Church of Grace & Glory v. Commonwealth, Department of Transportation

76 A.3d 101, 2013 WL 4398860, 2013 Pa. Commw. LEXIS 329
CourtCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania
DecidedAugust 16, 2013
StatusPublished
Cited by22 cases

This text of 76 A.3d 101 (Church of Grace & Glory v. Commonwealth, Department of Transportation) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Church of Grace & Glory v. Commonwealth, Department of Transportation, 76 A.3d 101, 2013 WL 4398860, 2013 Pa. Commw. LEXIS 329 (Pa. Ct. App. 2013).

Opinion

OPINION BY

Judge BROBSON.

Appellant The Church of Grace and Glory (Church) appeals from the July 25, 2012 order of the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County (trial court), which sustained Appellee/condemnor Department of Transportation’s (DOT) preliminary objections to the Church’s petition for appointment of a board of viewers. For the reasons set forth below, we affirm the trial court’s order.

On May 1, 2006, DOT filed with the trial court a declaration of taking under what is now the former Eminent Domain Code (former Code),1 docketed at GD-06-10196. (Reproduced Record (R.R.) at 6a-17a.) The declaration of taking sought to condemn “all right, title, and interest in and to [subsurface coal]” of a property located in the Townships of Collier and Robinson. (R.R. at 9a.) In its declaration, DOT alleged that, despite a diligent search, it was unable to identify or otherwise determine the owner(s) of the subsurface coal at the property. (R.R. at 12a.) The record indicates that DOT also filed with the trial court a declaration of taking, docketed at GD 06-010194, condemning the surface property owned by the Church at the same location as the subsurface coal. (Id. at 134a-42a.) On May 10, 2006, DOT published, pursuant to former Section 405(b) of the Code, 26 P.S. § l-405(b), a notice of the taking and estimated just compensation in the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and the Pittsburgh Legal Journal.2 (Id.) The notice read in pertinent part:

In the Court of Common Pleas of Allegheny County,
Pennsylvania
D.B.-Volume 12829 Page 546
In Re: Condemnation by the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania, Department of Transportation, of the right-
of-way for State Route 0079, Section A23 in the
Township of Collier and the Township of Robinson.
No. 2006-13177 Term, 2006
[104]*104Eminent Domain Proceeding in Rem
Notice of Condemnation and Deposit of Estimated Just Compensation
Notice is hereby given that the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, by the Secretary of Transportation ... pursuant to the provisions of Section 2008(e) of the Administrative Code of 1929, P.L. 177, 71 P.S. [§ ] 513(e), as amended, has filed on May 1, 2006, a Declaration of Taking to the above term and number, condemning the property shown on the plans of the parcels listed on the Schedule of Property Condemned which have been recorded in the Recorder’s Office of the above county at the places indicated on the said schedule. The name(s) of the owner(s) of the property interest(s) condemned is (are) also shown on the aforesaid Schedule....
The purpose of the condemnation is to acquire property for transportation purposes.
Plans showing the property condemned from the parcels listed on the Schedule of Property Condemned have been recorded in the aforesaid Recorder’s Office at the places indicated on the Schedule, where they are available for inspection. The Property Interest thereby condemned is designated on the Declaration of Taking heretofore filed. The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is not required to post security, inasmuch as it has the power of taxation.
Because the Identity or the whereabouts of the condemnee(s) listed below is (are) unknown or for other reasons he (they) cannot be served, this notice is hereby published in accordance with Section 405(b) of the Eminent Domain Code of 1964 (26 P.S. [§ ] l-405(b)). Claim No. 0200458000; Parcel No. 37; Name Unknown Owner; Address
Furthermore Notice is Given That the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Transportation, pursuant to Section 522 of the Eminent Domain Code of 1964 (26 P.S. [§ ] 1-522), will, no less than twenty (20) day[s] subsequent to the expiration of the statutory period for the filing of preliminary objections to the Declaration of Taking, present a petition to the Court of Common Pleas of the above county to deposit into court the just compensation estimated by the Commonwealth to be due to all parties in interest for damages sustained as the result of the condemnation of the property herein involved.
... After estimated just compensation has been deposited into court, the said monies may be withdrawn by the persons entitled [thereto] only upon petition to the court.

