Devillier v. Fidelity & Deposit Co. of Md.

709 So. 2d 277, 1998 WL 100361
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedMarch 6, 1998
Docket97-1200
StatusPublished
Cited by5 cases

This text of 709 So. 2d 277 (Devillier v. Fidelity & Deposit Co. of Md.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Devillier v. Fidelity & Deposit Co. of Md., 709 So. 2d 277, 1998 WL 100361 (La. Ct. App. 1998).

Opinion

709 So.2d 277 (1998)

Kenneth J. DEVILLIER, et al. Plaintiffs-Appellants,
v.
FIDELITY & DEPOSIT COMPANY OF MARYLAND, et al. Defendants-Appellees.

No. 97-1200.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Third Circuit.

March 6, 1998.

*278 Robert G. Nida, Alexandria, for Kenneth J. Devillier, et al.

Maura Zivalich Pelleteri, Eugene R. Preaus, New Orleans, for Fidelity & Deposit Company of Maryland.

Thomas Edward Loehn, Jedd Malish, New Orleans, for Fidelity & Deposit Co. of Md. Gen. Liab. Carrier.

David Ramsey Lestage, DeRedder, for City Savings Bank & Trust Co., et al.

George Bartlett Hall, Jr., David M. Korn, New Orleans, for Trinity Universal Ins. Co.

James A. Bolen, Jr., Alexandria, for City Sav. Bank, et al. on Behalf of Trinity Univ.

Before DECUIR, AMY and PICKETT, JJ.

DECUIR, Judge.

Plaintiffs, Kenneth J. Devilllier, Joy M. Lindsay, Eveline D. Nash, Bobbie C. Shirley, and Mary Ernestine Hillman, all former employees of City Savings Bank And Trust Company (CSB), filed suit seeking damages, attorney's fees and punitive damages, as well as injunctive relief, against CSB, its president, Glen Bertrand, individual members of the Board of Directors of CSB, Fidelity & Deposit Company of Maryland (F & D), the directors' and officers' liability insurer and general liability insurer of CSB, and Trinity Universal Insurance Company (Trinity), also general liability insurer of CSB.

Plaintiffs allege that during 1992 and 1994, defendant Bertrand engaged in threatening, hostile, and humiliating treatment of female employees and retaliation against the plaintiffs for opposing Bertrand's allegedly abusive behavior. Specifically, plaintiffs contend that Bertrand's abusive conduct constitutes violations of the Louisiana Commission on Human Rights Act (LCHRA), La.R.S. 51:2231, et seq., prohibiting discrimination because of age and sex and retaliation for opposing illegal employment practices. Plaintiffs further contend that Bertrand's conduct constitutes negligent and/or intentional infliction of mental distress. Additionally, plaintiffs allege that Bertrand's tortious conduct was motivated by an active desire to cause mental anguish and distress, and Bertrand believed with substantial certainty that mental anguish and distress would result from his conduct towards plaintiffs.

As to the Board of Directors, plaintiffs contend that the Board was negligent: (1) in hiring Bertrand and in failing to thoroughly and properly investigate Bertrand's background and reputation; (2) in failing to take immediate and appropriate action to terminate Bertrand's conduct after having been informed of same; and (3) in failing to insure that Bertrand would not retaliate against plaintiffs for opposing Bertrand's practices. Plaintiffs also allege that CSB is obligated under its charter and/or bylaws to indemnify the defendant directors for any amounts they may be legally obligated to pay as a result of the claims asserted by plaintiffs. Finally, plaintiffs allege that the defendant Bank and *279 the Board are vicariously liable for the acts of Glen Bertrand under the doctrine of respondeat superior.

A number of peremptory exceptions and motions for summary judgment were filed by defendants on a variety of issues, and three separate judgments were rendered.

A judgment rendered on April 3, 1997, granted the motion for summary judgment on behalf of F & D in its capacity as the comprehensive general liability insurer of CSB.

By judgment rendered April 11, 1997, the trial court sustained in part and denied in part the peremptory exception of no cause of action filed by Trinity. Specifically, the trial court sustained the exception: (1) as to plaintiffs' claims against defendant Bertrand individually for violation of La. R.S. 51:2231, et seq.; (2) as to plaintiffs' claims for negligent infliction of emotional distress; (3) as to plaintiffs' claims against the individual members of the Board of Directors; (4) as to plaintiffs' allegations of negligent hiring and retention of defendant Bertrand against the Board and CSB; and (5) as to plaintiffs' demand for punitive damages. The trial court denied Trinity's exception in part ruling that: (1) plaintiffs' petition states a cause of action for intentional infliction of emotional distress against Bertrand individually; (2) plaintiffs' petition states a cause of action for retaliation against CSB; and (3) plaintiffs' petition states a cause of action for sex discrimination against CSB.

The judgment of April 11, 1997, also granted in part and denied in part the motion for summary judgment filed by F & D on its directors' and officers' liability policy (D & O policy). Specifically, the trial court granted the motion ruling: (1) that the D & O policy does not provide coverage for any claim against the directors and officers of CSB committed or alleged to have been committed prior to September 29, 1993; (2) that the D & O policy does not provide coverage for the vicarious liability of CSB; and (3) dismissing plaintiffs' claims for attorney's fees and for punitive damages. The motion for summary judgment by F & D was denied in part, the trial court ruling that the "insured v. insured" exclusion and the "bodily injury" exclusion were inapplicable.

By the judgment of June 23, 1997, the trial court granted Trinity's motion for summary judgment finding that Trinity's comprehensive general liability policies do not provide coverage for the claims asserted by plaintiff.

Thus, remaining are plaintiffs' causes of action against CSB under La.R.S. 51:2231, et seq., and against defendant Bertrand and CSB for intentional infliction of emotional distress.

Plaintiffs appeal contending that the trial court erred: (1) in finding that only employers are liable for harassment or discrimination and retaliation, and that Glen Bertrand is not an "employer" under La.R.S. 51:2231, et seq.; (2) in finding that neither F & D's nor Trinity's comprehensive general liability policies provide coverage for plaintiffs' claims; (3) in pretermitting the question as to whether F & D's directors' and officers' liability policy provides coverage for attorney's fees; and (4) in finding that punitive damages are unavailable under La.R.S. 51:2231, et seq.

"Employer" Under La.R.S. 51:2232(4)

The trial court ruled that defendant Bertrand is not an "employer" as defined in La.R.S. 51:2232(4)[1] and dismissed plaintiffs' claims against Bertrand in his individual capacity for violation of the LCHRA, established by La.R.S. 51:2231, et seq. The stated purpose of the enactment of the LCHRA is set forth in La.R.S. 51:2231(A) in pertinent part as follows:

A. It is the purpose and intent of the legislature by this enactment to provide for execution within Louisiana of the policies embodied in the Federal Civil Rights Act of 1964, 1968, and 1972 and the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967...

The term "employer" is defined in Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, 42 U.S.C. § 2000e(b), et seq. as "a person engaged in an industry affecting commerce ... and any agent of such person ..." (Emphasis added.)

*280 La.R.S. 51:2232(4) defines "employer" as follows:

(4) "Employer" means the state or any of its political subdivisions, any person employing eight or more persons within the state, or any person acting as an agent

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
709 So. 2d 277, 1998 WL 100361, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/devillier-v-fidelity-deposit-co-of-md-lactapp-1998.