Williams, Chuck

• Court: Court of Appeals of Texas
• Decided: January 15, 2015
• Docket: WR-26,781-02
• Status: Published

Opinion

\“\m\.§\r\_r~\f‘\%r\ \“\$_\_\_?_f\.©m_§\&\c\ gmi fz~_ /L®'H'/QBURTS'ECC§%S£‘ANPPEALS £'_r>m>.& § (`_R‘\mtr\m\_ F\@ U\_“. JAN 75 2015 S§<>. QM \;M>%. C_A mm §W@mn Ab@* wm Ceerk Q\u_§::'n `\T'Lm§`\%'\\ \~QBDX

IRN_M~\P\RQ\\ AO\.FJ

C?>P\°L‘YET ma Hon\:>f\f%\al'i_:§ués;kz §§ SA`\Q\_\ O_©u&°\;§

PL°?_GSQ_ R\_LDLLJ (`Y\$_ `\“C> RQ%\"\DLL).\_?_¢§:F_. \;jm\_\ `\‘_\r\\=\~\; 1 \r~\g\-)¢L P\‘r`-_(‘_?_`\u€_r\ '~¥\m<;_ 'Y\Q~\»-ie_z_‘-\P\om "rh

guzlu_%"\'_ bn QB\L\».- `\r\‘-\c>@\m-§c\c ~m?_ 5\»‘\(\¢\‘\ `3\"(\%`_(\`£c\ m -{-\p?\_'\ac_\~¥`.rm \§®®` b_\s>\`\~\ inv Hc“\\:)<,'_\§$ (l@%§;us ~\ u,>\\\>r\\§u"r e\ m<\`\~\-¥zr\ 1393 Q_A 130 §\~Y\S_Q§C\c§`m 5 §§ A\-\/\‘?_ `\'1>\`\<>\\_ Lm_\P$x fm\~`\»ne.dc 9 \\"LQP\\¢\, .

\~\r\r\a@\@.\z¥z_ :\JW§ i_ §§ 3©.`\¢§ (\_0\_1@3¥?"\ \O\_%_f-\§i_ D\_\_mg m?_`\fm

L\§Y\ mm Ar\c\. `\’n?_ (\_r>u§>c\ \\»C> LDnS`\c\sP\ Q .SQS,C.S Al P\?,\_)\"»_<_\$ (\_DP\QU§ m\¢§ ‘\*hz\`\c§LLc>L_\)‘.r\?_\ c~\@QM m<)n\\~@\#\an PP\?_'<.?_,\’\¥%_Q\ 63 ‘L\A'\<§$_nc_i_ Wr® 5\_\$3§30@\\' mL. Q\_\_%c'\ r_\‘\"\@ng DQ "'\f\z;_. ??_L“\"\Qi_ AS§'\SWQF\C_L B\\~ CDQ(\SE\_ ¢~ `\r\u<>\_\_\r\*\'\’~\@\>§ §§\_"LQ ¥\F\c§ 00 &\_>}c§$_r\a& ~\“0 iuppm°$; +h& (\_}r\r~\€‘\<;t

} - §P»L`gumzr\`r:j__;

` ®\_n=\§r\g § lS`\CXm C_C>r\@&:>\s_n<‘_i_ 14_\\\¥¥\ A\\~Ymi-`\rm;\…<\.m@\-Ph&m §s~_>Am@m>\ Dn®mmb;v\ \\»<§©`\A~ l A.%`Y\$_<§ m%§?_ »ma\_m\ qu*r wm hug amasz mch 'a@mc~_wm §§ m ama mr cq<-\

