Clawson v. Grays Harbor College District No. 2

61 P.3d 1130, 148 Wash. 2d 528
Washington Supreme Court·Decided January 23, 2003·No. No. 72113-1·Published·Cited by 17 cases

Opinions

Smith, J.*

Petitioners Diane L. Butcher-Evans and K.

Ann McCartney, part-time community college instructors, seek discretionary review of a decision of the Court of Appeals, Division One, which affirmed an order of the King County Superior Court dismissing on summary judgment their claim against community colleges for unpaid overtime wages under the Washington Minimum Wage Act, chapter 49.46 RCW.* 1 We granted review. We affirm.

QUESTION PRESENTED

The sole question in this case is whether the Court of Appeals was correct in affirming a decision of the trial court concluding that part-time community college instructors are professional employees compensated on a salary basis and therefore not covered by the wage and overtime provisions of the Washington Minimum Wage Act.

STATEMENT OF FACTS

The material facts are not in dispute. The parties dispute only the legal effect of those facts.

Petitioners Diane L. Butcher-Evans and K. Ann McCartney were employed as part-time faculty members [532] (instructors) at Green River Community College and Whatcom Community College.2 They, along with 10 other part-time instructors, sued five of Washington’s community colleges3 for unpaid minimum and overtime wages they claimed were owed them under the Washington Minimum Wage Act (MWA), chapter 49.46 RCW.4 The instructors claimed they were hourly employees and that the colleges’ compensation arrangement did not pay them for their non-classroom work, including, for example, preparing for class, grading examinations, developing coursework, and attending meetings. The colleges responded that the instructors were employed in a “bona fide professional capacity’ and compensated on a “salary basis,” thus exempting them from the MWA.

The community colleges hire part-time faculty (instructors) under individual contracts on either an annual or quarterly basis.5 The colleges calculate an instructor’s compensation by multiplying the number of credits or “contact hours,” which are the number of in-class instruction hours for each course,6 by the monetary rates specified in the applicable collective bargaining agreements.7 The instructors are then paid at regular intervals throughout [533] the quarter in equal or near-equal installments8 regardless of their teaching performance or the number of instructional days in a pay period.9 The applicable collective bargaining agreements between the colleges and the instructors’ union state that an instructor’s compensation includes payment for work done outside the classroom, such as “course preparation, grading, student conferences, and office hours.”10

Petitioner Butcher-Evans’ complete employment history is not before us. An example is that she was hired by Green River Community College to teach two mathematics classes during the 1996 fall quarter for $4,129.40.* 11 Beginning on October 10, 1996 she was paid $688.25 and then was paid $688.23 on or near the 10th and 25th of each month until the end of the quarter.12 These payments were made even though the number of instruction days per pay period ranged from 6 to 11.13 The following chart illustrates the compensation Petitioner Butcher-Evans received during the 1996 fall quarter:

CONTRACT SUMMARY FOR PETITIONER DIANE L. BUTCHER-EVANS GREEN RIVER COMMUNITY COLLEGE

Contract Contract Pay Date Instruction Gross Pay
Period Amount
Fall Quarter 1996 $4,129.40 October 10 6 $688.25
October 25 11 688.23
November 8 11 688.23
November 25 9 688.23
[534] Contract Period Contract Pay Date Amount Instruction Gross Pay
December 10 8 688.23
December 24 7 688.23
Totals 52 $4,129.40

Petitioner McCartney’s complete employment history is not before us. An example is that she was hired by Whatcom Community College to teach two public speaking classes during the spring quarter for $3,358.08.14 Beginning on April 30, 1998 she was paid $1,119.36 and was paid that same amount on May 29, 1998 and on June 10, 1998,15 regardless of the number of instruction days during each pay period. The following chart illustrates the compensation petitioner McCartney received during the 1998 spring quarter:

CONTRACT SUMMARY FOR PETITIONER K. ANN MCCARTNEY WHATCOM COMMUNITY COLLEGE

Contract Period Contract Pay Date Amount Instruction Gross Pay Days
Spring Quarter 1998 $3,358.08 April 30 19 $1,119.36
May 29 20 1,119.36
June 10 15 1,119.36
Totals 54 $3,358.08

Respondent Green River Community College prorated pay deductions from part-time faculty whenever instructors missed classroom hours for personal or health reasons after their accrued sick or annual leave had been exhausted.16 The deductions were calculated by multiplying the number [535] of contact hours missed by the compensation rate under the collective bargaining agreement.17

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Clawson v. Grays Harbor College District No. 2, 61 P.3d 1130, 148 Wash. 2d 528 (Wash. 2003).

61 P.3d 1130 (Clawson v. Grays Harbor College District No. 2) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Maria Sherry, V. Dept. Of Employment Security
Court of Appeals of Washington, 2021
Rahman v. State
170 Wash. 2d 810 (Washington Supreme Court, 2011)
Rahman v. State
150 Wash. App. 345 (Court of Appeals of Washington, 2009)
Kettenring v. Los Angeles Unified School District
167 Cal. App. 4th 507 (California Court of Appeal, 2008)
Sanders v. City of Seattle
156 P.3d 874 (Washington Supreme Court, 2007)
Mitchell v. PEMCO Mutual Insurance
142 P.3d 623 (Court of Appeals of Washington, 2006)
Crisp v. VanLaecken
130 Wash. App. 320 (Court of Appeals of Washington, 2005)
City of Seattle v. Mighty Movers, Inc.
96 P.3d 979 (Washington Supreme Court, 2004)
Clawson v. Grays Harbor College Dist. No. 2
61 P.3d 1130 (Washington Supreme Court, 2003)