Duran v. Mission Mortuary

258 P.2d 241, 174 Kan. 565, 1953 Kan. LEXIS 352
CourtSupreme Court of Kansas
DecidedJune 6, 1953
Docket38,802
StatusPublished
Cited by17 cases

This text of 258 P.2d 241 (Duran v. Mission Mortuary) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Kansas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Duran v. Mission Mortuary, 258 P.2d 241, 174 Kan. 565, 1953 Kan. LEXIS 352 (kan 1953).

Opinions

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Wertz, J.:

This was an action for damages for personal injuries sustained by plaintiff and for the wrongful death of her husband, Pete Duran, resulting from a collision between two motor vehicles.

Plaintiff Josephine Duran and her invalid husband were being transported from Pratt to the Veterans Administration Hospital at Wichita, in an ambulance owned by Mission Mortuary, a corporation, and driven by its employee Lorenzo F. Butler. A collision occurred between the ambulance and a sheriff's patrol car being driven by Richard L. Phillips, a deputy sheriff of Sedgwick county.

Plaintiff brought the action against Mission Mortuary, Lorenzo F. Butler, and Robert S. Gray, sheriff of Sedgwick county and Richard L. Phillips, his deputy. The jury returned a verdict for plaintiff and against all defendants, and assessed her damages for wrongful death at $15,000, and for her personal injuries, $8,500.

Defendant Phillips cross-petitioned against defendants Mission Mortuary and Butler for his personal injuries. The jury returned a verdict against Phillips and in favor of Mission -Mortuary and Butler. Defendant Mission Mortuary cross-petitioned against Phillips and Gray to recover damages sustained to its ambulance. The jury returned a verdict against Mission Mortuary and in favor of Phillips and Gray.

Defendants Mission Mortuary and Butler have appealed from the judgment in favor of the plaintiff, and defendant Mission Mortuary has appealed from the judgment against it on its cross-petition. Phillips and Gray have appealed from the judgment in favor of the plaintiff, and defendant Phillips has appealed from the judgment against him on his cross-petition.

For convenience, the parties will be hereinafter referred to as follows: Appellee Josephine Duran as plaintiff; appellant and cross-appellant Mission Mortuary as defendant mortuary; appellant Lorenzo F. Butler as defendant Butler; appellant Robert S. Gray as defendant Gray or sheriff, and appellant and cross-appellant Richard L. Phillips as defendant Phillips or deputy sheriff.

[568]*568The pertinent facts may be summarized as follows: On October 31, 1949, Pete Duran employed the defendant mortuary to transport him and his wife by ambulance to the Veterans hospital at Wichita. The ambulance was driven by its agent, defendant Butler. Plaintiff was riding in the ambulance as attendant at the request of the mortuary. Their destination was the Veterans hospital where Pete Duran was to be treated surgically. The hospital is located on the east side of Wichita. The city limits at that time were immediately east of the hospital grounds. These grounds are situated on the north side of Kellogg, an east and west thoroughfare, which is a wide concrete highway providing four lanes for moving traffic, two eastbound and two westbound, with an additional area for parallel parking on either side. There are two entrances to the hospital grounds, one at its west boundary and one near its east boundary. When defendant mortuary’s ambulance approached the west gate of the hospital grounds, it was moving slowly. Pete Duran was on a cot in the rear portion of the ambulance. Plaintiff was sitting in a chair at his side. John Duran, Pete’s brother, was sitting on the right of the front seat of the ambulance beside the driver. The ambulance siren was silent but the red lights on the top front of the ambulance were illuminated. Traffic was heavy. Butler determined to go on to the east gate. On the night in question, defendant Phillips, deputy sheriff, was assigned to road patrol. About 6:20 p. m. he was driving a sheriff’s patrol car when he received a message informing him of a fatality and bad injury accident east of the city limits on Kellogg. He had general instructions to get to this accident in a hurry. The dispatcher from the sheriff’s office informed him by radio of the accident and that a Gordon ambulance had also been dispatched to the place of the accident. Phillips proceeded east on Kellogg. His sheriff’s patrol car was equipped with two 4M inch flashing red lights over the windshield, one on each corner, and a battery-operated siren with a lock switch. When he first received the message, he turned on the red lights and the siren. As he neared the intersection of Oliver and Kellogg streets, about I2 mile west of the hospital, he turned off his siren to listen for the Gordon ambulance which he was expecting. The Gordon ambulance came south on Oliver and turned east on Kellogg. Phillips testified he then turned on his siren and went through the intersection on a red light. The Gordon ambulance was about lh blocks in front of him when he got through the intersection. About halfway between the hospital gates, defendant Butler, driver of the mor[569]*569tuary ambulance, heard the siren of the Gordon ambulance to the rear. He pulled over to the right-hand side of the street, permitting the Gordon ambulance to pass on his left and to continue on east. After the Gordon ambulance had passed, defendant Butler looked in his rear view mirror on the left side of defendant’s ambulance and saw nothing unusual. There were lights of motor cars a half to three-fourths block behind him. Butler undertook to make a left-hand turn back into the lane nearest the center and then north across the street to go into the east gate of the hospital grounds. When Butler had almost completed the turn and his ambulance was about in the center of Kellogg street, he heard brakes screaming behind him. He looked out the left window and saw the red lights of the approaching car. At that time his ambulance was in high gear. He tided to accelerate it to get out of the way, but did not succeed and the front end of the sheriff’s patrol car collided with the left rear end of the ambulance. Pete Duran and the plaintiff were both thrown out the rear of the ambulance onto the pavement, Pete Duran sustaining serious injuries resulting in his death two days later, and plaintiff sustaining serious personal injuries by reason thereof.