` `\(\ Dm*v\r\\s u~\§$_ `\\?`\* gm \\@ *Bi@\.~:_@u@\\r»\% mw wm\\ \._L\@UL<§` b?_ h`.§- c`;\a@zms?_ \`r\ \\+\`.'_<. M~\Sz. m@\.§z;umou& -` »(R%.pgc_\~\ra@\ *}~Y\<‘L Sf-\m(`r\\ \\~h“.§ UASQL`\Q \\\ ;o\¥o`\”s>m\_

l \\-’mi'n \\ro\.c§ …P\.§?J;\m¢>uf\ .\\J\r~\&`¥ :\_ @§or§"\‘ (\'?_$_c§ \\“OA“(A\\\ LJ\\W\

h`sm' f~\hm.;¥ mg 910 o§`.c\g 0,€1\§?_ 906 2)€15"\'%<2_,1\¥¢\2® C©nv&f°\&m.&_ k F\C\O(Y\. _L

Y\DMM_’!T\'\; \s_ \_?§H`?_<\ @@\nm mck \”Y\m-Vham§&umam\m\m¥w\

gug\_m\\* \5.3@\`5-. l 9633<;_0`\’ r-\s `\ Q\§_‘F_ r-\\\-‘.or\

bz_`\m (‘_:;)'¢‘-_I>\c_$_c§ *m\~z;> §J\_$_Ac§‘mg(;§\\‘.b\w(\nn¢\ m-(~\\€’m FM\ `\r\o'.')\_un`\“r~\m_()\

p\_¢¢mc§. :\__n @AAQCAF\A$M Li ev P\.§<;t§mc>»_,c\ \_$_;\-\*§_1\ 963<2_3_ r~w\&_\\§\\'z. \_`.s`\s_c§ osbo_wm$_.r\`¥$ …P\.§L\;\mQLJR\`CDE.BCL`\*ACX'\¢§`\“C> S\ f\-. f-\.f\r\ ® {\0`\~ E)€~\s §§Hnlr\o.- {‘\\_So (\D`¥`.c_s_»`m §§c-\SACAR

lll w mf-\.S°%xmmw\'. F\C§m‘.\»+s_¢\ ‘W\Q';lv \m'z_ mm n$_L)iP\ P\Pgmir\*r$_,§ ms mg

PY¥-\’c>@\n$_x;\~ DQ~ RQL.Q®RQ§“ ®n®&`£$_m\m,v\ \3\'¢\€)\'&»» AL_\P`\`.NA'€~\F\ f~\ umi<`\'f

ma 52 mou@ 3\4(04<;;\&5¥$_€\ ‘\~h@uvs\\~¥\ h\.s C-_o$'_<°\w `\m§€¢:. \¥MAXS\B(\\\\$_ :uc§\`c_:r¢>.\_ (\_D(\Q$__S$

