William E. Johnson v. State of Texas, Texas Department of Criminal Justice

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided March 20, 2018·No. 01-18-00068-CV·Published

Opinion

£TU-L L. rfCTLoK? /Jo. 61- i£~ &&£)£#- zis

TAJ TU £ £ a an r /? A s? S f y?s? /LJ"

AVAST JDjr^T/PJ-^ 7~ A/E ->Y"^A

//ausrw. 7-yT^r

TEXAS

mar 20

°**S?i

AtfJLJrSA? y£ - ^ &MA/S*^^^y 9***.* ^u

s&A*'& /y' ////?,/>/* y? //yUr. /

J^L.

T cTSHAyZ <?/? rA-yyS. Ajs-aaj />y?rr s-s?r»7. .-jMt-r. r^ si J . .

A?* 7^*,<J/*<*Ts_A/fAiAo/f*^ * ! ^

SJst-rj/J 7-z */?'.<• At 7~4 ry/A

s^AAA/l A~y£* Z?A> S?J 2-SS SS, /?yi> Ac:-T

TO r/t-JF J/JA/0Psf-JZ<Ly£ AX/P^T s-yrty^T- ^ y^ sP J* A> s*Ts4 2-C 1

>%^/;///^r,./L,/

A /

sz/sy/s. y> ~y*> /?.m & r t ALL j4 /r A^Afy^y, //V/y /fy*A./A*-*-,«i-g a# yy* s4>^>M*/y!s<>r ^/v/ r? A SsiZ. J^^g-j^ J^~S ^a.^74$**L* y1 •"- " - — *~ •" y 'r <^ +t sir J^ y'_r A-e -** s*« s~i/ / +1 < iry t-i ZL_ 7= A7, r-f'/&> £- r/Ar < .y^,*-*"* *• a <?s • ^^-— V yJ-0 A*.-^,^/^^_ As /s4?l* ^ ^ sA>^> ^ A zC ^ - ^ f^ <i AL 4"?. yyaA^ A?*+r«/ J&. y"a /yr. AAf*~r -^ shA *~-r ->-^- *•. -A^e rj?t y/< *-jCS< S y/^^s.^y^,^.

r

7^W ^bZ. •=» y *-*.{ Z^_ y-ftn yAtn'y^^Y^y^r /.s9 a.jt)

s?«^r—^;*>y&A A y,/«.—?^^^ /^s? r/?y,^y?*>*,.7^ ^ / //f ^ ^ ^ /„ ,z I'JJ /y.^ **r/ s^y< /. z s zj ~-J: y?^/» / _e£

T

j- <? ^/ ^y ^ y r/yog ~/. /: j, j£yL &±£ y +n -*<>^ y ^ y ~7*

•v

&> yyrf & Ay<-^, o< <?-cz *<? y s^gr <?-A^~L •v . r / 4t & ^sTr^^s^rr//^ ^r^y.

>>- /

=2L

7T~ ^y^y^ ', y^ ^ y ~A A 7A* ^A^J^A?*/ T AAA? yAAy Aa Ssi s~ r/ r~s~-e <rS ' yy^ ''** y°r-r s? <z>z«^ y <**->-*' s^A,

Mi //W»-> y? yf- j-^<a a&/- zT^<.y>,-y ^y y^^,y^-*-,, y A *Ti

-s~yAyA*~ ~A A/.f^~^A*A~y?-~i ^c/. / e /&f ^/ / ^.j ^-arrtF. < ^"^-> *> Ay" As^ A 'a r> ,^>- r . Z ^" /<£" *

\j2) /^/./^/^zy^;.,/ ^^ ^ -*a:s- ^.A/y < t- a

. <?*~y~<A_ Az*Z.. jT —STjg~i-i c g *&-*** <?-t~ *As A^ <Ar7&y* -e A^^<, ^aC^^-,^^^^ s^s aa, AA-e y% yAy-qji ^ y ^<r~^y ^>^s~7~^ y& AA,\ r^^ *A ^aa>aj ^;yy;&„ '

.=H2—rf^v—aa/a—/vv?w yy~e y^y^^y ~rA<?t-/A Azyr**/^ ^^*„^(/*y jn^y-y^s t—A^y^A ^sAyA* <g A ^cAfAA/^-^^ .s^^> <A<^ <z,//,f -<^i ^2 /m4' c,c g/- y4*C A^^y^-r _si? AAzn-i -y aA/?-+i e^y^ / '^ Ay An*7*e yAAr^—A/sjt / AAyy-c As,s /g A^> j^*- <• j ^z. +* *sA-

