Concordia Parish School Board v. Louisiana MacHinery Rentals, LLC

• Court: Louisiana Court of Appeal
• Decided: March 12, 2014
• Docket: CA-0012-0422
• Status: Unknown

Opinion

STATE OF LOUISIANA COURT OF APPEAL, THIRD CIRCUIT

12-422

CONCORDIA PARISH SCHOOL BOARD CONCORDIA PARISH HOSPITAL DISTRICT #1 CONCORDIA PARISH POLICE JURY CITY OF VIDALIA TOWN OF FERRIDAY

VERSUS

LOUISIANA MACHINERY RENTALS, LLC

********** APPEAL FROM THE SEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT PARISH OF CONCORDIA, NO. 45,820 “A” HONORABLE KATHY JOHNSON, DISTRICT JUDGE OPINION ON REMAND ********** JAMES T. GENOVESE JUDGE

**********

Court composed of John D. Saunders, Elizabeth A. Pickett, and James T. Genovese, Judges.

REVERSED AND REMANDED. Jesse R. Adams, III Kathryn S. Friel Andre Brian Burvant Matthew A. Mantle Jones, Walker, Waechter, Poitevent, Carrère & Denègre, L.L.P. 201 St. Charles Ave., 51st Floor New Orleans, Louisiana 70170-5100 (504) 582-8000 COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT/APPELLANT: Louisiana Machinery Rentals, LLC

Jack Hendrix McLemore, Jr. Post Office Box 520 200 Advocate Row, Suite B Vidalia, Louisiana 71373 (318) 336-9189 COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFFS/APPELLEES: Concordia Parish School Board, Concordia Parish Hospital District #1, Concordia Parish Police Jury, City of Vidalia, and Town of Ferriday

Robert R. Rainer Drew M. Talbot Rainer, Anding & McLindon 8480 Bluebonnet Blvd., Suite D Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70810 (225) 766-0200 COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFFS/APPELLEES: Concordia Parish School Board, Concordia Parish Hospital District #1, Concordia Parish Police Jury, City of Vidalia, and Town of Ferriday GENOVESE, Judge.

Pursuant to a writ of certiorari granted January 17, 2014, by the Louisiana

Supreme Court under Docket No. 2012-2503, this case was remanded to this court

with instructions “to consider the matter in light of this court’s recent opinions in

Washington Parish Sheriff’s Office v. Louisiana Machinery Company, LLC,

13-0583 (La. 10/15/13), [126] So.3d [1273], and Catahoula Parish School Bd. v.

Louisiana Machinery Company, LLC, 12-2504 (La. 10/15/13), [124] So.3d

[1065].”

In doing so, we note that the Washington case was decided based on the

reasons assigned in the Catahoula1 case. In Catahoula, the supreme court affirmed

this court’s reversal of the trial court’s grant of partial summary judgment in favor

of the Catahoula Parish School Board and the Catahoula Parish Police Jury, with a

remand for further proceedings. Specifically, the supreme court ruled that the

mandatory notice requirements of La.R.S. 47:337.51 were deficient and, therefore,

not final; that “the validity of the notices of assessments constituted an essential

element of the Collector’s claims rather than strictly a defense asserted by the

Companies[]”; and, that the defenses asserted by the Companies were timely filed.

Id. at 1076.

After due “consideration” of the supreme court’s rulings in the Washington

and Catahoula cases, and in accordance with its instructions, we again reverse the

trial court’s grant of the partial summary judgment in favor of the Concordia Parish

School Board, Concordia Parish Hospital District #1, Concordia Parish Police Jury,

City of Vidalia, and the Town of Ferriday and remand the matter to the trial court

for further proceedings. Costs of this appeal are assessed equally to the Concordia

1 The Catahoula case consists of the case of Catahoula Parish School Board v. Louisiana Machinery Rentals, LLC, 12-443 (La.App. 3 Cir. 10/24/12), 105 So.3d 169, which was consolidated with the case of Catahoula Parish School Board v. Louisiana Machinery Rentals, LLC, 12-444 (La.App. 3 Cir. 10/24/12), 105 So.3d 169. Parish School Board, Concordia Parish Hospital District #1, Concordia Parish

Police Jury, City of Vidalia, and the Town of Ferriday in the amount of $2,223.50

pursuant to La.R.S. 13:5112.

REVERSED AND REMANDED.