iam . A¢\mar\`\;\”\mic§\' P\wm>@\`mg~ 99 P\Q\_S_ `LB'\"@\_(~\\~\QA&¢, r~\r\c§ %L'C_sc>¢\-\CILAHQ¢\ ac (I\QQ$_\§_Q`H__ @\`\§\Xs \B@Q\ R`°»r\®(°mi ms.(€\l\;\na E,~ no\$§i.r\ &R l u_)`.\L b$_ ;`>S_F\X€r\c$_ Ar’o §§ _?_RK 0€\'\_`\©$_' §\\ :\_ go WO`\“P\`\!A\_ on \\+\:s aaa \QZQ_r-\u$$_ '~\»h`\s w`\L\ \m_ m\A“\Jr\‘\P\A wnu\<§¥lm\. @s\c\:"m @S_Ae\ :\'_' BLz~Ar\ \\A(\$_."%\’\_`\$\j$_c§ namié <§Dcum$,r\\' \_;3¥\`\&\ z_-\f-\§ $Y\$_c\' ,+_~;@ \r\(~\r\o§i(»> `_\\“D mS.&n`o}l\SS_(\ bd m\?.§?_imou&,h_¥\wom`a§¥\$_f\ SG`D"\\L Rnc§ LQQ\\K$_¢B 'YAU,\r-m;\. ms. &,m>,)§sid 0$;,02&@00\§ \\~°\m$_`\‘o %>spla‘\m %‘0 mt mhf§)\“ l was 5`\0\'\‘\!\/04. @u\' §'m»m-E_£\`¢A`\€_\_. Q\u_S\'w<¢<§ m"`L"\f\X'O ;L\c\;~:l\‘\ @\Qom lavch A“C»\_C\ mi`\’{) if.f\"\~‘é_(“§l f-\ P`L'i(-\“QP~CLI»U.“*- Rn`c§' S€~\;,\ l:l% § \\-0 9 L\_`\]-’f\$_ Cj`u$_;§\r`©r\ KH/w$_ §uc§"(<:x$_ QS\§ mix P\(\c§ c§`c\ t\c>“r ‘E_XSL\_Q\¢'\ mg B'\`\*ua"\‘}c.r\ SnR€X&U»./\Q\\`ng m\_: P¢\P\c,'\_‘§_ 9003 q-Q:}__ (‘_`\R" am ms+@maz_s_ 139 ~\»\»\\.\. ¢Q§,s_‘ i>¥ ~3\@@¢\ ‘:Q\s_ r~mc\ \_ @_®n(v\z.<>\_`m&uc>\ §§rr-\+"Le\ hi C_©\(\~OR* C-OO@\"?~"\ f\c>P\ éz_c\. $\-_ha`¥ \wi_ h<\mia?_mb£f\\\fl{)\é§.\ g u`\c\?_~’§ c_z>r\@?,?\?_(\&‘i_ \;_\.(A> QD(\¢§\_\C§'?A

q:>c\@z¢;c»_m\oz_€\ `\\\ BDI& \_LM~>(\ @uhl`{c_® §zm¢\<& Q\“\';>P\n$'_\;& (US-Q » §"_\_"\_§\nc\ Z_O§V\‘§m gmc§ …9,. …@`\~¥`h$_m §$_Amg\_m\.

®.

