Anonymous

New York Supreme Court

Anonymous

3 How. Pr. 293, 1848 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 14

DecidedSeptember 1, 1848

StatusPublished

This text of 3 How. Pr. 293 (Anonymous) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering New York Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Anonymous, 3 How. Pr. 293, 1848 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 14 (N.Y. Super. Ct. 1848).

Pincite

Opinion

Hand, Justice.

I do not think the complaint need be published. (Code, §§ 106, 107, 114, 116 and 117.) The 114th section in terms requires the publication of the summons only, and that includes the notice mentioned in § 108, but not the complaint. Summons and complaint are not synonymous in the code, nor does one include the other. It is true that some provisions of that act may appear to be inconsistent with this view. Thus,- the 109th section requires the complaint to be served with the summons except in certain cases. Proof of the service of the summons and complaint to obtain judgment on failure to answer, is necessary by § 202. If a copy of the complaint be not published, it is not served on an absent Defendant, (not appearing) in any way. And [294]*294it is not clear how a Defendant is to obtain a copy, if he appear, in such cases. But on the other hand, a complaint is not to be served in every case, (§ 109, and see § 117,) and § 202, therefore, requires proof of the service of the complaint only where such service must be made; and probably if an absent Defendant should appear and the Plaintiff should refuse to give him a copy of the complaint the court would find some mode of relief. . The language of the 114th section is explicit; and it could not have been intended that the complaint, which would sometimes, notwithstanding every effort at brevity, be very voluminous, should be published. Besides, in some cases, as in actions for a divorce -for adultery or impotency, &c., such publication would offend public decency, and might be grossly unjust to third persons.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Hand, Justice.

I do not think the complaint need be published. (Code, §§ 106, 107, 114, 116 and 117.) The 114th section in terms requires the publication of the summons only, and that includes the notice mentioned in § 108, but not the complaint. Summons and complaint are not synonymous in the code, nor does one include the other. It is true that some provisions of that act may appear to be inconsistent with this view. Thus,- the 109th section requires the complaint to be served with the summons except in certain cases. Proof of the service of the summons and complaint to obtain judgment on failure to answer, is necessary by § 202. If a copy of the complaint be not published, it is not served on an absent Defendant, (not appearing) in any way. And [294]*294it is not clear how a Defendant is to obtain a copy, if he appear, in such cases. But on the other hand, a complaint is not to be served in every case, (§ 109, and see § 117,) and § 202, therefore, requires proof of the service of the complaint only where such service must be made; and probably if an absent Defendant should appear and the Plaintiff should refuse to give him a copy of the complaint the court would find some mode of relief. . The language of the 114th section is explicit; and it could not have been intended that the complaint, which would sometimes, notwithstanding every effort at brevity, be very voluminous, should be published. Besides, in some cases, as in actions for a divorce -for adultery or impotency, &c., such publication would offend public decency, and might be grossly unjust to third persons.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

3 How. Pr. 293, 1848 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 14, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/anonymous-nysupct-1848.