Willard v. Trustees of Methodist Episcopal Church of Rockville Centre

66 Ill. 55

• Court: Illinois Supreme Court
• Decided: September 15, 1872
• Status: Published

Opinion

Mr. Justice Thornton

delivered the opinion of the Court:

This suit was brought upon an instrument in writing, purporting to be a subscription paper, with the name of appellant thereon as a subscriber.

The execution. of the instrument was not put in issue by sworn plea, and it was therefore not error to refuse to allow the subscriber to testify that he did not sign the paper.

The other point made for reversal is, that there was not an organization of the corporation in strict conformity to the statute, at the time the subscription was made, nor at the time the suit was commenced.

There was an organization in fact, and though the subscription was made prior thereto, it inured to the benefit of the corporation thereafter created. In this case there was a corporate body de facto. The trustees made contracts, superintended the erection of a church, and generally performed the duties pertaining to their position. The formal certificate afterwards signed by the trustees referred to the original organization, and, with other proof, established the fact.

This organization and user under it proved the existence of the corporation for the purposes of this suit, notwithstanding the plea of nul tiel corporation. Cross v. Pinckneyville Co. 17 Ill. 54; Griswold v. Trustees of Peoria University, 26 Ill. 41; Mitchell v. Deeds, 49 Ill. 417; Baker v. Admr. of Backus, 32 Ill. 79.

There is no merit in the defense, and the judgment is affirmed.

Judgment affirmed.