Fannings v. State

997 So. 2d 953, 2008 WL 5220572
CourtCourt of Appeals of Mississippi
DecidedDecember 16, 2008
Docket2007-KA-00112-COA
StatusPublished
Cited by11 cases

This text of 997 So. 2d 953 (Fannings v. State) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Mississippi primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Fannings v. State, 997 So. 2d 953, 2008 WL 5220572 (Mich. Ct. App. 2008).

Opinion

997 So.2d 953 (2008)

James Arthur FANNINGS, Jr., Appellant
v.
STATE of Mississippi, Appellee.

No. 2007-KA-00112-COA.

Court of Appeals of Mississippi.

December 16, 2008.

*955 Johnnie E. Walls, Jr., Greenville, attorney for appellant.

Office of the Attorney General by Deirdre McCrory, Jackson, attorney for appellee.

Before MYERS, P.J., GRIFFIS, BARNES and ISHEE, JJ.

BARNES, J., for the Court.

¶ 1. A Bolivar County jury found James Arthur Fannings, Jr., guilty of murdering his girlfriend, Stacey Hazelton (Stacey). The trial judge sentenced Fannings to life imprisonment in the custody of the Mississippi Department of Corrections (MDOC) without eligibility for parole. Fannings now appeals, raising six issues: (1) whether the trial court erred in failing to grant a judgment notwithstanding the verdict (JNOV) due to the insufficiency of the evidence to support the charge of murder; (2) whether the trial court erred in not granting a JNOV due to the sufficiency of the evidence to support only the charge of manslaughter; (3) whether the trial court failed to advise him of his right to testify; (4) whether he received ineffective assistance of counsel; (5) whether he was improperly sentenced; and (6) whether the cumulative effect of these errors warrants reversal. Finding no error, we affirm Fannings's conviction and sentence.

SUMMARY OF FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

¶ 2. In April 2004, Stacey drove from Lancaster, Pennsylvania to Alligator, Mississippi with her boyfriend, Fannings (a/k/a "Beans" or "J"), and his friend, Chavon Mack (a/k/a "Pierre" or "P"). They rode in Stacey's teal-green 1996 Chevrolet Blazer, which her father had given her. Stacey was approximately twenty-one years old at the time and was a life-long resident of Pennsylvania. Stacey's mother, Natalie Hazelton, testified that Stacey was a hard worker, and before coming to Mississippi, she had worked two jobs in Pennsylvania: one at a restaurant and another at a gas station. It is at the gas station that Stacey met Fannings, who also worked there. Mrs. Hazelton testified that Stacey had mentioned Fannings, but Mrs. Hazelton had never actually met him. She remarked, however, that "[h]e wasn't that good for [Stacey]."

¶ 3. In April 2004, Stacey had been living at home with her parents when she informed them that she had decided to go to Mississippi to "start over." She did not mention to them with whom she would be traveling. Her parents were concerned with her decision, but Stacey agreed to keep in touch. Mrs. Hazelton testified *956 that, for the next few weeks, Stacey called from Mississippi and talked to her mother by cellular phone three to four times a day.

¶ 4. When Stacey, Fannings, and Mack first arrived in Alligator, Mississippi, they stayed for approximately two and one-half weeks in the three-bedroom apartment of Rochelle Williams (a/k/a "Big Mama"), where her daughter, Telisia (a/k/a "Tee-Tee"), and two other people resided; then the trio moved to a trailer in nearby Duncan, Mississippi. In late April 2004, Stacey drove back to Lancaster to retrieve some personal items from her parents' home such as clothing, a sewing machine, her bicycle, and a Play Station 2 video console. Before Stacey's return to Mississippi, her mother testified that Stacey appeared upset and acted "like she didn't want to go." Her parents reassured her that she could stay at home, but she decided to leave anyway. Her parents gave her a hug and told her they loved her. They also gave her $500 for gas and food. This was the last time Stacey's parents saw her.