<**//?/y~y—<? y—yy<—.AA&r-r-'A—y^ <~a^, a ^ s A-»AA*~y-r

<—^/ A -^"yrtfi^L y3*tpy6 <S^r~ ASt *~r A a A -AZ~ AAy•'g. As A*= A\' —

.Si^y/—5? ^^<ftr n <Aj~—>** r~-t A? <f~-<?</< <?• AAt. ^ y <* A7~L\. ^- ^ AA, AJ ' M ejT 7<>^/ yjt*ra&^ y<t 4-A—-<^<r ^a5r y AAr yA , y^^^AJ

<">^ A7M) sA^^^A^^-A

AC aA-a*. y^^ t-Aa A* Ay <? *r>

AA-P ASa/**i~A' ,/tf;^" -?V,^ ^/V //rr A"rf -^ y, ^^ <+**-** A yAq s^>^ aC

A

><?/—AaL*.—?a*i*<;j—fty? <r^ir*i *—1^»^~-A.—y~A aa*. a^>^x« y y^yy^- 1A A y*? r. A\f -^y^<^ /**- nA* g sAss^n y **- «= Aft* y^> ^s- AA ^/A y~< As-yA^m^ A^> ^s *J/ &<zrA< Art AA*—^JV <y Af&y^c- 7 &A AYjOy7 *?-^ /If As, yA^^-A^ ,• AZ^^n <Af A~& ^& S ~ ,

y? £ AM /*r/£ m/r

£lax A

/<? t,y jp.i<,/• //tr sry-L yA -i A. A<^ A^ & y^~? A g^ A />-*•«- ^

s^ y /

-1L y«Ay- •a—r y*~?*z>^ <2£tt =C yy y^ a /<***«. y /tr.r^^- y^y, yy^y<^n<A^n Aa as/a/ y<7 y£r *-e->* yy* •^y X /AC A* y^ AAjS-A Zy>***Ay°^ /AAy^^L X, _ 5"VCU As ^C •=? <g-<-7 g- V i^-^y y y^^A - —

-y y*' yy a*> <y ~^<=^ -^ * -^o^^- y a* ^a* y* y / n<3 a°/<a /*, y> //> y^ A /-^<P^y A~A'°Aa. AAg n a, AAy y ^ <*-+- **^ -A<?-<l<A ** ~^Ay^^-^> A*> *Af^/A

y

'A'Aji

A As y __ _ Ay AAf _C AA

A

^ A'A _?*, <AA % ;<a'<

*-t\ y - / *>~rl y^^,7 ^- Ay Ay* Aa AA* <*-c*tSy j, <g. y.

<ac <^ r~y <f- r-> y

y ^A I' AA^AAy^y Ay'j^> A-y^^^y AAf <py^A/ sy^AX —/w/oje// A?£~ -A

Jp^t-r- c* A<^n^ « A y?f# ca/<j y~~-y. y^. / j;*> -/. /;/ ~

zv a?<~^a A/^y / i/a:) '„ \ y s~t k>^ , j- , \uy //v *• Ay^'y ^AA* <* <A s_~ C--*-v y*-< 'Tf ,i a •< i Ay** sAf, /*? <-n zA jlX xdrV aAA*^- <y sAy A*,~*s, -^ y^*^ ** ^ y ^ ^ A* AA-J ,yj A*y?6< j- lly>/<u* yyA^. AAL A 'y~ —\ e- •ALA !**. si*"? (-A^"'*'^''**''

~y ~7 yAyyA*A^ *A Ay, 7. A. <L <?. - /2~-* X, A/v A^^.A? y>y/ /•T'<?Z.

A J?y .Tyy^; y£jA,A« 'r A>^., ^

A. „ A AA A7A* <T. * <?. yAF -\.

y ^ g - c, *~, *s^r

y

A^-* cy gX ) ryy^f r<AA /"* -7

Asc-* A^r. ^ ^ / y^yL 1 ^*#, ;</#AAya A^A **~/^ y •A» r,*Au— y, ;, ^r~

—As, y^y S?<^> A ( <y. y y a.

^ Ty.

