Creek v. Union Nat. Bank in Kansas City

266 S.W.2d 737
CourtSupreme Court of Missouri
DecidedFebruary 8, 1954
Docket43239
StatusPublished
Cited by28 cases

This text of 266 S.W.2d 737 (Creek v. Union Nat. Bank in Kansas City) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Missouri primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Creek v. Union Nat. Bank in Kansas City, 266 S.W.2d 737 (Mo. 1954).

Opinions

BOHLING, Commissioner.

Robert V. Creek and Douglas W. Creek sued the Union National Bank in Kansas City, the trustee, and the other beneficiaries (hereinafter designated “other defendants”) in equity to decree the termination (except as to provisions for certain charitable institutions) of a trust agreement and amendments executed by Helena Reicher, Plelena Reicher, trustee for Rosa Reicher, and Rosa Reicher, under which the beneficiaries receive a trust estate of approximately $330,000 to the exclusion of trustors’ heirs at law, and for distribution. The trustee; having been notified that the heirs at law claimed the trust estate, had refused to make distribution.

The other defendants took the same position as the plaintiffs. The heirs at law were brought in under appropriate proceedings by the trustee, and the trustee by its pleadings sought, briefly stated, a decree that the trust agreement and amendments were valid and the approval of the administration of the trust.

The trustors’ heirs at law (second and further removed cousins of trustors, with the exception of a first cousin, and herein designated claimants) attacked the trust agreement and amendments mainly on the grounds of alleged mental incompetency of and alleged undue influence exercised upon the trustors by the grandmother, Mrs. Cora Bower, and the mother, Mrs. Helen Creek, of the plaintiffs. They also claim an interest in some of the trust assets under testamentary trusts in the will of the father and in the. will of- the brother of the trustors. Claimants state voluminous pleadings gave the court full jurisdiction.

The decree, final so" far as here involved, sustained the' trust agreement and amendments and, its ‘ administration. Claimants have appealed.

The record, replete with a detail of facts, is lengthy, as are the briefs. The testimony is frequently partisan, contains statements later disclosed as hearsay or conclusions, and irreconcilable. We shall endeavor to give the facts essential to a determination.

Mr. and Mrs. Morris Reicher had three children — Solomon (known in the record as Sol), Rosa and Helena. None of the children ever married. They were natives of Poland, resided for a time in Leavenworth, Karisas, and lived at 1317 Cherry Street, Kansas City, in the 1890s, and 3219 Campbell Street in the early 1900s. Morris Reicher' operated a wholesale drygoods business. He made Sol a full partner. The business was known as “M. Reicher & Son.” Mrs. Reicher predeceased her husband. Morris Reicher died January 15, 1913. Solomon Reicher continued the business. He died September 29, 1927. Rosa and Helena had an apartment in the St. Regis Hotel from 1931 until 1939. They tben lived. at 7236 Jarboe, and about a year later ‘purchased.a home at 601 West 57th Street Terrace.

Mrs. Cora Bower, who had nursed Morris Reicher, continued in the employ of the Reicher family for twenty-seven years as housekeeper and companion until her death, due to cancer, about November, 1940.

Mrs. Creek followed her mother, Mrs. Bower, as housekeeper and companion under the directions of the sisters. She died suddenly March 1, 1942. Mrs. Grace R. Buck followed Mrs. Creek.

Helena Reicher, who was a few years younger than Rosa, died November 11, 1941, the result of burns sustained when her gown caught fire from a gas heater. Mrs. Creek was severely burned at the time.

[740]*740Rosa Reicher,’ about 85 or 86, died November 11; 1950.

The original trust agreement was executed December 7, 1927, and signed: “Helena L. Reicher; Helena L. Reicher, Trustee for Rosa Reicher; Rosa Reicher, Trustors. New England National Bank and Trust Company in Kansas City by Thad B. Landon, Vice president and Trust Officer, Trustee.” It provided, among other things, for the payment of the income to the trustors or the surviving trustor, and, upon the death of the surviyor, for the distribution of the trust estate to named employees of M. Reicher & Son, plaintiffs and named charitable institutions. The trustors or the surviving trustor could “modify, alter, terminate or revoke” (herein referred to as amendments) the trust agreement in whole or in part.

The New England National Bank and Trust Company (herein-referred to as the New England Bank) merged with the Fidelity National Bank and Trust Company of Kansas City (referred to as the Fidelity Bank) January 1, 1929. The Fidelity Bank went into liquidation in 1933. The Union National Bank in Kansas City (referred to as the Union Bank) was organized ¡in July, 1933.