y '\-'\QL»_>‘L\_)LP\ P\$_;;\AP\¢§\`F\§ …(\.F`{\A\+h?_w \_<é\~¥z?\ z§m*\'$_c§ QLA;_;B\LA§V\‘§\ D|§ §§P\°c§ °J\W 913 ip`\c\F$v m ' <=\\_\_$_- c>;\*\on n =?\n§c-\a mo\\' m\;'\(~\+¥@¢=\r\' § P\C;QQP\$ `\'c\ his ccom `Lx_)&?\c§§ . "\dhs_ c§caum?_r\`\~m`\'{©(\§ 1 3`;<: r\$'_o§ b.)£\§ C\$;_\)&;R <‘¢> 324 ruiko Qm<§ m?\.(?\\<§\~¥hiu;) c)\`c\ C\Q`\ \\‘“zlp § 09\ ` @s@s_& hhs 953\5 mmz`m V'\\:og (»\r\ Qppzcyl §§ ~\Y\"\_s C,%§z Cm\¢_)t<§`@'c\. m%. mr$\~\Y\Zu`) <§‘.C\ S'z`_r\c§ db§>\;`\§ §§ G\\L\W\$'_ \_"\S\z> c§c;>gumzn`¥$ _'*\*nour’\g-Pn \W\z_ ("_\_\FL¢\X ~'A‘\‘<@P\c\z;` Qgsk;s*rf~\hgi »©Qc;x¢mm 'z§§>na §\AX~>_ Q\m\ DQ `\Ji>m up(m m\;\_ R§Q)_uu\\’". ‘@\}s.s@ '»g>[,._;\;iuc_ &¢Sw¢\z_<< <§A@N\<\:.\_(~\?r\ OR\\~Q\K L,_z`\V\J?\-£Y\i f~\\®ou`& %$_ \_`\5\'€_0> ¢§oc_umir\¥s \c\ m&. …F\`Hh$_uu `\_%"_%\“UK 1395 0!\¥‘1('1 (A»§S`.; R(\QL j\F\ \‘\<;.lp§r\:l 'm& §;(\LS_ mix 'AQQ$_QL `~\(\ \\_?\§_5 m(_\~\_\/$_B“ \~)\C>n-a(°\%\cili:§uc§(c_¢`$_ \ …th) '\_z§\-¥B (Y\‘z_ SP-Mzr\) ». ' ‘§>NJ§ _'§L~u\;\_`\@_ c\_~z:<¢c\c\z<\ F\"r\»i>%m__ (`{\P\.Yac-\m\l\®c>uz\km ~. m§m¢>`r\;:_`z_<§ am.m¢¥ m>s`\ \`_r\mz_n`\§ (c~\s §§ a e_@mrr\@r\ Qn.:§ Q\m.\\\dim_ pwx&%m_ `\~n'\\&w$a. @L).b\.\<'_®‘§§f\&‘i?\l§ (C§§\Lix ma Cl\_\i$\¢`\ur\ ~\’0 \Eic>u \‘\Dc\oaub\_%,\:\\_ic§ ¥_`~ \*\ s_\_kz_r\ `\3 \\\N»:‘< AAL\\R\$_§L A\-&DRA?_\;\ L_>\\'\\~\c\`\§\s_ DU\GL:[\DQ_QZQAU m lo_%_ ALP\-*<\DP\`\;°L 460 §P~<~=.oj~ic§_$m_§n Rc>u~\r\`n$_ F\c`§v ~\~c c‘;§fw>\r\§i_ muca% st\ » nmi(\$rs 1-@\\¢¢\ (’\r\` ou\~ ©`\\\r\ o. (Y\Q`¥`\an \\Jo §§Q%®P\z® 1,§\w\ <\_ow\\~ Pe\z§zr\§n :§\Ao\g\s_f>. l Y\r~\L>L F\ \_105 (~\(\o§ 00 D(\$'_ %,B\§_ O?\ "H\z_ ©).A\Q`L\`c_® 2.@;_(\&2@\ @@\‘@_. \`\ou)w'i_f’\ -Q\\Mmzx …%®m§\c\sq P$z_p®i.~ §‘Lc\`\'l@r\ \\& ®”\(>m:\?_c§ Qou@\\` AS§`\;(\`(\\’Y\$.(\~\ u;>`\`\$h oak F\QX/\Oo'@\°cc§§`\(\c(',\ .(`<_\?. @Q \’\?_\. wl\$*(\ §P\'iw€r\§ QF~\`>Q\ mg c_¢\§.& . , ’ 3.

\

'H g (\Dm\;m._f§m>§z \'\ mm \ _ z ®\_arasi \c\%_ H-c§u§s‘z_"\>r`\¢$\? cnc,s_`j_ -,%`_\.“ &091§3 mcxc\%_`®§ (`{\Q\,'.

\:RN\Y\-®mu 1413 3 pac ;\_§~\’EIA <§_§?\ @<>R P\QL`Q.°<@<\`.Bn Cm%m~

ing mL?\

{~\\_§Q A\Lcw mz\\~c> b(>»¥r\ §§ 4a ` mm F\*\~¥°¢_r$<§m\ n\,:@z\\\\ihz. C;@_\<>\_\ wm ':x_r\ A:L§@ P\<§:> \\»O<»»W_C_P»\mm\®;gwm# (Lm@\+ fm `m®m\_\c:\$ (:_our\§~ . \`9.)<(-)$ ~ ?_ assic§`m §u¢§¢;m;¢\»\m_\_©\.§n\p%§» mz=\ °Hm_ (\_.@L..<>\%.s ~Rpp¢‘.m%z_a\ st>£\`k&. §m‘.'\in wm \AP\$_@A<=<~;Q;QA\Q@§ L'§'Q@<\:§~ Qc\c§

f l‘_on¢\§u:~.`\ons QQ \_Au) QD<.>\ \-Y\?_ C_c>uR`\ 9\ mc\&`m m \,\§0;9\ 639 \~\A\Q°;Qs L<>P\ LL§- gm %-\L~ §®\L\ -. 1 P\ic_`\&uzr§ m%. Q\:)‘z\ ~ ac:s¥ca.'\\$b\i CLS.P\Y\ Oi§v`»c§,