- AAtsyAyyA / _r /4 A* AAy^-^r ~

A#(i.<uX -—- -z Ar<=<*r ZL A - v r r, /

AyX. A £! ' /y, j: Ar^_rA y/^/^ V/ a 11 - r^.^^A,^ cry- - ,A

At" -ye^-r A?& <l A^-yA e ) J A-—y?y

y

y^c/~* A>^yses,ALAr27+yy? A^ ^^ J?*A*A* A:- AA aA* / a< A- yy_ &?/y„ As***/*?-y^ / f a^ a,, aaz^

V

A<^ Aa^ *Z~,-rA. A?r/> /AA^'AA. ZyZ-sA^-t y / f7 _.A S. r '/ ^A /~r

Py3

^,) ^v -y+rrs** AAy.,°r, y?yy y*> "y>y* y, i**r < X •*-? ^ ///?

y^y 7y? • yy.S. ?y<^y ^^7 -^.^ yyp y.'-jr yy* &~-y>y* s

y~y^*t e y y 4&-ri *<yy-c4< y -?~> s* y yy ^ s^r •*-, r A At -£" <r^>-_<- y. S* ? "?

yAAry^A^s-y^As y^. •A Af^Z. J € A?) ^;AA~A

A

A **^+r s A A A *r A AA yu e. Ayr^D*- s y r 7 A& zU.y^ / AAy? AV• £,A/' <S> n „•£

A. «. is yyy.jr y^y^y A;/ <6'c f /* y*~-*~AL,-~.As ; a^

j

y^^y. ry?A i €£* A&-A a-- f/?) ^/y/^/ A^ '-^A -y

<A<£ /y -?<znrL VS f re A a ^S. y*s^~ <A /-A x^^,y^^.-/)A <j) y%^ yZ~-^>~7 yfy-ryz&yty A jr/yy? A^-,^7 jg > g ^ ^ /^/K AA* A ^y^^yy <r tAt? <-<y y?A~-r Ze ^ ^ ^ ^ <* < •>•; a^a* > yiA** aA* <• y.

C Ay, ATy-y^X, A?rX / / /C; .

^A^Ay^y* a*A* X/ COO. &t-i-t *y± -**- —^ S ***"' -A^ ^~ <=- <L'

2A—\ Asr '^<* yry <i- ^„ <^y u-A^^yy y\ a? ?-? **?-rs ^y ^ "aa

i ~;n<y*y<ntsiA/, e- o A X ^C

X?^ A^^, ^ ^ X A<* AAj~ A^Az.Ar, At Ay >-* A,-^_r A<*<&syaL <- +-,

ypyy-rArA* A7*<. A*,, ,yAAA*yy A^~y ALsy( y& ^^y* a *&/—<<> A* e As <r f s>^. AA< .A^ <&• <r. As-

-y--^ **•* C£ A ry.j *-y* A?^ ^ 7 -f /-r

, *? rr cX A A -t AT~ A^y -A cT-ti.~ A rA A« yy

y

*> "*~7^ r ** A / / *~t '3, C

y

AA**-y / yj £ yy„,A,^ yy SA" <• y'y yy A_ fr 'iA^y <r^-^'-^- A 7^7 t^-i- X AZAA»„, ryTUl°y$&r*yS?-l £• CCty y-

y

<- e y*?—*' ~s-*

At'S.——7t< c A •A

* s?4 / A/Lr jy- yy^^> A^ <^ y*£—— 40~^- -^2s a/

<!y-s.{. y/sr^y i? z y*?*i y A* yy.7 s s*? y y y e 72- y s y y* «= aaZs,„y^ y^

y y/ Acr~ c /,' r? 71 . 7 A <£ <—L ''- ^ <~- -^-n -y* y^- y*„ -as<*.*-, ^ y 7 —y*

y* y<h y^r-. ^y^^- y^7'</y^ y^Ayt A^^^yy x^Ay'^yi^yj^^y^^'^^t y^*y.

A_V

—y?oA^yy^y< A.yJ A'Af.y-yy a~,a „„ a , y,y^ ^saf^ta yfA^y^A, 7,7771 ^<*y«/~rA>*. ?*/*,*„ yf yy y^/y.

___\—rAS A a 7tti f'r -mAe-ry—As- y / s^AAA ^~^> y^^^A AA,

AAa~ As'yr, *• y^y* iX, ^ ^~y aa^^^ ^/„ A+A+ A a,.

<y„„? y;AA,?y <Z> 7*>7 / - f^ r / <~= ^

aAa, y? yy a~aA yy„ a yy •^-*"v»-r yyzy As A Ai< -^r~r-

A, ~yt"~ S~?^t~y> A± -^S" S y _r *r y yz^^yy <£-

^ y as * Ae* A. - ^ •- tf- y Jn

y cAxA <yA-,^ c /eAy^&yyyAryy^TAA yA. A -.y^yy s~,.Ay> 6 <iS is1 Ayd- ^ A /Zy -g r/tf ~, ^ t~ s-^^A^^yA a^ y AAy7<-T _7__ S»7 rt. .AAc^rr—y7> ^»>- 7yr f Ao -C<•< ZjlL

