Byrd v. Greene County School Dist.

633 So. 2d 1018, 1994 Miss. LEXIS 58, 1994 WL 37974
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedFebruary 3, 1994
Docket91-CC-0938
StatusPublished
Cited by17 cases

This text of 633 So. 2d 1018 (Byrd v. Greene County School Dist.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Byrd v. Greene County School Dist., 633 So. 2d 1018, 1994 Miss. LEXIS 58, 1994 WL 37974 (Mich. 1994).

Opinion

633 So.2d 1018 (1994)

James Rodney BYRD
v.
GREENE COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT.

No. 91-CC-0938.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

February 3, 1994.

*1020 Chester D. Nicholson, Gail D. Nicholson, Nicholson & Nicholson, Gulfport, for appellant.

Perry Sansing, Brunini Grantham Grower & Hewes, Jackson, for appellee.

Before DAN M. LEE, P.J., and McRAE and SMITH, JJ.

McRAE, Justice, for the court:

This appeal arises from a July 30, 1991, award of damages by the Greene County Chancery Court in an appeal from an employee "reduction in force" proceeding conducted pursuant to the School Employment Procedures Law of 1977, Miss. Code Ann. § 37-9-101, et seq. (1990). The Greene County School District, on cross-appeal, asserts that the chancellor applied the wrong legal standard in making his determination that the hearing officer should have recused himself. The District further contends that the chancellor erred in finding that its dire financial situation was not "good cause" pursuant to Miss. Code Ann. § 37-9-59 (1990) for the rescission of a teacher's contract. The appellant and cross-appellee, James Rodney Byrd, asserts that the chancellor improperly recalculated the damages awarded him. Finding that the chancellor erred only in ruling that the hearing officer should have recused himself, we find that there was not good cause for the rescission of Byrd's contract and affirm the award of damages to him.

I.

James Rodney Byrd was employed by the Greene County School District from 1983 through 1988. He worked first as a teacher and coach. In 1985, after completing his Master's Degree in counseling and psychology, he was hired as an elementary and junior high school guidance counselor.

In March, 1986, the Greene County School District adopted its Reduction in Force Policy (RIF) in an attempt to comply with the State's Minimum Foundation Program funding levels. The procedures developed for the RIF were intended to balance the need for fairness to the teachers with the best interests of the school children when reductions were necessary.

The District had a long-standing practice of cutting timber from its Sixteenth Section land to meet any budget shortfalls or expenses not covered by ad valorem tax revenues. Since 1984, timber valued at $1,327,532.00 had been cut at the School Board's request, an average of $331,883.00 per year. In March 1988, the District began its annual negotiations with the Forestry Commission. In late May, the Forestry Commission completed its evaluation of the District's timberlands and recommended that timber sales should slow down to an average annual rate of $50,000.00.

At its February 12, 1988, meeting, the Greene County School Board acknowledged that a reduction in staff would be necessary to effect a cut in the District's budget over the next three years. The recommendations considered by the Board included a decrease in the number of guidance counselors. At that meeting, it was recommended that Byrd and another guidance counselor be hired instead as teachers.[1] The minutes of the February 12, 1988, Executive Meeting, indicate that the decision was made to rehire Byrd as a Guidance Counselor. On February 29, 1988, the Board held a hearing and unanimously voted to re-employ Byrd and seven other teachers and counselors in their present positions for the 1988-1989 school year.

On June 12, 1988, the Superintendent informed the Board that there existed a $401,095.00 shortfall in the District Maintenance budget. Because of the immediate need for deep cuts in the budget as well as the District's RIF policy, the Board voted not to *1021 renew the 1988-1989 school year contracts for Byrd and nineteen other school employees on June 27, 1988.

Byrd and his colleagues were sent written notice of the Board's decision on June 29, 1988. The letters stated that the action was not a reflection of past performance, but "was necessitated by the lack of funds in our district" and that the reduction in staff was "intended to get the school district operating at or about the funding level provided by the State of Mississippi in the Minimum Foundation Program."

