Fernander v. Bonis

947 So. 2d 584, 2007 WL 5742
CourtDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida
DecidedJanuary 3, 2007
Docket4D06-407
StatusPublished
Cited by13 cases

This text of 947 So. 2d 584 (Fernander v. Bonis) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering District Court of Appeal of Florida primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Fernander v. Bonis, 947 So. 2d 584, 2007 WL 5742 (Fla. Ct. App. 2007).

Opinion

947 So.2d 584 (2007)

Ronnie FERNANDER, Appellant,
v.
Mario BONIS, individually, Craig Scarlett, individually, and the City of Miramar, a Florida municipal corporation, Appellees.

No. 4D06-407.

District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fourth District.

January 3, 2007.

*586 Hugh L. Koerner of Hugh L. Koerner, P.A., Hollywood, for appellant.

Jamie A. Cole, Matthew H. Mandel and Gregory A. Haile of Weiss, Serota Helfman Pastoriza Cole & Boniske, P.A., Fort Lauderdale, for appellees.

SHAHOOD, J.

Appellant, Ronnie Fernander, appeals from the final judgment granting defendants' motion to dismiss his complaint. We affirm.

The extensive and somewhat complex facts giving rise to this case are necessarily set forth in this opinion as alleged in appellant's complaint. On August 3, 1997, Eusebio Christian gave Captain Mario Bonis of the Miramar Police Department a sworn statement describing a narcotics transaction with a man named "Steve," whom Christian said he had known a long time ago. Christian had agreed to purchase a kilogram of cocaine for Steve in exchange for a fee of $4,500 for Christian. Steve provided Christian with $15,000 purchase money for the deal.

Christian met with two men in Miramar and exchanged the money for two packages of what he thought was cocaine. When he returned to Steve with the packages, they discovered the packages contained dry-wall instead. Steve threatened to kill Christian and his family unless Christian provided him with $15,000 or a kilogram of cocaine. Christian contacted the FBI, who referred him to the City of Miramar Police Department. Christian agreed to assist the police as an informant in a sting operation with the goal of apprehending Steve and others.

As part of the sting operation, Christian arranged to meet Steve at a set place and time to give him a kilogram of cocaine. Members of the South Broward Drug Enforcement Unit set up surveillance of the location. Christian was approached at the location by Fernander's cousin, Marlon Butler. Christian entered Butler's car and law enforcement apprehended the men as the car began to leave. Butler was arrested.

Butler also agreed to work as an informant for the Miramar Police Department following his arrest. Butler gave Captain Bonis and Detective Hector Bertrand a sworn statement. According to Butler, Steve told him about being ripped off in the earlier cocaine transaction involving Christian. Butler had agreed with Steve to pick up Christian and drop him off for $100, knowing Christian would have cocaine *587 for Steve. Butler described Steve as a "big man." He said that Steve was a seven foot tall black male. He estimated Steve's weight as about the same as Detective Bertrand. He said Steve was a student at North Miami Beach Senior High School. Butler was the cousin of Fernander and Fernander's sister, Patrice. Patrice was married to a man named Steven Bailey, also known as "Steve." Fernander and Steven Bailey are therefore brothers-in-law.

Captain Bonis obtained Steve's cellular phone number from Butler's pager after Butler's arrest. Captain Bonis obtained a subpoena duces tecum for telephone records for Steve's telephone number. The records showed that the subscriber for the telephone was Ronnie Fernander and the billing address was in Fernander's name. Captain Bonis also obtained Fernander's driver's license photograph. On August 26, 1997, Christian gave another sworn statement to Captain Bonis. Christian identified Fernander as Steve by picking Fernander's photograph out of a photographic lineup of six African-American males. Christian stated in his identification that the photo he picked out was Steve, "with a little more weight." However, Christian was sure of the identification. Captain Bonis included the above information in a police report.

Captain Bonis submitted a probable cause affidavit to the Broward County State Attorney's Office in support of filing cocaine trafficking charges against Fernander. The affidavit stated that Fernander was positively identified under oath by an informant as Steve and listed Fernander as an alias for Steve. The probable cause affidavit described Fernander as 5'11", 190 lbs. On November 23, 1998, the State filed an information charging Fernander with trafficking in cocaine and issued a warrant for his arrest.

Butler was also charged with trafficking in cocaine for his part in the deal. He entered into a substantial assistance agreement with the State. On June 2, 1999, Butler took a polygraph examination at the Miramar Police Department. The polygraph examination and pre-test interview were conducted by Detective Craig Scarlett. Butler allegedly stated during the pre-test interview and the actual examination that Fernander had no part in the drug deal with Steve. Detective Scarlett concluded, however, that there was a ninety-eight percent probability that Butler was not truthful. Butler was later convicted of cocaine trafficking and sentenced to a minimum of fifteen years in prison for his role in the drug deal with Steve.

Fernander was arrested on August 2, 2000, on the warrant for trafficking cocaine. He remained in jail until approximately October 27, 2000. On September 11, 2002, Fernander's case was nolle prossed. The nolle prosse memorandum issued by the Assistant State Attorney stated that in comparing pictures of Fernander and the man purported to be Steve by Fernander's family, Steve resembled Fernander. The memorandum noted that the telephone records for the telephone used by Steve were in Fernander's name. The memorandum recalled that Christian had identified Fernander in the photo lineup, but had stated more than once "with a little more weight." The memorandum stated that Butler had been deposed and testified Fernander was not Steve and that Steve was married to Butler's cousin. The memo expressed doubt of the possibility of convicting Fernander in light of Butler's testimony.

Fernander filed a nine-count complaint containing various federal and state claims against the City as well as Captain Bonis and Detective Scarlett in their individual capacities. The complaint alleged: violation *588 of Fernander's Fourth Amendment rights pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983; a claim against Captain Bonis in his individual capacity for malicious prosecution pursuant to 42 U.S.C. § 1983; state law claims of malicious prosecution and false imprisonment; causes of action against the City and Scarlett individually based on the allegedly negligent performance and reporting of the polygraph examination administered to Butler; a cause of action against the City for negligent infliction of emotional distress; and a claim against Captain Bonis for intentional infliction of emotional distress. The trial court granted defendants' motion to dismiss as to all counts with prejudice.

We first address Fernander's claim the trial court erred in finding that Captain Bonis was entitled to qualified immunity as to Fernander's 42 U.S.C. § 1983 due process claims. The parties agree that immunity is unavailable under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 if the unlawful nature of the governmental official's action is apparent under pre-existing law. Wilson v. Layne, 526 U.S. 603

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Irving v. St. John
M.D. Florida, 2022
Volp v. Sasser
M.D. Florida, 2021
Bellay v. Shue
M.D. Florida, 2020
John Cottam v. Douglas Pelton
Eleventh Circuit, 2018
Swanson v. Scott
334 F. Supp. 3d 1203 (M.D. Florida, 2018)
Wesley v. Rigney
913 F. Supp. 2d 313 (E.D. Kentucky, 2012)
Brown v. Jenne
122 So. 3d 881 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2012)
Drudge v. City of Kissimmee
581 F. Supp. 2d 1176 (M.D. Florida, 2008)
Town of Southwest Ranches v. Kalam
980 So. 2d 1121 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2008)
Sharp v. City of Palatka
529 F. Supp. 2d 1342 (M.D. Florida, 2007)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
947 So. 2d 584, 2007 WL 5742, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/fernander-v-bonis-fladistctapp-2007.