At* A-* ^ y al*~ yy a. , y^ >~7 y j - s y & n <?*- s-^f. ' y-ss o ^

/) yy y~y, ~ yy^. y*7~ss.s. yf A^y„ A^ Af 2 ' tAA^

_ yyyy', a??a)~>

2/ yy. a^^A y^y^ y Aly jt&a?. a> sa?> - ^ &-s* Ayyy a^9-7? .7> Air. A*^A. y,y, A jr&tf. ,z&yz r

A

77 &~x> ~A^

y

"'*• ^ •*y^~"yy

y /

yy^ A-s <* ^& .t ) -\ y ) *a<a A A AXX _?—%£*£. Af AA'*r?+y tAaXr*y< y ^~jP yy^^A^^.Ay y*s-*> 1/>y-f^. <Ay AA.i"A yy^y -g x oi,^; X F

ytyA? ^ 2 <?Z S'7 <s> ~y

-A?y'r Ay—<ALc ej*r*?s*y A A^-^^ <?y^/A, AX •/.

7Asf? 7-ti At* <?~r« X Asyyj- *r*y CAs. /4 Ay^ A <A ^ A'A,' er ^v-7 £Z. A *£*-. t-7-rA £L£2- k- -c, { yA _^y^Ay , AA^^y^ yy yA2>y y sAtrrr Ay\*^y» A~A*r^T7- A^ y?.<: " ' Cj C T7**-- yy*<- 77°<i7 S-

f

^y*7- A>~y<. * 7A~ 7>&<tyA^, /*/,?„ A?ssy y^/^y *c-/*j ,~y><r--e <y/'<r/sty A,—-A* As g?^t A A-**y ^ ^><y yA^ AAA^/ A. J>y yA*>*-7A7 &7 —V>r-f—Ay s> ys-^y- /'y g> A A<-3^yl 1 <7.y *-+ **t -e yA^>*^—A *a-^ ^C : Ay-yyy yiy^^^?y y%^^ya a y^ „**„ a<.

-rrn t y/r7 j-r<u#

7£>-f> Ae^Aa-^ Ar ^ 7^ /-<: L-z AAc Ac A3A' «- A AA* A AA^ yy<*.y~y? X/yy i ^y^^^- ^^y s-a*a^ ^a*.^ a* ^yg-r A?7e*zA7?ry?y?j A-^&y-n 7^/o.y.^7~ *r-.^w y*Ay <rAyy s ye Ay^- —^A*n*y y* yALy^A AA« y yA< y<y* ^-T,y y*y^ aA^ _±__aa ^-^* ^^? A^^y **- n A <y^<y? X& A<y g A AX*./ f A?- A A . AX/7^s AA < -.<•**, y,.

A' ^^ / <&« /X //« y^TTsyr *^*y JT^y-;, / J^^ A^AAA —^y+tfy—r- ./tf^-rf-.f A&H-'. yA-e*. y? ^^^ ^ &^ A-* f\y_ -^ ^ <*"*•+* A^-^s y ^

j JT ^yS^s-TT eyA Ay y*r<ar^s- y***, Ay~*^ A A<2-c*J> „ yyAa^, ^>-^7_e &^^-Ay ^A.

^£Z?n Ar-A^X' yTJPAryPyyyyr r AA*> s^^y^ —A^-^^. yAy^y j^-^-^ y^ S^^gyy S?£> A s~^>j*yys?y^y*e yy *y- yiy*r-*~r <a~t <r *• ^ &-^jA<£^^s-> jT7*JT ^ \Ar< yr <r*~T A/erA <* fyey* r*- / A. r^. f f f ^ ^ A AaJ. ;„ A> AA -~y.* C y a >• j. j. .

y^r

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

£TU-L L. rfCTLoK? /Jo. 61- i£~ &&£)£#- zis

TAJ TU £ £ a an r /? A s? S f y?s? /LJ"

AVAST JDjr^T/PJ-^ 7~ A/E ->Y"^A

//ausrw. 7-yT^r

TEXAS

mar 20

°**S?i

AtfJLJrSA? y£ - ^ &MA/S*^^^y 9***.* ^u

s&A*'& /y' ////?,/>/* y? //yUr. /

J^L.

T cTSHAyZ <?/? rA-yyS. Ajs-aaj />y?rr s-s?r»7. .-jMt-r. r^ si J . .