QP\c>mP\\~\n$_ C_A\`mlr\'.¢>\\_ A§;_lpia>\\_ aoup\`\ unc§w"§@\.(`_\\».(\uLQ\\*B\Q%-Lo?>“);&((`\\ \_L)(\` §\_o 1 `\%\`DB .“r¥\€_ CDQG\`§\\Q§ c~§z_<\`\$_§' LJ\\\-¥\OJP mv\‘.v\-\J$_r\ -®‘P~»>i_& N\A LBQ§Y. \-\o@s_@ic< 1 \mm>z C_\c;`,`v \R$_Q§=L\)z_ ms [~\QP£\\_ m@.J\-¥z& .: §U‘_\m€m$_ u_\,%c$‘vi_\\-\'\i_ 35.~<>:¥1 \_c.x§> \_`1\3@'@@% \ :_nmq\r flng gamma w 95 (%zciu;s~_cl\ b F{\P\.£\\QL& (\¢~_Q&\Q bu\@% \'\(\us_ nc¥ F~.$_£_Q_`\ui_ f~\(`\:! Q\Z_SQQ(\¢§. lw@u\¢\ \__`.\Ks_‘~\~(> \'Amm)\) §\AOL,\P\

Lc>miw\ c@%:§ ma‘v%z& \ \\ P\‘z_m>r\:>\ézk Bp?_¢m\_ ?\21_\‘\2<.0 @Q m QQQUL @cm§ A\_LL>U¢ cwaon gvpn§z_ 'm\:&@aumsn&s

r~mc§ mL }nr\DC£F\L$_. Lim§$_. . . v (A` b 53 .'\F¢LN_\_H L\A$r\ K‘R‘E§psci Cmch LQ‘.LV.QM% MDA&\ \`-\\.\`¥c_‘n`\ns L\n`\% ` F\ld`l~ 6

`§\L

inv-\MM-`~ 3 9#\;¢1'1€“1@ ` )5@0 a mm C_\;@m @\A. \?Q\D(Y\ mQ\.mR\'\`Y\§JO ga mCUF\ ®QL\_ABH_'§}QS W`BSL‘ \

Sr~`f¥zc§ ©\u:u's`\ 1530 3

_ E_><-\\ s 1311 (~\ , :Lm)ol_ \..1 ri`l’f»\ €~‘~/1:1 ij lies N\§ W\\sa‘zpaesm`le+`.an C/\~\r\*o?\(\'z_»/_i. `

REGIoNAL PUBLIC DEFENDER FoR CAPITAL CASES P. o. Box 2097 1 Lubbock, Texas 79408 Main Phone: (806) 775-5650 Fax: (806) 775-7954

August 15, 2013

Mr. Chuck Williams #620981 Joe F. Gurney Unit E1-49B 1385 FM 3328

Palestine, Texas 75803

Re: Your Request for Information as Referred to Me by CAAP; Record #607731 Dear Mr. Williams:

I am writing in response to your letter that I received from the Client-Attorney Assistance Program of the State Bar of Texas. Please note that I am no longer employed with the Dallas County Public Defender’s Office and your letter was forwarded to my new employer at the Lubbock office, which was then forwarded on to me at my horne office. I received your letter today and please note that this initial response is drafted and mailed this same day.

