Adams v. State

799 So. 2d 1084, 2001 WL 1295382
District Court of Appeal of Florida·Decided October 26, 2001·No. 5D00-1685·Published·Cited by 2 cases

Opinion

799 So.2d 1084 (2001)

Richard Lee ADAMS, Appellant,
v.
STATE of Florida, Appellee.

No. 5D00-1685.

District Court of Appeal of Florida, Fifth District.

October 26, 2001.

*1085 James B. Gibson, Public Defender, and A.S. Rogers, Assistant Public Defender, Daytona Beach, for Appellant.

Robert A. Butterworth, Attorney General, Tallahassee, and Belle B. Schumann, *1086 Assistant Attorney General, Daytona Beach, for Appellee.

COBB, J.

Richard Adams appeals from his convictions for aggravated child abuse and first degree murder in the beating death of six year old Kayla McKean.[1] He asserts that the trial court erred in instructing the jury, over objection, on the element of malice in connection with the charge of aggravated child abuse, thus requiring reversal of that conviction and precluding its use to support the first degree murder conviction under a felony murder theory. Adams further asserts that the state failed to present sufficient evidence to support the first degree murder conviction under a premeditation theory.

The indictment charging first degree murder alleged two alternate theories, premeditation and felony murder. The trial evidence revealed that Kayla McKean died on November 25, 1998 as a result of blood loss secondary to blunt trauma injury. The pathologist explained that her injuries were caused by "massive blunt force, the type you see in a high speed automobile accident, just incredible force." Kayla was four feet, two inches tall and weighed 48 pounds at the time of her death. She was spanked with a wooden paddle made from a piece of two by six inch board. This paddle left distinct bruises on her buttocks and left hip. The blows were too numerous to count individually. In addition to severe bruising, the paddle caused massive internal blunt trauma such that the muscles in her legs and buttocks bled internally, which was in itself a fatal injury. Internal bleeding caused her heart to go into cardiac arrest. There was bleeding from the skin under her buttocks and lower back through the muscle, all the way to and beneath the peritoneal lining, the lining of the abdomen. In an apparent effort to shield herself from this paddling, Kayla's forearms were covered with bruises which extended from her elbows to fingers on both arms.

Kayla's right leg was swollen twice the size of her left leg and her hip appeared to be out of its socket. This injury was not caused by the paddle, but rather from an injury inflicted with "high force." Her head had been slammed with extreme force against a hard, flat surface like a wall or the floor. This caused a skull fracture on the right side, as well as a skull fracture on the opposite, left side as her skull recoiled in whiplash motion. This injury could not have been caused by the paddle. This resulted in the entire right side of her head swelling up so that it was flush with the bridge of her nose. Bruising on the back of her neck indicated that she had been gripped there by "really hard squeezing." Her liver was severed in three places by a "tremendous blow to the front of the abdomen." This injury was inflicted from the front, because her spine severed part of her liver.

Four of Kayla's ribs were broken, which punctured her lungs. Both kidneys were bruised and bleeding. This was caused by a severe compression injury that "squashed" her body from back to front, consistent with a foot stomping her back while she lay face down on the floor. There was blood in the sac surrounding the heart, indicating trauma to the heart. The pathologist could not testify as to the sequence of the injuries and testified the injuries seemed very random. The injuries could have been inflicted "as quickly as someone could move." However, Kayla survived long enough to lose enough blood *1087 in her abdomen so as to go into shock and suffer cardiac arrest.

After Adams' brutal attack, he wrapped Kayla's body in a sheet and informed her stepmother that the child had stopped breathing. Adams then put Kayla's wrapped body in a bag and after threatening the stepmother had her drive to a remote area where he buried the body. The police were then informed by Adams that Kayla was missing and an intense search was undertaken. Five days later Kayla's stepmother informed the police of the child's death and led them to the burial site. Because Kayla had been buried for five days prior to the discovery of her body, it was not possible to determine with medical certainty which of the injuries was inflicted first. The injuries to the liver and/or internal bleeding would have been fatal by themselves and possibly the brain injury would also have been fatal.

Kayla's stepmother testified that when she returned from work on the day of Kayla's death, Adams told her the child defecated in her pants and he made her take a bath after which time she stopped breathing. When the stepmother asked Adams why he did not call 911, Adams replied, "Do you know what they do to people like me in jail?" He said that "Kayla wasn't worth it and he never wanted her anyway." The telephones in the house had been unplugged.

Adams asserts that the trial court committed reversible error by improperly defining the element of malice to the jury in respect to the charge of aggravated child abuse.

Section 827.03, Florida Statutes (1998) provides in relevant part:

(2) "Aggravated child abuse" occurs when a person:
(a) Commits aggravated battery on a child;
(b) Willfully tortures, maliciously punishes, or willfully and unlawfully cages a child; or
(c) Knowingly or willfully abuses a child and in so doing causes great bodily harm, permanent disability, or permanent disfigurement to the child.
A person who commits aggravated child abuse commits a felony of the second degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082, s. 775.083, or s. 775.084.

While the indictment against Adams specifically references subsection (2)(b), the language of the indictment in charging willful abuse of the child victim causing great bodily harm, permanent disability or permanent disfigurement also implicates the charge of aggravated child abuse under subsection (2)(c).[2] The failure to expressly reference subsection (2)(c) is not fatal. See Youngker v. State, 215 So.2d 318 (Fla. 4th DCA 1968)(erroneous statutory citation does not render conviction invalid where charging document clearly charged offense and there was no showing that the error prejudiced the defendant). Thus the indictment charged aggravated child abuse by either "maliciously punishes" or by willful abuse causing great bodily harm, etc. Defense counsel conceded below *1088 that Count 2 alleged both forms of aggravated child abuse.

The trial court gave the following instructions on aggravated child abuse:

Before you can find the defendant guilty of aggravated child abuse as charged in count one, the state must prove the following two elements beyond a reasonable doubt: Number one, Richard L. Adams maliciously and intentionally punished Kayla Victoria McKean; or Richard L. Adams willfully and intentionally abused Kayla Victoria McKean, and thereby intentionally caused her great bodily harm, permanent disability, or permanent disfigurement. Number two, Kayla Victoria McKean was under the age of 18 years.
"Maliciously" means wrongfully, intentionally, without legal justification or excuse.
"Willfully" means knowingly, intentionally, and purposely.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Adams v. State, 799 So. 2d 1084, 2001 WL 1295382 (Fla. Ct. App. 2001).

799 So. 2d 1084 (Adams v. State) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Calamia v. State
125 So. 3d 1007 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2013)
Skanes v. State
821 So. 2d 1102 (District Court of Appeal of Florida, 2002)