A?* 7^*,<J/*<*Ts_A/fAiAo/f*^ * ! ^

SJst-rj/J 7-z */?'.<• At 7~4 ry/A

s^AAA/l A~y£* Z?A> S?J 2-SS SS, /?yi> Ac:-T

TO r/t-JF J/JA/0Psf-JZ<Ly£ AX/P^T s-yrty^T- ^ y^ sP J* A> s*Ts4 2-C 1

>%^/;///^r,./L,/

A /

r

7^W ^bZ. •=» y *-*.{ Z^_ y-ftn yAtn'y^^Y^y^r /.s9 a.jt)

s?«^r—^;*>y&A A y,/«.—?^^^ /^s? r/?y,^y?*>*,.7^ ^ / //f ^ ^ ^ /„ ,z I'JJ /y.^ **r/ s^y< /. z s zj ~-J: y?^/» / _e£

T

j- <? ^/ ^y ^ y r/yog ~/. /: j, j£yL &±£ y +n -*<>^ y ^ y ~7*

•v

&> yyrf & Ay<-^, o< <?-cz *<? y s^gr <?-A^~L •v . r / 4t & ^sTr^^s^rr//^ ^r^y.

>>- /

=2L

7T~ ^y^y^ ', y^ ^ y ~A A 7A* ^A^J^A?*/ T AAA? yAAy Aa Ssi s~ r/ r~s~-e <rS ' yy^ ''** y°r-r s? <z>z«^ y <**->-*' s^A,

Mi //W»-> y? yf- j-^<a a&/- zT^<.y>,-y ^y y^^,y^-*-,, y A *Ti

-s~yAyA*~ ~A A/.f^~^A*A~y?-~i ^c/. / e /&f ^/ / ^.j ^-arrtF. < ^"^-> *> Ay" As^ A 'a r> ,^>- r . Z ^" /<£" *

\j2) /^/./^/^zy^;.,/ ^^ ^ -*a:s- ^.A/y < t- a

. <?*~y~<A_ Az*Z.. jT —STjg~i-i c g *&-*** <?-t~ *As A^ <Ar7&y* -e A^^<, ^aC^^-,^^^^ s^s aa, AA-e y% yAy-qji ^ y ^<r~^y ^>^s~7~^ y& AA,\ r^^ *A ^aa>aj ^;yy;&„ '

<**//?/y~y—<? y—yy<—.AA&r-r-'A—y^ <~a^, a ^ s A-»AA*~y-r

<—^/ A -^"yrtfi^L y3*tpy6 <S^r~ ASt *~r A a A -AZ~ AAy•'g. As A*= A\' —

.Si^y/—5? ^^<ftr n <Aj~—>** r~-t A? <f~-<?</< <?• AAt. ^ y <* A7~L\. ^- ^ AA, AJ ' M ejT 7<>^/ yjt*ra&^ y<t 4-A—-<^<r ^a5r y AAr yA , y^^^AJ

<">^ A7M) sA^^^A^^-A

AC aA-a*. y^^ t-Aa A* Ay <? *r>

AA-P ASa/**i~A' ,/tf;^" -?V,^ ^/V //rr A"rf -^ y, ^^ <+**-** A yAq s^>^ aC

A

y? £ AM /*r/£ m/r

£lax A

/<? t,y jp.i<,/• //tr sry-L yA -i A. A<^ A^ & y^~? A g^ A />-*•«- ^

s^ y /

-y y*' yy a*> <y ~^<=^ -^ * -^o^^- y a* ^a* y* y / n<3 a°/<a /*, y> //> y^ A /-^<P^y A~A'°Aa. AAg n a, AAy y ^ <*-+- **^ -A<?-<l<A ** ~^Ay^^-^> A*> *Af^/A

y

'A'Aji

A As y __ _ Ay AAf _C AA

A

^ A'A _?*, <AA % ;<a'<

*-t\ y - / *>~rl y^^,7 ^- Ay Ay* Aa AA* <*-c*tSy j, <g. y.

<ac <^ r~y <f- r-> y

y ^A I' AA^AAy^y Ay'j^> A-y^^^y AAf <py^A/ sy^AX —/w/oje// A?£~ -A

Jp^t-r- c* A<^n^ « A y?f# ca/<j y~~-y. y^. / j;*> -/. /;/ ~

~y ~7 yAyyA*A^ *A Ay, 7. A. <L <?. - /2~-* X, A/v A^^.A? y>y/ /•T'<?Z.

A J?y .Tyy^; y£jA,A« 'r A>^., ^

A. „ A AA A7A* <T. * <?. yAF -\.

y ^ g - c, *~, *s^r

y

A^-* cy gX ) ryy^f r<AA /"* -7

Asc-* A^r. ^ ^ / y^yL 1 ^*#, ;</#AAya A^A **~/^ y •A» r,*Au— y, ;, ^r~

—As, y^y S?<^> A ( <y. y y a.

