Whaley, Michael Dwayne

Court of Appeals of Texas·Decided March 17, 2015·No. WR-34,395-26·Published

Opinion

~:'

• .Iu ~t. Loud J Lc:M~~o.\ ot Affeo.\~ of .Te.x:u-:. • f.o. ~c.1- lZ.~o~ Co.~~\~\ '"'Yht\\(.,t-\ o f\u~t·.r..\, Tel(~S l~ll\

No±;< e. MJ.d Se.c.u:u_ J AH\~c.a.f:.li~ fc. -\:: tc.u This document contains some Ft>r \A.h a A~ MaN An Mll ~ pages ~hat are of poor qualitlf at the t1me of imaging. ""t, The.. l-\c~ofa.\,le.. .JuJ. ~e_(")) o-\- fut.. o.bo\lf. ~a;c! Lotilt: t-.....\oi:~Li. ON.(\ ~~\"~ce.. ('.) hdt.~'l ~~\lt.u aucl. MaAL- -\-~c.Lt -t\tu__ o.-t-\:o.t.hl.d ~\,a c\ N\.o.t>idoo.mus tlr-ld (\J\o+~o~ Fo, Lc.a.~t. ·\-o E \.t.. hos be..~i\1. .\-;\t.A ~u tht.. Ccu,{ o~ L\~\~lt.i.~\ A. ff~.a.\<:. 0. ~ 0.~1\.\."l-t 'Stl~d' Au.-thor~ti tcH -C-14\~N- ~ -\:o f~, ~c< M M•~:~-t<..t ~c..\ Du.t:<.s uud.( c 1\..(=\: ._\(.__ \\ .() 1 . ~CL. ~ t.t-~·e}\ .. f-..u\c 2ol U.').c'\.wt 1tx.. ~->Jf E.y:ckw.<.!. nut\ ( odt..ot 'Jud~L~a.\ Lo~ciu£..-t LO.N.o~ ~-CJ· (8) o.\uu\. w>t~--. . '\tc (\.u.\.<..''~ et Lo~ut'"::. \loL _\_. ~ ~\-n-\-e.. ~ .. . R.u.\~-::. e>\ A.\f<:..llo.te.. f{cc..eJur<. /RECE~\/f[)JWJ .f

w.dhLr-1 l~O do..i~ trom t-ht. clct+<- ot- ct..Le_~p-t c~ ihe. ufel\caf:c.u ~-t -HM®IA©OMPC~~~ Sto.h.• the Lot-l\l~L=\:t>.\ Q, Loud: ~~o.\\ (t~:::.c\\lL dill~ l~~U<-"') ·-\he~.t L.c::.u\-\ ~ na. +~md-1 de:-:'11\lu:t.e.J to( (t.":.t>\.u:\:~ol>.i. A-Mi. Mot~ol\1 tee t.'Lte.\-\~ic.~ c~ +~ML Mu<:.t ~e_ -f~lt.ci ~M tht. Lc~.Ht u\. Lt~N\it..~.o.\ 1\ffc.ab ~<..~o((_ +~L <.i.~~\0.-\:~oN cf fuL. l~O An.i eu~ed.

0 M.a:l td ou 0 / I ·i. •· .. 'i '

I~ l"C Leur+ of Lc:m:~ .. \ ~~fco.h ~+- \c..x.o.~

We~* ....\o. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _..;...

MIL h<\.t. \ \.Jho.lc..Y "* bt\~~~ ~ ~L\o:\:o( o 1\t'f\~L.tu.L-\:-

\1.

Jua'\~. ~.D.f:Jo~ \2.00~ La.e~t-cl ~to.t~c\.1, {\...u~~:t-i.k~u~ lt)7l\ Luul-\- ot L\~MI.N.o.\ ot 1\.U.:.o..\s of- \e..ti.S

~L~t.rl. 4:-:. Ce:.uct lr-\ a M.ct~cM tor Le.a.\k. to ElL Q /o.M De~ ':\IMC1l 1\ff'Lc..o.t~uJ .C.oc \k)t:t ct 1\l\llt-.lda.MU":. tn.M The.. Louvt c.\ Lc-.N\~t.ul\ c.+ 1\ffe. Lo.e~hl "S,-tc.l-\~ct-1, f\\l~t; ...L Te..to.-> 1~1l\ Wr~-t est \-\o.bu':i Lc.l Pu."l Lo.u.se. 1--\u..mbu :

·-r. Lt. 1--lo. Wct\-tt"~6tt\·~ (G). w(Z.-')t3~~,2~ Tt. Lt. ~o. W ~l.- 'jlo~\17 ·· s (_f). ~\ R..- '3l\. ~1\'S- 2.. '-1 ' ' Tr. Lt. ~o. W '\~- ul'l'b~·~ (_f). w~- -~'\. ::>

~M.[)±

I.

