Benton v. International Paper Co.

817 So. 2d 443, 2002 La. App. LEXIS 1221, 2002 WL 904513
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedMay 8, 2002
Docket35,977-WCA
StatusPublished
Cited by2 cases

This text of 817 So. 2d 443 (Benton v. International Paper Co.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Benton v. International Paper Co., 817 So. 2d 443, 2002 La. App. LEXIS 1221, 2002 WL 904513 (La. Ct. App. 2002).

Opinion

817 So.2d 443 (2002)

Lesia BENTON, Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
INTERNATIONAL PAPER COMPANY, Defendant-Appellant.

No. 35,977-WCA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

May 8, 2002.

Van Hoof & Associates by Kathryn Fowler Van Hoof, for Appellant.

Theodore J. Coenen, IV, Rayville, for Appellee.

Before NORRIS, STEWART and CARAWAY, JJ.

CARAWAY, J.

In this default judgment setting, the employer's representative attended the mediation conference required by the Workers' Compensation Act and signed a waiver of citation and acceptance of service. The mediation report of the Office of *444 Workers' Compensation ("OWC") was signed by the parties and the mediator and listed a "framework or plan for proceeding... in hopes of a resolution of the claim prior to trial." No additional report or notice pertaining to the mediation occurred. The employee therefore obtained a preliminary default without notice to the employer and confirmed the default before a workers' compensation judge ("WCJ"). The employer appeals, seeking to annul the default judgment. We reverse.

Facts

Claimant, Lesia Benton ("Benton"), was injured in a work-related accident on May 21, 2000, while she was an employee of International Paper Company ("IP"). The accident occurred while Benton was assisting a co-employee dismantle a steel pipe. The co-worker was working on a ladder, approximately 15 feet above Benton. The co-worker dropped a wrench; the wrench struck Benton on the upper lip. Benton's front tooth was knocked out of her mouth and her lip was cut. Benton received both medical and dental attention. Her upper lip was sutured, and her front tooth replaced. Benton recovered from her injuries, but claims that she has a disfiguring scar between her lip and nose that is circular in shape and approximately the size of a dime.

The record of the OWC shows the following pleadings and notices in chronological listing. The dates shown are the dates on the instrument unless the date of filing is stated. The OWC record fails to include a filing date stamp on each instrument, which leads to some minor disagreements in the interpretation of the record by the parties as noted below.

Benton filed a Form 1008 workers' compensation claim on May 14, 2001, asserting entitlement to 100 weeks of benefits under La. R.S. 23:1221(4)(p). The notices of mediation conference next appear in the record. The first notice sets the conference for June 5. The second notice resets the conference for June 14. Nevertheless, the conference was actually held on June 25 as shown below.[1] The notices indicate that IP was given notice as the employer and "Yvonne or Margaret," as the insurer.[2]

The OWC record next shows "Waiver of Citation and Acceptance of Service" forms which were signed by Yvonne R. Rosen and IP, by its agent, Maurice B. Marquis. The waivers are dated June 5, 2001.[3] The OWC's citation form reads, in pertinent part:

YOU HAVE BEEN SUED:
* * * *
You must either do what the claim form/petition asks, or, within fifteen (15) days after you have received these documents, you must file an answer or other legal pleadings with the Office of Workers' Compensation.
*445 If you do what the petition asks, or if you do not file an answer or legal pleadings within fifteen (15) days of receipt of this citation, a judgment of default may be entered against you without further notice....

The form also states that each party acknowledged "receipt of the disputed claim form ... and waives citation and accepts service, reserving all other rights and legal delays...."

The next record in the proceedings is the "Mediation Case Report." The report is signed by Doniele Staten, as mediator, Benton, IP, through its agent Marquis, and Rosen, for the "adjuster/insurance company." The report states that the mediation hearing was held on June 25. The OWC's mediation case report form allows the mediator to select one of several options regarding the outcome of the mediation conference, and Staten marked the form, in part, as follows:

___ Completely resolved. Parties reached acceptable resolution on all issues. Claim is dismissed. Agreement is attached. ___ Partially resolved. Parties reached acceptable resolution on some, but not all issues. Agreement is attached. Citations issued or waived. √ Procedural framework or plan for proceeding established with respect to some or all issues. A framework was established for an exchange of necessary information in hopes of a resolution of the claim prior to trial. Agreement is attached. Citations issued or waived. ___ Unresolved. No resolutions reached on substantive or procedural issues. No agreement attached. Citations issued or waived. ___ Mediation Conference Not Held. Failure to appear by ______ after due notice of conference. This case may be submitted to the judge for assessment of penalties against the party(ies) failing to appear; in addition, if claimant failed to appear, case may be submitted to the judge for dismissal, and if defendant(s) failed to appear, citations shall be issued, all in accord with L.R.S. 23:1310.3(2).
Service of Process made upon or accepted by Yvonne Rossen and Maurice Marquis for employer/insurer.
* * * *
At a mediation conference conducted by Doniele N. Staten, after a discussion of all the issues raised by claimant's case, the parties who have signed their names below agree to the following:
1. Insurer will contact their attorney to determine the viability of a PPD (scarring). If determined that claim is viable insurer will contact plastic surgeons for evaluation.
* * * *

The next record on file with the OWC is a letter dated August 17, 2001, by Benton's attorney, requesting entry of a preliminary default against IP. The August 27, 2001, Minutes of Court reflect that a preliminary default was entered ("PD entered") and noted that defendant "was served 6/5/01 no answer." A "Notice of Hearing on Rule to Show Cause" prepared by the OWC was filed September 6, 2001 and sent to Benton and her attorney, but not to IP. The notice set the confirmation hearing for September 24. Benton confirmed her default on September 24 as evidenced by the Minutes of Court. A Default Judgment was signed by the WCJ on September 25, 2001, which granted Benton benefits for her disfigurement. The "Notice of Signing of Judgment" was sent to IP on September 25 via certified mail.

*446 IP brings this appeal of the default judgment seeking its nullification.

Discussion

La. C.C.P. art. 2002(A)(2) provides that a final judgment shall be annulled if it is rendered against a defendant "whom a valid judgment by default has not been taken." It is well settled that this article applies to technical defects of procedure or form of the judgment. National Income Realty Trust v. Paddie, 98-2063 (La.7/2/99), 737 So.2d 1270. Such technical defects of procedure may be reviewed on appeal of the default judgment, and a reversal by the appellate court on the grounds of nullity may be rendered. Draper v.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Harris v. Johnson Plumbing, Inc.
880 So. 2d 112 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2004)
Elkins v. Louisiana Department of Agriculture & Forestry
839 So. 2d 992 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2003)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
817 So. 2d 443, 2002 La. App. LEXIS 1221, 2002 WL 904513, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/benton-v-international-paper-co-lactapp-2002.