^ Ty.

- AAtsyAyyA / _r /4 A* AAy^-^r ~

A#(i.<uX -—- -z Ar<=<*r ZL A - v r r, /

AyX. A £! ' /y, j: Ar^_rA y/^/^ V/ a 11 - r^.^^A,^ cry- - ,A

At" -ye^-r A?& <l A^-yA e ) J A-—y?y

y

y^c/~* A>^yses,ALAr27+yy? A^ ^^ J?*A*A* A:- AA aA* / a< A- yy_ &?/y„ As***/*?-y^ / f a^ a,, aaz^

V

A<^ Aa^ *Z~,-rA. A?r/> /AA^'AA. ZyZ-sA^-t y / f7 _.A S. r '/ ^A /~r

Py3

^,) ^v -y+rrs** AAy.,°r, y?yy y*> "y>y* y, i**r < X •*-? ^ ///?

y^y 7y? • yy.S. ?y<^y ^^7 -^.^ yyp y.'-jr yy* &~-y>y* s

y~y^*t e y y 4&-ri *<yy-c4< y -?~> s* y yy ^ s^r •*-, r A At -£" <r^>-_<- y. S* ? "?

yAAry^A^s-y^As y^. •A Af^Z. J € A?) ^;AA~A

A

A **^+r s A A A *r A AA yu e. Ayr^D*- s y r 7 A& zU.y^ / AAy? AV• £,A/' <S> n „•£

A. «. is yyy.jr y^y^y A;/ <6'c f /* y*~-*~AL,-~.As ; a^

j

y^^y. ry?A i €£* A&-A a-- f/?) ^/y/^/ A^ '-^A -y

C Ay, ATy-y^X, A?rX / / /C; .

^A^Ay^y* a*A* X/ COO. &t-i-t *y± -**- —^ S ***"' -A^ ^~ <=- <L'

2A—\ Asr '^<* yry <i- ^„ <^y u-A^^yy y\ a? ?-? **?-rs ^y ^ "aa

i ~;n<y*y<ntsiA/, e- o A X ^C

X?^ A^^, ^ ^ X A<* AAj~ A^Az.Ar, At Ay >-* A,-^_r A<*<&syaL <- +-,

ypyy-rArA* A7*<. A*,, ,yAAA*yy A^~y ALsy( y& ^^y* a *&/—<<> A* e As <r f s>^. AA< .A^ <&• <r. As-

-y--^ **•* C£ A ry.j *-y* A?^ ^ 7 -f /-r

, *? rr cX A A -t AT~ A^y -A cT-ti.~ A rA A« yy

y

*> "*~7^ r ** A / / *~t '3, C

y

AA**-y / yj £ yy„,A,^ yy SA" <• y'y yy A_ fr 'iA^y <r^-^'-^- A 7^7 t^-i- X AZAA»„, ryTUl°y$&r*yS?-l £• CCty y-

y

<- e y*?—*' ~s-*

At'S.——7t< c A •A

* s?4 / A/Lr jy- yy^^> A^ <^ y*£—— 40~^- -^2s a/

<!y-s.{. y/sr^y i? z y*?*i y A* yy.7 s s*? y y y e 72- y s y y* «= aaZs,„y^ y^

y y/ Acr~ c /,' r? 71 . 7 A <£ <—L ''- ^ <~- -^-n -y* y^- y*„ -as<*.*-, ^ y 7 —y*

y* y<h y^r-. ^y^^- y^7'</y^ y^Ayt A^^^yy x^Ay'^yi^yj^^y^^'^^t y^*y.

A_V

—y?oA^yy^y< A.yJ A'Af.y-yy a~,a „„ a , y,y^ ^saf^ta yfA^y^A, 7,7771 ^<*y«/~rA>*. ?*/*,*„ yf yy y^/y.

___\—rAS A a 7tti f'r -mAe-ry—As- y / s^AAA ^~^> y^^^A AA,

AAa~ As'yr, *• y^y* iX, ^ ^~y aa^^^ ^/„ A+A+ A a,.