( I} ~L R.Lla.+o c tlt J Q. Mot~()"' .\.u ~uc\;L~a.l ~ o-\:~te. o~ 1\cUut\: c.a.t:\1 '- tcu.h ll~ d. oeY~ch.lu.~ti +o hur-6. ~\.1. ~t... Luurt o\- (_(:tJ\tioLtA.\ c.\-- ~Uu.ls 0~ t"{.~Cl ~I Vur~uClu-\- h lule. ~ol (A1 [t\J (n1 (£] ru.J.a (j:]ot Tn:Q.~ ~ules o-f. £\l~ckJ.i.Le.. Iu. th\:-;. Wt~--\ c~ \-\o..h<.a.~ l.o<~u':> P(cLt.<.di~-L'L K.u.\.e... 1.ol CD] K.<...\ll~Us o.. Lt>ur+ '1\tnll -\-a.k.L 'Jud~L~d.\ 1-.\ot\U. I~ rt.tu.tshci ~i o.. Ftl(t-( d.N..d ~uH\~td w\~ t\te_ 1-lU.:.t.'Y:.Cld 1&-L{C>\'N\a.+:llt!."Tn.~~ \~ 6.. M.n~Jutud c\u.ti ot fuL tou\t. lol (c..'] C.t-.Lt~-\\(.~ D.. VcK\:1 -'\::"' he htl.Lc-A uQeu -t~Me.l-1 H. 'tu fe o.""::CII-lCl~lt.. l~~fu.h_ w~~'-h l~ ~o.lHo.\\1 k~owu (\.\~-\h~b-1 ~t -1-di.,h,~o.\ iur~~ ~~L\-:~~ o~ 1-hf-. +r~nl L. (\urt wk~:.~ (}.({ Ln.fo. b\e "-\- ( tnAi o.~A 0.<-<.ur().t<-. dLte. fN\.I:~crt~~t-1 bi \t.'::lor+ h ~QLHle.') w\\o~t o..ccuco.c'l Cat-1 \.le.t bL ,\euS.Mlo.\o\.'1 'l.IJ.< ~\-~

(f.) ~t..\11-\:or L()t,rttt-Ld.S t~ll-\: he.. ~Je.d h~"':l M~hb\\1 \.~ ~Ill~ C.. 6U~1: ti-l -f\t<-~~H~-\- c.t l-\o.hw .. ~\fi.l"> eHILt.e..c\~M~ \ 0.'-ld Kt:.-:.eouc\.~t-\:-\ 1uc\.~t. \\Q~ ~(._tu:~{d. +(> e..cu:tuta.<.t-.1 ~ll-~d Md~o\..L rue \\le').(_ \(~~61-.\.'S.. 0..\\1\.C>~~-::.-t t~~'S.<- e:,-\-~~\'S> I

'M.t.t..\+~~t.!.tJ 1.~ -t\te £.i-\-·hu_hed Mo~do.M.u'S f<..-t-~-\-:6~.

( j_) Whe.~.~ 0M-e.. \ ~ hdA ~"" Lu~-\c.d '( Ut>lc\.t.r L~P\u~\.1-\- llt.l~ ~{_~l~ re.\e.c.~t_ \:d ha. \o-uts Leduc:.,~\- \.-:. \~ C.uM \-.>e.\1-\ d.fo\.1 -"'.t.. ""'l:.-\~-t<- -h. l.t.rt.;c AulL 0.. ~atu ~t ~~M. lie\ e._( Su{tL~t.~-\ e.\l~c\c.tC:l\ ~.w. U ?:,'to. ~'\1 (\n.Lt. ~H. l\~G~. fleaS<. su. ~tJ.dt.r 'J. ~\a-k. '1':J'D ~-W. 'l~ 'L 18. (T-u... L\. P..~t l\~~ ). fiLIISe 'Se.<. D.o.-.t~~ \1. ~\-~-\:<., 11~ ~-W.'Ld <\.o'-\.~Mo l\e'&..f\n.·~L.r-\:Wcct~ l~~'\.ec.i:. ~raM-hd) flttt'J{ sec El-.l~dl.~l\\~ \J.. ~tah."l~o~.w.U u3 (1-~:'l.Lt.l\n \'\b~)