(Id. at 111 a.)

On July 18, 2006, under Section 522 of the former Code, 26 P.S. § 1-522,3 DOT petitioned the trial court to deposit estimated just compensation of $28,400 into court, because DOT sought possession of the condemned property and could not determine the owners of the subsurface coal. (Id. at 19a-20a.) On the same day, the trial court granted DOT’S petition and ordered that the sum of $28,400 be paid into court in an interest-bearing account. (Id. at 22a.)

[105]*105On July 31, 2007, in. connection with DOT’s declaration of taking with regard to the Church’s surface property, the Church served interrogatories on DOT, asking for information regarding, inter alia, (1) the ownership of the coal estate beneath the Church’s property, (2) the quantity of coal removed, and (3) any sale of the removed coal. (Id. at 134a-39a.) On September 20, 2007, DOT responded to the Church’s interrogatories and provided the Church with a copy of its coal ownership analysis.4 (Id. at 136a-40a.)

On December 28, 2010, Champion Processing, Inc. (Champion), one of the entities identified by DOT as a potential owner of the coal estate, assigned to the Church

all of Champion’s right, title, and interest (if any) in and to a claim or claims for damages, which include but are not limited to estimated as well as just compensation, that Champion may have or has against [DOT] pursuant to the [Code], for certain coal taken by [DOT] pursuant to the Declaration of Taking filed in April 2006 by [DOT] in the [trial court] at [docket number] GD 06-10196.

(Id. at 75a (emphasis added).) The assignment further provided:

Although the aforesaid Declaration of Taking states that the Condemnees are unknown, Champion acquired its interest in all of the Pittsburgh vein or seam of coal, including the roof and rooster coal, and all seams of coal lying above horizon of the Pittsburgh vein or seam, (which may include all or a portion of the coal condemned by [DOT]) pursuant to a Deed from Consolidation Coal Company to Champion dated June 30, 1983 and recorded in the Office of Recorder of Deeds of Allegheny County.... The Church shall have the full right to maintain the claim or claims and to collect, sue for, settle, compromise, or reassign such claim or claims, or to tender a release in full discharge of any liability thereunder.

(Id. (emphasis added).)

On October 12, 2011, asserting a right to compensation for the condemned subsurface coal based upon the Champion assignment, the Church petitioned the trial court to appoint a board of viewers to determine the value of the condemned subsurface coal. (Id.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

C. Kennedy v. Sharon Hill Borough
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2024
A. Saunders v. M. Munch
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2024
F. Nellom v. DHS
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2024
M. Gjini v. UCBR
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2023
Eagle Run Holdings, LLC v. ZHB of the City of Reading
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2023
G. Pignetti & J. Pignetti v. DOT
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2023
P.J. Thiel v. SERB
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2022
Jet-Set Restaurant, LLC v. PA LCB
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2022
D.L. Bussard v. PA DCNR (State Board of Property)
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2022
City of Philadelphia v. F. Galdo
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2021
Blue Pilot Energy, LLC v. PA PUC
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2020
J.J. Burke v. PBPP
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2019
P. Serrano v. PA BPP
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2016
G.R. Giuliano v. PA BPP
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2016
York Road Realty Co., L.P. v. Cheltenham Twp.
136 A.3d 1047 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2016)
C. Wyatt v. UCBR
Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2015
Hill v. Kilgallen
108 A.3d 934 (Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania, 2015)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
76 A.3d 101, 2013 WL 4398860, 2013 Pa. Commw. LEXIS 329, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/church-of-grace-glory-v-commonwealth-department-of-transportation-pacommwct-2013.