A. R. Strother was trust officer for the Fidelity Bank. R. B. Hewitt became vice-president and 'assistant trust officer of the Fidelity Bank in 1929, succeeded Mr. Strother in about two years, became vice-president and trust officer and in 1951 president of the Union ' Bank. William E. Estes, an assistant trust officer of the New England, Fidelity and Union banks, administered the Reicher trust until he resigned in 1935 or 1936; and, Whitney Ogden, with the trust, departments of the Fidelity and the. Union banks since, 1922, administered it thereafter under Mr. Hewitt.

The trustors’ first amendment of the trust agreement appointed the Union Bank as successor trustee on December 22, 1933. ,

Soon after Sol’s death, F. W. Everest, and perhaps Matt McCormack (who died in 1929), employees, managed M. Reicher & Son, with the advice of Alfred Ha'rt, a cotton goods broker and a close friend and business advisor of the Reicher family prior and subsequent to Sol’s death. Helena Reicher and Rosa Reicher, contracted on April 13, 1929, with F. W. Everest, C. W. Smith, O. P. Berger, John McCormack (employees named as beneficiaries in the original trust agreement), 'John F. Chappell, Morris Katz, R. E. Coleman, and other employees of M. Reicher & Son to transfer all assets, except cash, to a corporation to be known as M. Reicher & Son, Incorporated, with a capital of $120,000, represented by 1,200 shares of stock. The sisters agreed to and gave .between 17½ and 5 shares of the stock to individual .employees in recognition of services rendered, and agreed -to permit.'any employee to purchase up to 50 shares of said stock and give a 4-year note therefor. M. Reicher & Son, Inc., .was incorporated May 7, 1929. Mr. Everest was president, Mr. Chappell wa.s vice-president, and Mr. Smith was secretary-treasurer. The corporation lost money, and Helena, who had been connected with the business, complained that the store was being badly managed. In April, 1940, Mrs. Creek telephoned Morris Katz.about finding a-buyer for the stock. Mr. Katz went to the home, talked with Mrs. Creek and Mrs. Bower in the presence of Helena and Rosa, and, according to Mr. Katz, after Mrs. Creek sent the sisters upstairs, told them he could “get $25,000 for it; and Mrs. Creek and Mrs. Bower stated they would see.

Hyman and Jake Uenowitz (Katz had talked to Hyman before seeing the sisters) purchased M. Reicher & Son in May, 1940. Mr. Smith testified the sisters gave the employees a week ;to meet the offer but Mr. Katz denied this. The purchasers soon liquidated the business for more than $43,000, realizing a net profit of $18,000 on which the Denowitzes “cut, in” Mr. Katz for $6,000. , '

By an amendment of May 28, 1940,. the trustors provided for, after the death of both trustors, three charitable trusts of $20,000 each; and for the distribution of the remaining assets to Robert V. Creek, Douglas W. Greek and' Helen Creek in [741]*741equal shares, or their' children per stirpes.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Brandin v. Brandin
918 S.W.2d 835 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1996)
Combs v. Rubin
101 B.R. 590 (W.D. Missouri, 1989)
Hammons v. Eisert
745 S.W.2d 253 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1988)
Staples v. Miller
319 N.W.2d 57 (Supreme Court of Minnesota, 1982)
Matter of Estate of Head
615 P.2d 271 (New Mexico Court of Appeals, 1980)
Poppe v. Taute
615 P.2d 271 (New Mexico Court of Appeals, 1980)
Webb v. St. Louis County National Bank
551 S.W.2d 869 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1977)
Holland v. Holland
509 S.W.2d 91 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1974)
S____ J____ B v. S____ F____ S
504 S.W.2d 233 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1973)
S___ J___ B___ v. S___ F___ S___
504 S.W.2d 233 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1973)
Lee v. Smith
484 S.W.2d 38 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1972)
Adams v. Foster
466 S.W.2d 706 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1971)
Miller v. Riegler
419 S.W.2d 599 (Supreme Court of Arkansas, 1967)
Horton v. Estate of Elmore
420 S.W.2d 48 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1967)
Reed v. Eagleton
384 S.W.2d 578 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1964)
Kluck v. Metsger
349 S.W.2d 919 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1961)
Sebree v. Rosen
349 S.W.2d 865 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1961)
Murphy v. Mercantile Trust Co.
347 S.W.2d 224 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1961)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
266 S.W.2d 737, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/creek-v-union-nat-bank-in-kansas-city-mo-1954.