Whaley, Michael Dwayne

Texas Supreme Court

Whaley, Michael Dwayne

DecidedSeptember 23, 2015

DocketWR-34,395-24

StatusPublished

This text of Whaley, Michael Dwayne (Whaley, Michael Dwayne) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Texas Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Whaley, Michael Dwayne, (Tex. 2015).

Pincite

Opinion

N.c . 1l- '-\SoL\ l ql- ?'>L t\11 i.Jc. MOTI~~D~II!IED PATE;_ - S-Is- Nu. C{)- ol4 '6 t BY: ·--:!!"""A. ,L . -- c• e .

1- ;u the_ Lc.u.d u+ Lci,,\~l..l.!.ll i\I:Pt:ul~ Au<.:.-\.:.~, \c~U.":>

RECEIV.ED :IN COURT OF CRIMINAl APPEAL \/. SEP 23 2015 Ab~IAOOSta, Clerk

f~: . . r~, :\a~c..\ \.lo. _Ll_ _ ___;. , q?=>- 6 V-l <()<6 ....1~~-~ll::...:::.S_oL\....l...·~l~-- ,ct....!:...t~-~~~fu__,~,l\~1 -[{,a.\ Lil.o."":>c.. t-...\c.. W L- 3l\, :)q:S- t) . .._\c. •. Wt.- ~l\. 1 -'J ct.~) .. 2.£1 t...\u. W t- 3~ ,)9 ~- 2-5 j

lM ~lL- tJ·,~\,·~d LoU.\-\: \::J«.l\11'":> Lcc,t-l-t-t, ~~u.~ / L~2.,\lA. J~c\~c.~a\ D;~tc:L--t I \=r~Aw.l L{c"->ld L<.v.t-\·) f:Ju.l. ~c.\I.N. \

~~ ~'- HoN.u~Cl~\'- .Jt.i.A~t":l 1J +he LL~.d· e~ Cc~.,\~r.ial Af<~11h ~ Lomci t..ic.IA.J 1\J\~d'\1)..{.\ Who..\{-/, f-Lt~tluUH .::..J.c\ ~;lts -ll,:·~ ft+~t:1\rJ +~c l-..L..·t.C~uA-~uiJ l~J~c.w c.~ ~d.:\-1 { <.tu) do.is ~1\.1. wh~Lh -\-c. \:lt. c.. it.t~-\-~DrJ \t.l i-!t.t:+:Lid-~ul\.\ R..~"~( w .l..~-1 ~u\tu\-\ c.+ th~c, {t:t~-t~u~, ft.·f.-\-l.u;..\-t( r':>.\lilu...;":, ·i\tc ( GL~\t .tht t,\\uL.·,~..L ~ ( '".:>): . I. fuc..rd~-\'\oi.le.( \.,\..)(l') Lu\..1\iic-h.tl ll\i thL Lt z...~a. Ju.~:cial l)i":,·\\~d· L Cu\t (;* Du.\\a.s Lc>u.u.ti lt1...o.'> G~ -the.. uttcr..\.-:,c... et I I

l. {\ ~ 'H ~'-\lc.t;h.A ~o ~ bd i t..h. . ...lq..!:.l-----~: • ..JS.....~.l.....·....,3~lc..._·.l.\.u1~..-7!--_ _ _ __ _l_;...\ "5. f\~j(I),\IQ.-\:<:J Lb\o.e.(i 1\\u. _q.l-.l3_-...!::6~V~-\.'6:...::b~------- ~·· (l ~ {I (\ (dJ:&i\\<-<" r\(f~ul fl.tiu\;Jd t Cuuct Afi~;~trJ 1'. • ( \ , \' \ (_ •l •) r.C'Lu \t',j t(; ·hL. 1 .;i.i.ct·ct h(((c.l S l. -the J

1"\ tu.l u.J.fub\~~~,j c_,{·;~'"~:vl..\ { Ct."'J<- o.\u . il-~)-cc.()D • Cf \l+h. Cr·,ud· u~ A(\~u\·~ DtCem'br ( '1 1 l 'l

JL.

I . .\ij\\t:\tL lm·:.;{· r1\l(1 -- .

