Commonwealth v. Keenan

11 Pa. D. & C.5th 289
CourtPennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Berks County
DecidedMarch 16, 2010
Docketno. CP-06-CR-523-09
StatusPublished
Cited by2 cases

This text of 11 Pa. D. & C.5th 289 (Commonwealth v. Keenan) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Pennsylvania Court of Common Pleas, Berks County primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Commonwealth v. Keenan, 11 Pa. D. & C.5th 289 (Pa. Super. Ct. 2010).

Opinion

LUDGATE, J,

The matter before the court is the defendant’s direct appeal from judgment of sentence. The court adopts and incorporates its findings of fact and conclusions of law issued June 10, 2009.

I. PROCEDURAL AND FACTUAL HISTORY

On June 18, 2009, Jessie Keenan (defendant) was charged by information with arson, 18 Pa.C.S. §3301(a) (l)(i), arson, 18Pa.C.S. §3301 (a)( 1 )(ii), arson, 18Pa.C.S. §3301(c)(l), 18 Pa.C.S. §3301(c)(2), causing or risking catastrophe, 18 Pa.C.S. §3302(b), criminal mischief, 18 Pa.C.S. §3304(a)(l) and recklessly endangering another person, 18 Pa.C.S. §2705.

On June 9, 2009, the court held a hearing on the defendant’s omnibus pretrial motion. On June 10, 2009, the court issued findings of fact and conclusions of law and denied the defendant’s suppression and habeas corpus claims.

On September 23, 24 and 25, 2009, the court held a jury trial. At trial, the Commonwealth presented the testimony of Officer Eric Driesbach of City of Reading Police Department. (N.T. 9/23/2009-9/25/2009, p. 9.) Officer Driesbach testified that on June 18, 2006 at approximately 10:45 p.m., he was walking to his patrol car near city hall when he heard two loud bangs or explosions. (N.T. pp. 9-10.) Officer Driesbach observed smoke and flames at the comer of 9th and Washington Streets, one-half block from city hall. (N.T. p. 10.) Officer Driesbach observed a white male walking north on Cedar [292]*292Street; another officer on a motorcycle motioned with his arms, which Officer Driesbach interpreted to mean the white male should be stopped. (N.T. pp. 10-11.) By the time Officer Driesbach reached the white male, other officers had already approached the white male; no one else was outside in the intersection of Cedar and Washington Streets. (N.T. p. 11.) Officer Driesbach said the building at 9th and Washington Streets was engulfed in flames when he arrived at the scene, and he had left city hall only 30-45 seconds before arriving. (N.T. p. 13.) Officer Driesbach testified that he was scared but felt comfortable once the fire department arrived. (N.T. p. 14.)

Officer Arnold Labella testified that he is a police officer with the Reading Police Department. (N.T. p. 18.) On June 19,2006, Officer Labella was riding his motorcycle towards city hall to work the midnight patrol shift. (N.T.p. 18.) At that time, Officer Labella heard an explosion and observed the building at 9th and Washington Streets to be on fire. (N.T. pp. 18-19.) Officer Labella observed a large white male walking from an alleyway towards Washington Street. (N.T. p. 19.) No one else was in the area at that time. (N.T. p. 20.)

Sergeant Marc Pentheny testified that he is employed by the Reading Police Department and was working on June 18, 2006. (N.T. p. 22.) At approximately 11 p.m., Sergeant Pentheny was leaving city hall at the conclusion of his shift when he received a call for an explosion and fire at 9th and Washington Streets. (N.T. p. 23.) While walking to the scene, Sergeant Pentheny ran into a male [293]*293who was staggering, incoherent and had been severely burned; Sergeant Pentheny assumed the male was a victim of the fire. (N.T. pp. 23-24.) The male was identified as the defendant. (N.T. p. 24.) Once emergency medical personnel got to the defendant, Sergeant Pentheny went to the scene of the fire. (N.T. p. 25.)

