Whaley, Michael Dwayne

Texas Supreme Court·Decided September 23, 2015·No. WR-34,395-24·Published

Opinion

N.c . 1l- '-\SoL\ l ql- ?'>L t\11 i.Jc.

MOTI~~D~II!IED PATE;_ - S-Is-

Nu. C{)- ol4 '6 t BY: ·--:!!"""A.

,L

. -- c• e .

1- ;u the_

Lc.u.d u+ Lci,,\~l..l.!.ll i\I:Pt:ul~ Au<.:.-\.:.~, \c~U.":>

RECEIV.ED :IN COURT OF CRIMINAl APPEAL

\/. SEP 23 2015 Ab~IAOOSta, Clerk

f~: . . r~, :\a~c..\ \.lo. _Ll_ _ ___;. , q?=>- 6 V-l <()<6 ....1~~-~ll::...:::.S_oL\....l...·~l~-- ,ct....!:...t~-~~~fu__,~,l\~1 -[{,a.\ Lil.o."":>c.. t-...\c.. W L- 3l\, :)q:S- t) . .._\c. •. Wt.- ~l\. 1 -'J ct.~) .. 2.£1 t...\u. W t- 3~ ,)9 ~- 2-5

j

lM ~lL- tJ·,~\,·~d LoU.\-\: \::J«.l\11'":> Lcc,t-l-t-t, ~~u.~ / L~2.,\lA. J~c\~c.~a\ D;~tc:L--t I \=r~Aw.l L{c"->ld L<.v.t-\·) f:Ju.l. ~c.\I.N. \

~~ ~'- HoN.u~Cl~\'- .Jt.i.A~t":l 1J +he LL~.d· e~ Cc~.,\~r.ial Af<~11h ~ Lomci t..ic.IA.J 1\J\~d'\1)..{.\ Who..\{-/, f-Lt~tluUH .::..J.c\ ~;lts -ll,:·~ ft+~t:1\rJ +~c l-..L..·t.C~uA-~uiJ l~J~c.w c.~ ~d.:\-1 { <.tu) do.is ~1\.1. wh~Lh -\-c. \:lt. c.. it.t~-\-~DrJ \t.l i-!t.t:+:Lid-~ul\.\ R..~"~( w .l..~-1 ~u\tu\-\ c.+ th~c, {t:t~-t~u~, ft.·f.-\-l.u;..\-t( r':>.\lilu...;":, ·i\tc ( GL~\t .tht t,\\uL.·,~..L ~ ( '".:>):

. I.

fuc..rd~-\'\oi.le.( \.,\..)(l') Lu\..1\iic-h.tl ll\i thL Lt z...~a. Ju.~:cial l)i":,·\\~d· L Cu\t (;* Du.\\a.s Lc>u.u.ti lt1...o.'> G~ -the.. uttcr..\.-:,c... et I I

l. {\ ~ 'H ~'-\lc.t;h.A ~o ~ bd i t..h. . ...lq..!:.l-----~:<i='S_c. . : 1.\.~\- - - - - 2. E.u1L\c)(~~ Dr'llli-l~"Z..cd C_r~,,\\M.a.\ ML·h\i~-\:i t...\t> • ..JS.....~.l.....·....,3~lc..._·.l.\.u1~..-7!--_ _ _ __ _l_;...\

"5. f\~j(I),\IQ.-\:<:J Lb\o.e.(i 1\\u. _q.l-.l3_-...!::6~V~-\.'6:...::b~-------

~·· (l ~ {I (\ (dJ:&i\\<-<" r\(f~ul fl.tiu\;Jd t Cuuct Afi~;~trJ 1'. • ( \ , \' \ (_ •l •)

r.C'Lu \t',j t(; ·hL. 1 .;i.i.ct·ct h(((c.l S l.

-the J

1"\ tu.l u.J.fub\~~~,j c_,{·;~'"~:vl..\ { Ct."'J<- o.\u . il-~)-cc.()D • Cf \l+h. Cr·,ud· u~ A(\~u\·~ DtCem'br ( '1 1 l 'l<t) J. ~\uflc.\\1.:. J:A:c. ~a.\ \.'\ ~-;\.;:d. -\\~L C. uSc.. w.:. <. ,.JL 1\i, '"'\ ~~1-l OeU.\"\\~..:( '1.Lttqj_

JL.

I . .\ij\\t:\tL lm·:.;{· r1\l(1 -- .

