Charter Township of Canton v. Kaufman

Michigan Court of Appeals

Charter Township of Canton v. Kaufman

276 N.W.2d 505, 87 Mich. App. 719, 1979 Mich. App. LEXIS 1929

CourtMichigan Court of Appeals

DecidedJanuary 3, 1979

DocketDocket 77-4284

StatusPublished

Cited by7 cases

This text of 276 N.W.2d 505 (Charter Township of Canton v. Kaufman) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Michigan Court of Appeals primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Charter Township of Canton v. Kaufman, 276 N.W.2d 505, 87 Mich. App. 719, 1979 Mich. App. LEXIS 1929 (Mich. Ct. App. 1979).

Pincite

Opinion

Per Curiam.

Plaintiff brought this condemnation action against the defendants on June 15, 1973. Prior to trial the defendants incurred substantial legal expenses in challenging the authority of the plaintiff to acquire property through condemnation proceedings without a referendum of the people. Prior to trial the plaintiff filed a notice of discontinuance of the action. Defendants filed motions for attorney fees and appraisal preparation fees. The trial court awarded attorney fees in the amount of $7,548.25 and appraisal fees in the amount of $8,000. Plaintiff appeals, alleging that the award of attorney fees was improper.

It has long been the rule that attorney fees may not be taxed and awarded as costs in condemnation cases unless specifically authorized by statute or by court rule, Hester v Commissioners of Parks and Boulevards of the City of Detroit, 84 Mich 450; 47 NW 1097 (1891); Detroit Edison Co v Janosz, 350 Mich 606; 87 NW2d 126 (1957). In condemnation cases, except those dismissed after the jury is impaneled, attorney fees are authorized by MCL 213.37; MSA 8.27, only up to a maximum of $25. 1 No jury having been impaneled in this case, the award of attorney fees may not exceed $25.

Defendants contend that the rule regarding attorney fees in condemnation cases was abrogated *721 by the adoption of GCR 1963, 504.1(2), which confers upon the trial court the power to dismiss upon motion of the plaintiff upon such terms and conditions as it deems just and proper. While this rule may empower the court to tax costs as a condition of dismissal, it may still tax only those costs authorized by statute, GCR 1963, 526.1. Attorney fees are taxable only as authorized by statute, MCL 600.2405; MSA 27A.2405.

We are not unsympathetic to defendants’ plight. They have gone to considerable expense preparing to defend an action which was dismissed over their objection, with no guarantee that they will not be subjected to a new proceeding with its attendant expense. However, we are bound by the statutes and court rules. In the case at bar, the applicable statute authorizes attorney fees up to a maximum of $25, MCL 213.37; MSA 8.27. The trial court erred in awarding a greater amount as attorney fees.

The award of attorney fees is reversed. We remand to the trial court! for an award of attorney fees not to exceed $25. Plaintiff may tax its costs of appeal.

1

Cases dismissed after a jury has been impaneled are governed by MCL 213.38; MSA 8.28, which authorizes reasonable attorney fees.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Per Curiam.

Plaintiff brought this condemnation action against the defendants on June 15, 1973. Prior to trial the defendants incurred substantial legal expenses in challenging the authority of the plaintiff to acquire property through condemnation proceedings without a referendum of the people. Prior to trial the plaintiff filed a notice of discontinuance of the action. Defendants filed motions for attorney fees and appraisal preparation fees. The trial court awarded attorney fees in the amount of $7,548.25 and appraisal fees in the amount of $8,000. Plaintiff appeals, alleging that the award of attorney fees was improper.

It has long been the rule that attorney fees may not be taxed and awarded as costs in condemnation cases unless specifically authorized by statute or by court rule, Hester v Commissioners of Parks and Boulevards of the City of Detroit, 84 Mich 450; 47 NW 1097 (1891); Detroit Edison Co v Janosz, 350 Mich 606; 87 NW2d 126 (1957). In condemnation cases, except those dismissed after the jury is impaneled, attorney fees are authorized by MCL 213.37; MSA 8.27, only up to a maximum of $25. 1 No jury having been impaneled in this case, the award of attorney fees may not exceed $25.

Defendants contend that the rule regarding attorney fees in condemnation cases was abrogated *721 by the adoption of GCR 1963, 504.1(2), which confers upon the trial court the power to dismiss upon motion of the plaintiff upon such terms and conditions as it deems just and proper. While this rule may empower the court to tax costs as a condition of dismissal, it may still tax only those costs authorized by statute, GCR 1963, 526.1. Attorney fees are taxable only as authorized by statute, MCL 600.2405; MSA 27A.2405.

We are not unsympathetic to defendants’ plight. They have gone to considerable expense preparing to defend an action which was dismissed over their objection, with no guarantee that they will not be subjected to a new proceeding with its attendant expense. However, we are bound by the statutes and court rules. In the case at bar, the applicable statute authorizes attorney fees up to a maximum of $25, MCL 213.37; MSA 8.27. The trial court erred in awarding a greater amount as attorney fees.

The award of attorney fees is reversed. We remand to the trial court! for an award of attorney fees not to exceed $25. Plaintiff may tax its costs of appeal.

1

Cases dismissed after a jury has been impaneled are governed by MCL 213.38; MSA 8.28, which authorizes reasonable attorney fees.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

276 N.W.2d 505, 87 Mich. App. 719, 1979 Mich. App. LEXIS 1929, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/charter-township-of-canton-v-kaufman-michctapp-1979.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack