Whaley, Michael Dwayne

Court of Appeals of Texas

Whaley, Michael Dwayne

DecidedMarch 17, 2015

DocketWR-34,395-26

StatusPublished

This text of Whaley, Michael Dwayne (Whaley, Michael Dwayne) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Whaley, Michael Dwayne, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Pincite

Opinion

~:'

• .Iu ~t. Loud J Lc:M~~o.\ ot Affeo.\~ of .Te.x:u-:. • f.o. ~c.1- lZ.~o~ Co.~~\~\ '"'Yht\\(.,t-\ o f\u~t·.r..\, Tel(~S l~ll\

No±;< e. MJ.d Se.c.u:u_ J AH\~c.a.f:.li~ fc. -\:: tc.u This document contains some Ft>r \A.h a A~ MaN An Mll ~ pages ~hat are of poor qualitlf at the t1me of imaging. ""t, The.. l-\c~ofa.\,le.. .JuJ. ~e_(")) o-\- fut.. o.bo\lf. ~a;c! Lotilt: t-.....\oi:~Li. ON.(\ ~~\"~ce.. ('.) hdt.~'l ~~\lt.u aucl. MaAL- -\-~c.Lt -t\tu__ o.-t-\:o.t.hl.d ~\,a c\ N\.o.t>idoo.mus tlr-ld (\J\o+~o~ Fo, Lc.a.~t. ·\-o E \.t.. hos be..~i\1. .\-;\t.A ~u tht.. Ccu,{ o~ L\~\~lt.i.~\ A. ff~.a.\<:. 0. ~ 0.~1\.\."l-t 'Stl~d' Au.-thor~ti tcH -C-14\~N- ~ -\:o f~, ~c< M M•~:~-t<..t ~c..\ Du.t:<.s uud.( c 1\..(=\: ._\(.__ \\ .() 1 . ~CL. ~ t.t-~·e}\ .. f-..u\c 2ol U.').c'\.wt 1tx.. ~->Jf E.y:ckw.<.!. nut\ ( odt..ot 'Jud~L~a.\ Lo~ciu£..-t LO.N.o~ ~-CJ· (8) o.\uu\. w>t~--. . '\tc (\.u.\.<..''~ et Lo~ut'"::. \loL _\_. ~ ~\-n-\-e.. ~ .. . R.u.\~-::. e>\ A.\f<:..llo.te.. f{cc..eJur<. /RECE~\/f[)JWJ .f

w.dhLr-1 l~O do..i~ trom t-ht. clct+<- ot- ct..Le_~p-t c~ ihe. ufel\caf:c.u ~-t -HM®IA©OMPC~~~ Sto.h.• the Lot-l\l~L=\:t>.\ Q, Loud: ~~o.\\ (t~:::.c\\lL dill~ l~~U<-"') ·-\he~.t L.c::.u\-\ ~ na. +~md-1 de:-:'11\lu:t.e.J to( (t.":.t>\.u:\:~ol>.i. A-Mi. Mot~ol\1 tee t.'Lte.\-\~ic.~ c~ +~ML Mu<:.t ~e_ -f~lt.ci ~M tht. Lc~.Ht u\. Lt~N\it..~.o.\ 1\ffc.ab ~<..~o((_ +~L <.i.~~\0.-\:~oN cf fuL. l~O An.i eu~ed.

0 M.a:l td ou 0 / I ·i. •· .. 'i '

I~ l"C Leur+ of Lc:m:~ .. \ ~~fco.h ~+- \c..x.o.~

We~* ....\o. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _..;...

MIL h<\.t. \ \.Jho.lc..Y "* bt\~~~ ~ ~L\o:\:o( o 1\t'f\~L.tu.L-\:-

\1.

Jua'\~. ~.D.f:Jo~ \2.00~ La.e~t-cl ~to.t~c\.1, {\...u~~:t-i.k~u~ lt)7l\ Luul-\- ot L\~MI.N.o.\ ot 1\.U.:.o..\s of- \e..ti.S

~L~t.rl. 4:-:. Ce:.uct lr-\ a M.ct~cM tor Le.a.\k. to ElL Q /o.M De~ ':\IMC1l 1\ff'Lc..o.t~uJ .C.oc \k)t:t ct 1\l\llt-.lda.MU":. tn.M The.. Louvt c.\ Lc-.N\~t.ul\ c.+ 1\ffe. Lo.e~hl "S,-tc.l-\~ct-1, f\\l~t; ...L Te..to.-> 1~1l\ Wr~-t est \-\o.bu':i Lc.l Pu."l Lo.u.se. 1--\u..mbu :

·-r. Lt. 1--lo. Wct\-tt"~6tt\·~ (G). w(Z.-')t3~~,2~ Tt. Lt. ~o. W ~l.- 'jlo~\17 ·· s (_f). ~\ R..- '3l\. ~1\'S- 2.. '-1 ' ' Tr. Lt. ~o. W '\~- ul'l'b~·~ (_f). w~- -~'\. ::>

~M.[)±

I.

