Department of Health v. Lutheran Hospitals & Homes Society

416 N.W.2d 222, 227 Neb. 116, 1987 Neb. LEXIS 1105
CourtNebraska Supreme Court
DecidedDecember 11, 1987
Docket86-129
StatusPublished
Cited by33 cases

This text of 416 N.W.2d 222 (Department of Health v. Lutheran Hospitals & Homes Society) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Nebraska Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Department of Health v. Lutheran Hospitals & Homes Society, 416 N.W.2d 222, 227 Neb. 116, 1987 Neb. LEXIS 1105 (Neb. 1987).

Opinions

[117]*117Per Curiam.

The applicant, Lutheran Hospitals and Homes Society of America, doing business as Grand Island Memorial Hospital, filed an application for a certificate of need for the acquisition and installation of a linear accelerator and for development of radiation therapy services. The Nebraska Department of Health recommended denial of the application. The Certificate of Need Review Committee found that the applicant had failed to demonstrate that the proposed project met the review criteria specified in Neb. Admin. Code tit. 182, ch. 2, § 005 (1983), and denied the application. The applicant then appealed to an appeal board of the Nebraska Certificate of Need Appeal Panel, which reversed the decision of the review committee and approved the application. The appeal board’s decision was affirmed by the district court. The Department of Health has appealed to this court.

This court’s review of an administrative agency’s decision is de novo on the record. Neb. Rev. Stat. § 84-918 (Reissue 1981); Haeffner v. State, 220 Neb. 560, 371 N.W.2d 658 (1985); Department of Health v. Grand Island Health Care, 223 Neb. 587, 391 N.W.2d 582 (1986). This does not mean that we ignore the findings of fact made by the board and the fact that it saw and heard the witnesses who appeared before the board at its hearing.

At the time of the hearing there were two hospitals in health planning subarea III which were equipped to furnish radiation therapy. Good Samaritan Hospital in Kearney, Nebraska, had a Linac 6 unit and The Mary Lanning Memorial Hospital in Hastings, Nebraska, had a Cobalt-60 unit. The Mary Lanning hospital had obtained a certificate of need for a 12-MeV (megaelectron volt) unit, which was expected to be operational in 1985.

The project proposed by the applicant was the acquisition of a 6-MeV medical linear accelerator, with the intent to expand the hospital’s present abilities to treat oncology patients. Locally, the linear accelerator would be shared with St. Francis Medical Center and the Veterans Administration Medical Center, in addition to providing service for patients who travel to Grand Island from outlying communities.

[118]*118In addition to purchasing the linear accelerator, a 3,700- to 4,000-square-foot building was to be constructed to accommodate the radiation equipment and to provide three examination rooms, office space, and a waiting room. The estimated cost of the entire project was $885,191; the equipment and furnishings to total $413,075, while construction of the therapy center (including architectural and engineering fees) was estimated at $472,116. Financing for the equipment was to be through Nebraska financing authority at .08875 percent interest. Construction costs were to be financed with $300,000 of donated funds; the remaining balance of $172,116 was to be commercially financed at an estimated 13.5-percent interest.

The useful life of the linear accelerator would be about 7 to 10 years. The annual anticipated total cost of operation was estimated to be $217,000. From this data, it was calculated that the break-even point for operating costs would be 163 patients or 4,075 treatments per year. The approximate cost per treatment to the patient for the first year of operation was estimated to be $65, which was comparable to existing services.

The administrator of the applicant, Ken Klaasmeyer, testified that during 1983 the applicant operated at a loss but that in 1984 the applicant realized a net growth or profit of $330,000. In terms of actual occupancy rates, Klaasmeyer stated that of the 128 beds within the hospital, approximately 60 percent of the 108 medical-surgical beds were occupied in 1983.