Officer Matthew Schappell testified that he is employed by the Reading City Police Department and was so working on June 19,2006. (N.T. p. 27.) Officer Schappell responded to a fire at North 9th and Washington Streets; upon his arrival, paramedics asked Officer Schappell to drive their ambulance to Reading Hospital because an individual who was injured in the fire required the attention of both paramedics. (N.T. p. 28.) Officer Schappell drove the ambulance to Reading Hospital then returned to city hall; Officer Schappell returned to Reading Hospital to stay with the individual who was injured in the fire. (N.T. p. 28.) That individual was the defendant. (N.T. p. 29.) Officer Schappell collected the clothing the defendant was wearing when he arrived at the hospital, consisting of pairs of pants, boots and socks. (N.T. p. 29.) Officer Schappell turned the clothing over to Officer Naugle, an evidence technician. (N.T. p. 29.)

Thomas Kemmery testified that he is employed by the City of Reading Fire Department. (N.T. p. 33.) Mr. Kemmery is a firefighter and registered nurse with specialty in pre-hospital care. (N.T. p. 38.) Mr. Kemmery responded to the fire at 9th and Washington Streets on June 18, 2006. (N.T. pp. 33-34.) At that time, Mr. Kemmery came into contact with the defendant, who was badly [294]*294burned. (N.T. p. 36.) The defendant had bums to about 55 percent of his body including his torso, face, arms, left upper leg; the defendant also had injury to his breathing passages as a result of fire. (N.T. p. 39.) Mr. Kemmery testified that injury to breathing passages indicates a person was in close proximity to a fire because inhaling radiant heat can cause redness and swelling of the soft tissue inside the nose, throat and mouth. (N.T. pp. 39-40.)

Dale Kite testified that in June of 2006 he was living in an apartment at 839 Washington Street, Reading, Berks County, Pennsylvania; this address is two doors away from Sunny’s Steaks, which is at the comer of 9th and Washington Streets. (N.T. p. 52.) Mr. Kite testified that on June 18, 2006 there was a large explosion which knocked a clock off his wall. (N.T. p. 53.) Mr. Kite looked out his window to the roof of 841 Washington Street; at that time, Mr. Kite heard a male voice say something to the effect of “which way do I go” or “where do I go.” (N.T. pp. 53,55.) Mr. Kite said it is possible to get to the roof of 841 Washington from the roof of Sunny’s Steaks. (N.T. pp. 54-55.) Mr. Kite went out his front door to Washington Street and saw a pile of bricks that were burning; the bricks came down from the second floor of the restaurant. (N.T. pp. 55-56.) Mr. Kite helped neighbors get out of 841 Washington Street, which contained three apartments, including George Butler, who had heart problems. (N.T. pp. 56-58.) While going to find his neighbors, Mr. Kite saw the defendant and recognized him as the source of the voice he heard on the roof. (N.T. pp. 58-59.) The defendant was known to Mr. Kite because [295]*295the defendant had been a cook at Sunny’s Steaks, a restaurant Mr. Kite frequented, and Mr. Kite did odd jobs for the defendant and the owner of the restaurant. (N.T. pp. 60-62.)

Richardo Pena testified that in 2006 he worked with his father-in-law managing his properties, including 100 and 102 North 9th Street. (N.T. p. 66.) Mr. Pena’s father-in-law sold a restaurant at that location to John Thomas, who began operating the restaurant as Sunny’s Steaks. (N.T. p. 67.) Before transferring the property to Mr. Thomas, Mr. Pena cleaned out the second and third floors above the restaurant; the floors did not contain drywall or gas or electric utilities. (N.T. pp. 68-69.) There is no way to access the second and third floors from the first floor restaurant; those floors are only accessible through the roof. (N.T. p. 69.) Mr. Pena identified the defendant, whom he recognized because the defendant had worked for John Thomas at a different restaurant. (N.T. pp. 70-71.)

Officer Michael Dobrosky testified that in 2006 he was employed as an evidence technician for the City of Reading Police Department. (N.T. p. 84.) Officer Dobrosky photographed the scene and collected evidence on June 19,2006, following the fire.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

People v. Kowalski
954 N.E.2d 442 (Appellate Court of Illinois, 2011)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
11 Pa. D. & C.5th 289, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/commonwealth-v-keenan-pactcomplberks-2010.