~cA(\\\e~t J~ ~\(( Ol.il\~-\- (. C . bo~ !1D ~-t.l\.l"t:.\L~ \k, -\~)1-_

'i.L. (.\.\~~ L'1

]f[. (1

r.lt..h·hui\.\i'\~ .1• J.• I i' I \ 1..--"\.I.A.t-~-t \i>\- u Cl\1.\ 1'-\u-T~f~ccd:c>;..\ \~ - tJ • . . ~ . iI:JI.\cJ-Lcl' I l ~ 'I OIU "t\\L ·tt>l c.W~..i\·hld-:. (· w o

fi.:ta~~>~<-.r ·..No..'::. ~~~'-t ~ru.\c:.o\l?~l t..\- th.t... 1~ ... L.~~ctt L\...07 L~ 1\\i:.. c~IJ.\'t ,.\- Lci.i\\~..lu.\ 1'\ffc.o.l-s et leu<.. ot d.utc...: 7 /It; I ·z,,i 'I . 5•~\Lt tha-I +~1\h'.. f. -\~-\.'ul\<( hu<.. b.:e.t..i. c-'tT-e;li.H·~i\.\. '\ h ju_~.~ it.~ a l ft.frLS(.t\.ltu-\~t.._.\ ~t-i. th~":. Ma-t-h.\_ t-\.~-~ Cltt'c.o..\.t-1 tu.lA.. t...\{i\:11.\ liftunJ..:'f 6M the ,:.l\'(:CQ\ Mu . 1.l-t~_:_.. G~[3u hu.-s. lll.d'6(\\\(J t~t-\+~c.i,\f( +hot +\lii LJ0i(l Nu+ c.dlnnu+ h~.\\ t.M

·t\1.: r~ta~ul-l Ll th~., 111L> t~Jt.t.ilL du.io\\.

\tuhHt t·ure.. \~t~+:t.kt-t:.\ ?u. ...J-s \\,L C~>ud 5cu.M·~ .ft1l<:. feLt~.:.•.!. ~(.;( ~\t.+J~c::.o. +~c.io..\ I.At.~.t.\ iiLll\.towl~cl'\L .'t\).L +~1\\c\:..t.L ~i.i\ t~\t\i.'\ -\:\tL \\\.it.i~":!lu:o..\ lhlht.<, ll.i. • Luu. · \.:.. ..lo . .\t-.H< ,., ,,"..J\1l, •Jr.< J ' j- 'L.. £\ 1 ;I rJ,,. Wl. · T1, 'W. "Shl.-\:U\'\.L~t-:, c\- ~A.L-\-"5 :

P. -{f l~ Le..r\~~Lil.t"L e~ K.dc.r-\:{..\ \...\a.'I UL H . Gl"'\. .y\ ( J ~ (_ . (_ . \Z. . [ t',Z...tJ.d . ,\udi:L~al LJ~•.y\-fZd- ~u..M: t\111\ll Lrot...Jtd LbllCh {ju~lcl~\\1.. ~ b.::.l\Q'), Te~u. ~ -l.e. l. !..~·'\k.l...l.e... • 11 'i I d L.....ll /f...P:. ·: :. ._ . . ?- <.! F· IV....J...; -...JO ....J "<. ,j

Le.HJ:.~c_u:+e... IJ.o. iZ....~~ E"-f\{1.\.~~~>'~ t\a-h. . : il.... /3tl'l.s

'31:.

~J~o..i Ot~\t. (~ ht..\A ihl LU.':J·t&Lti Lll\l.rlt< ( c;\\ll~~M.{ llhlc\ ":::>c.e.l:•) \deD..')c.... ~·"'' Hu VJ-t:.O. ~ L Of' ?l}. s ~-\: \. ";;. ll'lLU.\\'\ ~ ..:.N..-t Ll..~61-l the.... -s·tu.·k. rc. ~N.T'c. dul~ ol '\Q.~Iool'S t h ~ (\, \ "Su~-\~L~e...-..1.~ e.\l.~tluu:t.L t-o ~\\e:.w {'\G~c,\uk Ld.\1..'"::1(. \-(>( hu\A~,-..~..1\ \\~111 lt\.\ Lu-:-.r-hcl-f.

~Lt. 5& XN-lL Wi.\.\~Q\\\~ ~~Y1 ~Mi-LA ~'\.l ( "le.-1-.LL~l\\. I \\1 q_ \ i\((. ~e_c E~t (o..d:c# \l . j.tf.A..t~, lD 0\ ~- w. L.A )qt.,, ~·U Uo... (...,, t\t'\. l\ 1,()\. 'S<.t:. . lxt.+~\e..\ '\1. '":J-\u.""t~. 1'':J9_, . >u';. . LJ. 'L1b C-c~-~..Lc u\(?. ~\tr>·L 'Stc b(l.--t~~ \l. ~\:.\A.\. Z...d. u-.s_ t "1<-k.. ( ~' t\(('.. l \tt.· .l.

