White v. Delta Foundation, Inc.

481 So. 2d 329
CourtMississippi Supreme Court
DecidedDecember 18, 1985
Docket55149
StatusPublished
Cited by11 cases

This text of 481 So. 2d 329 (White v. Delta Foundation, Inc.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Mississippi Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
White v. Delta Foundation, Inc., 481 So. 2d 329 (Mich. 1985).

Opinion

481 So.2d 329 (1985)

Roger WHITE and Joyce White
v.
DELTA FOUNDATION, INC., Lester F. Smith, William A. Murrain and Michael Espy.

No. 55149.

Supreme Court of Mississippi.

December 18, 1985.
Rehearing Denied January 15, 1986.

*330 David A. Bowers, Thomas, Price, Alston, Jones & Davis, and Lester F. Smith, Perry, Morrison & Smith, Jackson, for appellants.

Before PATTERSON, C.J., and HAWKINS and ROBERTSON, JJ.

HAWKINS, Justice, for the Court:

Roger White and wife Joyce Y. White appeal from a final decree of the Chancery Court of Madison County sustaining a demurrer to their bill of complaint filed against Delta Foundation, Inc., and its trustees under a deed of trust, and dismissing the bill. The bill of complaint challenged the validity of a foreclosure. Finding the bill of complaint stated a cause of action, we reverse.

FACTS

On June 14, 1977, Roger and Joyce Y. White executed a deed of trust to John Nichols, trustee for Delta Foundation, Inc., a non-profit corporation with principal offices in Washington, but domiciled in this state, to secure a principal debt of $5,000, evidenced by a promissory note payable in monthly installments of $115.15 each, beginning July 15, 1977. The deed of trust covered a house and lot in Madison County.

The Whites defaulted and Delta Foundation foreclosed. Before instituting foreclosure proceedings the following substituted trustee appointment was filed and recorded on the land deed records of Madison County:

APPOINTMENT OF SUBSTITUTE TRUSTEE
UNDER AND BY VIRTUE of the authority vested in the undersigned mortgagee, DELTA FOUNDATION, INC. OF GREENVILLE, MISSISSIPPI, by that certain deed of trust hereinafter listed, the aforesaid mortgagee, acting by and through its duly authorized officer, KEITH EARLY, General Counsel, does hereby nominate and appoint WILLIAM A. MURRAIN as Substitute Trustee in the hereinafter listed deed of trust, with full power to act in the place and stead of the original trustee therein named, to-wit:
"Deed of Trust from Roger White et ux Joyce Y. White to John Nichols, Trustee for Delta Foundation, Inc., dated December 22, 1977 and recorded in Book 470 at page 564."
The above listed deed of trust is on file and of record in the office of the Chancery Clerk of Madison County at Canton, Mississippi.
WITNESS THE SIGNATURE AND SEAL OF STATE MUTUAL FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION, Jackson, Mississippi, hereto affixed on the 19th day of September, 1980.
DELTA FOUNDATION, INC. BY: /s/ Keith Early KEITH EARLY ATTEST: ____ STATE OF MISSISSIPPI COUNTY OF HINDS. . . . .
PERSONALLY appeared before me, the undersigned authority in and for the jurisdiction aforesaid, the within named KEITH EARLY, who acknowledged that he signed and delivered the above and foregoing instrument of writing on the day and in the year therein mentioned.
*331 /s/ Dawn E. Sutton NOTARY PUBLIC (SEAL) MY COMMISSION EXPIRES: OCTOBER 23, 1983 STATE OF MISSISSIPPI, COUNTY OF MADISON
I, BILLY V. COOPER, Clerk of the Chancery Court of said County, certify that the within instrument was filed for record in my office this 21 day of October, 1980 at 4:25 o'clock P.M. and was duly recorded on the 22 day of October, 1980 Book No. 476 Page 639 in my office.
WITNESS my hand and seal of office, this the 22 day of October, 1980.
BILLY V. COOPER, CLERK BY /s/ N. Wright Lot 23 Gatewary North (I)

[R. 14-15]

There was a foreclosure and a substitute trustee's deed executed by William A. Murrain to one Michael Espy of Jackson.

