Casey v. Casey

2 Barb. 59

• Court: New York Supreme Court
• Decided: December 18, 1847
• Status: Published

Opinion

Edmonds, J.

A plaintiff may state in his bill any matter of evidence, or any collateral fact, the admission of which, by the defendant, may be material in establishing the general allegations of the bill as a pleading, or in ascertaining or determining the nature, extent, or kind of relief to which the plaintiff may be entitled; or which may legally influence the court in determining the question of costs. And where the averment in the bill may, if admitted by the defendant, or established by proof, thus affect the decision of the cause, it is relevant, and cannot be excepted to as impertinent.

The averment here excepted to may affect the decision of the court, not only as to alimony, part of the relief prayed for, and as to the costs, but also as corroborative of the principal charge of adultery. It cannot, therefore, be impertinent; and the exception is overruled.