-~ ~'

0 c () ' { . 1

1\fi'. {u;L.. ~\L r~o ld l : £.\c.~>i l'::. a.~ +c. ':-t.e.... +hu-t ::,ut't;c.~ct-J.-t .

Wll..\di {' 1\u\c':> Lll( l\.fi'.:. \\a.uT fCLCrL\ l":, f;;C)i.r..\.-t-c~ t,, -::.h~>W -enc.,- \t 'tU~(~~l (NH"So'J. •'/

Uu·dt.\o (\ule.., 1\ff. (~i,L ~utn rjO (dJ,'Jj (()~ Ac\'~\\ul\l.\ ht1-:.. rlut-1 +u Cn.-hc-t i . l . \• .\ f• ~ \ , lc.Lor.,l lllurl nc.\.1 '\ tT \6fWC~\o •·or :~"" U.J~ev.J. ·l \ C.::,uit' n\ (u.. s abc). \1Lvl4.(>'A.':, Al\11\i.lc-i..u~ L.L. r (~.{\-:,. 'S b. 'l L fj b. \hiU.\.Jtt\ ~1\.\t-.\.- Tc~u'5 Lo~J.·t. ~!\i\ltl-lrb'"'S.Io.lll:

.Deh(i\\~1..\at;ui\\ b4 -\T;c..l ~\url~j.t. o{ \lc.\ull.d·o.(.L.\i':")"> o~ uLCU<)cJ\ Lul\.lt~-:.<:.~vl-l e\:o( l+s o.<.\n\(.-,.-s,~,.~ \l-\·h, f'>\;J.c.MLL ~:, \u.,--\:"' Cuw.":J·'t~-\:u.t~oi.io..\ dtJ.t\ ~.::.:ra·h..t(.H fe..'tUI.\e~\ot\ LA~-.iJ. Mu.-::-.·t ~L 1\\c..t-1.\~'t:-:,-\- c.C. f c ( ul cl.

n re.-tit;oM.ct \e.Cill.e.~-\-(-.>J \-u\ c:~fu.N.~t.:X J CaSe..~. e.~Nlc('o.t~CJI-o.\. tUI\\ ({;"Sa~ bu().u")(. -t\t<... ~~lo.i.-tuJ:Les wCI-')1 l'S, L-.;e{t.. t'lo..li:S":l:-.!e. Aut. h t'lu ~~\\~\:J~-\: / f.'J:le..t-tc_e. P\<-':le.,~-ta.·hr.~. Uu.t. fl.'\ .f.- uXkl\.t \\\L. t'.\\c\ -h:, £A({o::\.\a.t-~.-t c_G\.1(-\-s. rc(.\ud~Le. ~~ +hL L.t.:d-l.civK e\ -tl\L ~~-hlu1:~t'.\..l. De..c:o.u"_,c. c~ -\-\u.').:. \U~"::>o~'S. LO.\'.\ \t\1><·~1-i"~ fuc..t -\-\'\<.. tlKe:Y;.!i.\i -h.'a..\ o~C'-;""\-s, ~ll b~~L. w·~l\ d:":ltLA."S":> -\-hL (o~:J\\)~\~1--\ cJ o. .\-c..\Ju!c..'o\.-.:_ n:_C.id\\i\\eMo.:h'c\1 \~-.t ~'\-{ (!i"SL·

\..Jh~H.t.>\t:.. Afd~t.Ll\\1.-\: fled 'J -tk~ \:-\c,I\Lo~u.\Ae.. L.,u.\-\, l c\\\Aud· at-..\. t.v:deutu< { hu. .~~io-.\.1 0.1\.tA -\'-tN.rtt-~.\ c~ ~o.c\- (s) cui~ -t\\.HLo..~-h' ~\~ d<.udue-c.J. --h. -\-nL t{-.k<. \~j\\\ L'-'ur\-:s \t.~lli.c~~ b'-1 O.\-t.. lLv7 (c\.) \J..f\.L.Lf. \-0r tu.{-\\L<-< u.c.t~t.~ \d -+\\e..

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI