Craft v. Caldwell Parish Police Jury

455 So. 2d 1226, 1984 La. App. LEXIS 9396
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedAugust 22, 1984
Docket16161-CA
StatusPublished
Cited by12 cases

This text of 455 So. 2d 1226 (Craft v. Caldwell Parish Police Jury) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Craft v. Caldwell Parish Police Jury, 455 So. 2d 1226, 1984 La. App. LEXIS 9396 (La. Ct. App. 1984).

Opinion

455 So.2d 1226 (1984)

Lonnie CRAFT
v.
CALDWELL PARISH POLICE JURY, et al.

No. 16161-CA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

August 22, 1984.

*1228 Paul B. Wilkins, Columbia, for plaintiff-appellee-appellant Lonnie Craft.

Don C. Burns and Iley H. Evans, Columbia, for defendant-appellant Caldwell Parish Police Jury.

Cotton, Bolton & Hoychick by John Hoychick, Jr., Rayville, for defendant-appellee Marie Louise Snellings, Individually and in her capacity as the Testamentary Executrix of the Succession of George H. Snellings, Jr. and Louisiana Farm Bureau Mut. Ins. Co.

Before HALL, JASPER E. JONES and SEXTON, JJ.

JASPER E. JONES, Judge.

Caldwell Parish Police Jury, a defendant, appeals a judgment rendered against it in the amount of $11,100.00 in favor of Lonnie Craft, plaintiff, for damages sustained by him as a result of damage to his cattle trailer caused when a parish bridge collapsed beneath it. The judgment rejected plaintiff's demand for these damages against George M. Snellings, Jr. and Marie Louise Snellings aka Snellings Farm, and their insurer, Louisiana Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Company. Plaintiff appeals the judgment rejecting his demands against the Snellings and their insurer. George M. Snellings, Jr. died while this case was pending on appeal and his succession representative, his duly qualified testamentary executrix, Marie Louise Snellings, has been substituted for him as a party defendant.

FACTS

In the spring of 1979, because of flooding conditions affecting the Snellings' farm in Caldwell Parish, they moved their cattle herd from this farm to a farm operated by them north of Monroe, Louisiana. After the flood conditions terminated the Snellings made plans to return the cattle to their Caldwell Parish farm. In order to reach this farm it was necessary to traverse a rural Caldwell Parish road referred to in the pleadings as Parish Road # 32.[1] The right of way for this road was dedicated to the Caldwell Parish Police Jury on April 27, 1970, by Bodcow Company, owner *1229 of the land subject to the right of way, and the dedication was accepted by the Caldwell Parish Police Jury as reflected by the formal right of way grant which is of record in the conveyance records of Caldwell Parish. The record does not establish who constructed the bridge located on this road which collapsed under the weight of plaintiff's trailer loaded with cattle. However, the record establishes the police jury built and worked the road following the dedication and did some work on the bridge immediately before and after this accident occurred and perhaps at earlier times.

The Snellings employed Archie McClanahan to perform various duties for them in connection with the cattle operation. He was referred to by some of the witnesses as their foreman. McClanahan observed that the bridge was in a state of disrepair and was not safe to cross with the cattle. McClanahan advised the Snellings of the problem with the bridge and was instructed by them to contact the police jury and have the bridge repaired. McClanahan, and Mrs. Snellings, contacted the police jury and requested it to repair the bridge in order that they could move the cattle. McClanahan called the parish road superintendent, Mr. Harrison, and Mrs. Snellings contacted the police juror, Mr. Moreno, who was elected from the ward in which the road and bridge was located. Moreno and Harrison were told the bridge needed repair in order that cattle could be moved over it. Moreno contacted Harrison and requested him to check the bridge.

After this request for repair was made to the police jury, some work by it was performed on the bridge. The extent of this work is not totally clear from the record. Harrison testified the only work performed on the bridge was the replacement of the capsills which are the timbers which cross traversely under the bridge decking and rest immediately upon top of the bridge pilings. He testified this work was done by lifting the bridge decking from the pilings with a piece of parish machinery. Other employees of the jury who performed work on the bridge testified four of the planks in the bridge decking were replaced and that runners were laid lengthwise across the top of the bridge decking. McClanahan stated that after the police jury had worked on the bridge he checked the bridge and found the only work performed on it by the police jury was the re-nailing of the old bridge decking with 15 or 20 nails.