Plaintiff’s petition alleged that the defendants mortuary and Butler were guilty of negligence in making a left-hand turn from a right-hand lane across Kellogg for the purpose of entering a private driveway without giving any signal or warning of the driver’s intention to so do, and in making such left-hand turn in such close proximity with other moving vehicles as to constitute an immediate hazard, without ascertaining that the turn in crossing the street could be made safely, and in failing to keep a proper lookout for others using the highway, and in failing to remain at a standing position until the left-hand turn could be made safely.

Her petition further alleged that defendant Phillips was driving the sheriff’s patrol car on his own behalf and on behalf of defendant Gray, and was on duty in furtherance of the business of the office of the sheriff in proceeding to investigate an automobile accident on a highway in the county; that their negligence consisted of operating the patrol car on a city street at a high and excessive rate of speed, in excess of 50 miles per hour, and at such an excessive rate of speed that after sliding the wheels of the patrol car a distance of 152 feet, it struck the ambulance in which the plaintiff was a passenger with such force that it was pushed after the impact a distance of 46 feet; in failing to reduce the speed of the patrol car, stop, turn [570]

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Attorney General Opinion No.
Kansas Attorney General Reports, 2002
Conner v. Janes
981 P.2d 1169 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1999)
Saarinen v. Kerr
644 N.E.2d 988 (New York Court of Appeals, 1994)
Littell v. Maloney
593 P.2d 11 (Court of Appeals of Kansas, 1979)
Monroe v. Darr
559 P.2d 322 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1977)
Poole v. Brunt
338 So. 2d 991 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1976)
City of Tucson v. Wondergem
466 P.2d 383 (Arizona Supreme Court, 1970)
Scogin v. Nugen
464 P.2d 166 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1970)
Waters v. Bates
227 F. Supp. 462 (E.D. Tennessee, 1964)
Commisso v. Meeker
168 N.E.2d 365 (New York Court of Appeals, 1960)
Kurdziel v. Van Es
306 P.2d 159 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1957)
Libby v. Schmidt
298 P.2d 298 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1956)
Lyon v. Kansas City Fire & Marine Insurance
271 P.2d 291 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1954)
Garrison v. Hamil
271 P.2d 307 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1954)
Duran v. Mission Mortuary
258 P.2d 241 (Supreme Court of Kansas, 1953)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
258 P.2d 241, 174 Kan. 565, 1953 Kan. LEXIS 352, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/duran-v-mission-mortuary-kan-1953.