~cA(\\\e~t J~ ~\(( Ol.il\~-\-

(. C . bo~ !1D

~-t.l\.l"t:.\L~ \k, -\~)1-_<i:. 11 ~,l\1-0C4-U

'i.L. (.\.\~~ L'1<f••~l ( _,,u\t CJH ~­ i':Sj 1\.\. LJ,{~IL.~t.i..Gtt. b~l\ll;, 1 -r~ l~Lo 7

]f[.

(1

r.lt..h·hui\.\i'\~ .1• J.• I i' I \ 1..--"\.I.A.t-~-t \i>\- u Cl\1.\ 1'-\u-T~f~ccd:c>;..\ \~ - tJ • . . ~ . iI:JI.\cJ-Lcl' I l ~ 'I OIU "t\\L ·tt>l c.W~..i\·hld-:.

(· w

o

fi.:ta~~>~<-.r ·..No..'::. ~~~'-t ~ru.\c:.o\l?~l t..\- th.t... 1~ ... L.~~ctt<t.it<. du~n1 ui\1·\'J HtL tl~.-.l 'l v·f 1-\,;..~·;:.U.~ (_.,_lfl1'> L\...07 L~ 1\\i:.. c~IJ.\'t ,.\- Lci.i\\~..lu.\ 1'\ffc.o.l-s et leu<.. ot d.utc...:

7 /It; I ·z,,i 'I .

5•~\Lt tha-I +~1\h'.. f. -\~-\.'ul\<( hu<.. b.:e.t..i. c-'tT-e;li.H·~i\.\. '\ h ju_~.~ it.~ a l ft.frLS(.t\.ltu-\~t.._.\ ~t-i. th~":. Ma-t-h.\_ t-\.~-~ Cltt'c.o..\.t-1 tu.lA.. t...\{i\:11.\ liftunJ..:'f 6M the ,:.l\'(:CQ\ Mu . 1.l-t~_:_.. G~[3u hu.-s. lll.d'6(\\\(J t~t-\+~c.i,\f( +hot +\lii LJ0i(l Nu+ c.dlnnu+ h~.\\ t.M

·t\1.: r~ta~ul-l Ll th~., 111L> t~Jt.t.ilL du.io\\.

\tuhHt t·ure.. \~t~+:t.kt-t:.\ ?u. ...J-s \\,L C~>ud 5cu.M·~ .ft1l<:. feLt~.:.•.!. ~(.;( ~\t.+J~c::.o. +~c.io..\ I.At.~.t.\ iiLll\.towl~cl'\L .'t\).L +~1\\c\:..t.L ~i.i\ t~\t\i.'\ -\:\tL \\\.it.i~":!lu:o..\ lhlht.<, ll.i.

• Luu. · \.:.. ..lo . .\t-.H<

,.,

,,"..J\1l, •Jr.<

J ' j-

'L.. £\ 1 ;I

rJ,,. Wl. · T1, '<c;.t:;.

J' J - L'')·

U-:~e..c:...h\lt- htcl•l..-h\\tii.f (-:.) dc.~i\1 duL +~.:. ~c E\J;de uu. . ~fGI\\ ~u'i.t.i ·-r;~ . .~ ~c\~v-t~~:>W. "Shl.-\:U\'\.L~t-:, c\- ~A.L-\-"5 :

P. -{f l~ Le..r\~~Lil.t"L e~ K.dc.r-\:{..\ \...\a.'I UL H . Gl"'\. .y\ ( J ~ (_ . (_ . \Z. . [ t',Z...tJ.d . ,\udi:L~al LJ~•.y\-fZd- ~u..M: t\111\ll Lrot...Jtd LbllCh {ju~lcl~\\1.. ~ b.::.l\Q'), Te~u. ~ -l.e. l. !..~·'\k.l...l.e... •

11

'i I d L.....ll

/f...P:. ·: :. ._ . . ?- <.! F· IV....J...; -...JO ....J

"<. ,j

Le.HJ:.~c_u:+e... IJ.o. iZ....~~ E"-f\{1.\.~~~>'~ t\a-h. . : il.... /3tl'l.s

'31:.

~J~o..i Ot~\t. (~ ht..\A ihl LU.':J·t&Lti Lll\l.rlt< ( c;\\ll~~M.{ llhlc\ ":::>c.e.l:•) \deD..')c.... ~·"'' Hu VJ-t:.O. ~ L Of' ?l}. s ~-\: \. ";;. ll'lLU.\\'\ ~ ..:.N..-t Ll..~61-l the.... -s·tu.·k. rc. ~N.T'c. dul~ ol '\Q.~Iool'S t h ~ (\, \ "Su~-\~L~e...-..1.~ e.\l.~tluu:t.L t-o ~\\e:.w {'\G~c,\uk Ld.\1..'"::1(. \-(>( hu\A~,-..~..1\ \\~111 lt\.\ Lu-:-.r-hcl-f.