First, I was never appointed as your attorney-of-record» in this matter. Initially, you were represented by Mr. F rank Douglas, and when he changed court assignments (as is a common and rout1ne practice in the Public Defender’S Office), you were then represented by Mrs. Elisha _Enoksen. Both are still employed by the Dallas Public Defender’s Offlce and can be contacted by mail at the following address: 133 N Riverfront Blvd, LBZ, Dallas, Texas 75207-4399.

Second, as l do not readily available access to your case file, I can neither confirm nor deny that 1 had a videoconference with you on the date you noted (i.e., December 11, 2012). I can say,with absolute certainty, however, that vldeoconferences are neither audio nor video recorded so ft is

_. not possible for me to provide you with a copy of any such communication I have sent a copy of this letter to Mrs. Enoksen, and I will ask her to review her file for information and notes about a

€videoconference. b

(Third, while I was never your attorney of record§l do however have public access to the documents you requested Therefore, I have attached the following documents:

1.J udicial Information 7.Motion to Strike Enhancement

2.lndictment Paragraphs

3.Aff1davit for Arrest 8.Admonishment RegardingParole ` 4.Judgment Violations

5.Plea Agreement 9.Certiflcation of Appellate Rights

6.Judicial Confession

lhs_ Qb@tfz_ \_`.s~¥z[§ cioct_lm$'_mirs r>\a\s_“r\/\s_¢§oal_im?_n\\rs l`<\t%.(`(\¢r\-\hzoo§ ,moL\P\ usda C@?_F\US iec~li¢.-s irc ij ms_+o 5`1;10\1#\$_ about mesa l_i:\z Sov_ums mt i_~\o `< (`\"\5. @ULBY\G\ indem \>\.»\(~ d';<§ ma up\r.\z(\ \lo ms what I tom signing

Page 2 of 2

Last, I see in the public record that, as indicted, you could have faced a minimum 25 year sentence in the penitentiary, and that the Assistant District Attorney’s initial offer (via your then attorney F rank Douglas) was 30 years imprisonment I See from thejudgment and associated record that your attorney Elisha Enoksen was able to have the State strike the enhancement paragraphs and negotiated the minimum sentence of two (2) years, and that your fine was probated by the Court.

I will write to you if and when I receive any additional information - if any - from your original file, which is with the Dallas County Public Defender’s Offlce. Please be advised that retrieving a file from storage may take some time, so please be patient.

Thank you for your time and consideration

S lncerely’ Digita||y signed by Matthew Seymour * i ;,. Matthew DN:cn=Matthew Seymour,o=Regiona| M &M Public Defenders for Capital Cases, ou, /’ g 11 ‘_ emai|;mseymour@rpdo.org,c=US §M" Seym 0 u r Date:2013.08.1514:14:28 -OS'OO`

Matthew Seymour

cc Jessica A. Bergeman [via email] Elisha Enoksen [via email]

f\\_s@ (%i anc§`.ng\\\#\§s \_$,MQJA *(\o¥.®_ \his_ issues ¢i\\@m\\).»-_s_ l§‘IC-§sci i\_orii~\zenem$§`\s 15 how l bar;nrm_ e“ married usi\lh mix i\(\niii\m) §"~ inch 00®12_.\\\3@\§», is `rs(i:,` n \_i`\¢\zo Q.QF\QUM\QELS engel ua\`i`i\ Wis.§_\_`\slie am ir\.

m (PwUl§or\ C<>P\ (R$_\u&§‘\ir)/cx@o@\ C\ CLQ§JR as §L,\Q§r\ QIZ`\B mi`l,\_ 131/ioaa bohrai 1131 \H~\L\S Hbcd+. v `

l \r\a@l \§`\c§m C/‘r\li\ nll_"\\>\\~z_ nnmz¢\ i>n\slt§rh‘§s;naa>\ F\\llmanztg hzaz`)n'. …n.`Faenl/\Qau§\as -\ mas,?_l`.s'hn Enohi>m ~. ach 11 `)R.…ni¥m@ S§\;\mau<é\. §_ \GZM

C_Or\CLR nci$.