¶ 5. On May 21, 2004, Stacey talked to her mother on the telephone, crying. She said she wanted to come home. Her parents offered to come get her from Mississippi, but Stacey said she would make the drive to Pennsylvania after her Blazer was repaired. Her parents wired her $400 to the Wal-Mart in Cleveland, Mississippi for the repairs and gas. The plan was for Stacey to repair her vehicle and come home to Pennsylvania. However, after this date, Stacey's telephone calls to her parents ceased. Also, sometime in May, worried about not hearing from Stacey, her mother contacted the Bolivar County Sheriff's Department, and Officer Charles Griffin conducted a "welfare check" on Stacey to find out how she was doing. Stacey was found to be still living at the apartment in Alligator.[1] In January 2005, having not heard from Stacey over the holidays, her parents filed a missing person's report with Pennsylvania law enforcement.

¶ 6. In June 2005, Corporal Patrick Quigley, of the Pennsylvania State Police, took over the investigation of Stacey's disappearance. Corporal Quigley determined that Fannings was her boyfriend and interviewed him for the first time.[2] At this point, no foul play was suspected. Fannings told Corporal Quigley that he met Stacey when they worked at a gas station together. Fannings explained they had been dating about seven months when Stacey became pregnant, and when Stacey's parents were told, they "flipped out"; so Stacey and Fannings came to Mississippi. Fannings said the last time he saw Stacey or her Blazer was about four weeks after they had arrived in Mississippi, in April 2004, at which time she had decided to drive back to Pennsylvania in her Blazer with Mack.

¶ 7. In September 2005, Corporal Quigley found Stacey's Blazer in a Pennsylvania impound lot, where it had been towed on June 9, 2004.[3] An investigation of Lancaster police records showed the vehicle had been stopped by law enforcement on *957 June 8, 2004, in Lancaster, in connection with a complaint by a man named Frank Grubbs. Grubbs was interviewed by law enforcement and testified at trial that Fannings, an acquaintance, had stopped by his house in June 2004 in Lancaster County. Grubbs testified Fannings was driving a teal-green Blazer. Another man was with him, and they stole Grubbs's motorcycle. This testimony directly conflicts with Fannings's statement that the last time he saw Stacey's Blazer was in April 2004 in Mississippi.

¶ 8. In the course of investigating Stacey's whereabouts, Corporal Quigley spoke with numerous witnesses, and he determined that none of Stacey's friends or family had heard from her since May 2004. A credit history check on Stacey showed the only recent activity was in January 2005 when her cellular phone bill had gone to a collection agency. Continuing his investigation of Stacey's disappearance with the Bolivar County Sheriff's Department and Officer Griffin, Corporal Quigley traveled to Mississippi, where he interviewed Rochelle and her daughter Telisia, who had lived near Fannings in Pennsylvania at one time. Rochelle gave Corporal Quigley Stacey's sewing machine; however, he was unable to locate any other belongings of Stacey's, including her clothing or the Play Station 2.

¶ 9. A break in the case occurred in October 2005, when Corporal Quigley interviewed Mack for the first time. Allegedly, he was the last person to have seen Stacey, having left Mississippi for Pennsylvania with her in May 2004, according to Fannings's statement. At this interview, Mack provided information which led to Fannings's arrest. Fannings was subsequently incarcerated in a Lancaster County, Pennsylvania prison.

¶ 10. On January 18, 2006, Fannings waived his Miranda rights and gave a second statement to Corporal Quigley from the Lancaster prison, a transcription of which was entered into evidence at trial. At this time Fannings stated the last time he saw Stacey was around May 20, 2004, when he dropped her off at the bus station in Cleveland, Mississippi, for Pennsylvania.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Fannings v. Hood
N.D. Mississippi, 2022
Spearman v. State
58 So. 3d 30 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2011)
Wells v. State
57 So. 3d 40 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2011)
Dora v. State
61 So. 3d 226 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2011)
Cosby v. State
66 So. 3d 161 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2010)
Williams v. State
24 So. 3d 360 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2009)
Whitaker v. State
22 So. 3d 326 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2009)
Young v. State
33 So. 3d 1151 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2009)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
997 So. 2d 953, 2008 WL 5220572, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/fannings-v-state-missctapp-2008.