Community Care Center of Vicksburg v. Mason

966 So. 2d 220, 2007 WL 2917585
CourtCourt of Appeals of Mississippi
DecidedOctober 9, 2007
Docket2006-CA-00599-COA
StatusPublished
Cited by7 cases

This text of 966 So. 2d 220 (Community Care Center of Vicksburg v. Mason) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Mississippi primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Community Care Center of Vicksburg v. Mason, 966 So. 2d 220, 2007 WL 2917585 (Mich. Ct. App. 2007).

Opinion

966 So.2d 220 (2007)

COMMUNITY CARE CENTER OF VICKSBURG, LLC d/b/a Heritage House Nursing and Rehabilitation Center and Legacy Healthcare Services, Inc., Appellants
v.
Carolyn C. MASON, Appellee.

No. 2006-CA-00599-COA.

Court of Appeals of Mississippi.

October 9, 2007.

*222 Marjorie S. Busching, S. Mark Wann, Jackson, attorneys for appellants.

Henry Dean Andrews, attorney for appellee.

Before KING, C.J., GRIFFIS and BARNES, JJ.

BARNES, J., for the Court.

¶ 1. Community Care Center of Vicksburg, LLC d/b/a Heritage House Nursing and Rehabilitation Center and Legacy Healthcare Services, Inc., appeal the judgment of the Circuit Court of Warren County, which denied the Appellants' motion to dismiss and compel arbitration. We find the trial court erred and thus reverse and remand this case for an order compelling arbitration.

STATEMENT OF FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

¶ 2. On April 18, 2003, Carolyn Mason admitted herself into the Heritage House Nursing and Rehabilitation Center ("Heritage House") in Vicksburg, Mississippi as a private-pay patient. Previously, Mrs. Mason had resided at her home in Vicksburg, where she was cared for by home health personnel as well as private-duty sitters. Mrs. Mason has cerebral palsy and was approximately sixty-nine years old at the time she entered Heritage House. According to medical records, Mrs. Mason had been hospitalized from February 8, 2003 to February 14, 2003 for viral gastroenteritis. Also, her husband had passed away in February.[1] In April of 2003, according to home health care personnel records, Mrs. Mason was ambulating and eating well. Then, on April 17, 2003, she tripped and fell in her home *223 when her robe became caught on a door. That evening, Mrs. Mason told her private-duty sitter, Faith Bunch, that she felt fine. However, when Bunch returned the next morning, Mrs. Mason's arm was swollen and bruised. Initially, Mrs. Mason requested Bunch take her to Heritage House, which Mrs. Mason had inquired about at an earlier time. Instead, Bunch took Mrs. Mason to her primary care physician, where Mrs. Mason was diagnosed with a fractured wrist. Then, Bunch took her to Heritage House, where she remained with Mrs. Mason during the admissions process. Once Mrs. Mason was situated in a room, Bunch noted in her records she "seem[ed] to be content."

¶ 3. On the day of her admission of April 18, 2003, Mrs. Mason signed numerous admission documents in her room. One such document was an admission agreement, which contained an arbitration provision. The seven page admission agreement was properly executed by Mrs. Mason on page six. Directly above her signature on this page, in bold-faced and all capital letters, it states:

ANY RESPONSIBLE PARTY OR PARTIES EXECUTING THIS AGREEMENT REPRESENT AND WARRANT THAT THEY HAVE AUTHORITY, EITHER EXPRESS, IMPLIED OR APPARENT, TO ACT AS AGENT FOR THE RESIDENT AND TO EXECUTE THIS AGREEMENT ON RESIDENT'S BEHALF.

On the next page, Mrs. Mason executed the agreement again, after the following statement in all capital letters and bold faced font:

THE UNDERSIGNED ACKNOWLEDGE THAT EACH OF THEM HAS READ AND UNDERSTOOD THIS AGREEMENT, INCLUDING THE ARBITRATION PROVISION AND HAS RECEIVED A COPY OF THIS AGREEMENT, AND THAT EACH OF THEM VOLUNTARILY CONSENTS TO AND ACCEPTS ALL OF ITS TERMS.