McClanahan, at the time of his initial examination of the bridge, stated there were some loose planks on the bridge decking where the water had been over it and that about a dozen of the timbers used in construction of the bridge decking appeared weakened and needed to be replaced by new timbers. At the time of McClanahan's examination of the bridge following the police jury's repair of it, he stated that only the loose planks had been nailed and that no other work had been performed on the bridge and the weakened timbers which he observed had not been replaced. McClanahan was concerned about the safety of the bridge after the police jury worked on it and again called Mr. Harrison about the bridge and was advised by Harrison the bridge was all right and would hold up. Following McClanahan's observation of the bridge repair performed by the police jury, he personally secured sixteen 2X6's from the Snellings' farm and with them braced the pilings under the bridge. He performed no work on the bridge decking.

McClanahan, on instructions by the Snellings, contacted James Hopper who had on prior occasions hauled cattle for the Snellings' farm, and requested Hopper to move a load of the cattle. Hopper had, a few months before this, sold his 18 wheeler cattle truck and trailer to Lonnie Craft and he secured Craft to haul the cattle for the Snellings, although neither McClanahan nor the Snellings were advised that Craft would haul the cattle rather than Hopper.

On July 13, 1979, the day following McClanahan's supplemental work on the bridge, the cattle moving operation was undertaken. McClanahan, with a pickup truck and a gooseneck type cattle trailer, went to the Snellings' farm and secured a *1230 load of cattle. He had earlier made arrangements with Hopper for him to also move cattle on this date. McClanahan was loading cattle at the Snellings' farm north of Monroe when Lonnie Craft arrived with his 18 wheeler cattle moving rig to secure a load of cattle. McClanahan departed with his load of cattle before Craft and never advised Craft of the condition of the bridge.

Mrs. Snellings, who was at the farm while the cattle were being loaded, advised Craft as to the destination of the cattle and the route required to reach it. Mrs. Snellings, who had earlier been advised by the police jury that the bridge had been repaired, told Craft the bridge on the road approaching her farm had recently been repaired by the police jury but he should have no trouble crossing it. McClanahan, with the pickup truck and gooseneck trailer load of cattle safely crossed the bridge. Craft had never crossed the bridge before. When he arrived at the bridge, he observed the new planks on the bridge and felt it was safe to cross. He put the truck in low gear and eased across the bridge at a speed of about 5 m.p.h., and just as the tractor cleared the bridge on the other side, the bridge decking collapsed and the trailer fell and came to rest upon the pilings. The record does not establish the weight of the trailer but the 37 cattle in it were estimated to weigh 600 pounds each which would have made the cattle weigh approximately 11 tons.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Guerra v. White
755 So. 2d 894 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1999)
Jones v. Celotex Corp.
683 F. Supp. 555 (E.D. Louisiana, 1987)
Rodgers v. National Dealer Services, Inc.
508 So. 2d 1007 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1987)
State v. Skeetoe
501 So. 2d 931 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1987)
Harris v. Pineset
499 So. 2d 499 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1986)
Kitchen v. Duke's Escort Service
493 So. 2d 829 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1986)
Shafouk Nor El Din Hamza v. Bourgeois
493 So. 2d 112 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1986)
Geisler v. Allstate Insurance Co.
489 So. 2d 429 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1986)
Marzula v. White
488 So. 2d 1092 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1986)
DeSoto Parish Police Jury v. Bell
463 So. 2d 887 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1985)
Jacks v. Allstate Ins. Co.
463 So. 2d 833 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1985)
Blakeney v. Tidewater Compression Service, Inc.
463 So. 2d 914 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 1985)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
455 So. 2d 1226, 1984 La. App. LEXIS 9396, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/craft-v-caldwell-parish-police-jury-lactapp-1984.