Neb. Rev. Stat. § 71-5830(6) (Reissue 1986) requires that a certificate of need be obtained prior to “[a]ny capital expenditure or obligation incurred by or on behalf of a health care facility in excess of the capital expenditure minimum made ... [f] or the purchase... of clinical equipment....” Minimum capital expenditure is defined in Neb. Rev. Stat. § 71-5805.01 (Reissue 1986) as a “base amount of five hundred thousand dollars . . . .” Because the cost of the proposed project was anticipated to exceed $500,000, a certificate of need was required.

The Nebraska Legislature has declared the purpose of the certificate of need act:

[T]o conserve the limited health care resources of [119]*119personnel and facilities in order to provide quality health care to all citizens of the state, to minimize unnecessary duplication of facilities and services, to encourage development of appropriate alternative methods of delivering health care, to promote wherever appropriate a more competitive health care delivery system, to encourage the provision of high-quality health care which is available and accessible to all citizens of the state, and to maximize the effectiveness of expenditures made for health care.

Neb. Rev. Stat. § 71-5802 (Reissue 1986).

Whether the applicant should receive a certificate of need is to be determined from the provisions of the Nebraska Health Care Certificate of Need Act encompassed in Neb. Rev. Stat. §§ 71-5852 to 71-5855 (Reissue 1986); the Department of Health regulations (promulgated under the certificate of need act), Neb. Admin. Code tit. 182, ch. 2, §§ 005-006 (1983); and the Nebraska State Health Plan 1982-1987 (Neb. Dept. of Health 1982). Department of Health v. Grand Island Health Care, 223 Neb. 587, 391 N.W.2d 582 (1986).

The statutes require the Nebraska Department of Health to promulgate criteria by which to assess applications for certificates of need. According to the rules adopted by the Department of Health, the applicant “bears the burden of demonstrating in its application that the proposal satisfies all of the review criteria” applicable to the proposal at hand. Neb. Admin. Code, supra, § 003.02C. However, in an appeal from a decision granting a certificate of need, the party appealing bears the burden of proof that the application does not meet the applicable criteria. Neb. Rev. Stat. § 71-5865 (Reissue 1986).

The decision of an appeal board of the Nebraska Certificate of Need Appeal Panel is the final determination of the health department. Neb. Rev. Stat. § 71-5866 (Reissue 1986). There is no presumption of error, and, as in any usual appellate situation, the party alleging error has the burden of proof to establish error.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

In re Application No. OP-0003 -- (TransCanada)
303 Neb. 872 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 2019)
Law Offices of Ronald J. Palagi, P.C. v. Dolan
558 N.W.2d 303 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1997)
Ballard v. Nebraska Department of Social Services
515 N.W.2d 437 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 1994)
Ballard v. NEBRASKA DEPT. OF SOCIAL SERVICES
515 N.W.2d 437 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 1994)
Jantzen v. Diller Telephone Co.
511 N.W.2d 504 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1994)
Beverly Enterprises-Nebraska, Inc. v. Columbus Health Care, Inc.
510 N.W.2d 569 (Nebraska Court of Appeals, 1993)
In re Transfer Mining Permit No. 416 from Homestake Mining Co.
472 N.W.2d 766 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 1991)
Matter of Homestake Min. Co.
472 N.W.2d 766 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 1991)
Omaha Health Facilities, Inc. v. Department of Health
439 N.W.2d 78 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1989)
Heritage of Yankton, Inc. v. South Dakota Department of Health
432 N.W.2d 68 (South Dakota Supreme Court, 1988)
Dieter v. STATE, DEPT. OF SOCIAL SERVICES
422 N.W.2d 560 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1988)
Dieter v. State, Department of Social Services
422 N.W.2d 560 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1988)
Meier v. STATE, DEPT. OF SOCIAL SERVICES
417 N.W.2d 771 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1988)
Department of Health v. Lutheran Hospitals & Homes Society
416 N.W.2d 222 (Nebraska Supreme Court, 1987)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
416 N.W.2d 222, 227 Neb. 116, 1987 Neb. LEXIS 1105, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/department-of-health-v-lutheran-hospitals-homes-society-neb-1987.