Weston v. Stoddard

16 N.Y.S. 605, 42 N.Y. St. Rep. 76, 1891 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 2130

Opinion

Learned, P. J.

The action of partition has long been an equitable remedy. 1 Story, Eq. Jur. § 646, and subsequent sections. There was also a special proceeding provided for by the Revised Statutes, which might be taken in courts of law. But that left, in express language, the jurisdiction of the court of chancery unaffected. Such an action is not within section 968 or section 3228. It is governed by section 3230, and costs are in the discretion of the court. An issue of fact in the action is triable by a jury. Section 1544. But that does not determine that the action is so triable, or bring the action within section 3228, subd. I.¹ The right to award costs to plaintiff and to defendant was recognized in Henderson v. Scott, 43 Hun, 22, and this must overcome the special term decision of Davis v. Davis, 3 N. Y. St. Rep. 163. We think, therefore, that the matter was in the discretion of the. special term, and there is no question that the discretion was not properly exercised. Order affirmed, with $10 costs and printing disbursements.

1 The several provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure here referred to are as follows:

Section 968 provides that a jury trial may be had in (1) “an action in which the complaint demands judgment for a sum of money only, (3) an action of ejectment, for dower,_ for waste, for a nuisance, or to recover a chattel. ”

Section 1544 provides, with respect to the action of partition, that “an issue of fact joined in the action is triable by a jury. ” “Unless the court directs the issues to be stated, as prescribed in section nine hundred and seventy of this act, the issues may be tried upon the pleadings. ”

Section 3388, subd. 1, provides that “plaintiff is entitled to costs as of course on rendition of final judgment in his favor in * * * (1) an action triable by a jury, to recover real property, or an interest in real property, or in which a claim of title to real property arises upon the pleadings, or is certified to have come in question upon thfe "trial. ”

Section 8280 provides that “the court may, in its discretion, award costs to any party ■upon the rendering of a final judgment. ”