<y„„? y;AA,?y <Z> 7*>7 / - f^ r / <~= ^

aAa, y? yy a~aA yy„ a yy •^-*"v»-r yyzy As A Ai< -^r~r-

A, ~yt"~ S~?^t~y> A± -^S" S y _r *r y yz^^yy <£-

^ y as * Ae* A. - ^ •- tf- y Jn

y cAxA <yA-,^ c /eAy^&yyyAryy^TAA yA. A -.y^yy s~,.Ay> 6 <iS is1 Ayd- ^ A /Zy -g r/tf ~, ^ t~ s-^^A^^yA a^ y AAy7<-T _7__ S»7 rt. .AAc^rr—y7> ^»>- 7yr f Ao -C<•< ZjlL

At* A-* ^ y al*~ yy a. , y^ >~7 y j - s y & n <?*- s-^f. ' y-ss o ^

/) yy y~y, ~ yy^. y*7~ss.s. yf A^y„ A^ Af 2 ' tAA^

_ yyyy', a??a)~>

2/ yy. a^^A y^y^ y Aly jt&a?. a> sa?> - ^ &-s* Ayyy a^9-7? .7> Air. A*^A. y,y, A jr&tf. ,z&yz r

A

77 &~x> ~A^

y

"'*• ^ •*y^~"yy

y /

yy^ A-s <* ^& .t ) -\ y ) *a<a A A AXX _?—%£*£. Af AA'*r?+y tAaXr*y< y ^~jP yy^^A^^.Ay y*s-*> 1/>y-f^. <Ay AA.i"A yy^y -g x oi,^; X F

ytyA? ^ 2 <?Z S'7 <s> ~y

-A?y'r Ay—<ALc ej*r*?s*y A A^-^^ <?y^/A, AX •/.

7Asf? 7-ti At* <?~r« X Asyyj- *r*y CAs. /4 Ay^ A <A ^ A'A,' er ^v-7 £Z. A *£*-. t-7-rA £L£2- k- -c, { yA _^y^Ay , AA^^y^ yy yA2>y y sAtrrr Ay\*^y» A~A*r^T7- A^ y?.<: " ' Cj C T7**-- yy*<- 77°<i7 S-

f

-rrn t y/r7 j-r<u#

A' ^^ / <&« /X //« y^TTsyr *^*y JT^y-;, / J^^ A^AAA —^y+tfy—r- ./tf^-rf-.f A&H-'. yA-e*. y? ^^^ ^ &^ A-* f\y_ -^ ^ <*"*•+* A^-^s y ^

j JT ^yS^s-TT eyA Ay y*r<ar^s- y***, Ay~*^ A A<2-c*J> „ yyAa^, ^>-^7_e &^^-Ay ^A.

y^r

y^s—y&r-—a___ 5 y7y $ ^^- y*.^y_r ^^/yy^-a*?^ aa<h ^wg/v.^/

aa7< ^ ,AA> A y« a&a A; «7c aA 7yaaAs* AA yy^-A^ A, ~A yy^rr y" A* Ay< g ** ~ r "

y7s7*77~7^yA A

AAtf-tf/iA

y

a« A/rtr*—-^r-ar1 y< y^^y^y Ay y>y>^ y^-yAi-<. ^y t <Ay^^t—a!P(=> gy7'y Acy*> tA^ a<& ** A**- .* yy^^*y^ , ^a<* y<. __e. _ _ Ay4»S~*AA At? 7~~e y> ^*tS<:^t A ^? _f 77<yf?*y yS^s-A-y Ayf _T^c yT —Ay 7><*,A*—AA?*? Aa AA<z j- ^ y*.yy.— >y^?„ ^,yy )*? AA /~<'/lA,r,yr-ry4.c*7*~i • .sAlAr^, 7A <Aa<-7t.tr; Ay A AA.A S~AJ S~A>Q

A^- ^

-££ ?«? -r-^/- .r?v c/37z^ f~ *~ fy,y^Ar*»*y *.,/• A*, y^ y,,. yy<—t77"y—AA<&y r-caa<-cuy<-a Ay yx<- y^tm ^y A/y/^s. .->^ ?A<fiy A^—-—\AA f'tirtziA Art/'- **s y*s ;>-*>/> ^ ~i A//*j~/y .*-, y AX* <• a 7?,-r7yy y^sX cyy yXt A^.y.^r. -^.i-.» ^ y^^^< Ay* y?~^ y s*s. a^ '"- y/ yy '< ^ ~?~y *p A/a inXi" XX—i— {/(*' <ft X/y—^0/7 //^ <i/ /; / ,^^/- / /*, /A* A- < S, <2. <$7- <I a n ** -*-*<& ^yy X<? A A^^ u *> ^A*^-^ Ay/*/ .Tl>A«~ y 7 „./v y^y^y A*- j~c Z *>*i y^-ry^y^^ f/gZ^//^ ^ ^ ^ r y//*><# Ar?7-yA 7; y^/V * AVfy+J. ytf#A-/A*fATJtSr *i*J A^r? +-***.*- XsA.

