Young v. Hyde

164 S.W. 228, 255 Mo. 496, 1914 Mo. LEXIS 37
CourtSupreme Court of Missouri
DecidedMarch 3, 1914
StatusPublished
Cited by7 cases

This text of 164 S.W. 228 (Young v. Hyde) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Missouri primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Young v. Hyde, 164 S.W. 228, 255 Mo. 496, 1914 Mo. LEXIS 37 (Mo. 1914).

Opinion

WOODSON, P. J.

This was a suit instituted in the circuit court of Buchanan county, under old section 650, Revised Statutes 1899, to quiet and determine the title to certain real estate, particularly described in the pleadings.

No question is raised as to the sufficiency of the pleadings, and consequently they are put aside with a summary statement of the issues thereby presented.

A trial was had which resulted in the rendition of a judgment decreeing a life estate in George W. Young, with remainder, share and share alike, in Wallace B. Young and Maggie Young Adcock, and adjudging that none of the other defendants had any right, title or interest in and to said premises, and the contest upon this appeal is entirely between George W. Young, plaintiff, and-Maggie Young Adcock, defendant, and Cynthia Young and Wallace B. Young, also defendants, the last named defendants also having appealed.

The facts of this case are few and undisputed; and the statement of the case, as made by counsel for the respective parties, is practically the same. We will [500]*500largely draw from that of appellant, because it is somewhat the shorter of the two.

The adverse claimants to George W. Young predicate their claim of interest in and to said land upon a certain trust deed made and executed by him and others, dated September 18, 1878, which was in words and figures as follows:

“This deed of trust, made and entered into this 18th day of September, 1878, between George W. Young of Buchanan county, Missouri, and Mary T. Ridenbaugh of the city of St. Louis, Missouri, parties of the first part, and Anlyffe C. Hyde of Buchanan county, Missouri, party of the second part, Witnesseth:
‘ ‘ That for and in consideration of the sum of five dollars in hand paid by the said party of the second part to the parties of the first part and the trust hereinafter created and impowered, the said parties of the first part have given, granted, bargained and sold and by these presents do give, grant, bargain, sell and convey to the party of the second part and his successors in and to the trusts hereinafter created and impowered the following described real estate lying and being in the county of Buchanan and State of Missouri, to-wit:
“Three hundred and fifty-nine acres of land lying south of St. Joseph and being the farm upon which George W. Young now lives and has been living for several years last past, and being the same farm that was owned by George Young, at the time of his death and known and recognized as the ‘home farm’ of said George Young, deceased, to have and to hold forever in trust for the following uses and purposes, viz.:
“The annual rents and profits of said real estate are to be applied to the support and maintenance of George W. Young and his wife'and children, and should the said George W. Young die before each and all of the children whose support is herein provided for, have if males, arrived at the age of twenty-one years, [501]*501and if females at the age of eighteen years, then all. the rents and profits arising from the real estate above mentioned are to be applied to the support, use and-maintenance of the widow of the said George W. Young and the child or children of said George W. Young and the descendants of such children, if any, until the youngest child of the said George W. Young so provided for, shall arrive at the age above mentioned, at which last mentioned time, all of the real estate mentioned in this deed shall vest in the child or the children of said George W. Young, share and share alike,- but should the said George W. Young die without children or the descendants of such children, then the annual rents and profits of said real estate mentioned in this deed shall be applied to the use of his widow during her natural life, and upon her death all of said real estate and the title thereto is to vest in Mary T. Ridenbaugh, if living, and if she be dead in her child or children and the descendants of such child or children, but should the real estate herein mentioned as herein provided vest in the children and grandchildren of said Mary T. Ridenbaugh the grandchildren of said Mary T. Ridenbaugh are only to receive an interest equal to that which would vest in the parent of such grandchild or children were such parent the child of said Mary T. Ridenbaugh, and living, it is further expressly understood and provided that in the event the widow of George W. Young accepts the provisions made for her in this deed, that such provisions are to be in lieu of dower, so far as the real estate in this deed mentioned is concerned and that she is to- set up no claim to dower therein as the widow of George W. Young.”

This deed was duly signed, acknowledged and recorded in the Recorder’s office of Buchanan county.

The defendant, Maggie Adcock, set up- certain ether deeds of trust executed by George W. Young and his wife, in favor of Wallace B. Young, and asked for [502]*502the cancellation of the same. Since, however, they are not material to the merits of this case, they will be eliminated herefrom.

The defendants George Yonng Ridenbangh, Shelby Baker, Cora Baker Choteau, Thomas J. Brown, Gideon Brown, John C. Brown, Felix Brown, Cynthia Yonng, Sarah J. Bailey and Elizabeth Lane, all failed to answer, and in dne time a judgment by default was rendered against them and later the default was made final.

The defendants Calvin A. Hyde, Charles Hyde, James B. Hyde, John H. Hyde, William Hyde, Cassie Edds, Augustus Connor, Plarry Martin, Arch Martin, Julia Martin, Blanch Martin, and Ollie Martin, all filed answers expressly disclaiming any interest in said lands and final judgment was accordingly entered against them.

Those filing disclaimers constitute the only heirs of Anlyffe C. Hyde, the grantee in the trust deed before copied.

The plaintiff, George W. Young, replied denying the execution and delivery of the trust deed before set out, and stated that all parties thereto considered and treated said deed as null and void, and that the plaintiff claimed title thereto by adverse possession, alleging that he had been in the open, adverse, continuous and notorious possession of said lands for more than ten years, etc.

In addition to the judgment previously mentioned, the trial court decreed that Cynthia Young, the wife of plaintiff, still alive, had no interest in said lands.

It is contended by George W. Young that under the undisputed testimony he owns said real estate in fee under the showing made of adverse possession. It is also contended by him that by a correct construction of the deed of trust in question at this time, he is the owner of said real estate in fee.

[503]*503It is contended by Geo. W. Young, Wallace B. Young, tbe son of George W. Young and Cynthia Young, and by Cynthia Young, also appellants, that Cynthia Young has a life estate in all of said real estate, subject to the life estate of George W. Young; and it is further contended by Cynthia Young that in any event, she is entitled to be endowed in said real estate upon the death of George W. Young, her husband, all of which is denied to her by the decree in question.

The real estate in question descended to plaintiff herein from his father, George Young, who died leaving two children, Mary Ridenbaugh and George W. Young, plaintiff. George W.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Chevalier v. Director of Revenue, State
928 S.W.2d 388 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1996)
Payne v. Barnes
638 S.W.2d 299 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 1982)
Fisher v. Cox
312 S.W.2d 775 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1958)
Brown v. Bibb
201 S.W.2d 370 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1947)
Stephens v. Moore
249 S.W. 601 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1923)
Huntington Real Estate Co. v. Megaree
217 S.W. 301 (Supreme Court of Missouri, 1919)
Lee v. Albro
178 P. 784 (Oregon Supreme Court, 1919)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
164 S.W. 228, 255 Mo. 496, 1914 Mo. LEXIS 37, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/young-v-hyde-mo-1914.