( I} ~L R.Lla.+o c tlt J Q. Mot~()"' .\.u ~uc\;L~a.l ~ o-\:~te. o~ 1\cUut\: c.a.t:\1 '- tcu.h ll~ d. oeY~ch.lu.~ti +o hur-6. ~\.1. ~t... Luurt o\- (_(:tJ\tioLtA.\ c.\-- ~Uu.ls 0~ t"{.~Cl ~I Vur~uClu-\- h lule. ~ol (A1 [t\J (n1 (£] ru.J.a (j:]ot Tn:Q.~ ~ules o-f. £\l~ckJ.i.Le.. Iu. th\:-;. Wt~--\ c~ \-\o..h<.a.~ l.o<~u':> P(cLt.<.di~-L'L K.u.\.e... 1.ol CD] K.<...\ll~Us o.. Lt>ur+ '1\tnll -\-a.k.L 'Jud~L~d.\ 1-.\ot\U. I~ rt.tu.tshci ~i o.. Ftl(t-( d.N..d ~uH\~td w\~ t\te_ 1-lU.:.t.'Y:.Cld 1&-L{C>\'N\a.+:llt!."Tn.~~ \~ 6.. M.n~Jutud c\u.ti ot fuL tou\t. lol (c..'] C.t-.Lt~-\\(.~ D.. VcK\:1 -'\::"' he htl.Lc-A uQeu -t~Me.l-1 H. 'tu fe o.""::CII-lCl~lt.. l~~fu.h_ w~~'-h l~ ~o.lHo.\\1 k~owu (\.\~-\h~b-1 ~t -1-di.,h,~o.\ iur~~ ~~L\-:~~ o~ 1-hf-. +r~nl L. (\urt wk~:.~ (}.({ Ln.fo. b\e "-\- ( tnAi o.~A 0.<-<.ur().t<-. dLte. fN\.I:~crt~~t-1 bi \t.'::lor+ h ~QLHle.') w\\o~t o..ccuco.c'l Cat-1 \.le.t bL ,\euS.Mlo.\o\.'1 'l.IJ.< ~\-~

(f.) ~t..\11-\:or L()t,rttt-Ld.S t~ll-\: he.. ~Je.d h~"':l M~hb\\1 \.~ ~Ill~ C.. 6U~1: ti-l -f\t<-~~H~-\- c.t l-\o.hw .. ~\fi.l"> eHILt.e..c\~M~ \ 0.'-ld Kt:.-:.eouc\.~t-\:-\ 1uc\.~t. \\Q~ ~(._tu:~{d. +(> e..cu:tuta.<.t-.1 ~ll-~d Md~o\..L rue \\le').(_ \(~~61-.\.'S.. 0..\\1\.C>~~-::.-t t~~'S.<- e:,-\-~~\'S> I

'M.t.t..\+~~t.!.tJ 1.~ -t\te £.i-\-·hu_hed Mo~do.M.u'S f<..-t-~-\-:6~.

( j_) Whe.~.~ 0M-e.. \ ~ hdA ~"" Lu~-\c.d '( Ut>lc\.t.r L~P\u~\.1-\- llt.l~ ~{_~l~ re.\e.c.~t_ \:d ha. \o-uts Leduc:.,~\- \.-:. \~ C.uM \-.>e.\1-\ d.fo\.1 -"'.t.. ""'l:.-\~-t<- -h. l.t.rt.;c AulL 0.. ~atu ~t ~~M. lie\ e._( Su{tL~t.~-\ e.\l~c\c.tC:l\ ~.w. U ?:,'to. ~'\1 (\n.Lt. ~H. l\~G~. fleaS<. su. ~tJ.dt.r 'J. ~\a-k. '1':J'D ~-W. 'l~ 'L 18. (T-u... L\. P..~t l\~~ ). fiLIISe 'Se.<. D.o.-.t~~ \1. ~\-~-\:<., 11~ ~-W.'Ld <\.o'-\.~Mo l\e'&..f\n.·~L.r-\:Wcct~ l~~'\.ec.i:. ~raM-hd) flttt'J{ sec El-.l~dl.~l\\~ \J.. ~tah."l~o~.w.U u3 (1-~:'l.Lt.l\n \'\b~)