AtAA* /Z——yA<R7(?yyAy *ya-s T^^y s~ y-s*4*-ry^***yA is-e <=ssyyjLy o y Ay7 yX<^ y^ ^y AA—yy?yy. yk^*>A> y?>ys, ^^ ^?cy^,/>- 7t AffcT.—tf.,3ynXz./'tt A___—XL_—<A_ J<LyAy A*yy sy s? y^y, //X^ ^ Ai y^j/,<• cy y<p*+r-A* 'A/^yaa<s*-1-tt/i~y <£_-£ yy?<7*A<^> ^y AAc Ay**?.so, A^/^; / y „^. ^ yy A* r- ^A^,^>y"^a . yA y-roT Ay ^7yfcy IA J>-r Ay**** e. a yAy y~A<. Ay '< <f fTerrTl^jA ^Aa /L 7f a 7 y7^ 7 A-e Ay'^^ yz y~^, yu y-i *? „~7 7*f fetcx <*a AAt A^y*<<: tLl "•?"y~*?*y y= A *>*-*?r**-/• * Z?*->?~-P —Aer- Ayye/y*.*.—•^Aa^/cX X*—yQAAAZA"'/? <__. ^AyL^/L ^*^asA', »+ <*-*/'

y y

-s-^-7 y^y^ —y<* Ay

ye^yp^AA'Afr •*"•*• Xjtr ? yyAj /Vf^r A ALA^^y, y< yX/^*n Ar ,-77} Xr> SCnr &<& ?7 ^~jr~ S z.

AX- CT- & & • A* t'X ? * /A?

A

aa\ &o ^y; /<l y yy^* y

A^Xtr^y ft y r^r^ "7 "7 &&3.

A^y^A/^ STA/tf

*H.gDtN

1ST COURT QFArpiAlS

HOUSTON, TPXAS

MAR 20 2018

t—z^<S) ^yyA^r^ —Ary^^x-^ aa?** ,—« CHWSTQPHEfi A. miNE

CLBtK

_z yy^^y. -Zrz>i*y yAAyyfye^y >o,/,yy~ .Aaw.A yA"*-*^;

A

aA^ Ay&A>-<L

yf yy^yXy^, ^ AAA, yy)yyA ALyj*. ^y^JA;

A

y'y*^* yAs,^ &a- A^'A^e*?<? - <rtAr

.AjyA ?*y>i AyA^f—^/t^A-—^""^^^^^^^-f at? Aaw Ayyy^^AAct^i^)

y> y> - ° y yy* *y^z^-&r^e^,y & _____**_ yyyAAy^ s^~^A&<? —2^-~<^ . •y.

yy¥-

AAytyy^ <y7cy .-Ay?- vt i*y yy*^\ -y-

y--y> C tr^«=.-» >-^

rz^^yZ^^^y» ^A-ee A&4 _ _ . O—— A*

*^x*y~ yy<A AA.A S-/? JTATy-Z,/ A7<3-7^1^y

£~Z -j-y. / '-<.<-<£-. tA^aA, y^y^^y 7'7y yZ-jA*

y

A&y.

y, yX~ y* yA& -t^^AgAt ^* -as^z^^^ /X^7 yyA-^yXs*~^Ar * -y y^ • ^^ Ay ^y a* y yy<yiy—i-*i a .

r -yL^:-3-Ayy 7 s>

y^y^-^^yy-^A^ _^ yy~AA,^<_yAA, yyA, yyy-Ar A, *r>-> <Q ^ 7 /S^S~7 2.

•AZAy AA/***") fl <?*/< A-7-P ^T-O

>X.y^& Ay*yA ^yjy

yyy& yA^A^ AAy^A ^yAyrAA^A^y Ay -yyyoA-z.

HARRIS COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE JAIL Name: <^^y^~? a: yA^yXAy*^-, SPN: 0Z?AA~S-/z- ^ Cp\\-s£./a? Street Ayyy> y?^A^ yy HOUSTON, TEXAS 77002 aramark r—— •received RECEIVED

FIRST COURT OF APPEALS

;0URT OFAi • in1„ iqtoM

IQTOM TFYAb

TFV

MAR 2 0 201 sAyyy aa^-, *-*A CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE yoyy-

A^AyA- y)y^A>

INDIGENT iCLERK.

;3w

Ay y 7^>^'z-

y

iii^ikff^iii^^kw^^^i^hl^iiriPh

William E. Johnson v. State of Texas, Texas Department of Criminal Justice, (Tex. Ct. App. 2018).

Pincite

William E. Johnson v. State of Texas, Texas Department of Criminal Justice (William E. Johnson v. State of Texas, Texas Department of Criminal Justice) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.