The signature was witnessed by "D. Rogers," who is a social worker at Heritage House. Below this area is a section entitled "Witness Acknowledgment (to be executed when agreement signed by resident)." Here there was a place for the resident and a witness to sign. This area was not filled out or signed; however, the requisite signatures of the resident and witness were placed in the area above it.

¶ 4. Mrs. Mason did not, however, initial the top of page five of the agreement dealing with the arbitration provision. At the top of this page, a line was provided for initials, followed by the statement "ARBITRATION-PLEASE READ CAREFULLY." This page of the agreement contained the arbitration provision, explaining that any legal dispute which might arise "shall be resolved exclusively by binding arbitration." Further, continuing on page six, the arbitration agreement specifically informed the signatory that:

The Resident and/or Responsible Party understand that (1) he/she has the right to seek legal counsel concerning this agreement, (2) the execution of this Arbitration is not a precondition to the furnishing of services to the Resident by the Facility, and (3) this Arbitration Agreement may be rescinded by written notice to the Facility from the Resident within 30 days of signature.

There is no evidence that Mrs. Mason altered any part of the contract or rejected any of its provisions. Also, according to the record, Mrs. Mason did not present a power of attorney at any point during her stay at Heritage House or indicate that any person possessed legal authority over her.

*224 ¶ 5. Mrs. Mason resided at Heritage House until April 26, 2003, when an incident occurred. She alleges she was attacked by another resident while alone in her room. During the incident, Mrs. Mason fell, apparently trying to escape from the resident. She was taken to a hospital and diagnosed with a fractured hip. Then, on May 14, 2003, Mrs. Mason admitted herself to Shady Lawn Nursing Home. According to those admission documents, Mrs. Mason again was her own responsible party and indicated that on the advance directives form she did not have a power of attorney.

¶ 6. On May 6, 2004, Mrs. Mason filed suit against Community Care Center of Vicksburg d/b/a Heritage House in the Circuit Court of Warren County.[2] Mrs. Mason alleged negligence, negligence per se, premise liability, and gross negligence pertaining to the incident that occurred on April 26. Heritage House filed its answer and defenses, including a motion to compel arbitration. In her response to the motion to compel, Mrs. Mason submitted two affidavits: one by her and one by her sitter Faith Bunch. In Bunch's affidavit, she states she did not remember the term "arbitration" being discussed with Mrs. Mason, she does not know what the term means, and the facility representative "did not go into a lot of detail about what each document meant." In Mrs. Mason's affidavit, she states, upon admission to Heritage House she was handed a large stack of documents to sign without much explanation as to the meaning of each document. She also asserts at the time she was recovering from influenza which resulted in pneumonia and thus her condition was weak.[3] Therefore, she alleges she "was not as mentally alert as [she] would have been had [she] not been ill." Mrs. Mason also states in her sworn statement that the representative did not mention the term "arbitration," Mrs. Mason does not know what it means, she did not willfully or knowingly agree to any arbitration agreement, and she does not know what she signed that day.

¶ 7. The trial judge delayed ruling on the motion to compel arbitration in order to seek guidance from the Mississippi Supreme Court's pending opinion of Vicksburg Partners, L.P. v. Stephens, 911 So.2d 507 (Miss.2005). Once the opinion was released, the circuit court entered an order denying the Appellants' motion to compel arbitration, finding the arbitration clause on the admissions agreement procedurally and substantively unconscionable. In part, the circuit court based its decision on the fact

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Jane Doe v. Hallmark Partners, LP
227 So. 3d 1052 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2017)
Louisiana Extended Care Centers, LLC v. Carolyn Bindon
180 So. 3d 791 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2015)
City of Canton v. Nissan North America, Inc.
870 F. Supp. 2d 430 (S.D. Mississippi, 2012)
Cook Ex Rel. Wrongful Death Beneficiaries v. GGNSC Ripley, LLC
786 F. Supp. 2d 1166 (N.D. Mississippi, 2011)
Swindle v. Harvey
23 So. 3d 562 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2009)
Forest Hill Nursing Center, Inc. v. McFarlan
995 So. 2d 775 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2008)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
966 So. 2d 220, 2007 WL 2917585, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/community-care-center-of-vicksburg-v-mason-missctapp-2007.