The Whites employed counsel, efforts were made to "redeem" the property, and claims were made that the first foreclosure was fatally defective. Apparently, Delta Foundation agreed, because another foreclosure proceeding was begun by another substituted trustee, but later abandoned, and Delta Foundation chose to stand on the first foreclosure.

The Whites filed their bill of complaint in the Chancery Court of Madison County challenging the validity of the foreclosure, asserting inter alia, the substitution of trustee was fatally defective. We agree.

The deed of trust expressly gave Delta Foundation the right to appoint a substitute trustee, without which Delta Foundation would have had no authority to do so. Webb v. Biles, 192 Miss. 474, 6 So.2d 117 (1942); Laird v. Bethea, 215 Miss. 64, 60 So.2d 526 (1952). This power is strictly construed. Powers v. Interstate Trust & Banking Co., 163 Miss. 30, 139 So. 318, 320 (1932); West v. Union Naval Stores Co., 117 Miss. 153, 77 So. 961 (1918). In this case the deed of trust had the following provision:

The legal holder of any of the indebtedness secured hereby, whoever, it may be, may at any time appoint another person or a succession of persons to advertise and sell the property herein conveyed and carry out the further provisions of this trust in the place and stead of the Trustee herein named, and such other person or persons, when so appointed, shall have the power to do everything which this instrument expressley [sic] or impliedly authorizes the Trustee herein named to do.

[R. 9-10]

Miss. Code Ann. § 89-5-45, the statute authorizing substitution of trustees in deeds of trust, is as follows:

§ 89-5-45. Substitution of trustee must appear of record.
Sales of land made under deeds of trust by substituted trustees shall not convey the interest of the grantor or grantors therein, but shall be absolutely null and void, both at law and in equity, unless the substitution shall appear of record in the office of the chancery clerk of the county where the land is situated, and unless it shall so appear by being actually spread at large upon the record before the first advertisement or notice of sale shall have been posted or published; the filing for record or lodging with the clerk not being sufficient. Such substitution, however, may so appear by a separate instrument recorded as above set out in all respects, or a copy of such substitution may be recorded as above set out. [Emphasis added]

Delta Foundation had the authority to designate an agent for substituting a trustee. See: Adams et al v. St. Clair, 185 Miss. 416, 188 So. 559 (1939); Chandler v. Bank of Brooksville, 181 Miss. 529, 178 So. 797 (1938). It would have been subject to proof that Keith Early had such authority from Delta Foundation.

This appointment of substituted trustee is woeful draftsmanship. The final paragraph states it is "State Mutual Federal Savings & Loan Association" making the substitution. The instrument, however, *332 purports to be executed by Delta Foundation. The signature is ambiguous; headed "DELTA FOUNDATION," and with a signature "Keith Early," who does not designate whether he signs as agent or in his own individual capacity. The acknowledgment which follows is a personal acknowledgment, not a corporate acknowledgment, nor as agent and attorney for the corporation. Moreover, the notarization contains no final paragraph or date.

WHY APPOINTMENT DEFECTIVE
What is an acknowledgment?
1 C.J.S. Acknowledgments,

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Harrell v. Lamar Co., LLC
925 So. 2d 870 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2005)
Renee Williams v. Wells Fargo
Eighth Circuit, 2005
Estate of Dykes v. Estate of Williams
864 So. 2d 926 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 2003)
Ginger Dykes Williams v. Kathryn F. Tonguis
Mississippi Supreme Court, 2002
Chambers v. BancorpSouth Bank
822 So. 2d 1113 (Court of Appeals of Mississippi, 2002)
Morton v. Resolution Trust Corp.
918 F. Supp. 985 (S.D. Mississippi, 1995)
Thames v. Jackson Production Credit Ass'n
600 So. 2d 208 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1992)
Wansley v. First Nat. Bank of Vicksburg
566 So. 2d 1218 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1990)
Gregory v. Federal Land Bank of Jackson
515 So. 2d 1200 (Mississippi Supreme Court, 1987)
Federal Land Bank of Jackson v. Kennedy
662 F. Supp. 787 (N.D. Mississippi, 1987)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
481 So. 2d 329, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/white-v-delta-foundation-inc-miss-1985.