~Lt. 5& XN-lL Wi.\.\~Q\\\~ ~~Y1 ~Mi-LA ~'\.l ( "le.-1-.LL~l\\.

I \\1 q_ \ i\((.

~e_c E~t (o.<tL W~l\~l.l\\\':., 10""3 ~-v...\. {LA \.o19;. (\:<..'(. L;;- . w~\l~. l«t~b \. . ") c..c \1\o(>.d:c# \l . j.tf.A..t~, lD 0\ ~- w. L.A )qt.,, ~·U Uo... (...,, t\t'\. l\ 1,()\. 'S<.t:. . lxt.+~\e..\ '\1. '":J-\u.""t~. 1'':J9_, . >u';.

. LJ. 'L1b C-c~-~..Lc u\(?. ~\tr>·L 'Stc b(l.--t~~ \l. ~\:<i:\:<.., ·-n~ ~-W- 'LA L\\bl\.;l\uio C\-t.1-.. ,\a.-- toe\ Wt\\\, \ttrc,v..··) '3. e..c Eu ~.:..\~~1\l '1 \J . "')t-ext{' ' 1C".::;O ":>.\A.\. Z...d. u-.s_ t "1<-k.. ( ~' t\(('.. l \tt.· .l.

-~ ~'

0 c () ' { . 1

1\fi'. {u;L.. ~\L r~o ld l : £.\c.~>i l'::. a.~ +c. ':-t.e.... +hu-t ::,ut't;c.~ct-J.-t .

Wll..\di {' 1\u\c':> Lll( l\.fi'.:. \\a.uT fCLCrL\ l":, f;;C)i.r..\.-t-c~ t,, -::.h~>W -enc.,- \t 'tU~(~~l (NH"So'J.

•'/

Uu·dt.\o (\ule.., 1\ff. (~i,L ~utn rjO (dJ,'Jj (()~ Ac\'~\\ul\l.\ ht1-:.. rlut-1 +u Cn.-hc-t i . l . \• .\ f• ~ \ , lc.Lor.,l lllurl nc.\.1 '\ tT \6fWC~\o •·or :~"" U.J~ev.J.

·l \

C.::,uit' n\ (u.. s abc). \1Lvl4.(>'A.':, Al\11\i.lc-i..u~ L.L. r (~.{\-:,. 'S b. 'l L fj b. \hiU.\.Jtt\ ~1\.\t-.\.- Tc~u'5 Lo~J.<i.-t . . A(t.l~_LQ ~ ll.'S.L.i\. (.:,1\l':>·t. ~!\i\ltl-lrb'"'S.Io.lll:

.Deh(i\\~1..\at;ui\\ b4 -\T;c..l ~\url~j.t. o{ \lc.\ull.d·o.(.L.\i':")"> o~ uLCU<)cJ\ Lul\.lt~-:.<:.~vl-l e\:o( l+s o.<.\n\(.-,.-s,~,.~ \l-\·h, f'>\;J.c.MLL ~:, \u.,--\:"' Cuw.":J·'t~-\:u.t~oi.io..\ dtJ.t\ ~.::.:ra·h..t(.H fe..'tUI.\e~\ot\ LA~-.iJ. Mu.-::-.·t ~L 1\\c..t-1.\~'t:-:,-\- c.C. f c ( ul cl.

n re.-tit;oM.ct \e.Cill.e.~-\-(-.>J \-u\ c:~fu.N.~t.:X J CaSe..~. e.~Nlc('o.t~CJI-o.\. tUI\\ ({;"Sa~ bu().u")(. -t\t<... ~~lo.i.-tuJ:Les wCI-')1 l'S, L-.;e{t.. t'lo..li:S":l:-.!e. Aut. h t'lu ~~\\~\:J~-\: / f.'J:le..t-tc_e. P\<-':le.,~-ta.·hr.~. Uu.t. f<c.Le5~ \l~c,\.CLt"l.uiJ. o~ -\-\,._lLlth. 1\1\\.t.lol..d..\\\t.\ool-t ~.:.(u.ust 11\Huii.l.d vJCl'5 ll\L~'~tc\:~\lt. ~til .\-!A-.\~I>l.'\ .f.- uXkl\.t \\\L. t'.\\c\ -h:, £A({o::\.\a.t-~.-t c_G\.1(-\-s. rc(.\ud~Le. ~~ +hL L.t.:d-l.civK e\ -tl\L ~~-hlu1:~t'.\..l.