Due process hearings for Byrd and others affected by the Board's decision were held during August, 1988. Ben J. Piazza, Jr., a Jackson attorney who represented the Hinds County School Board, served as the hearing officer. He was retained to serve in this capacity by the law firm of Brunini, Grantham, Grower and Hewes, which represented the Greene County School District in the proceedings. He had served as a hearing officer at the request of the Brunini firm on four or five other occasions when the firm was representing a school board. Because of the alleged relationship between Piazza and the Brunini firm, Tom Matthews, counsel for Byrd and five other teachers, conducted a voir dire to determine whether Piazza could function as a fair and impartial hearing officer. Piazza then denied Matthews' request to recuse himself.

In his written "Findings and Recommended Decision," the Hearing Officer found that pursuant to Greene County's RIF Policy and Miss. Code Ann. § 37-9-59, the District's financial crisis constituted "other good cause" for the termination or suspension of school personnel. Accordingly, he recommended that the Board accept Superintendent James' decision to terminate Byrd's contract. Without taking any formal action on the Hearing Officer's recommendation, the Board notified Byrd on September 29, 1988, that it had accepted the Superintendent's decision not to renew his contract for the 1988-1989 school year.

Byrd appealed the Board's decision to the Chancery Court of Greene County on October 5, 1988.[2] The chancellor found that a reasonable person would have doubted the impartiality of the hearing officer and ruled that Piazza should have recused himself. He further found that the District's financial crisis did not constitute "other good cause" for dismissal. Moreover, he found that the Board's action in terminating Byrd was not supported by substantial evidence and was, therefore, arbitrary. On November 27, 1990, the chancellor entered a judgment ordering the Board to pay damages in the amount of $32,564.50, plus legal interest, based on the sum Byrd would have received under a twelve month contract with the District for the 1988-1989 school year.

The District filed a Motion to Alter or Amend Judgment on November 19, 1990, requesting clarification of the method used to calculate damages. Further, it asserted that Byrd's employment contract with the Wayne County School District for the 1988-1989 school year served to mitigate his damages. Pursuant to Miss. Code Ann. § 37-9-101, the School Employment Procedures Act, the chancellor remanded the case to the School Board for a hearing on the issues of mitigation and the expenses incurred in reducing damages.

The Board held a hearing on July 16, 1991. The transcript of those proceedings reflects that neither Byrd nor his attorney were present at the hearing.[3]

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Leland School District v. Michell C. Brown
Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2022
South Panola School District v. Cammie Rone
Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2020
Louis Edward Bourgeois v. City of Bay St.Louis Civil Service Commission
270 So. 3d 1039 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2018)
Carter v. Cleveland School District
118 So. 3d 673 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2013)
Alexander v. Reeves
90 So. 3d 1273 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2012)
Howze-Campbell v. MOUND BAYOU SCHOOL DIST.
914 So. 2d 1284 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2005)
Amite County School Dist. v. Floyd
935 So. 2d 1034 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2005)
Aguilera v. Board of Education
2005 NMCA 069 (New Mexico Court of Appeals, 2005)
McKnight v. Mound Bayou Public School Dist.
879 So. 2d 493 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2004)
Crockett v. Board of Trustees for the Mound Bayou Schools
770 So. 2d 1030 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2000)
Burks v. Amite County School Dist.
708 So. 2d 1366 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1998)
BD. OF TRUST. OF JACKSON SCHOOL v. Knox
688 So. 2d 778 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1997)
Valle v. Johnson Controls World Services, Inc.
957 F. Supp. 1404 (S.D. Mississippi, 1996)
Alvin Burks v. Amite County School District
Mississippi Supreme Court, 1994
BD. OF TR. OF JACKSON PUBLIC SCH. D. v. Knox
638 So. 2d 1278 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1994)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
633 So. 2d 1018, 1994 Miss. LEXIS 58, 1994 WL 37974, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/byrd-v-greene-county-school-dist-miss-1994.