. \L\.) kc ~lAe.5 1\H. f1cc. ~u\es 'So (4): Bm~\<-w \~ t.N. o.te(_t\a.~-\ -\--o "S.tL -+~u+ ~u.-\.t~L~u1-\ ft.Cutd l">. er-t..~iJ.-\--td -\-u ~UuW -f.Hc.( (-e_ '\U~t~~~ (NH5G.\. Je~. hu\-e~ A.u. frK. t..u.\.e...:~ ~{) (J), e.-.)~ ll<-.):. t\(k\\o.~-\ \\11":> do.H *u ~\t.-t<.c\- (<.l<>rcl nt..tc\ br~N.~ ·1.-\- -\crwnn\ ~M ( ou.t\- .e\- i\ee{C-\.\-:. \e.\l~e.w. \/t.nle;~\ f\..t.l~.·\-e;... C.L.t Cld:-s.. jh.zz..,"J~.l'L §(o \Lull<>.;s.I\.N.t-..\.·-:ru.. C..et.l~:\-. 1\d·.\ § \o~ U.~.l:. 1\. l.c»~±. 1\rn-~:-N.d':::. . "2l. kd4: t\<--\:-t.UV\lN.o.t.:Q.\1 h-t \na.t.iuc\.~t. o~ \l<>\u~\a\~t-ltS~ cJ QLLU<:.e.c\.'s ( ()1\.ltc_'S~\()t-..\ ~t~l)( h ~\~ o.c\M~-:-":.~6~ \.~-\-1:> e'IL~de.~lt l":\ both lot-l-:::.-\::tut~o..W.\ nt-id. ~-hx\u:\:()Ci H..'\U.~~t:..Mud· O.M.d rf\u"'::t\ot..Mil.t-!~~e.~-\: 0~ (Ltof£L t"-t.. lt.\a:\o< N\b\.1.!':. .fu~~ t.Du~-\: ~(o..\-.1.\- ~~'S. ("(\<:iTtt.\U. ~c( .Ltn.\lt:.. +o ~~le. CalA ~~~ll(. (\ W(-~-\ cJ Mc.u..~do.MI.l~. \v.l~-t_((.t6rt. uPc~ C\.\.\ \'SSU.:tS r(t~e.-.1-\:-ed C.ou~l.c.\u~~ -\-\t(. t(.\o.tc{ (u).--1 ~oA­ Cb.ld t"-~-:- Lou~-\ ~{ ~+ --\\\~~ M.c-\~ ()~ O.t-ld. \.N.~ttud -\\t... L\ul. h c.\<~oL~t.t -tht. c ~~<- £1.-.!A cuhx ~(. ~~()\ld.u.L-\ h. t~ \.{.. f\ I A~ O.t..\. ~\IJU ·h) fuc.. w~~\ o\- 1\1\a.N.d..a.mu:. ~th-\:-~oU. "-fcu<<:. Re"'.f~ct+\l\l-t , AuwJid~

~t. it re.ri\t.n'\bt..(el +ho..+ oll.l -\-he. bt.\cw j~\lc.~ d.n.tc +ht. t.do.h./., Mc-,-\-~L'>~ ~()( Lel.UR. +I> ElL 4.L a.tto.c..hul W\~\- c' Mo.-..l.d.ll.rou<.. wo.<::. bu>.ut<..!. T\\L dc.:dk ct ..fu:s U..ur-\-

- Ufcu -\:~e._ Loutfs dc.Lk.c..+ , luud ~e.(\LL Ll.tcd~c.IJ. ~t":>~ouctt.t.l.+ ()\>1. 1\tL Iu-::.·hULti.u.'\ 'rt~nl /~o' ·h, ~-.l<- {\ /Ai.i o.N.~WC..v w~th~~ 'LG \o\1~~1..\.tS<:, da.'l-:,. ~ft~l'\'\ ..fut £ktL c~ -fu~":) L6Utt\ c;;.{c\.c..{.

DatL! · - - - - - - - - - - - - ----· .ll\l l\\e_ Cell{+ ct (_c~M~t\.\ut AHe._a\"J c.t ~$..(). s

V.-h~t "-\ (). - - - - - - - - - -

f\A~~_~a.~l!A.\ha.lcf ~ (o~~ ~ '3 3 klo.-tc.c

v.

~Ltt.tt..

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Whaley, Michael Dwayne, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Whaley, Michael Dwayne (Whaley, Michael Dwayne) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.