Arkansas Department of Human Services Crimes Against Children Division v. Steven D. Mitchell

2021 Ark. 188

Opinion

Cite as 2021 Ark. 188

Digitally signed by Susan Williams SUPREME COURT OF ARKANSAS Reason: I attest to the accuracy No. CV-19-63 and integrity of this document Date: 2023.09.26 14:06:15 -05'00'

Opinion Delivered: October 21, 2021

ARKANSAS DEPARTMENT OF

HUMAN SERVICES CRIMES APPEAL FROM THE IZARD AGAINST CHILDREN DIVISION COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT APPELLANT [NO. 33CV-18-76]

V. HONORABLE MAUREEN HARROD, JUDGE

STEVEN D. MITCHELL

APPELLEE ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE DECISION AFFIRMED; CIRCUIT COURT ORDER REVERSED;

COURT OF APPEALS OPINION

VACATED.

SHAWN A. WOMACK, Associate Justice

Appellant Arkansas Department of Human Services (DHS) appeals two orders from the Izard County Circuit Court reversing the DHS administrative law judge’s (ALJ’s) finding in separate administrative appeals that appellee Steven Mitchell sexually abused two minors, B.T. and J.C., by sexual contact. In reversing, the circuit court determined that DHS failed to properly notify Mitchell of its true findings against him in both cases.

DHS has separately appealed both circuit court orders. This case concerns the ALJ’s true finding with respect to J.C. In a companion case addressing the ALJ’s true finding with respect to B.T., DHS argued (1) substantial evidence supported the ALJ’s finding that Mitchell sexually abused B.T. by sexual contact; (2) Mitchell was not deprived due process because he received an administrative hearing; and (3) Mitchell’s substantial rights were not

2

prejudiced. Ark. Dep’t of Human Servs. v. Mitchell, 2021 Ark. 187 (CV-19-62). We determined that substantial evidence supported the ALJ’s decision and that Mitchell received the requisite notice and a meaningful hearing. Id. DHS raises the same arguments in this case. Thus, for the reasons set forth in Mitchell, 2021 Ark. 187, we affirm the ALJ’s finding of sexual abuse with respect to J.C.

Administrative law judge decision affirmed; circuit court order reversed; court of appeals opinion vacated.

Ellen K. Howard, Office of Chief Counsel, for appellant.

Steven D. Mitchell, pro se appellee.