WHEELHOUSE REAL ESTATE, LLC v. Bommarito

284 S.W.3d 761
CourtMissouri Court of Appeals
DecidedMay 15, 2009
DocketSD 28997
StatusPublished
Cited by1 cases

This text of 284 S.W.3d 761 (WHEELHOUSE REAL ESTATE, LLC v. Bommarito) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Missouri Court of Appeals primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
WHEELHOUSE REAL ESTATE, LLC v. Bommarito, 284 S.W.3d 761 (Mo. Ct. App. 2009).

Opinion

284 S.W.3d 761 (2009)

WHEELHOUSE MARINA REAL ESTATE, L.L.C., Appellant
v.
Anthony BOMMARITO d/b/a Docknockers Bar & Grill and Docknockers, L.L.C., Respondents.

No. SD 28997.

Missouri Court of Appeals, Southern District, Division Two.

May 15, 2009.

*764 Donald E. Heck, Chesterfield, MO, for Appellant.

Lewis Z. Bridges, Curran & Sickal, Osage Beach, MO, for Respondents.

JOHN E. PARRISH, Judge.

Wheelhouse Marina Real Estate, L.L.C., (Wheelhouse Real Estate) brought an unlawful detainer action against Anthony Bommarito and Docknockers, L.L.C., (defendants) seeking rent and possession regarding premises in Camden County, Missouri, known as Docknockers Bar & Grill. Judgment was entered for defendants. This court affirms. The case, however, is remanded with instructions that a scrivener's error that is identified in n. 3, infra, be corrected.

There are a number of related entities and people who were involved with the events that led to this appeal. An understanding of their identities is relevant to the facts recited in this opinion. The individual defendant in the unlawful detainer action is Anthony Bommarito. He is the grandson of Ralph Keeney, Jr., (Keeney Jr.) who is the owner of Wheelhouse Marina Holding, L.L.C. (Wheelhouse Holding) and Wheelhouse Real Estate. Ralph Keeney, III, (Keeney III) is the son of Keeney Jr. and the uncle of Anthony Bommarito. Keeney III is a manager of Wheelhouse Holding. Mary Gordon, a previous owner of the property that is the subject of this action, was Keeney Jr.'s secretary.

Anthony Bommarito operates Docknockers Bar & Grill on property presently owned by Wheelhouse Real Estate. He took possession of the property May 30, 1993. At that time the property was owned by Mary Gordon. The following is a chronology of documents relative to the property where Docknockers Bar & Grill is located.

March 3, 1993 Date of one-page document entitled COMMERCIAL LEASE that identifies the "Leased Premises" as a certain commercial building. The document identifies Ralph Keeney as "Landlord" and Tony Bommarito as "Tenant(s)."[1] It is in evidence as Defendants' Exhibit A.
May 19, 1993 Date of notary public acknowledgement on document entitled RESTURANT [sic] RENTAL AGREEMENT bearing signatures of Ralph Keeney "acting in owners [sic] behaft [sic] Mary Sgordan [sic]" and Anthony Bommarito identified as "Tenant Anthony Bommarito."[2] The property is where Docknockers Bar & Grill is located. It is in evidence as Petitioner's Exhibit 2.
September 29, 1993 Date of notary public acknowledgement on quitclaim deed bearing date of September 1993 (the day of the month does not appear on the instrument). Grantor on the *765 deed is Mary S. Gordon. Grantee is Keeney Jr. The property includes that where Docknockers Bar & Grill is located.
April 28, 2006 Date of quitclaim deed to property that includes the property where Docknockers Bar & Grill is located. Keeney Jr. is grantor. Wheelhouse Holding is grantee.
April 28, 2006 Date of quitclaim deed to property that includes the property where Docknockers Bar & Grill is located. Wheelhouse Holding is grantor and Wheelhouse Real Estate is grantee.

In 2006 Wheelhouse Real Estate notified Anthony Bommarito that his "month to month lease [was to be] terminated as of 12 p.m. on September 3, 2006." Bommarito was advised that if he remained on the premises after the stated date, an unlawful detainer action would be filed seeking "eviction, past due rentals, attorney's fees, and damages, if any." Keeney III notified Bommarito that he would be required to execute a new lease in order to be permitted to continue to occupy the property. Bommarito had paid $600 per month rent prior to that time. He contended that he was occupying the property under the terms of a 20-year lease that was dated March 3, 1993, that had been executed by he and Keeney Jr. See n. 1, supra. Bommarito did not execute a new lease.

The trial court entered judgment that recited the appearances of the parties; that at the conclusion of the evidence, the parties were permitted to submit "post trial briefs"; that following receipt of the briefs, the trial court found the issues in favor of the defendants. The judgment states the following findings:

It is clear to the Court that Ralph Keeney, III[sic][[3]] and defendant Bommarito entered into a lease agreement that was to become effective when Mr. Keeney acquired title to the subject property, which he did. Defendant [Anthony Bommarito] is not in breach of the lease. Any improvements made by defendant was [sic] done with the knowledge and consent of [Keeney III], and landlord not only approved said improvement but continued to accept rental payments knowing of the improvements. Court further finds that said argument re: improvements is beyond the scope of the pleadings and defendants have not consented to trying this issue.
The Court finds Judgment should be entered for defendants. The Court enters Judgment in favor of defendants and against Plaintiffs [sic][[4]]. All costs are assessed against Plaintiffs [sic].

Wheelhouse Real Estate's Point I states:

The trial court erred in failing to find that the six month rental contract between Mary S. Gordon and Respondent Anthony Bommarito dated June 1, 1993 (Appendix A) constituted a novation thereby terminating all prior agreements, if any, including the alleged lease contract dated March 3, 1993 ([A]ppendix B), regarding the rental of the real *766 estate known as Dockknockers [sic] Bar and Restaurant, because all prior agreements merged into the last entered into agreement as an accord. As a result no other agreements to rent existed and Respondent was after November 1993 a month to month tenant subject to termination upon proper notice.

"Appendix A" to Wheelhouse Real Estate's appellant's brief is a copy of the one paragraph document entitled "RESTURANT [sic] RENTAL AGREEMENT" identified in the chronology of documents that appears, supra, as the document that has the notary public acknowledgment of May 19, 1993. The document states in its entirety, less the notary acknowledgment:

RESTURANT [sic] RENTAL AGREEMENT
I, Anthony Bommarito, agree to rent the restaurant and fixtures at 700 Crow Road for the season starting June 1, 1993 and ending November 1, 1993 for six months at the rate of six hundred dollars per month. All utilities will be paid by Anthony Bommarito also to include the apartment at the end on the building. If all goes well the rental can be extended beyond this year providing all bills are paid and the property is kept clean. There must also be no complaints from the surrounding property owners of the noise. This agreement is binding for June 1, 1993 till November 1, 1993 providing that all liscense [sic] and insurance requirements are met.
/s/ Ralph Keeney Ralph Keeney acting in owners [sic] behaft [sic] Mary Sgordan [sic]. /s/ Anthony J. Bommarito Tenant Anthony Bommarito

Wheelhouse Real Estate's assertion of "novation" is raised for the first time on appeal. The broad definition of novation is "a substitution of a new contract or obligation for an old one which is thereby extinguished." W. Crawford Smith, Inc. v. Watkins, 425 S.W.2d 276, 279 (Mo.App. 1968).

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

D.J.B. Ex Rel. Boschert v. Brown
284 S.W.3d 761 (Missouri Court of Appeals, 2009)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
284 S.W.3d 761, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/wheelhouse-real-estate-llc-v-bommarito-moctapp-2009.