. He did not personally know the person who spoke to him.

On cross examination Sheriff Sims testified he had seen the house many times. When Mr. McCoy used to be living up there, he had been there on a few occasions. The house was there before Mr. McCoy died and the wall that would obscure cars from the highway was built during Mr.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Robert Lee Jones v. State of Alabama
Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 2022
Harnage v. State
274 So. 2d 333 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Alabama, 1972)
Creel v. State
159 So. 2d 809 (Alabama Court of Appeals, 1963)
Fiorella v. State
142 So. 2d 894 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 1959)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
142 So. 2d 885, 41 Ala. App. 3, 1959 Ala. App. LEXIS 345, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/fiorella-v-state-alactapp-1959.