De..c:o.u"_,c. c~ -\-\u.').:. \U~"::>o~'S. LO.\'.\ \t\1><·~1-i"~ fuc..t -\-\'\<.. tlKe:Y;.!i.\i -h.'a..\ o~C'-;""\-s, ~ll b~~L. w·~l\ d:":ltLA."S":> -\-hL (o~:J\\)~\~1--\ cJ o. .\-c..\Ju!c..'o\.-.:_ n:_C.id\\i\\eMo.:h'c\1 \~-.t ~'\-{ (!i"SL·

\..Jh~H.t.>\t:.. Afd~t.Ll\\1.-\: fled 'J -tk~ \:-\c,I\Lo~u.\Ae.. L.,u.\-\, l c\\\Aud· at-..\. t.v:deutu< { hu. .~~io-.\.1 0.1\.tA -\'-tN.rtt-~.\ c~ ~o.c\- (s) cui~ -t\\.HLo..~-h' ~\~<ed a.tJ.. {)(~\~'( -\-o +\t.:.i\.\.~i\1~\ -ttl{._ ru:.otA -thu."> d<.udue-c.J. --h. -\-nL t{-.k<. \~j\\\ L'-'ur\-:s \t.~lli.c~~ b'-1 O.\-t.. lLv7 (c\.) \J..f\.L.Lf. \-0r tu.{-\\L<-< u.c.t~t.~ \d -+\\e.. Ccu.H ~~a.~-\-~1~~ \<.\.'~c~ -t() whi.d\ ·H\L '(c-t-.·\-~iJN.ec / Vttf<.l\aw-\- L":'1 e.t-\.-L\:\.cJ.

I. C-t~--\-~t,.u'-( L~\'fJ~ +hcd: t4 -hue.. th.lc\ cd'i c~ -t\1L t1lc-.JL atJd f.oiL~cit-1. ~ L6f'it.d

f":·K\-~ciJ t,,:- J ...-t~t:c...,;.:t-~~1-1 t\.-t.."~~~~.... hi).~, \Jn~ tuiu.H~i"-<.j \1·1 tL'S. ma:l, i'u'S-t-o.D}t: ft e...i'o.~J t,,.:.:. t L.J~~'; +(, "'·h<. :

(\.) txcdc A.. 6u">hcc:.: /A.tt~o!t.1 A L"' /1oj ~r~t. J,~..L..ld / ~L.i:\:~ Z..lL / 1h<- t),, wc.ii I l:Jc..l\o.'}, -reous -t-:>Sl> L.

(3,) \.~\c.~uc.. ~- Olm~tul.Lc)u\t t~Jette\ /Lf>Z.t.~.ci. -:La~L:a.\ D;<>t>~t.+ (..al,-t I f\c..ul LJcw\cf &uac:.t~~ \ i "Do..\.\ti s, l-c·~o.) ·1"";:;.Z..c 7

. \/u.·c.-•C:.At..c.;u.$ .. I

:I. 1\i\;d\o.d \0J\U\d. Li~du--~ta\\ij ·thL Cul>.\.d.~t~u\.1 e~ ~\ :\u\-.f tiN.c.\ tle. -te\ ,,\t~i. wh~t\ltc .\:.lt-.tt\~,-i~S n.rc ~d(~;\-\:e."\ -~~ -the e\l~AwLe.., t\at.lYi~i-\-~iliJ cf \r:o..l 'S\-a.h_,\'\.luf~ e.-\- fu(--\-<) a":> 'f..'kh~~l.t ,. f\ •· ..lc~.~U fH:.;.·u-\t'J . _.

~.

9 Tt(E 5\'AT£. 6;f tf.XAS I CCU#t T'(. Of OALL.NS

1/

4 r~ WAVi'ilt K. (,)LM.'ST£0~ Q·ffic.ial (.our-t iU.('ottt.r in dnd 5 fer -tht.18ll\d Jud.tdal o~~tric:.it (our-\: of c,al\a~ (c>un.tt~~ 6-ta-\t..

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Whaley, Michael Dwayne, (Tex. 2015).

Whaley, Michael Dwayne (Whaley, Michael Dwayne) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.