. \L\.) kc ~lAe.5 1\H. f1cc. ~u\es 'So (4): Bm~\<-w \~ t.N. o.te(_t\a.~-\ -\--o "S.tL -+~u+ ~u.-\.t~L~u1-\ ft.Cutd l">. er-t..~iJ.-\--td -\-u ~UuW -f.Hc.( (-e_ '\U~t~~~ (NH5G.\. Je~. hu\-e~ A.u. frK. t..u.\.e...:~ ~{) (J), e.-.)~ ll<-.):. t\(k\\o.~-\ \\11":> do.H *u ~\t.-t<.c\- (<.l<>rcl nt..tc\ br~N.~ ·1.-\- -\crwnn\ ~M ( ou.t\- .e\- i\ee{C-\.\-:. \e.\l~e.w. \/t.nle;~\ f\..t.l~.·\-e;... C.L.t Cld:-s.. jh.zz..,"J~.l'L §(o \Lull<>.;s.I\.N.t-..\.·-:ru.. C..et.l~:\-. 1\d·.\ § \o~ U.~.l:. 1\. l.c»~±. 1\rn-~:-N.d':::. . "2l. kd4: t\<--\:-t.UV\lN.o.t.:Q.\1 h-t \na.t.iuc\.~t. o~ \l<>\u~\a\~t-ltS~ cJ QLLU<:.e.c\.'s ( ()1\.ltc_'S~\()t-..\ ~t~l)( h ~\~ o.c\M~-:-":.~6~ \.~-\-1:> e'IL~de.~lt l":\ both lot-l-:::.-\::tut~o..W.\ nt-id. ~-hx\u:\:()Ci H..'\U.~~t:..Mud· O.M.d rf\u"'::t\ot..Mil.t-!~~e.~-\: 0~ (Ltof£L t"-t.. lt.\a:\o< N\b\.1.!':. .fu~~ t.Du~-\: ~(o..\-.1.\- ~~'S. ("(\<:iTtt.\U. ~c( .Ltn.\lt:.. +o ~~le. CalA ~~~ll(. (\ W(-~-\ cJ Mc.u..~do.MI.l~. \v.l~-t_((.t6rt. uPc~ C\.\.\ \'SSU.:tS r(t~e.-.1-\:-ed C.ou~l.c.\u~~ -\-\t(. t(.\o.tc{ (u).--1 ~oA Cb.ld t"-~-:- Lou~-\ ~{ ~+ --\\\~~ M.c-\~ ()~ O.t-ld. \.N.~ttud -\\t... L\ul. h c.\<~oL~t.t -tht. c ~~<- £1.-.!A cuhx ~(. ~~()\ld.u.L-\ h. t~ \.{.. f\ I A~ O.t..\. ~\IJU ·h) fuc.. w~~\ o\- 1\1\a.N.d..a.mu:. ~th-\:-~oU. "-fcu<<:. Re"'.f~ct+\l\l-t , AuwJid~

~t. it re.ri\t.n'\bt..(el +ho..+ oll.l -\-he. bt.\cw j~\lc.~ d.n.tc +ht. t.do.h./., Mc-,-\-~L'>~ ~()( Lel.UR. +I> ElL 4.L a.tto.c..hul W\~\- c' Mo.-..l.d.ll.rou<.. wo.<::. bu>.ut<..!. T\\L dc.:dk ct ..fu:s U..ur-\-

- Ufcu -\:~e._ Loutfs dc.Lk.c..+ , luud ~e.(\LL Ll.tcd~c.IJ. ~t":>~ouctt.t.l.+ ()\>1. 1\tL Iu-::.·hULti.u.'\ 'rt~nl /~o' ·h, ~-.l<- {\ /Ai.i o.N.~WC..v w~th~~ 'LG \o\1~~1..\.tS<:, da.'l-:,. ~ft~l'\'\ ..fut £ktL c~ -fu~":) L6Utt\ c;;.{c\.c..{.

DatL! · - - - - - - - - - - - - ----· .ll\l l\\e_ Cell{+ ct (_c~M~t\.\ut AHe._a\"J c.t ~$..(). s

V.-h~t "-\ (). - - - - - - - - - -

f\A~~_~a.~l!A.\ha.lcf ~ (o~~ ~ '3 3 klo.-tc.c

v.

~Ltt.tt..

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI